Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Principles of Quantum Mechanics

R. Shankar

Published Jan 22, 2013• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Over the decade and a half since I wrote the first edition, nothing has altered my belief in the soundness of the overall approach taken here. This is based on the response of teachers, students, and my own occasional rereading of the book. I was generally quite happy with the book, although there were portions where I felt I could have done better and portions which bothered me by their absence. I welcome this opportunity to rectify all that.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.4457638

Related papers

Principles of Quantum Mechanics

R. Shankar

Given the number of books that already exist on the subject of quantum mechanics, one would think that the public needs one more as much as it does, say, the latest version of the Table oflntegers. But this does not deter me (as it didn't my predecessors) from trying to circulate my own version of how it ought to be taught. The approach to be presented here (to be described in a moment) was first tried on a group of Harvard undergraduates in the summer of '76, once again in the summer of '77, and more recently at Yale on undergraduates ('77-'78) and graduates ('78- '79) taking a year-long course on the subject.

•Jan 21, 2021•0 citations

Path Integral Formulation of Quantum Mechanics

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

We choose to examine a phenomenon which is impossible, absolutely impossible, to explain in any classical way, and which has in it the heart of quantum mechanics. In reality, it contains the only mystery. —Richard P. Feynman In this chapter we show that a reformulation of quantum mechanics, namely Feynman's path integral approach, is equivalent to the earlier ones, due to Schrödinger and Heisenberg. We shall introduce and apply it in this chapter to interpret the Aharonov–Bohm effect, which is considered to be a “quantum wonder.” It underscores the importance of electromagnetic potentials. We shall find that in addition to the dynamical phase introduced in Chapter 1, another angle, namely the geometric phase (Pancharatnam–Berry phase), is an important physical property of the wavefunction whose consequences are measurable. 2.1 Propagator: Propagation of a Quantum of Knowledge Notwithstanding the equivalence of wave mechanics and matrix mechanics, Schrödinger and Heisenberg did not appreciate each other's methodologies [1]. In 1926, Schrödinger said: “ I knew of [Heisenberg’s] theory, of course, but I felt discouraged, not to say repelled, by the methods of transcendental algebra, which appeared difficult to me, and by the lack of visualizability. ” Heisenberg's dislike for Schrödinger's wave mechanics was equally intense. In the same year, in a letter to Pauli, he wrote “ The more I think about the physical portion of Schrödinger's theory, the more repulsive I find it…. What Schrödinger writes about the visualizability of his theory ‘is probably not quite right,’ in other words it's crap .” In the mean time, Paul A. M. Dirac, who had made path-breaking contributions [2] in that eventful year (1926) to the formulation of quantum mechanics, had drawn a penetrating analogy [3] between classical and quantum mechanics. Dirac's remark drew the attention of Richard P. Feynman, who used it to build the path integral approach to quantum mechanics based on the variational principle. Feynman was introduced to the principle of extremum action [4] rather early, while in high school. He reveals in his book [5] that “ my Physics teacher … Mr. Bader … told me something … absolutely fascinating…. Every time the subject comes up, I work on it … the principle of least (rather, ‘extremum’) action. ”

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Principles of quantum mechanics /2nd enlarged edition/

V.A. Fok

MoIzN•Jan 1, 1976•0 citations

Could Feynman Have Said This?

