Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

University of Chicago Press eBooks

10. Metaphysical Principles and Heuristic Rules

Slobodan Perović

Published Jan 1, 2021• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Building on the previous analysis, the chapter offers a unified understanding of the inductive-hypothetical process which led to complementarity. It discusses Bohr’s hands-on epistemological and methodological standpoint that can be subsumed under a few heuristic rules, in stark contrast to Schrödinger’s methodological stance driven by particular metaphysical principles with its own advantages and limitations.

DOI
10.7208/chicago/9780226798479.003.0010

Related papers

The methodological lesson of complementarity: Bohr’s naturalistic epistemology

Henry J. Folse

Bohr's intellectual journey began with the recognition that empirical phenomena implied the breakdown of classical mechanics in the atomic domain; this, in turn, led to his adoption of the 'quantum postulate' that justifies the 'stationary states' of his atomic model of 1913. His endeavor to develop a wider conceptual framework harmonizing both classical and quantum descriptions led to his proposal of the new methodological goals and standards of complementarity. Bohr's claim that an empirical discovery can demand methodological revision justifies regarding his epistemological lesson as supporting a naturalistic epistemology.

Physica Scripta•Dec 1, 2014•6 citations

Exploring the depths of existence

Sudip Patra, Menas C. Kafatos

We have referred to general organising principles of quantum mechanics (QM) in the previous chapter, which can be extended (as principles) to several other domains. Among such principles, contextuality-complementarity is perhaps most important in its applicability to different domains of reality. There is a consensus now ( Khrennikov, 2022 ) that these principles emerged through the original works of N. Bohr. Khrennikov (2025) has produced a seminal work in which contextuality becomes the basis of reformulation of QM, and even non-locality, which is argued to be a central feature in the orthodox QM interpretation (rather than the Copenhagen(ish) approaches), can also be reformulated in terms of local contextuality. We will hold a different approach to non-locality later in the chapter, which builds upon our earlier works ( Nadeau and Kafatos, 2001 ). We also mention here that some authors ( Plotnitsky, 2022 ) have attempted to formulate a ‘reality without realism’ view based on Bohr’s original insights. In this chapter, we provide a more detailed view of Copenhagen(ish) approaches to contextuality-complementarity. Since we think that a quantum-like framework (QLF) is also related to such approaches, contextuality-complementarity in QLF can also be formulated in the same line.

Routledge eBooks•May 26, 2026•0 citations

6. Reception

Slobodan Perović

Chapter 6 argues Bohr’s model was the final stage of the elaborate inductive-hypothetical process he gradually developed and reflected upon and shows how it extended into the community of physicists working on quantum phenomena at the time. The chapter explains why his novel hypothesis induced as the synthesis of broad novel evidence was widely accepted and yet bound to be perceived as counterintuitive by his contemporaries.

University of Chicago Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

On Bohr's Principle of Complementarity

Li Qi

Analysis of Bohr's complementarity of quantum dialectics,we may achieve the philosophy of quantum theory,there is a more in-depth knowledge and understanding.

Journal of Bijie University•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Comparative Discussion

Harald Atmanspacher A, Dean P. Rickles

There are no overt lines of in?uence between the quantum-inspired dual-aspect approaches presented in previous chapters – though Pauli’s and Wheeler’s inspirations might have a common origin in some of Bohr’s ideas, and some of Bohm and Hiley’s speculations build on Eddington. But they were essentially each developed independently from one another, somewhat surprisingly converging onto numerous common features that are compared in this chapter. Connections are sought amongst their deeper philosophical foundations, especially those by Spinoza, Kant, Schelling and Hegel. Also explored is the way in which different elements of the surface structure and deep structure of meaning are positioned at the core of their metaphysical projects, along with the way in which the mind-matter connection is understood. A synoptic overview facilitates the comparison of key concepts and notions utilized in the three approaches.

Routledge eBooks•Jan 31, 2022•0 citations

On complementarity and beyond

Marc E. Carvallo

Introduction: On Issues in Complementarity and Beyond M.E. Carvallo. Part I: Complementarity, Epistemology, and Ontology. 1. Complementarity-Polarity-Dialectic-Autology: A Conceptual Analysis of Opposition and Unity A. Locker. 2. Complementarity as Challenge: Prefigurations in the History of Thinking H. Fischer-Barnicol. 3. Bohr's Idea of Complementarity J. Hilgevoord. 4. Complementarity and Our Knowledge of Nature H.J. Folse. 5. Ontological Implications of Complementarity K.V. Laurikainen. 6. Aspects of Complementarity R. Vallee. Part II: Complementarity: Alternative Views and Applications. 7. The Probability Trees of Quantum Mechanics: Probabilistic Meta-Dependence and Meta-Meta-Dependence M. Mugur-Schachter. 8. Complementarity in Language: Toward a General Understanding L. Loefgren. 9. Language, Incompleteness and Continuous Domains: Considerations of Complementarity of Abstractions H.W. Campbell, D.G. Stuart. 10. The Measurement Problem in Physics, Computation, and Brain Theories H.H. Pattee. 11. On the Double Architecture of the Semantic Memory P. Erdi, T. Groebler, P. Marton. 12. Axiomatic Methods in Science P. Suppes. 13. Complementarity in the Theory of Conversations and Lp G. Pask. 14. A Theory of Bargains in Experience S.M. Lindenberg. Part III: Beyond Complementarity, Beyond Physics. 15. Complementarity or Process? T. Bastin. 16. Can Quantum Computation Provide a Physically Realistic Model of the Self and Its Brain? P.J.Marcer. 17. Non-Locality in Nature and Cognition F.D. Peat. 18. Spontaneity of Consciousness V.V. Nalimov. 19. A Brief Prolegomenon to the Principle of Metaphoricity M.E. Carvallo. Name Index. Subject Index.

