Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Anderson localization: the naïve view of an AMO experimentalist

Alain Aspect

Published Sep 15, 2008• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Related papers

Bell’s Theorem: The Naive View of an Experimentalist

Alain Aspect

arXiv:quant-ph/0402001•Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2002•151 citations

Penetrating the Quantum Limit: The Experimentalists’ View

M. D. Levenson, Robert M. Shelby

Springer proceedings in physics•Jan 1, 1986•1 citation

Energy transfer and Anderson localization

R. Orbach

Physics Letters A•Jul 1, 1974•19 citations

Anderson localization with correlated disorder

M. D. Stephens, James L. Skinner

Chemical Physics•Dec 1, 1993•3 citations

Peer review Bell's Theorem - The Naive View of an Experimentalist Alain Aspect

Livolsi Edoardo

This work presents a critical peer review of Alain Aspect's Bell's Theorem: The Naive View of an Experimentalist from the perspective of foundational theoretical physics. While recognizing the manuscript as a landmark historical and experimental contribution to quantum optics, the review examines its underlying logical architecture rather than its experimental methodology. It is argued that the central ingredients of the analysis—including the entangled state, hidden variables, probability measure, locality condition, subsystem separability, and wavefunction collapse—are introduced as axiomatic assumptions rather than derived from a more fundamental physical principle. Consequently, the observed violation of Bell inequalities establishes the incompatibility of quantum mechanics with a restricted class of local hidden-variable theories, but does not uniquely determine the ontological structure of physical reality. The review distinguishes experimental validation from foundational derivation and emphasizes that alternative theoretical architectures based on globally coherent fields or emergent non-separable dynamics remain logically outside the scope of Bell's theorem. The manuscript is therefore assessed as an outstanding experimental milestone whose foundational conclusions remain structurally incomplete.

•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Deterministic Interpretation of the Malus Law and Correlation in Experiments with Entangled Photons

Александр Иванович Гончаров

This paper examines a local deterministic model of an experiment involving correlated photons. The experimental setup involves a source that emits two linearly polarized photons in each act, two two-channel analyzers, and detectors included in the coincidence scheme. The orientation angle of the photon polarization plane is a random variable with a uniform distribution, and it is the same for simultaneously emitted photons. The model presented here is a generalization of the “naive example of hidden variable theory” described in A. Aspect's article ‘Bell's Theorem: The Naive View of an Experimentalist. In our model, the outcome of the photon interaction with the analyzer (hit in one of the two channels) is uniquely determined by the angle between the photon polarization plane and the analyzer axis and is described by a step function. The difference in our model is that the step function contains a large number of segments of different lengths. The location and lengths of the segments are set so that the probability of a photon hitting a specific channel of an ideal analyzer, determined by averaging the outcomes over small neighborhoods of angles, approaches the Malus law when the maximum length of a segment decreases. This ensures that the classical model is self-consistent. When ideal analyzers are used, the absolute value of the correlation coefficient of detector readings mainly does not exceed the values from Aspect's ‘naive example’. However, when analyzers with absorption are used, the calculated correlations for some orientations of the analyzers exceed the quantum mechanical values. Key words: linear polarization of photons, Malus law, entangled photons, correlations, hidden parameters.

Izvestiya of Altai State University•Mar 28, 2023•2 citations
This work presents a critical peer review of Alain Aspect's Bell's Theorem: The Naive View of an Experimentalist from the perspective of foundational theoretical physics. While recognizing the manuscript as a landmark historical and experimental contribution to quantum optics, the review examines its underlying logical architecture rather than its experimental methodology. It is argued that the central ingredients of the analysis—including the entangled state, hidden variables, probability measure, locality condition, subsystem separability, and wavefunction collapse—are introduced as axiomatic assumptions rather than derived from a more fundamental physical principle. Consequently, the observed violation of Bell inequalities establishes the incompatibility of quantum mechanics with a restricted class of local hidden-variable theories, but does not uniquely determine the ontological structure of physical reality. The review distinguishes experimental validation from foundational derivation and emphasizes that alternative theoretical architectures based on globally coherent fields or emergent non-separable dynamics remain logically outside the scope of Bell's theorem. The manuscript is therefore assessed as an outstanding experimental milestone whose foundational conclusions remain structurally incomplete.
This paper examines a local deterministic model of an experiment involving correlated photons. The experimental setup involves a source that emits two linearly polarized photons in each act, two two-channel analyzers, and detectors included in the coincidence scheme. The orientation angle of the photon polarization plane is a random variable with a uniform distribution, and it is the same for simultaneously emitted photons. The model presented here is a generalization of the “naive example of hidden variable theory” described in A. Aspect's article ‘Bell's Theorem: The Naive View of an Experimentalist. In our model, the outcome of the photon interaction with the analyzer (hit in one of the two channels) is uniquely determined by the angle between the photon polarization plane and the analyzer axis and is described by a step function. The difference in our model is that the step function contains a large number of segments of different lengths. The location and lengths of the segments are set so that the probability of a photon hitting a specific channel of an ideal analyzer, determined by averaging the outcomes over small neighborhoods of angles, approaches the Malus law when the maximum length of a segment decreases. This ensures that the classical model is self-consistent. When ideal analyzers are used, the absolute value of the correlation coefficient of detector readings mainly does not exceed the values from Aspect's ‘naive example’. However, when analyzers with absorption are used, the calculated correlations for some orientations of the analyzers exceed the quantum mechanical values. Key words: linear polarization of photons, Malus law, entangled photons, correlations, hidden parameters.