N. David Mermin

Fifteen years ago, I mused in a Reference Frame column on how different generations of physicists differed in the degree to which they thought that the interpretation of quantum mechanics remains a serious problem (Physics Today, Physics Today 0031-9228 42 4 1989 9 https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2810963. April 1989, page 9 ). I declared myself to be among those who feel uncomfortable when asked to articulate what we really think about the quantum theory, adding that "If I were forced to sum up in one sentence what the Copenhagen interpretation says to me, it would be "Shut up and calculate!"In the intervening years, I've come to hold a milder and more nuanced opinion of the Copenhagen view, but that should be the subject of another column. The subject of this one is the habit of misquotation or misattribution that afflicts our profession, a rather different example of which I pointed out a few months ago (February 2004, page 10).Given my capacity for intellectual development ("inconsistency," in the terminology deployed in the current American political season), it's fortunate that I've now reached an age at which I tend to forget about things I've written more than a few years ago. Indeed, I find it downright irritating when somebody asks me questions about papers I wrote a mere half dozen years ago, naively identifying me with the author of those ancient texts. Until quite recently, I had no memory of ever having written such a childishly brusque dismissal of such an exquisitely subtle point of view, much less of having published it in so widely read a venue.This amnesia, combined with the evolution in my thinking that had distanced me from my long forgotten words, may explain why I was initially somewhat puzzled by the slight sensation of discomfort that passed over me when, browsing the e-print archive earlier this year, I read a characterization of Max Born's probability rule as "the favorite ingredient of what has been nicknamed, after Feynman's famous dictum, the shut up and calculate interpretation of quantum mechanics."I yield to nobody in my admiration for Richard Feynman's aphorisms on the nature of quantum mechanics. Indeed, long ago I published a poem (Physics Today, April 1985, page 47) consisting of nothing more than a resetting as verse of a paragraph Feynman had written about his own attitude toward the quantum theory, in his now (but not then) famous article that launched the whole field of quantum computation. I like to think I have devoured everything Feynman ever wrote on the character of quantum mechanics. But while "shut up and calculate" sounded dimly familiar to me as a characterization of a certain interpretive stance, I couldn't recall where Feynman had written it. Mulling this over, a terrible thought began to dawn on me. Could it be that I myself had once used the phrase? If so, then it would appear that I had picked it up from something by Feynman, forgotten the source, and presented it as my own. Devastating!It was devastating because I have a horror of writing or uttering any witticism that is not original with me, unless I make it absolutely clear where and (if known) from whom I got it. I don't even like to tell jokes unless I've made them up myself. (I digress to offer you my favorite:Question: What is the difference between theoretical physics and mathematical physics? Answer: Theoretical physics is done by physicists who lack the necessary skills to do real experiments; mathematical physics is done by mathematicians who lack the necessary skills to do real mathematics. Mathematical physicists tend not to like this joke, but other physicists seem to. Nonphysicists, of course, are entirely immune to its charms.)So with growing trepidation, I searched through my past writings on quantum mechanics. I was dismayed when I came upon my 1989 column, which confirmed my worst fears. Not only had I appropriated without proper attribution a Feynman quote, but it appeared to be a famous one. How humiliating! I was afflicted with visions of knowledgeable Physics Today readers shaking their heads 15 years ago at what must have struck them as my shameless attempt to ride to literary glory on the unacknowledged shoulders of Feynman.So I went to the Web to find the source, hoping I could then salvage my reputation by persuading Physics Today to print an addendum or erratum. Google gives more than 130 hits containing both "shut up and calculate" and "feynman." Most of these do not directly link the two, but about a dozen do. Here are a few: "Shut up and calculate" was a motto of Richard Feynman.For example, there's Feynman's "shut up and calculate."My personal philosophy is that of the famous physicist Richard Feynman, who said: "Shut up and calculate."When asked which interpretation of QM he favored, Feynman replied "Shut up and calculate."Richard Feynman foreslog ligefrem en "shut up and calculate" fortolkning af kvantemekanikken.Shut up and calculate—Richard Feynman.Just to make sure, I also searched for "shut up and calculate" and "mermin." I found only 10 hits, all of them mentioning me in ways that had nothing to do with their use, elsewhere, of "shut up and calculate." So it would have been clear to the world that I had indeed passed off Feynman's words as my own.Or had I …?I noticed that not a single one of the Web sites attributing the phrase to Feynman cited a source or hinted at the circumstances under which he had said it. A ray of hope flickered on: Could I once again have become a victim of the Matthew effect?The Matthew effect was enunciated by the great sociologist of science, Robert Merton. 1 1. R. K. Merton, Science 159, 56 (1968). