Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Applied

Measurement of the Low-Temperature Loss Tangent of High-Resistivity Silicon Using a High- Q Superconducting Resonator

Mattia Checchin, D. Frolov, Andrei Lunin, Anna Grassellino, Alexander Romanenko

Published Sep 7, 2022• 33 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Even though silicon is widely used in superconducting quantum processors as the substrate upon which qubits are fabricated, the effect of silicon on the performance of the qubits is not fully understood. Using ultrahigh-quality microwave cavities to measure dielectric loss with parts-per-billion precision, the authors clearly show that using silicon is detrimental to qubit coherence time. The loss tangent found here is an order of magnitude worse than previously measured. This study sheds light on the physical mechanisms behind dissipation in silicon, and highlights the need for further work to fully understand the origin of these losses, and how to mitigate them.

DOI
10.1103/physrevapplied.18.034013

Related papers

Measurement of the Low-Temperature Loss Tangent of High-resistivity Silicon Wafers with High-Q Superconducting Resonators

Mattia Checchin, D. Frolov, Andrei Lunin +2 more

In this Letter, we present the first direct loss tangent measurement of high resistivity (100) silicon wafers in the temperature range ~70 mK to 1 K. The measurement was performed by means of an innovative resonant technique taking advantage of a high quality factor superconducting niobium resonator, that allows to achieve unprecedented level of accuracy. We report Si loss tangent values at the lowest temperature one order of magnitude larger than what typically expected, and we observe non-monotonic trend of the loss tangent as a function of temperature. With this study, we established a new capability to directly measure the loss tangent of insulating materials with high accuracy and precision. This technique will allow to identify substrates and materials with low losses aiming to maximize coherence in quantum devices.

•Aug 19, 2021•2 citations

Measurement of the Low-temperature Loss Tangent of High-resistivity Silicon with a High Q-factor Superconducting Resonator

Mattia Checchin, Frolov, Daniil, Andrei Lunin +2 more

In this letter, we present the direct loss tangent measurement of a high-resistivity intrinsic (100) silicon wafer in the temperature range from ~ 70 mK to 1 K, approaching the quantum regime. The measurement was performed using a technique that takes advantage of a high quality factor superconducting niobium resonator and allows to directly measure the loss tangent of insulating materials with high level of accuracy and precision. We report silicon loss tangent values at the lowest temperature and for electric field amplitudes comparable to those found in planar transmon devices one order of magnitude larger than what was previously estimated. In addition, we discover a non-monotonic trend of the loss tangent as a function of temperature that we describe by means of a phenomenological model based on variable range hopping conduction between localized states around the Fermi energy. We also observe that the dissipation increases as a function of the electric field and that this behavior can be qualitatively described by the variable range hopping conduction mechanism as well. This study lays the foundations for a novel approach to investigate the loss mechanisms and accurately estimate the loss tangent in insulating materials in the quantum regime, leading to a better understanding of coherence in quantum devices.

arXiv:2108.08894•Aug 19, 2021•5 citations

Origins of microwave losses in superconducting circuits made with silicon-on-insulator substrates

Simon Messelot, Nicolas Aparicio, Kazi Rafsanjani Amin +11 more

Silicon-on-insulator technology is widely used to fabricate silicon based devices, from advanced transistors to photonic circuits or nanomechanical systems. Integrating low loss superconducting quantum circuits with silicon-on-insulator substrates enables to couple the advantages offered by the mature silicon technology to the exquisite sensitivity of superconducting circuits. The natural approach, inherited from research in superconducting microwave devices, is to use a substrate made with highly resistive silicon, known for its low level of microwave losses. In this work, using superconducting microwave resonators, we show that counterintuitively, standard resistivity silicon-on-insulator substrates perform better than high resistivity silicon-on-insulator substrates at cryogenic temperatures. In the latter case, the presence of a parasitic sheet conduction at the interface between bulk silicon and silicon oxide acts as the dominant loss mechanism. This parasitic sheet can be suppressed using substrates with intentionally induced traps. In such substrates, losses are ultimately limited by the dielectric losses of the silicon oxide layer. These substrates offer interesting perspectives for the development of superconducting nanoelectromechanical systems. First, the release, i.e. the removal of the silicon oxide, could be limited to the moving parts, thereby maintaining the mechanical integrity of the rest of the device. Additionally, such structure would enhance heat evacuation into the bulk of the substrate which is an issue in current devices such as microwave-to-optics converters.

cond-mat.mes-hallCross-listedarXiv:2607.29154•Aug 3, 2026•0 citations

Precision Measurement of the Microwave Dielectric Loss of Sapphire in the Quantum Regime with Parts-per-Billion Sensitivity

