Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations

Telling the Wave Function: An Electrical Analogy

Leonardo Chiatti

Published Oct 8, 2022• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The double nature of material particles, i.e., their wave and corpuscular characteristics, is usually considered incomprehensible, as it cannot be represented visually. It is proposed to the student, in introductory courses, as a fact justified by quantum interference experiments for which, however, no further analysis is possible. On this note, we propose a description of the wave function in terms of a simple electrical analogy, which reproduces at least some of its essential properties. Our aim is to provide a cognitive representation of an analogical type: starting from a classical context (electrical circuits) and introducing in an appropriate way the notions of “wave” and “particle”, we show how typically quantum properties such as delocalization and entanglement emerge in a natural, understandable, and intuitive way.

DOI
10.3390/foundations2040058

Related papers

A Pedagogical Pathway to Quantum Mechanics: Deriving Foundational Models from Classical and Wave-Based Intuition.

Sharma, Anchit

This paper presents a pedagogical framework for understanding quantum mechanics through classical and wave-based intuition. Starting from algebraic derivations rooted in Newtonian mechanics and wave properties, and incorporating de Broglie's matter-wave duality, we re-derive Planck's relation E=hf. Using the same classical-wave analogy, we extend the approach to foundational quantum models such as the particle in a box, the quantum harmonic oscillator, and other related systems. The goal is to provide an intuitive, visual way helping learners grasp the physical meaning behind key models without relying solely on abstract formalism. Note: This is an updated version of a previously published paper, with refined derivations and an expanded conceptual framework.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantitative wave-particle duality

Tabish Qureshi

The complementary wave and particle character of quantum objects (or quantons) was pointed out by Niels Bohr. This wave-particle duality, in the context of the two-slit experiment, is here described not just as two extreme cases of wave and particle characteristics, but in terms of quantitative measures of these characteristics, known to follow a duality relation. A very simple and intuitive derivation of a closely related duality relation is presented, which should be understandable to the introductory student.

arXiv:1501.02195•American Journal of Physics•Jun 22, 2016•9 citations

A New Approach for Introducing Schrödinger’s Equation Using Maxwell’s Equations, Quantum Mechanics, and Special Relativity

Hye Jung Kang

The wave-particle duality for light has been well established by various experiments, such as Young’s double slit experiment and the photoelectric effect. This led de Broglie to propose that a particle also has wave characteristics. Schrödinger further established the wave equation for a moving particle. Many times, quantum mechanics textbooks do not show how Schrödinger’s equation was developed in an intuitive manner that is appropriate at the undergraduate level. This article presents a new approach for introducing Schrödinger’s equation. This new approach starts with Maxwell’s equations and then applies the quantized energy of a light wave and special relativity. This more intuitive approach should help undergraduate students understand the origin of Schrödinger’s equation in a more natural way.

American Journal of Educational Research•Jul 9, 2018•0 citations

Quantum physics from waves: An analogy-based approach for high school

Marcelo Arlego, María de los Ángeles Fanaro, Lorenzo Galante

In this paper we present a proposal for teaching basic aspects of quantum mechanics in high school. Our proposal is based on a wave approach that makes use of the analogies between wave phenomena at macroscopic scales and phenomena at atomic or subatomic scales. Although the classical and the quantum model are completely different, there is a common underlying wave mathematical layer. This allows to address, via analogies, quantum aspects that are not accessible to direct experience. The quantization of energy levels, the quantum interference and the uncertainty relations are examples of quantum aspects having an analog concept in classical physics wave phenomena. In our approach we break the wave-particle “duality”, which is totally counterintuitive. Instead we enhance the underlying wave mathematical structure as a path to reach and explain emerging features of particles and quantum systems in general.

Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Física•Jan 1, 2021•1 citation

MISCONCEPTIONS IN QUANTUM PHYSICS ARISING FROM THE CLASSICAL PHYSICS

Matúš Sitkey, Terézia Jindrová

In the introductory course of microworld physics and subsequently, in the introduction to quantum physics, students become acquainted with new, more abstract and less intuitive ideas about the microworld. As a result of a different view of measurement and the possibility of measuring physical quantities in the microworld, the definition of the state of the physical system changes. It differs from the definition of the state of the classical system. In classical state, it makes sense to ask about the value of any quantity. With this idea, the student enters the introductory course of quantum theory, where such a question may no longer make sense. In a particular quantum state, a quantum system may not have sharply defined values of all quantities. For a student with standard ideas, this fact can cause problems in understanding quantum theory. Correct classical ideas can thus become a source of incorrect ideas in quantum physics - misconceptions. In this paper, we address some such preconceptions arising from classical physics, which may be potential sources of misconceptions in quantum theory. We deal with the issue of wave-corpuscular dualism and superposition of states. In a sample of 56 students from university of technology in Slovakia, we used a test to determine the occurrence of preconceptions concerning the transition from classical physics to the physics of the microworld. The test consisted of 9 closed questions with the possibility of choosing the correct answer, created using a theoretical example of a double slit experiment. Based on the specific answers of students, we identified misconceptions initially rooted in the standard subject of physics. The students showed misconceptions concerning the different view between the classical and quantum wave, the issue of wave-corpuscular dualism and the principle of superposition. The revealing of these misconceptions and their analysis is beneficial in the future teaching process when the emphasis will be placed in those parts of quantum physics in which the given misconceptions occur and arise.