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.159.3810.56 Merton worked in those innocent days when sociologists were interested only in the behavior of scientists and not in the content of their science. (To be fair to contemporary sociologists of science, I should modify that last phrase to "and not in the manifestations of that behavior in the content of their science.") I first learned of the Matthew effect more than 20 years ago, on the occasion of my first and, perhaps until now, only, victimization at the hands of the New York Times.I learned the name for what the Times had done to me when I received a very nice note from P. W. Anderson in which he expressed his regret that the newspaper had given him exclusive credit for a nomenclatural advance that was entirely due to me. "A depressingly typical example of the Matthew effect" was how he characterized the misattribution. (I reported the entire history of this contretemps in these pages back in those dark ages [April 1981, page 46] before there were Reference Frame columns.) When I wrote back asking him what the Matthew effect was, he referred me to Merton.It was Merton who identified and named the tendency always to assign exclusive scientific credit to the most eminent among all the plausible candidates. At least I hope it was he, though I'm sure Merton, who invented many wonderful jokes himself, would have been delighted if the credit for it turned out to be misattributed to him. Merton named the effect after the Gospel According to Matthew, because there it is written, For unto every one that hath shall be given, and he shall have abundance: but from him that hath not shall be taken away even that which he hath.—Matthew 25:29.Could the widespread attribution of my wretched witticism to Feynman be another instance of this same deplorable practice? Had I once again been matthewed?Although I didn't say so in my old Reference-Frame article, what inspired this not so terribly bon mot were vivid memories of the responses my conceptual inquiries elicited from my professors—whom I viewed as agents of Copenhagen—when I was first learning quantum mechanics as a graduate student at Harvard, a mere 30 years after the birth of the subject. "You'll never get a PhD if you allow yourself to be distracted by such frivolities," they kept advising me, "so get back to serious business and produce some results." "Shut up," in other words, "and calculate." And so I did, and probably turned out much the better for it. At Harvard, they knew how to administer tough love in those olden days.This bit of history is relevant to the question of whether Feynman's abundance might have been augmented by a portion of the little that I had. Can you imagine the young Feynman ever having had a similar experience that seared "shut up and calculate" into his tender consciousness? No, of course you can't! Nobody could ever have had the slightest reason to direct the best human calculator that ever was to shut up and calculate.But perhaps Feynman was offering such advice to others who were searching for a better understanding of the quantum mechanical formalism. I can't believe that. He said that he "always had a great deal of difficulty understanding the world view that quantum mechanics represents," and added, "I still get nervous with it." 2 2. R. P. Feynman, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 21, 471 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02650179 Nobody who felt that way would ever respond with "shut up and calculate" to conceptual inquiries from the perplexed.Well maybe Feynman, like me, was merely dismissing an interpretive position of others by lampooning it as a "shut up and calculate interpretation." I find this unlikely. For one thing, his strong preference for working things out for himself and, of course, his well-known disdain for philosophy make me doubt that he ever paid much attention to the interpretive positions of others. For another, would one for whom calculation was so effortless and understanding so important be likely to translate anybody's admonition against fruitless speculation into such terms?In short, I suspect that it is only Feynman's habitual irreverence that has linked him in the minds of many to the phrase "shut up and calculate." Who else among the high and mighty—and Merton has taught us that it is only among the high and mighty that people tend to look—could have said it? Albert Einstein? Don't be silly. Erwin Schrödinger? Of course not. Niels Bohr? Don't make me laugh. None of them besides Feynman could have said it. Does that mean that Feynman said it? No!Broaden the search to embrace the low and powerless. Among them am I, who hereby put forth the hypothesis that I was the first to use "shut up and calculate" in the context of quantum foundations. I'm not proud of having said it. It's not a beautiful phrase. It's not very clever. It's snide and mindlessly dismissive. But, damn it, if I'm the one who said it first, then that means I did not, even unconsciously, appropriate the words of Richard Feynman and pass them off as my own. So I have nothing to be ashamed of other than having characterized the Copenhagen interpretation in such foolish terms—a lesser offense than unconscious plagiarism, in my moral bookkeeping.So, dear reader, if you have evidence that Feynman really did say "shut up and calculate," please send it to me. I will not be happy to receive it. I'd rather be a Matthew victim than a plagiarist. But I'd like to know the truth.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. R. K. Merton, Science 159, 56 (1968). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.159.3810.56 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. R. P. Feynman, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 21, 471 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02650179 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2004 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•May 1, 2004•138 citations

