Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Advances in Mathematics of Communications

Concrete analysis of approximate ideal-SIVP to decision ring-LWE reduction

Neal Koblitz, Subhabrata Samajder, Palash Sarkar, Subhadip Singha

Published Oct 19, 2022• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A seminal 2013 paper by Lyubashevsky, Peikert, and Regev proposed basing post-quantum cryptography on ideal lattices and supported this proposal by giving a polynomial-time security reduction from the approximate Shortest Independent Vectors Problem (SIVP) to the Decision Learning With Errors (DLWE) problem in ideal lattices. We give a concrete analysis of this multi-step reduction. We find that the tightness gap in the reduction is so great as to vitiate any meaningful security guarantee, and we find reasons to doubt the feasibility in the foreseeable future of the quantum part of the reduction. In addition, when we make the reduction concrete it appears that the approximation factor in the SIVP problem is far larger than expected, a circumstance that causes the corresponding approximate-SIVP problem most likely not to be hard for proposed cryptosystem parameters. We also discuss implications for systems such as Kyber and SABER that are based on module-DLWE.

DOI
10.3934/amc.2022082

Related papers

Classical reduction of gap SVP to LWE: A concrete security analysis

Palash Sarkar, Subhadip Singha

Regev (2005) introduced the learning with errors (LWE) problem and showed a quantum reduction from a worst case lattice problem to LWE. Building on the work of Peikert (2009), a classical reduction from the gap shortest vector problem to LWE was obtained by Brakerski et al. (2013). A concrete security analysis of Regev's reduction by Chatterjee et al. (2016) identified a huge tightness gap. The present work performs a concrete analysis of the tightness gap in the classical reduction of Brakerski et al. It turns out that the tightness gap in the Brakerski et al. classical reduction is even larger than the tightness gap in the quantum reduction of Regev. This casts doubts on the implication of the reduction to security assurance of practical cryptosystems.

Advances in Mathematics of Communications•Apr 7, 2021•2 citations

Reduction-Respecting Parameters for Lattice-Based Cryptosystems

Fletcher Gates

One attractive feature of lattice-based cryptosystems is the existence of security reductions relating the difficulty of breaking the cryptosystem to the difficulty of solving variants of the shortest vector problem (Regev, STOC 2005; Peikert, ePrint 2008). As there are no known polynomial-time algorithms which solve these lattice problems, this implies the asymptotic security of the cryptosystem. However, current lattice-based cryptosystems using the learning with errors (LWE) problem select parameters for which the reduction to the underlying lattice problem gives no meaningful assurance of concrete security. We analyze the runtime of the algorithm constructed in the reductions and select parameters for a cryptosystem under which the reductions give 128-bit security. While the resulting LWE-based cryptosystem is somewhat cumbersome, requiring a dimension of n = 1460, this is less than 2 times the dimension in the recently proposed Frodo cryptosystem (Bos et al., ACM CCS 2016), and could be implemented without catastrophic damage to communication times. We also investigate the runtime necessary for a reduction to give meaningful security assurances for current cryptosystems.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Hardness of the Shortest Vector Problem on Ideal Lattices under Quantum Reductions

Zen Revista, 10 MFC

The security of efficient post-quantum cryptographic primitives, particularly those based on the Ring Learning With Errors (Ring-LWE) problem, relies fundamentally on the presumed intractability of the Shortest Vector Problem (SVP) over ideal lattices. This monograph investigates the hardness of Ideal-SVP in the presence of quantum adversaries. We rigorously analyze the worst-case to average-case reductions that underpin the security of ideal lattice-based schemes, extending classical Gaussian smoothing arguments to the quantum setting. Specifically, we examine the impact of quantum sieving algorithms and the Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT) on the algebraic structure of number fields. While quantum algorithms provide a quadratic speedup for general lattice sieving, we argue that the additional algebraic structure of ideal lattices does not yield a catastrophic collapse in hardness under current quantum reduction models. We present a synthesis of recent results concerning the lower bounds of quantum query complexity for Ideal-SVP, establishing that for cyclotomic fields of degree n, the problem remains hard up to sub-exponential factors, thereby validating the asymptotic security of structured lattice cryptography.

