An important figure of merit for practical computing systems is energy-delay efficiency, which characterizes the number of operations a given device can perform per unit energy dissipated, per unit time taken for the operation.This efficiency metric appears to be limited in existing superconducting logic styles, motivating the search for novel, potentially more efficient forms of superconducting logic.One path to improving efficiency might be if we could remove the need for external control driven by slow clocks that is present in existing adiabatic SCE logic styles such as AQFP/RQFP.The Asynchronous Ballistic Reversible Computing (ABRC) paradigm offers an alternative model for ballistic, data-driven reversible computation.In an ongoing project at Sandia, we are attempting to demonstrate how the ABRC model can be implemented using Josephson junction circuits, while minimizing the energy-delay product.In this talk, we review the progress that has been made to date in this effort.An interesting direction for future research is to design physical mechanisms that explicitly invoke quantum processes exhibiting superadiabaticity (a.k.a."shortcuts to adiabaticity") to improve energy-delay efficiency in concrete computing technologies.We briefly review what is known about the potential applicability and limits of this approach.Dissipation-delay Efficiency (DdE) Sandia National Laboratories • The key motivating Figure of Merit (FOM) in the present study.• For a single primitive transition of the digital state of a system between two distinct informational states, consider:• The energy dissipation D incurred by that transition process.Relates to costs associated with supply of energy and cooling.• The delay d, defined as the time interval from start to end of process.Relates to costs associated with achieving a given level of parallel performance.• Then define the dissipation-delay product DdP = D • d.• Note that since refers specifically to energy dissipation, not to energy invested in the signal, in reversible processes, it is not subject to the "quantum speed limit" (QSL) lower bound of -h!No fundamental lower bound to DDP is yet known!-In fact, it would be identically zero for any perfectly-known unitary time-evolution.• Of even more general interest than DdP per se is dissipation as a function of delay, D(d), considered over a range of practical (tolerable) delay values... We'd like to extend the pareto frontier of this function within the useful range.• Dissipation-delay efficiency (DdE) of a computing technology just refers to the reciprocal of DdP, r/Dd = (Dd)-i.
An important figure of merit for practical computing systems is energy-delay efficiency, which characterizes the number of operations a given device can perform per unit energy dissipated, per unit time taken for the operation.This efficiency metric appears to be limited in existing superconducting logic styles, motivating the search for novel, potentially more efficient forms of superconducting logic.One path to improving efficiency might be if we could remove the need for external control driven by slow clocks that is present in existing adiabatic SCE logic styles such as AQFP/RQFP.The Asynchronous Ballistic Reversible Computing (ABRC) paradigm offers an alternative model for ballistic, data-driven reversible computation.In an ongoing project at Sandia, we are attempting to demonstrate how the ABRC model can be implemented using Josephson junction circuits, while minimizing the energy-delay product.In this talk, we review the progress that has been made to date in this effort.An interesting direction for future research is to design physical mechanisms that explicitly invoke quantum processes exhibiting superadiabaticity (a.k.a."shortcuts to adiabaticity") to improve energy-delay efficiency in concrete computing technologies.We briefly review what is known about the potential applicability and limits of this approach.Dissipation-delay Efficiency (DdE) Sandia National Laboratories • The key motivating Figure of Merit (FOM) in the present study.• For a single primitive transition of the digital state of a system between two distinct informational states, consider:• The energy dissipation D incurred by that transition process.Relates to costs associated with supply of energy and cooling.• The delay d, defined as the time interval from start to end of process.Relates to costs associated with achieving a given level of parallel performance.• Then define the dissipation-delay product DdP = D • d.• Note that since refers specifically to energy dissipation, not to energy invested in the signal, in reversible processes, it is not subject to the "quantum speed limit" (QSL) lower bound of -h!No fundamental lower bound to DDP is yet known!-In fact, it would be identically zero for any perfectly-known unitary time-evolution.• Of even more general interest than DdP per se is dissipation as a function of delay, D(d), considered over a range of practical (tolerable) delay values... We'd like to extend the pareto frontier of this function within the useful range.• Dissipation-delay efficiency (DdE) of a computing technology just refers to the reciprocal of DdP, r/Dd = (Dd)-i.