On some experiments leading to a revision of the foundations of quantum mechanics

A.B. Datzeff

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B•Sep 1, 1975•6 citations

Photonic sources and detectors for quantum information protocols: A trilogy in eight parts

Radhika Rangarajan

Quantum information processing (QIP) promises to revolutionize existing methods of manipulating data, via truly unique paradigms based on fundamental nonclassical physical phenomenon.However, the eventual success of optical QIP depends critically on the available technologies.Currently, creating multiple-photon states is extremely inefficient because almost no source thus far has been well optimized.Additionally, high-efficiency single-photon detectors can drastically improve multi-photon QIP (typical efficiencies are ~70%).In fact, it has been shown that scalable linear optical quantum computing is possible only if the product of the source and detector efficiencies exceeds ~67%.The research presented here focuses on developing optimized source and detector technologies for enabling scalable QIP.When I greeted the US at seventeen, moved from tropical warmth to a brutal mid-western winter, I learnt harsh life lessons from the minute I landed -tee-shirts and snow don't mix, all of the US doesn't look like New York (thanks Hollywood!), etc. Now, a few years later, I would like to thank all those people who helped me step into foreign lands in the pursuit of knowledge, and made it possible for me to endure these bitter winters, pursue fascinating ventures as well as a few idle thoughts, and of course buy a few-more-than-really-needed wool coats.First and foremost, thanks to the brave lady who boarded me onto that first international flight -Raji.Mom, thank you for letting me go on this adventure!After all these years of formal schooling, you have taught me that the most important lesson in life is to have fun.Thank you for being my best friend, my moral support and my fashion guru.I had a privileged childhood thanks to all my family.Thanks to the smart man who nurtured in me a deep seated love for science, adventure, business and socializing -Ranga Rajan.Dad, you instilled in me a passion for books and travel that helps me remain a poor graduate student -thank you, I know I am richer for the experience!Thanks for the trips to "Landmark" (yes, I really needed five books every time -if it is any consolation to your bank account, it was all those books that led me down this path.).Thanks to my brother Raghav for being smarter and choosing some games in addition to the books.I always wondered why you had more toys than me -if only I had realized then how important it is to diversify my portfolio of assets.It was perhaps because you and dad "altered" my big beautiful doll that I am an experimentalist today, although there might have been better ways to teach the lesson -somehow once she could talk she was never as pretty.I guess this is as good time as any to apologize for wearing your tee-shirts to high school (and taking over your room/ things during every visit home).Somehow your stuff is always cooler.Thanks also for listening to my experimental woes these past few years and sending flashes of insight (and nicknames) my way.Above all, thanks for truly being my big brother and shielding me when needed the most.I have been very lucky to have "uncles" and "aunts" who opened up their homes and hearts to me.Thank you!It was because of you that I could go to my dream high-schools, which were instrumental in making me curiouser and curiouser.The fact that I now have a reverse culture shock every time I visit my hometown is a good measure of how welcome I have felt in the US.This would be impossible without the first real cowboy I met in this country -Travis Dirks.You somehow knew we were meant to be more than just lab partners when we met (you did not say "lab partner") and I couldn't be happier that you were right.You inspire me

