Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Metrologia

Coherent fiber links operated for years: effect of missing data

Mads Tønnes, F. Schüller, Etienne Cantin, Olivier Lopez, Rodolphe Le Targat, Anne Amy‐Klein, Paul-Éric Pottie

Published Sep 21, 2022• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Aiming at delivering a highly available service, the French national optical fiber link network is run mostly unmanned and automatically, with the help of a global supervision. However, at a year scale, missing data are seemingly unavoidable. Here, we present a first study of the uncertainty of coherent fiber links with missing data. We present the tools to assess statistical properties for processes which are not strictly stationary, and a simulation of optical fiber links depending only on a handful of parameters. We show how missing data affects the phase-coherent optical fiber links, and how to mitigate the issue with a fill-in procedure that preserves the statistical properties. We apply the method for a 5 years-long data set of a 1410 km long fiber link. Second, we apply the method to the case of optical clock comparisons, where the downtimes of the optical clocks degrade the coherence of the links. We show that our methodology of processing the missing data is robust and converges to consistent mean values, even with very low uptimes. We present an offset and uncertainty contribution from the French fiber network of 2.4 (9.0) × 10−20, that is an improvement by a factor 5 as compared to a processing without taking the effect of missing data into account.

DOI
10.1088/1681-7575/ac938e

Related papers

Scientific Data Processing of a Fiber Network for Optical Frequency Transfer: Methods and Studies

Mads Tønnes, Etienne Cantin, Dan Xu +3 more

In recent years, the use of optical frequency dissemination through telecommunication fibers has steadily grown both in the context of stateof-the-art metrology like optical clocks and in the use of ultrastable reference signals for precision measurements in other fields of physics or earth science.Evaluating the performance of the fiber link can be difficult, as outliers and dysfunctioning regions lead to missing data.In this article, we discuss these challenges and investigate three different approaches to dealing with the missing data of a 1410-km-long optical link.We find a benefit in replacing the missing data with simulated noise with a statistical behavior similar to that of the original signal.

URSI Radio Science Letters•Jan 1, 2021•4 citations

Validating frequency transfer via interferometric fiber links for optical clock comparisons

Sebastian Koke, Erik Benkler, Alexander Kühl +1 more

Abstract We investigate the validation of fiber-based optical frequency transfer for frequency comparison applications. We specifically consider the frequency transfer validation for remote optical clock comparisons and want to ensure interferometric fiber link uncertainty contributions below the combined uncertainty of the clocks under test. The validation is based on signals obtained via looping back from the remote end to the sender site and comparing the input with the output of the loop. These loop-back data need to be averaged over intervals for reaching the validation goal, as the short-term instability of long-distance interferometric fiber links is typically higher than that of optical clocks. We introduce a two-step validation approach and address the finding of a compromise between opposing aspects of averaging: reaching low uncertainties versus achieving a high data coverage of the validated data set via a high temporal resolution of the fault identification. We discuss the impact of different averaging types and of the tolerance of filtering criteria on the achievable estimated uncertainty and on the coverage of the validated data set. Data from four multiple-week-long measurement campaigns on the fiber link between Physikalisch-Technische Bundesansanstalt and University of Strasbourg are used for this assessment.

New Journal of Physics•Aug 26, 2021•11 citations

First industrial-grade coherent fiber link for optical frequency standard dissemination

Fabiola A. Camargo, Vincent Ménoret, Etienne Cantin +10 more

. No shift is observed within the statistical uncertainty. We show a continuous operation over five days with an uptime of 99.93%. This performance is comparable with the state-of-the-art coherent links established by National Metrology Institutes in Europe. It is a first step in the construction of an optical fiber network for metrology in France, which will give access to an ultrahigh performance frequency standard to a wide community of scientific users.

arXiv:1909.08055•Applied Optics•Aug 23, 2018•54 citations

Improving Accuracy of Optical Frequency Transfer Over Non-Modified DWDM Optical Networks

Przemysław Krehlik, Krzysztof Turza, Łukasz Śliwczyński +1 more

Dedicated fiber links become the more precise and desirable mean for comparing optical clocks and for optical frequency transfer at distances up to a few thousands kilometers. The need of installing special equipment along the link, and usually renting fibers exclusively for frequency transfer, cause that this preferable solution is cumbersome and expensive, and so accessible in severely limited range. In this paper we propose an improved method for comparing optical clocks with use of standard (i.e. not modified for this purpose) DWDM optical telecommunication network. The proposed solution is based on identified correlation between residual phase noise present in a DWDM-based optical frequency transfer and the in-loop phase correcting signal, which can be easily registered and used for improving the comparison accuracy by means of data postprocessing. As we demonstrated, using the proposed method the clocks comparison, uncertainty may be reduced to well below 1×10-16for link length in range of 1500 km.