ICERI proceedings•Nov 1, 2020•1 citation

What Is The Wave Function

Celso Luís Levada, Tabata Vidal, Huemerson Maceti +2 more

Microscopic particles, like electrons, do not move following the classical laws of motion, given by Newtonian Mechanics. These particles, however, follow other laws that are associated to the propagation of waves. This becomes qualitatively clear when we observe an interference pattern arise in an experiment in which an electron beam passes through a double slit. In this brief study, we will deal with the quantum analysis of the dynamics of particles, by means of its postulates and its precise mathematical formulation. That is, we intend to introduce the wave function and the Schrodinger equation, as well as to interpret physically such a function. The scientific bases of this essay (1),(2),(3),(4),(5) can be found  in the  books listed in the bibliographic references.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
The double nature of material particles, i.e., their wave and corpuscular characteristics, is usually considered incomprehensible, as it cannot be represented visually. It is proposed to the student, in introductory courses, as a fact justified by quantum interference experiments for which, however, no further analysis is possible. On this note, we propose a description of the wave function in terms of a simple electrical analogy, which reproduces at least some of its essential properties. Our aim is to provide a cognitive representation of an analogical type: starting from a classical context (electrical circuits) and introducing in an appropriate way the notions of “wave” and “particle”, we show how typically quantum properties such as delocalization and entanglement emerge in a natural, understandable, and intuitive way.
This paper presents a pedagogical framework for understanding quantum mechanics through classical and wave-based intuition. Starting from algebraic derivations rooted in Newtonian mechanics and wave properties, and incorporating de Broglie's matter-wave duality, we re-derive Planck's relation E=hf. Using the same classical-wave analogy, we extend the approach to foundational quantum models such as the particle in a box, the quantum harmonic oscillator, and other related systems. The goal is to provide an intuitive, visual way helping learners grasp the physical meaning behind key models without relying solely on abstract formalism. Note: This is an updated version of a previously published paper, with refined derivations and an expanded conceptual framework.
The complementary wave and particle character of quantum objects (or quantons) was pointed out by Niels Bohr. This wave-particle duality, in the context of the two-slit experiment, is here described not just as two extreme cases of wave and particle characteristics, but in terms of quantitative measures of these characteristics, known to follow a duality relation. A very simple and intuitive derivation of a closely related duality relation is presented, which should be understandable to the introductory student.
The wave-particle duality for light has been well established by various experiments, such as Young’s double slit experiment and the photoelectric effect. This led de Broglie to propose that a particle also has wave characteristics. Schrödinger further established the wave equation for a moving particle. Many times, quantum mechanics textbooks do not show how Schrödinger’s equation was developed in an intuitive manner that is appropriate at the undergraduate level. This article presents a new approach for introducing Schrödinger’s equation. This new approach starts with Maxwell’s equations and then applies the quantized energy of a light wave and special relativity. This more intuitive approach should help undergraduate students understand the origin of Schrödinger’s equation in a more natural way.
In this paper we present a proposal for teaching basic aspects of quantum mechanics in high school. Our proposal is based on a wave approach that makes use of the analogies between wave phenomena at macroscopic scales and phenomena at atomic or subatomic scales. Although the classical and the quantum model are completely different, there is a common underlying wave mathematical layer. This allows to address, via analogies, quantum aspects that are not accessible to direct experience. The quantization of energy levels, the quantum interference and the uncertainty relations are examples of quantum aspects having an analog concept in classical physics wave phenomena. In our approach we break the wave-particle “duality”, which is totally counterintuitive. Instead we enhance the underlying wave mathematical structure as a path to reach and explain emerging features of particles and quantum systems in general.
In the introductory course of microworld physics and subsequently, in the introduction to quantum physics, students become acquainted with new, more abstract and less intuitive ideas about the microworld. As a result of a different view of measurement and the possibility of measuring physical quantities in the microworld, the definition of the state of the physical system changes. It differs from the definition of the state of the classical system. In classical state, it makes sense to ask about the value of any quantity. With this idea, the student enters the introductory course of quantum theory, where such a question may no longer make sense. In a particular quantum state, a quantum system may not have sharply defined values of all quantities. For a student with standard ideas, this fact can cause problems in understanding quantum theory. Correct classical ideas can thus become a source of incorrect ideas in quantum physics - misconceptions. In this paper, we address some such preconceptions arising from classical physics, which may be potential sources of misconceptions in quantum theory. We deal with the issue of wave-corpuscular dualism and superposition of states. In a sample of 56 students from university of technology in Slovakia, we used a test to determine the occurrence of preconceptions concerning the transition from classical physics to the physics of the microworld. The test consisted of 9 closed questions with the possibility of choosing the correct answer, created using a theoretical example of a double slit experiment. Based on the specific answers of students, we identified misconceptions initially rooted in the standard subject of physics. The students showed misconceptions concerning the different view between the classical and quantum wave, the issue of wave-corpuscular dualism and the principle of superposition. The revealing of these misconceptions and their analysis is beneficial in the future teaching process when the emphasis will be placed in those parts of quantum physics in which the given misconceptions occur and arise.
Microscopic particles, like electrons, do not move following the classical laws of motion, given by Newtonian Mechanics. These particles, however, follow other laws that are associated to the propagation of waves. This becomes qualitatively clear when we observe an interference pattern arise in an experiment in which an electron beam passes through a double slit. In this brief study, we will deal with the quantum analysis of the dynamics of particles, by means of its postulates and its precise mathematical formulation. That is, we intend to introduce the wave function and the Schrodinger equation, as well as to interpret physically such a function. The scientific bases of this essay (1),(2),(3),(4),(5) can be found  in the  books listed in the bibliographic references.