•May 20, 2010•2 citations
Over the decade and a half since I wrote the first edition, nothing has altered my belief in the soundness of the overall approach taken here. This is based on the response of teachers, students, and my own occasional rereading of the book. I was generally quite happy with the book, although there were portions where I felt I could have done better and portions which bothered me by their absence. I welcome this opportunity to rectify all that.
Given the number of books that already exist on the subject of quantum mechanics, one would think that the public needs one more as much as it does, say, the latest version of the Table oflntegers. But this does not deter me (as it didn't my predecessors) from trying to circulate my own version of how it ought to be taught. The approach to be presented here (to be described in a moment) was first tried on a group of Harvard undergraduates in the summer of '76, once again in the summer of '77, and more recently at Yale on undergraduates ('77-'78) and graduates ('78- '79) taking a year-long course on the subject.
We choose to examine a phenomenon which is impossible, absolutely impossible, to explain in any classical way, and which has in it the heart of quantum mechanics. In reality, it contains the only mystery. —Richard P. Feynman In this chapter we show that a reformulation of quantum mechanics, namely Feynman's path integral approach, is equivalent to the earlier ones, due to Schrödinger and Heisenberg. We shall introduce and apply it in this chapter to interpret the Aharonov–Bohm effect, which is considered to be a “quantum wonder.” It underscores the importance of electromagnetic potentials. We shall find that in addition to the dynamical phase introduced in Chapter 1, another angle, namely the geometric phase (Pancharatnam–Berry phase), is an important physical property of the wavefunction whose consequences are measurable. 2.1 Propagator: Propagation of a Quantum of Knowledge Notwithstanding the equivalence of wave mechanics and matrix mechanics, Schrödinger and Heisenberg did not appreciate each other's methodologies [1]. In 1926, Schrödinger said: “ I knew of [Heisenberg’s] theory, of course, but I felt discouraged, not to say repelled, by the methods of transcendental algebra, which appeared difficult to me, and by the lack of visualizability. ” Heisenberg's dislike for Schrödinger's wave mechanics was equally intense. In the same year, in a letter to Pauli, he wrote “ The more I think about the physical portion of Schrödinger's theory, the more repulsive I find it…. What Schrödinger writes about the visualizability of his theory ‘is probably not quite right,’ in other words it's crap .” In the mean time, Paul A. M. Dirac, who had made path-breaking contributions [2] in that eventful year (1926) to the formulation of quantum mechanics, had drawn a penetrating analogy [3] between classical and quantum mechanics. Dirac's remark drew the attention of Richard P. Feynman, who used it to build the path integral approach to quantum mechanics based on the variational principle. Feynman was introduced to the principle of extremum action [4] rather early, while in high school. He reveals in his book [5] that “ my Physics teacher … Mr. Bader … told me something … absolutely fascinating…. Every time the subject comes up, I work on it … the principle of least (rather, ‘extremum’) action. ”
Fifteen years ago, I mused in a Reference Frame column on how different generations of physicists differed in the degree to which they thought that the interpretation of quantum mechanics remains a serious problem (Physics Today, Physics Today 0031-9228 42 4 1989 9 https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2810963. April 1989, page 9 ). I declared myself to be among those who feel uncomfortable when asked to articulate what we really think about the quantum theory, adding that "If I were forced to sum up in one sentence what the Copenhagen interpretation says to me, it would be "Shut up and calculate!"In the intervening years, I've come to hold a milder and more nuanced opinion of the Copenhagen view, but that should be the subject of another column. The subject of this one is the habit of misquotation or misattribution that afflicts our profession, a rather different example of which I pointed out a few months ago (February 2004, page 10).Given my capacity for intellectual development ("inconsistency," in the terminology deployed in the current American political season), it's fortunate that I've now reached an age at which I tend to forget about things I've written more than a few years ago. Indeed, I find it downright irritating when somebody asks me questions about papers I wrote a mere half dozen years ago, naively identifying me with the author of those ancient texts. Until quite recently, I had no memory of ever having written such a childishly brusque dismissal of such an exquisitely subtle point of view, much less of having published it in so widely read a venue.This amnesia, combined with the evolution in my thinking that had distanced me from my long forgotten words, may explain why I was initially somewhat puzzled by the slight sensation of discomfort that passed over me when, browsing the e-print archive earlier this year, I read a characterization of Max Born's probability rule as "the favorite ingredient of what has been nicknamed, after Feynman's famous dictum, the shut up and calculate interpretation of quantum mechanics."I yield to nobody in my admiration for Richard Feynman's aphorisms on the nature of quantum mechanics. Indeed, long ago I published a poem (Physics Today, April 1985, page 47) consisting of nothing more than a resetting as verse of a paragraph Feynman had written about his own attitude toward the quantum theory, in his now (but not then) famous article that launched the whole field of quantum computation. I like to think I have devoured everything Feynman ever wrote on the character of quantum mechanics. But while "shut up and calculate" sounded dimly familiar to me as a characterization of a certain interpretive stance, I couldn't recall where Feynman had written it. Mulling this over, a terrible thought began to dawn on me. Could it be that I