Journal of Lightwave Technology•Oct 2, 2025•1 citation

Optical fiber link for ultra-stable frequency dissemination and atomic clock comparisons

Anne Amy‐Klein, Nicolas Quintin, N. Chiodo +42 more

The transfer of ultra-stable frequencies between distant laboratories is required by many applications from fundamental metrology to high-precision measurements. For that purpose, optical fibre links have been intensively studied over the last decade. They have demonstrated impressive results far beyond the GPS capabilities on distances up to 2000 km, thanks to an active compensation of the fiber propagation noise.Up to now, optical links has been mainly implemented between two labs, when future applications will require the development of metrological fiber networks. Towards this goal, we have developed a few techniques which allow us to distribute the ultrastable optical signal to many users simultaneously. We have designed repeater laser stations, which can be used to build a cascaded link or to distribute the ultrastable signal among two optical links [1]. These stations allow us also to compare the output end signals of two optical links. These versatile stations will be a key-component of the national metrological network currently being developed in France within the Refimeve+ project. To complete the network, we have demonstrated the extraction of the ultrastable signal from a main link and its seeding to a secondary link [2].Optical links are already been successfully used for clocks comparison. Recently we were able to compare the atomic clocks of the French and German National Metrology Institutes through two connected optical links of total length 1415-km [3]. We found that the two fully independent Sr lattice optical clocks at the two sites agreed to better than 5x10-17 limited only by the clocks uncertainties. A fractional statistical uncertainty of 3x10-17 was reached after only 1000 s averaging time, which is 10 times better, and more than four orders of magnitude faster than with any other existing frequency transfer method. The atomic fountain primary frequency standards from the two institutes were also compared and they were found to agree well within their combined uncertainties of a few 10-16 [4].

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Optical frequency transfer with a 1284 km coherent fiber link

Davide Calonico, Elio K. Bertacco, Claudio Eligio Calosso +10 more

We realized a coherent optical fiber link in Italy, with a fiber haul of 642 km. To characterize the link, we doubled the link to 1284 km, demonstrating a characterization technique based on the double round trip on a single fiber. The link is intended to significantly improve the frequency references used in radio-astronomy and precision measurements in atomic physics. The data analysis is based on the Allan deviation, whose expression is theoretically derived from the noise power spectrum. The demonstrated resolution is 3×10−19 in 1000 s and the uncertainty of the transfer is 5×10−19. The arming of a second fiber is avoided, and this could be rather beneficial to long hauls realizations for a continental fiber network for frequency and time metrology.