Alexander P. Read, Benjamin J. Chapman, Chan U Lei +5 more

To better understand decoherence in superconducting qubits, the authors develop a technique to measure the loss tangent of dielectric substrates and predict the impact of dielectric loss on qubit lifetimes. This is done with no need to fabricate planar devices; the technique is independent of material platform. Measurements of sapphire in a demonstration of the approach suggest that coherence of superconducting qubits on a common form of sapphire is limited significantly by bulk dielectric loss. The same technique also shows that another form of sapphire would substantially mitigate this bulk dielectric loss and prolong qubit coherence.

arXiv:2206.14334•Physical Review Applied•Mar 20, 2023•58 citations

Ultra-high Q-factor superconducting tantalum resonators on 300 mm Si wafers

R. Acharya, D. Perez Lozano, Ts. Ivanov +13 more

Superconducting resonators are central to superconducting quantum information technologies and essential for bosonic qubit architectures, where long-lived storage modes enable hardware-efficient error correction. Achieving ultra-high quality factors in scalable planar circuits is challenging because multiple dissipation channels contribute to the total loss. Here we report planar $α$-Ta resonators fabricated on 300 mm ultra-high-resistivity ($>10$ k$Ω$ cm) intrinsic silicon using industrial processes, achieving median internal Q factors exceeding 40 million and maxima above 60 million. Energy-participation-ratio analysis identifies a dominant participation-controlled interface loss mechanism and places conservative upper bounds on substrate-associated dissipation. For the best-performing substrate, the inferred substrate loss tangent is below $1.0 \times 10^{-8}$, establishing industrial MCZ silicon among the lowest-loss substrate platforms reported for superconducting resonators. At the same time, the exceptionally low losses show no clear correlation with commonly cited silicon substrate metrics such as room-temperature resistivity or impurity concentrations. More broadly, these studies establish industrial 300 mm processing, careful interface engineering, and 300 mm MCZ silicon substrates as a promising platform for resonator-heavy superconducting quantum architectures with ultra-high quality factors.

quant-pharXiv:2606.10719•Jun 10, 2026•4 citations

Investigation of Dielectric Losses in Hydrogenated Amorphoussilicon (a-Si:H) thin Films Using Superconducting Microwave Resonators

Alessandro Bruno, Sebastian T. Skacel, Ch. Kaiser +4 more

The improvement of the coherence times of superconducting qubits depends on the reduction of the dielectric losses in the insulating materials implemented for the device fabrication. These losses depend on the density of spurious dipoles of different nature (two-level systems, TLSs) which couple to phase qubits and, hence, limit their coherence times. Hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H), because of its lower loss tangent (tan δ) among conventional dielectrics (a-SiO, a-SiO2, a-SiNx:H), is considered as the best amorphous dielectric for superconducting qubit application. We have developed a reliable method for the direct measurement of dielectric losses in amorphous dielectric thin films using a novel design based on four lumped superconducting LC resonators connected in series without coupling capacitors. The losses are obtained as tan δ = 1/Q0, where Q0 is the intrinsic quality factor of the resonator, measured at 3 dB above the resonance frequency without any fitting procedure. The series type LC resonators with a-Si:H as dielectric were fabricated by the Nb technology. The measurements were done at the conditions of a qubit application (0.5 -10 GHz frequency range and low temperatures). The low values of the loss tangent of a-Si:H (up to 2.5 x 10−5 at 4.2 K) have required the development of superconducting housing for the resonators in order to eliminate a spurious dependence of tan δ on the microwave power, by reducing losses which were not originated in the dielectric itself. The results of the simulations agree well with the experiments.