myself had once used the phrase? If so, then it would appear that I had picked it up from something by Feynman, forgotten the source, and presented it as my own. Devastating!It was devastating because I have a horror of writing or uttering any witticism that is not original with me, unless I make it absolutely clear where and (if known) from whom I got it. I don't even like to tell jokes unless I've made them up myself. (I digress to offer you my favorite:Question: What is the difference between theoretical physics and mathematical physics? Answer: Theoretical physics is done by physicists who lack the necessary skills to do real experiments; mathematical physics is done by mathematicians who lack the necessary skills to do real mathematics. Mathematical physicists tend not to like this joke, but other physicists seem to. Nonphysicists, of course, are entirely immune to its charms.)So with growing trepidation, I searched through my past writings on quantum mechanics. I was dismayed when I came upon my 1989 column, which confirmed my worst fears. Not only had I appropriated without proper attribution a Feynman quote, but it appeared to be a famous one. How humiliating! I was afflicted with visions of knowledgeable Physics Today readers shaking their heads 15 years ago at what must have struck them as my shameless attempt to ride to literary glory on the unacknowledged shoulders of Feynman.So I went to the Web to find the source, hoping I could then salvage my reputation by persuading Physics Today to print an addendum or erratum. Google gives more than 130 hits containing both "shut up and calculate" and "feynman." Most of these do not directly link the two, but about a dozen do. Here are a few: "Shut up and calculate" was a motto of Richard Feynman.For example, there's Feynman's "shut up and calculate."My personal philosophy is that of the famous physicist Richard Feynman, who said: "Shut up and calculate."When asked which interpretation of QM he favored, Feynman replied "Shut up and calculate."Richard Feynman foreslog ligefrem en "shut up and calculate" fortolkning af kvantemekanikken.Shut up and calculate—Richard Feynman.Just to make sure, I also searched for "shut up and calculate" and "mermin." I found only 10 hits, all of them mentioning me in ways that had nothing to do with their use, elsewhere, of "shut up and calculate." So it would have been clear to the world that I had indeed passed off Feynman's words as my own.Or had I …?I noticed that not a single one of the Web sites attributing the phrase to Feynman cited a source or hinted at the circumstances under which he had said it. A ray of hope flickered on: Could I once again have become a victim of the Matthew effect?The Matthew effect was enunciated by the great sociologist of science, Robert Merton. 1 1. R. K. Merton, Science 159, 56 (1968). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.159.3810.56 Merton worked in those innocent days when sociologists were interested only in the behavior of scientists and not in the content of their science. (To be fair to contemporary sociologists of science, I should modify that last phrase to "and not in the manifestations of that behavior in the content of their science.") I first learned of the Matthew effect more than 20 years ago, on the occasion of my first and, perhaps until now, only, victimization at the hands of the New York Times.I learned the name for what the Times had done to me when I received a very nice note from P. W. Anderson in which he expressed his regret that the newspaper had given him exclusive credit for a nomenclatural advance that was entirely due to me. "A depressingly typical example of the Matthew effect" was how he characterized the misattribution. (I reported the entire history of this contretemps in these pages back in those dark ages [April 1981, page 46] before there were Reference Frame columns.) When I wrote back asking him what the Matthew effect was, he referred me to Merton.It was Merton who identified and named the tendency always to assign exclusive scientific credit to the most eminent among all the plausible candidates. At least I hope it was he, though I'm sure Merton, who invented many wonderful jokes himself, would have been delighted if the credit for it turned out to be misattributed to him. Merton named the effect after the Gospel According to Matthew, because there it is written, For unto every one that hath shall be given, and he shall have abundance: but from him that hath not shall be taken away even that which he hath.—Matthew 25:29.Could the widespread attribution of my wretched witticism to Feynman be another instance of this same deplorable practice? Had I once again been matthewed?Although I didn't say so in my old Reference-Frame article, what inspired this not so terribly bon mot were vivid memories of the responses my conceptual inquiries elicited from my professors—whom I viewed as agents of Copenhagen—when I was first learning quantum mechanics as a graduate student at Harvard, a mere 30 years after the birth of the subject. "You'll never get a PhD if you allow yourself to be distracted by such frivolities," they kept advising me, "so get back to serious business and produce some results." "Shut up," in other words, "and calculate." And so I did, and probably turned out much the better for it. At Harvard, they knew how to administer tough love in those olden days.This bit of history is relevant to the question of whether Feynman's abundance might have been augmented by a portion of the little that I had. Can you imagine the young Feynman ever having had a similar experience that seared "shut up and calculate" into his tender consciousness? No, of course you can't! Nobody could ever have had the slightest reason to direct the best human calculator that ever was to shut up and calculate.But perhaps Feynman was offering such advice to others who were searching for a better understanding of the quantum mechanical formalism. I can't believe that. He said that he "always had a great deal of difficulty understanding the world view that quantum mechanics represents," and added, "I still get nervous with it." 2 2. R. P. Feynman, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 21, 