•Feb 4, 2026•0 citations

Post-Quantum Key Exchange From Learning With Errors Over Rings

Rohit Khera

This note describes a key exchange method based on the ring-LWE (RLWE) assumption. It builds upon several results, including Regev's landmark quantum reduction from certain worst case lattice problems (approx. GapSVP and SIVP) to random instances of the search variant of a particular learning problem (LWE). It also builds on the follow on work of Lyubashevsky, Peikert and Regev on the average case hardness of the RLWE search variant for polynomially bounded numbers of RLWE samples, along with novel applications of automorphism groups in number fields for a RLWE search to decision reduction (thereby demonstrating pseudorandomness of RLWE in these number fields). Subsequently, these results were adopted for the construction of Diffie-Hellman like key exchange methods by Peikert, and then by Lindner and Peikert followed by Ding and then by Ding, Xie and Lin who proposed efficient variants of such protocols. Subsequent work by Peikert proposed another efficient variant, phrased as a key encapsulation method, incorporating a low bandwidth reconciliation technique allowing two parties to exactly agree on a uniformly distributed secret value from noisy RLWE instances. This was followed by a concrete instantiation with parameter sets by Bos, Costello, Naehrig, Stebila, followed by another instantiation by Alkim, Ducas, Poppelmann and Schwabe with the same ring polynomial but a smaller modulus and a different reconciliation method. Unlike most other public key cryptography based key exchange methods, it is believed that RLWE based key exchange would remain secure in the event that an adversary is able to build a quantum computer. This document is a product of the Crypto Forum Research Group (CFRG).

•Oct 24, 2017•0 citations

Rethinking Public-Key Cryptography: The Quantum-Secure Foundations of Ideal Lattices

Revista, Zen, MATH, 10

The advent of quantum computing poses a significant existential threat to the security of contemporary public-key cryptographic systems, such as RSA and Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC), which underpin global digital communication and secure transactions. These systems rely on the computational hardness of problems like integer factorization and the discrete logarithm problem, which are efficiently solvable by Shor's algorithm on a sufficiently powerful quantum computer. This paper comprehensively rethinks the foundations of public-key cryptography by exploring ideal lattice-based schemes as a promising, quantum-secure alternative. We delve into the mathematical underpinnings of ideal lattices, particularly focusing on their compact representation and efficient arithmetic derived from polynomial rings. We elucidate how the conjectured hardness of ideal lattice problems, such as the Ring Learning With Errors (RLWE) problem and the Ideal Shortest Vector Problem (Ideal-SVP), provides robust security against both classical and quantum adversaries. Through a detailed analysis of their cryptographic properties, efficiency benefits, and security guarantees, we argue for the critical role of ideal lattices in forging the next generation of resilient public-key infrastructures. This research highlights the advantages of ideal lattices in terms of performance and security compactness, making them leading candidates in the ongoing standardization efforts for post-quantum cryptography.

•Dec 3, 2025•0 citations

Post-Quantum RSA: Lattice-Based Constructs for Asymmetric Primitives

Revista, Zen, MATH, 10

The advent of quantum computing poses a significant existential threat to current public-key cryptographic systems, most notably RSA and Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC), which rely on the presumed hardness of integer factorization and discrete logarithm problems. Shor's algorithm, a quantum algorithm, can efficiently solve these problems, rendering classical asymmetric primitives insecure. This paper addresses the imperative need for post-quantum cryptography (PQC) by exploring lattice-based constructs as robust alternatives for asymmetric primitives. We provide a comprehensive overview of the fundamental mathematical problems underlying lattice-based cryptography, such as the Shortest Vector Problem (SVP), Closest Vector Problem (CVP), Learning With Errors (LWE), and Ring Learning With Errors (RLWE). The paper surveys prominent lattice-based schemes, including NTRU, CRYSTALS-Kyber, and CRYSTALS-Dilithium, analyzing their security foundations, performance characteristics, and the extent to which they offer a viable "post-quantum RSA." We delve into the methodology of constructing these primitives, discuss their resilience against both classical and quantum attacks, and evaluate their practical implications for key sizes, computational efficiency, and deployment challenges. Our analysis highlights that lattice-based cryptography, particularly the NIST-standardized schemes, presents a strong candidate for securing digital communications in the quantum era, offering provable security rooted in worst-case to average-case reductions for lattice problems.