Physics Procedia•Jan 1, 2012•8 citations
Even though silicon is widely used in superconducting quantum processors as the substrate upon which qubits are fabricated, the effect of silicon on the performance of the qubits is not fully understood. Using ultrahigh-quality microwave cavities to measure dielectric loss with parts-per-billion precision, the authors clearly show that using silicon is detrimental to qubit coherence time. The loss tangent found here is an order of magnitude worse than previously measured. This study sheds light on the physical mechanisms behind dissipation in silicon, and highlights the need for further work to fully understand the origin of these losses, and how to mitigate them.
In this Letter, we present the first direct loss tangent measurement of high resistivity (100) silicon wafers in the temperature range ~70 mK to 1 K. The measurement was performed by means of an innovative resonant technique taking advantage of a high quality factor superconducting niobium resonator, that allows to achieve unprecedented level of accuracy. We report Si loss tangent values at the lowest temperature one order of magnitude larger than what typically expected, and we observe non-monotonic trend of the loss tangent as a function of temperature. With this study, we established a new capability to directly measure the loss tangent of insulating materials with high accuracy and precision. This technique will allow to identify substrates and materials with low losses aiming to maximize coherence in quantum devices.
In this letter, we present the direct loss tangent measurement of a high-resistivity intrinsic (100) silicon wafer in the temperature range from ~ 70 mK to 1 K, approaching the quantum regime. The measurement was performed using a technique that takes advantage of a high quality factor superconducting niobium resonator and allows to directly measure the loss tangent of insulating materials with high level of accuracy and precision. We report silicon loss tangent values at the lowest temperature and for electric field amplitudes comparable to those found in planar transmon devices one order of magnitude larger than what was previously estimated. In addition, we discover a non-monotonic trend of the loss tangent as a function of temperature that we describe by means of a phenomenological model based on variable range hopping conduction between localized states around the Fermi energy. We also observe that the dissipation increases as a function of the electric field and that this behavior can be qualitatively described by the variable range hopping conduction mechanism as well. This study lays the foundations for a novel approach to investigate the loss mechanisms and accurately estimate the loss tangent in insulating materials in the quantum regime, leading to a better understanding of coherence in quantum devices.
Silicon-on-insulator technology is widely used to fabricate silicon based devices, from advanced transistors to photonic circuits or nanomechanical systems. Integrating low loss superconducting quantum circuits with silicon-on-insulator substrates enables to couple the advantages offered by the mature silicon technology to the exquisite sensitivity of superconducting circuits. The natural approach, inherited from research in superconducting microwave devices, is to use a substrate made with highly resistive silicon, known for its low level of microwave losses. In this work, using superconducting microwave resonators, we show that counterintuitively, standard resistivity silicon-on-insulator substrates perform better than high resistivity silicon-on-insulator substrates at cryogenic temperatures. In the latter case, the presence of a parasitic sheet conduction at the interface between bulk silicon and silicon oxide acts as the dominant loss mechanism. This parasitic sheet can be suppressed using substrates with intentionally induced traps. In such substrates, losses are ultimately limited by the dielectric losses of the silicon oxide layer. These substrates offer interesting perspectives for the development of superconducting nanoelectromechanical systems. First, the release, i.e. the removal of the silicon oxide, could be limited to the moving parts, thereby maintaining the mechanical integrity of the rest of the device. Additionally, such structure would enhance heat evacuation into the bulk of the substrate which is an issue in current devices such as microwave-to-optics converters.
To better understand decoherence in superconducting qubits, the authors develop a technique to measure the loss tangent of dielectric substrates and predict the impact of dielectric loss on qubit lifetimes. This is done with no need to fabricate planar devices; the technique is independent of material platform. Measurements of sapphire in a demonstration of the approach suggest that coherence of superconducting qubits on a common form of sapphire is limited significantly by bulk dielectric loss. The same technique also shows that another form of sapphire would substantially mitigate this bulk dielectric loss and prolong qubit coherence.
Superconducting resonators are central to superconducting quantum information technologies and essential for bosonic qubit architectures, where long-lived storage modes enable hardware-efficient error correction. Achieving ultra-high quality factors in scalable planar circuits is challenging because multiple dissipation channels contribute to the total loss. Here we report planar ααα-Ta resonators fabricated on 300 mm ultra-high-resistivity (>10>10>10 kΩΩΩ cm) intrinsic silicon using industrial processes, achieving median internal Q factors exceeding 40 million and maxima above 60 million. Energy-participation-ratio analysis identifies a dominant participation-controlled interface loss mechanism and places conservative upper bounds on substrate-associated dissipation. For the best-performing substrate, the inferred substrate loss tangent is below 1.0×10−81.0 \times 10^{-8}1.0×10−8, establishing industrial MCZ silicon among the lowest-loss substrate platforms reported for superconducting resonators. At the same time, the exceptionally low losses show no clear correlation with commonly cited silicon substrate metrics such as room-temperature resistivity or impurity concentrations. More broadly, these studies establish industrial 300 mm processing, careful interface engineering, and 300 mm MCZ silicon substrates as a promising platform for resonator-heavy superconducting quantum architectures with ultra-high quality factors.
The improvement of the coherence times of superconducting qubits depends on the reduction of the dielectric losses in the insulating materials implemented for the device fabrication. These losses depend on the density of spurious dipoles of different nature (two-level systems, TLSs) which couple to phase qubits and, hence, limit their coherence times. Hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H), because of its lower loss tangent (tan δ) among conventional dielectrics (a-SiO, a-SiO2, a-SiNx:H), is considered as the best amorphous dielectric for superconducting qubit application. We have developed a reliable method for the direct measurement of dielectric losses in amorphous dielectric thin films using a novel design based on four lumped superconducting LC resonators connected in series without coupling capacitors. The losses are obtained as tan δ = 1/Q0, where Q0 is the intrinsic quality factor of the resonator, measured at 3 dB above the resonance frequency without any fitting procedure. The series type LC resonators with a-Si:H as dielectric were fabricated by the Nb technology. The measurements were done at the conditions of a qubit application (0.5 -10 GHz frequency range and low temperatures). The low values of the loss tangent of a-Si:H (up to 2.5 x 10−5 at 4.2 K) have required the development of superconducting housing for the resonators in order to eliminate a spurious dependence of tan δ on the microwave power, by reducing losses which were not originated in the dielectric itself. The results of the simulations agree well with the experiments.