471 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02650179 Nobody who felt that way would ever respond with "shut up and calculate" to conceptual inquiries from the perplexed.Well maybe Feynman, like me, was merely dismissing an interpretive position of others by lampooning it as a "shut up and calculate interpretation." I find this unlikely. For one thing, his strong preference for working things out for himself and, of course, his well-known disdain for philosophy make me doubt that he ever paid much attention to the interpretive positions of others. For another, would one for whom calculation was so effortless and understanding so important be likely to translate anybody's admonition against fruitless speculation into such terms?In short, I suspect that it is only Feynman's habitual irreverence that has linked him in the minds of many to the phrase "shut up and calculate." Who else among the high and mighty—and Merton has taught us that it is only among the high and mighty that people tend to look—could have said it? Albert Einstein? Don't be silly. Erwin Schrödinger? Of course not. Niels Bohr? Don't make me laugh. None of them besides Feynman could have said it. Does that mean that Feynman said it? No!Broaden the search to embrace the low and powerless. Among them am I, who hereby put forth the hypothesis that I was the first to use "shut up and calculate" in the context of quantum foundations. I'm not proud of having said it. It's not a beautiful phrase. It's not very clever. It's snide and mindlessly dismissive. But, damn it, if I'm the one who said it first, then that means I did not, even unconsciously, appropriate the words of Richard Feynman and pass them off as my own. So I have nothing to be ashamed of other than having characterized the Copenhagen interpretation in such foolish terms—a lesser offense than unconscious plagiarism, in my moral bookkeeping.So, dear reader, if you have evidence that Feynman really did say "shut up and calculate," please send it to me. I will not be happy to receive it. I'd rather be a Matthew victim than a plagiarist. But I'd like to know the truth.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. R. K. Merton, Science 159, 56 (1968). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.159.3810.56 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. R. P. Feynman, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 21, 471 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02650179 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2004 American Institute of Physics.
Quantum information processing (QIP) promises to revolutionize existing methods of manipulating data, via truly unique paradigms based on fundamental nonclassical physical phenomenon.However, the eventual success of optical QIP depends critically on the available technologies.Currently, creating multiple-photon states is extremely inefficient because almost no source thus far has been well optimized.Additionally, high-efficiency single-photon detectors can drastically improve multi-photon QIP (typical efficiencies are ~70%).In fact, it has been shown that scalable linear optical quantum computing is possible only if the product of the source and detector efficiencies exceeds ~67%.The research presented here focuses on developing optimized source and detector technologies for enabling scalable QIP.When I greeted the US at seventeen, moved from tropical warmth to a brutal mid-western winter, I learnt harsh life lessons from the minute I landed -tee-shirts and snow don't mix, all of the US doesn't look like New York (thanks Hollywood!), etc. Now, a few years later, I would like to thank all those people who helped me step into foreign lands in the pursuit of knowledge, and made it possible for me to endure these bitter winters, pursue fascinating ventures as well as a few idle thoughts, and of course buy a few-more-than-really-needed wool coats.First and foremost, thanks to the brave lady who boarded me onto that first international flight -Raji.Mom, thank you for letting me go on this adventure!After all these years of formal schooling, you have taught me that the most important lesson in life is to have fun.Thank you for being my best friend, my moral support and my fashion guru.I had a privileged childhood thanks to all my family.Thanks to the smart man who nurtured in me a deep seated love for science, adventure, business and socializing -Ranga Rajan.Dad, you instilled in me a passion for books and travel that helps me remain a poor graduate student -thank you, I know I am richer for the experience!Thanks for the trips to "Landmark" (yes, I really needed five books every time -if it is any consolation to your bank account, it was all those books that led me down this path.).Thanks to my brother Raghav for being smarter and choosing some games in addition to the books.I always wondered why you had more toys than me -if only I had realized then how important it is to diversify my portfolio of assets.It was perhaps because you and dad "altered" my big beautiful doll that I am an experimentalist today, although there might have been better ways to teach the lesson -somehow once she could talk she was never as pretty.I guess this is as good time as any to apologize for wearing your tee-shirts to high school (and taking over your room/ things during every visit home).Somehow your stuff is always cooler.Thanks also for listening to my experimental woes these past few years and sending flashes of insight (and nicknames) my way.Above all, thanks for truly being my big brother and shielding me when needed the most.I have been very lucky to have "uncles" and "aunts" who opened up their homes and hearts to me.Thank you!It was because of you that I could go to my dream high-schools, which were instrumental in making me curiouser and curiouser.The fact that I now have a reverse culture shock every time I visit my hometown is a good measure of how welcome I have felt in the US.This would be impossible without the first real cowboy I met in this country -Travis Dirks.You somehow knew we were meant to be more than just lab partners when we met (you did not say "lab partner") and I couldn't be happier that you were right.You inspire me