European Frequency and Time Forum•Jun 1, 2014•10 citations
Abstract Aiming at delivering a highly available service, the French national optical fiber link network is run mostly unmanned and automatically, with the help of a global supervision. However, at a year scale, missing data are seemingly unavoidable. Here, we present a first study of the uncertainty of coherent fiber links with missing data. We present the tools to assess statistical properties for processes which are not strictly stationary, and a simulation of optical fiber links depending only on a handful of parameters. We show how missing data affects the phase-coherent optical fiber links, and how to mitigate the issue with a fill-in procedure that preserves the statistical properties. We apply the method for a 5 years-long data set of a 1410 km long fiber link. Second, we apply the method to the case of optical clock comparisons, where the downtimes of the optical clocks degrade the coherence of the links. We show that our methodology of processing the missing data is robust and converges to consistent mean values, even with very low uptimes. We present an offset and uncertainty contribution from the French fiber network of 2.4 (9.0) × 10−20, that is an improvement by a factor 5 as compared to a processing without taking the effect of missing data into account.
In recent years, the use of optical frequency dissemination through telecommunication fibers has steadily grown both in the context of stateof-the-art metrology like optical clocks and in the use of ultrastable reference signals for precision measurements in other fields of physics or earth science.Evaluating the performance of the fiber link can be difficult, as outliers and dysfunctioning regions lead to missing data.In this article, we discuss these challenges and investigate three different approaches to dealing with the missing data of a 1410-km-long optical link.We find a benefit in replacing the missing data with simulated noise with a statistical behavior similar to that of the original signal.
Abstract We investigate the validation of fiber-based optical frequency transfer for frequency comparison applications. We specifically consider the frequency transfer validation for remote optical clock comparisons and want to ensure interferometric fiber link uncertainty contributions below the combined uncertainty of the clocks under test. The validation is based on signals obtained via looping back from the remote end to the sender site and comparing the input with the output of the loop. These loop-back data need to be averaged over intervals for reaching the validation goal, as the short-term instability of long-distance interferometric fiber links is typically higher than that of optical clocks. We introduce a two-step validation approach and address the finding of a compromise between opposing aspects of averaging: reaching low uncertainties versus achieving a high data coverage of the validated data set via a high temporal resolution of the fault identification. We discuss the impact of different averaging types and of the tolerance of filtering criteria on the achievable estimated uncertainty and on the coverage of the validated data set. Data from four multiple-week-long measurement campaigns on the fiber link between Physikalisch-Technische Bundesansanstalt and University of Strasbourg are used for this assessment.
Dedicated fiber links become the more precise and desirable mean for comparing optical clocks and for optical frequency transfer at distances up to a few thousands kilometers. The need of installing special equipment along the link, and usually renting fibers exclusively for frequency transfer, cause that this preferable solution is cumbersome and expensive, and so accessible in severely limited range. In this paper we propose an improved method for comparing optical clocks with use of standard (i.e. not modified for this purpose) DWDM optical telecommunication network. The proposed solution is based on identified correlation between residual phase noise present in a DWDM-based optical frequency transfer and the in-loop phase correcting signal, which can be easily registered and used for improving the comparison accuracy by means of data postprocessing. As we demonstrated, using the proposed method the clocks comparison, uncertainty may be reduced to well below 1×10-16for link length in range of 1500 km.
The transfer of ultra-stable frequencies between distant laboratories is required by many applications from fundamental metrology to high-precision measurements. For that purpose, optical fibre links have been intensively studied over the last decade. They have demonstrated impressive results far beyond the GPS capabilities on distances up to 2000 km, thanks to an active compensation of the fiber propagation noise.Up to now, optical links has been mainly implemented between two labs, when future applications will require the development of metrological fiber networks. Towards this goal, we have developed a few techniques which allow us to distribute the ultrastable optical signal to many users simultaneously. We have designed repeater laser stations, which can be used to build a cascaded link or to distribute the ultrastable signal among two optical links [1]. These stations allow us also to compare the output end signals of two optical links. These versatile stations will be a key-component of the national metrological network currently being developed in France within the Refimeve+ project. To complete the network, we have demonstrated the extraction of the ultrastable signal from a main link and its seeding to a secondary link [2].Optical links are already been successfully used for clocks comparison. Recently we were able to compare the atomic clocks of the French and German National Metrology Institutes through two connected optical links of total length 1415-km [3]. We found that the two fully independent Sr lattice optical clocks at the two sites agreed to better than 5x10-17 limited only by the clocks uncertainties. A fractional statistical uncertainty of 3x10-17 was reached after only 1000 s averaging time, which is 10 times better, and more than four orders of magnitude faster than with any other existing frequency transfer method. The atomic fountain primary frequency standards from the two institutes were also compared and they were found to agree well within their combined uncertainties of a few 10-16 [4].
We realized a coherent optical fiber link in Italy, with a fiber haul of 642 km. To characterize the link, we doubled the link to 1284 km, demonstrating a characterization technique based on the double round trip on a single fiber. The link is intended to significantly improve the frequency references used in radio-astronomy and precision measurements in atomic physics. The data analysis is based on the Allan deviation, whose expression is theoretically derived from the noise power spectrum. The demonstrated resolution is 3×10−19 in 1000 s and the uncertainty of the transfer is 5×10−19. The arming of a second fiber is avoided, and this could be rather beneficial to long hauls realizations for a continental fiber network for frequency and time metrology.