•Dec 3, 2025•0 citations
A seminal 2013 paper by Lyubashevsky, Peikert, and Regev proposed basing post-quantum cryptography on ideal lattices and supported this proposal by giving a polynomial-time security reduction from the approximate Shortest Independent Vectors Problem (SIVP) to the Decision Learning With Errors (DLWE) problem in ideal lattices. We give a concrete analysis of this multi-step reduction. We find that the tightness gap in the reduction is so great as to vitiate any meaningful security guarantee, and we find reasons to doubt the feasibility in the foreseeable future of the quantum part of the reduction. In addition, when we make the reduction concrete it appears that the approximation factor in the SIVP problem is far larger than expected, a circumstance that causes the corresponding approximate-SIVP problem most likely not to be hard for proposed cryptosystem parameters. We also discuss implications for systems such as Kyber and SABER that are based on module-DLWE.
Regev (2005) introduced the learning with errors (LWE) problem and showed a quantum reduction from a worst case lattice problem to LWE. Building on the work of Peikert (2009), a classical reduction from the gap shortest vector problem to LWE was obtained by Brakerski et al. (2013). A concrete security analysis of Regev's reduction by Chatterjee et al. (2016) identified a huge tightness gap. The present work performs a concrete analysis of the tightness gap in the classical reduction of Brakerski et al. It turns out that the tightness gap in the Brakerski et al. classical reduction is even larger than the tightness gap in the quantum reduction of Regev. This casts doubts on the implication of the reduction to security assurance of practical cryptosystems.
One attractive feature of lattice-based cryptosystems is the existence of security reductions relating the difficulty of breaking the cryptosystem to the difficulty of solving variants of the shortest vector problem (Regev, STOC 2005; Peikert, ePrint 2008). As there are no known polynomial-time algorithms which solve these lattice problems, this implies the asymptotic security of the cryptosystem. However, current lattice-based cryptosystems using the learning with errors (LWE) problem select parameters for which the reduction to the underlying lattice problem gives no meaningful assurance of concrete security. We analyze the runtime of the algorithm constructed in the reductions and select parameters for a cryptosystem under which the reductions give 128-bit security. While the resulting LWE-based cryptosystem is somewhat cumbersome, requiring a dimension of n = 1460, this is less than 2 times the dimension in the recently proposed Frodo cryptosystem (Bos et al., ACM CCS 2016), and could be implemented without catastrophic damage to communication times. We also investigate the runtime necessary for a reduction to give meaningful security assurances for current cryptosystems.
The security of efficient post-quantum cryptographic primitives, particularly those based on the Ring Learning With Errors (Ring-LWE) problem, relies fundamentally on the presumed intractability of the Shortest Vector Problem (SVP) over ideal lattices. This monograph investigates the hardness of Ideal-SVP in the presence of quantum adversaries. We rigorously analyze the worst-case to average-case reductions that underpin the security of ideal lattice-based schemes, extending classical Gaussian smoothing arguments to the quantum setting. Specifically, we examine the impact of quantum sieving algorithms and the Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT) on the algebraic structure of number fields. While quantum algorithms provide a quadratic speedup for general lattice sieving, we argue that the additional algebraic structure of ideal lattices does not yield a catastrophic collapse in hardness under current quantum reduction models. We present a synthesis of recent results concerning the lower bounds of quantum query complexity for Ideal-SVP, establishing that for cyclotomic fields of degree n, the problem remains hard up to sub-exponential factors, thereby validating the asymptotic security of structured lattice cryptography.