Kluwer Academic Pub. eBooks•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations
Building on the previous analysis, the chapter offers a unified understanding of the inductive-hypothetical process which led to complementarity. It discusses Bohr’s hands-on epistemological and methodological standpoint that can be subsumed under a few heuristic rules, in stark contrast to Schrödinger’s methodological stance driven by particular metaphysical principles with its own advantages and limitations.
Bohr's intellectual journey began with the recognition that empirical phenomena implied the breakdown of classical mechanics in the atomic domain; this, in turn, led to his adoption of the 'quantum postulate' that justifies the 'stationary states' of his atomic model of 1913. His endeavor to develop a wider conceptual framework harmonizing both classical and quantum descriptions led to his proposal of the new methodological goals and standards of complementarity. Bohr's claim that an empirical discovery can demand methodological revision justifies regarding his epistemological lesson as supporting a naturalistic epistemology.
We have referred to general organising principles of quantum mechanics (QM) in the previous chapter, which can be extended (as principles) to several other domains. Among such principles, contextuality-complementarity is perhaps most important in its applicability to different domains of reality. There is a consensus now ( Khrennikov, 2022 ) that these principles emerged through the original works of N. Bohr. Khrennikov (2025) has produced a seminal work in which contextuality becomes the basis of reformulation of QM, and even non-locality, which is argued to be a central feature in the orthodox QM interpretation (rather than the Copenhagen(ish) approaches), can also be reformulated in terms of local contextuality. We will hold a different approach to non-locality later in the chapter, which builds upon our earlier works ( Nadeau and Kafatos, 2001 ). We also mention here that some authors ( Plotnitsky, 2022 ) have attempted to formulate a ‘reality without realism’ view based on Bohr’s original insights. In this chapter, we provide a more detailed view of Copenhagen(ish) approaches to contextuality-complementarity. Since we think that a quantum-like framework (QLF) is also related to such approaches, contextuality-complementarity in QLF can also be formulated in the same line.
There are no overt lines of in?uence between the quantum-inspired dual-aspect approaches presented in previous chapters – though Pauli’s and Wheeler’s inspirations might have a common origin in some of Bohr’s ideas, and some of Bohm and Hiley’s speculations build on Eddington. But they were essentially each developed independently from one another, somewhat surprisingly converging onto numerous common features that are compared in this chapter. Connections are sought amongst their deeper philosophical foundations, especially those by Spinoza, Kant, Schelling and Hegel. Also explored is the way in which different elements of the surface structure and deep structure of meaning are positioned at the core of their metaphysical projects, along with the way in which the mind-matter connection is understood. A synoptic overview facilitates the comparison of key concepts and notions utilized in the three approaches.
Introduction: On Issues in Complementarity and Beyond M.E. Carvallo. Part I: Complementarity, Epistemology, and Ontology. 1. Complementarity-Polarity-Dialectic-Autology: A Conceptual Analysis of Opposition and Unity A. Locker. 2. Complementarity as Challenge: Prefigurations in the History of Thinking H. Fischer-Barnicol. 3. Bohr's Idea of Complementarity J. Hilgevoord. 4. Complementarity and Our Knowledge of Nature H.J. Folse. 5. Ontological Implications of Complementarity K.V. Laurikainen. 6. Aspects of Complementarity R. Vallee. Part II: Complementarity: Alternative Views and Applications. 7. The Probability Trees of Quantum Mechanics: Probabilistic Meta-Dependence and Meta-Meta-Dependence M. Mugur-Schachter. 8. Complementarity in Language: Toward a General Understanding L. Loefgren. 9. Language, Incompleteness and Continuous Domains: Considerations of Complementarity of Abstractions H.W. Campbell, D.G. Stuart. 10. The Measurement Problem in Physics, Computation, and Brain Theories H.H. Pattee. 11. On the Double Architecture of the Semantic Memory P. Erdi, T. Groebler, P. Marton. 12. Axiomatic Methods in Science P. Suppes. 13. Complementarity in the Theory of Conversations and Lp G. Pask. 14. A Theory of Bargains in Experience S.M. Lindenberg. Part III: Beyond Complementarity, Beyond Physics. 15. Complementarity or Process? T. Bastin. 16. Can Quantum Computation Provide a Physically Realistic Model of the Self and Its Brain? P.J.Marcer. 17. Non-Locality in Nature and Cognition F.D. Peat. 18. Spontaneity of Consciousness V.V. Nalimov. 19. A Brief Prolegomenon to the Principle of Metaphoricity M.E. Carvallo. Name Index. Subject Index.