In an ongoing project at Sandia National Laboratories, we are attempting to develop a novel style of superconducting digital processing, based on a new model of reversible computation called Asynchronous Ballistic Reversible Computing (ABRC). We envision an approach in which polarized flux-ons scatter elastically from near-lossless functional components, reversibly updating the local digital state of the circuit, while dissipating only a small fraction of the input fluxon energy. This approach to superconducting digital computation is sufficiently unconventional that an appropriate methodology for hand-design of such circuits is not immediately obvious. To gain insight into the design principles that are applicable in this new domain, we are creating a software tool to automatically enumerate possible topologies of reactive, undamped Josephson junction circuits, and sweep the parameter space of each circuit searching for designs exhibiting desired dynamical behaviors. But first, we identified by hand a circuit implementing the simplest possible nontrivial ABRC functional behavior with bits encoded as conserved polarized fluxons, namely, a one-bit reversible memory cell with one bidirectional I/O port. We expect the tool to be useful for designing more complex circuits.
Today's industrial digital logic gates are reaching a technological limit and meanwhile, superconducting circuits produce fundamentally different technologies for the future of digital computing. The standard logic is irreversible and yet superconducting circuits allow digital reversible logic with a much higher energy efficiency per gate operation. Previous reversible gate circuits were “adiabatic,” meaning that they used adiabatic-clocking waveforms for their operation power. However, we are studying logic starting from a ballistic model, where ftuxons enable gates using only energy from their inertia. Our ftuxons are defined in Long Josephson Junctions (LJJs) and may travel ballistically, similar to a particle with negligible damping. Once a ftuxon's energy approaches close enough to the gate, a resonance is induced at the gate and the ftuxon loses its definite topology. Gates are comprised of the (few Josephson-penetration-depth long) ends of LJJs and a connecting circuit interface. Only after the resonance does a ftuxon get formed and yield the gate result without external power: a ftuxon for bit-state 0 or an antiftuxon for bit-state 1. Through earlier analysis of the numerically discovered phenomena we find that dynamics can be described with ftuxon- and antiftuxon-like excitations at the ends of LJJs within the gate. The bit-switching action in our gates is resonant indicating fundamentally different dynamics than the classic model of adiabatic reversible circuits. Our ballistic Reversible Fluxon Logic (RFL) gates have no added damping and calculated energy efficiencies of over 97%. Thus in our dynamical process the “bit energy” is preserved. However, irreversible logic completely dissipates this at each operation (e.g., charging energy in CMOS or SFQ energy in irreversible SFQ logic). An RFL gate can achieve a fast gate operation since its resonance is only few JJ plasma periods. We also describe the CNOT in our technology. It is enabled by a couple of vital gates: A IDSN logic gate, similar to our other ballistic gates, and a Store-aNd-Launch (SNL) timing gate to ensure proper synchronization of the bits. The latter allows bit storage followed by launching of a data ftuxon using an adiabatic pulse from a clock ftuxon with lower energy than the data ftuxon for good CNOT efficiency.
In a previous paper, we described a new abstract circuit model for reversible computation called asynchronous ballistic reversible computing (ABRC), in which localized information-bearing pulses propagate ballistically along signal paths between stateful abstract devices and elastically scatter off those devices serially, while updating the device state in a logically-reversible and deterministic fashion. The ABRC model has been shown to be capable of universal computation. In the research reported here, we begin exploring how the ABRC model might be realized in practice using single flux quantum solitons (fluxons) in superconducting Josephson junction (JJ) circuits. One natural family of realizations could utilize fluxon polarity to represent binary data in individual pulses propagating near-ballistically, along discrete or continuous long Josephson junctions or microstrip passive transmission lines, and utilize the flux charge (-1, 0, +1) of a JJ-containing superconducting loop with Φ0cL0to encode a ternary state variable internal to a device. A natural question then arises as to which of the definable abstract ABRC device functionalities using this data representation might be implementable using a JJ circuit that dissipates only a small fraction of the input fluxon energy. We discuss conservation rules and symmetries considered as constraints to be obeyed in these circuits, and begin the process of classifying the possible ABRC devices in this family having up to three bidirectional I/O terminals, and up to three internal states.
Reversible computing is considered to be a key technology to achieve an extremely high energy efficiency in future computers. In this study, we investigated the relationship between reversibility and energy dissipation in adiabatic superconductor logic. We analyzed the evolution of phase differences of Josephson junctions in the reversible quantum-flux-parametron (RQFP) gate and confirmed that the phase differences can change time reversibly, which indicates that the RQFP gate is physically, as well as logically, reversible. We calculated energy dissipation required for the RQFP gate to perform a logic operation and numerically demonstrated that the energy dissipation can fall below the thermal limit, or the Landauer bound, by lowering operation frequencies. We also investigated the 1-bit-erasure gate as a logically irreversible gate and the quasi-RQFP gate as a physically irreversible gate. We calculated the energy dissipation of these irreversible gates and showed that the energy dissipation of these gate is dominated by non-adiabatic state changes, which are induced by unwanted interactions between gates due to logical or physical irreversibility. Our results show that, in reversible computing using adiabatic superconductor logic, logical and physical reversibility are required to achieve energy dissipation smaller than the Landauer bound without non-adiabatic processes caused by gate interactions.
Complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor (CMOS) circuit technology has sustainedthe exponential growth of computing power for more than 20 years. However, it hasbeen estimated that the power consumption of a next-generation supercomputer willexceed the power supplied from a single power plant. This indicates the need to dramaticallyimprove the energy efficiency of logic devices to achieve future high-endcomputers.As an extremely energy-efficient logic, we proposed and have been investigatingadiabatic quantum-flux-parametron (AQFP) devices. Due to adiabatic switching operations,its bit energy (energy dissipation per bit) can go below Ic 0, where Ic is acritical current of a Josephson junction and 0 is a single-flux-quantum (SFQ). Ic 0corresponds to the energy dissipated at every 2 phase transition in conventional nonadiabaticsuperconductor logics.We have two objectives in this study. One is to reveal physical energy bounds oncomputation through investigation of the energy efficiency of AQFP logic. The otheris to develop fundamental circuits necessary for energy-efficient computing systemsusing AQFP logic.First, we numerically and experimentally demonstrated the sub-Ic 0 bit-energyoperations of AQFP gates to show that AQFP gates operate in adiabatic modes. Weinvestigated the dependence of energy dissipation and operation margins on circuitparameters. After optimizing the parameters, we calculated the bit energy and the biterror rate at 4.2 K to verify the sub-Ic 0 bit-energy operations at a finite temperature.Additionally, we measured the bit energy of an AQFP gate using a superconductorresonator-based method.Secondly, we numerically demonstrated the sub-kBT bit-energy operations, wherekB is the Boltzmann constant and T is temperature, to show that AQFP gates can operatebeyond thermodynamic energy bounds. We investigated the dependence of energydissipation on operation frequencies and damping conditions of Josephson junctions.By using underdamped junctions, we confirmed the sub-kBT bit-energy operationsat a finite temperature thorough circuit simulation. This result indicates that thereis no minimum energy dissipation required for the operations of AQFP gates unlessthe entropy of the system decreases, which corresponds to the Landauer’s argument on the minimum energy dissipation for computation. Also, we discussed quantummechanicalenergy bounds and experimentally demonstrated AQFP gates with underdampedjunctions.Additionally, we investigated reversible computing using AQFP logic with underdampedjunctions, in order to deal with an important but unresolved question: “Isreversible computing achievable by using practical devices?” We built a purely reversiblegate by using AQFP gates, which we designated as the reversible quantumflux-parametron (RQFP) gate. We calculated its energy dissipation and confirmed thatthere is no minimum energy dissipation for reversible logic operations using RQFPgates. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first calculation results that show nominimum energy dissipation in reversible computing that use practical circuit structures.Moreover, our experimental results have demonstrated the logical and physicalreversibility of the RQFP gate. We believe that this is the first demonstration thatshows both logical and physical reversibility using practical devices.Finally, we proposed a novel energy-efficient latch for AQFP logic, which we designatedas the quantum-flux-latch (QFL). Latches are necessary circuitries in largecomputing systems but had been missing in AQFP logic. We discussed its energyefficiency through simulation and experimentally demonstrated correct operations ofthe QFL and a 1-bit shift register using QFLs. Also, we proposed high-speed test circuitsusing QFLs and experimentally demonstrated logic operations of AQFP circuitsat high speed.We strongly believe that our results showed the extremely high energy efficiency ofAQFP logic. These results will move the AQFP logic to practical usage as extremelyenergy-efficient integrated circuits.
Adiabatic superconducting logic circuits can ensure the practical implementation of operations with the energy dissipation below the Landauer limit. However, applications of the existing solutions are limited because of two contradictory requirements of a high energy efficiency and a sufficiently fast response of devices. Josephson junctions with a negative critical current (π junctions) allow one to obtain a certain form of the potential energy of superconducting circuits and, as a result, a practically required degree of control of dynamic processes in the proposed reversible logic cells. The features of the current transport and balance of Josephson phases in circuits with π junctions make it possible to improve the coupling between the parts of a reversible computer by a factor more than 2. At the same time, the continuous evolution of the state is ensured at higher critical currents and higher characteristic voltages of the main Josephson junctions of adiabatic superconducting logic cells, which allows an increase in the response rate.