This note describes a key exchange method based on the ring-LWE (RLWE) assumption. It builds upon several results, including Regev's landmark quantum reduction from certain worst case lattice problems (approx. GapSVP and SIVP) to random instances of the search variant of a particular learning problem (LWE). It also builds on the follow on work of Lyubashevsky, Peikert and Regev on the average case hardness of the RLWE search variant for polynomially bounded numbers of RLWE samples, along with novel applications of automorphism groups in number fields for a RLWE search to decision reduction (thereby demonstrating pseudorandomness of RLWE in these number fields). Subsequently, these results were adopted for the construction of Diffie-Hellman like key exchange methods by Peikert, and then by Lindner and Peikert followed by Ding and then by Ding, Xie and Lin who proposed efficient variants of such protocols. Subsequent work by Peikert proposed another efficient variant, phrased as a key encapsulation method, incorporating a low bandwidth reconciliation technique allowing two parties to exactly agree on a uniformly distributed secret value from noisy RLWE instances. This was followed by a concrete instantiation with parameter sets by Bos, Costello, Naehrig, Stebila, followed by another instantiation by Alkim, Ducas, Poppelmann and Schwabe with the same ring polynomial but a smaller modulus and a different reconciliation method. Unlike most other public key cryptography based key exchange methods, it is believed that RLWE based key exchange would remain secure in the event that an adversary is able to build a quantum computer. This document is a product of the Crypto Forum Research Group (CFRG).
The advent of quantum computing poses a significant existential threat to the security of contemporary public-key cryptographic systems, such as RSA and Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC), which underpin global digital communication and secure transactions. These systems rely on the computational hardness of problems like integer factorization and the discrete logarithm problem, which are efficiently solvable by Shor's algorithm on a sufficiently powerful quantum computer. This paper comprehensively rethinks the foundations of public-key cryptography by exploring ideal lattice-based schemes as a promising, quantum-secure alternative. We delve into the mathematical underpinnings of ideal lattices, particularly focusing on their compact representation and efficient arithmetic derived from polynomial rings. We elucidate how the conjectured hardness of ideal lattice problems, such as the Ring Learning With Errors (RLWE) problem and the Ideal Shortest Vector Problem (Ideal-SVP), provides robust security against both classical and quantum adversaries. Through a detailed analysis of their cryptographic properties, efficiency benefits, and security guarantees, we argue for the critical role of ideal lattices in forging the next generation of resilient public-key infrastructures. This research highlights the advantages of ideal lattices in terms of performance and security compactness, making them leading candidates in the ongoing standardization efforts for post-quantum cryptography.
The advent of quantum computing poses a significant existential threat to current public-key cryptographic systems, most notably RSA and Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC), which rely on the presumed hardness of integer factorization and discrete logarithm problems. Shor's algorithm, a quantum algorithm, can efficiently solve these problems, rendering classical asymmetric primitives insecure. This paper addresses the imperative need for post-quantum cryptography (PQC) by exploring lattice-based constructs as robust alternatives for asymmetric primitives. We provide a comprehensive overview of the fundamental mathematical problems underlying lattice-based cryptography, such as the Shortest Vector Problem (SVP), Closest Vector Problem (CVP), Learning With Errors (LWE), and Ring Learning With Errors (RLWE). The paper surveys prominent lattice-based schemes, including NTRU, CRYSTALS-Kyber, and CRYSTALS-Dilithium, analyzing their security foundations, performance characteristics, and the extent to which they offer a viable "post-quantum RSA." We delve into the methodology of constructing these primitives, discuss their resilience against both classical and quantum attacks, and evaluate their practical implications for key sizes, computational efficiency, and deployment challenges. Our analysis highlights that lattice-based cryptography, particularly the NIST-standardized schemes, presents a strong candidate for securing digital communications in the quantum era, offering provable security rooted in worst-case to average-case reductions for lattice problems.