In (1), standard quantum perturbation theory is developed using Vo(x)+bV(x), W(x)=Wo(x)+bn1(x)+b*bn2(x)+... and E=Eo+E1b+b*bE2+... where b is small. These values are inserted into the time-independent Schrodinger equation and terms with like order of b collected. Multiplying by Wo and integrating over x yields an expression for Ei. Multiplying by Wk(x) and integrating yields a projection of <ni | k> where Wk is the kth eigenfunction of -1/2m d/dxd/dx +Vo(x). The projection <ni|Wo> is determined using <W |W>=1 and retaining terms of b to the power i. Thus, many terms are dropped from <W|W> and the approach used in (1) is a little tedious as noted in that reference. In this note, we consider W(x)=Wo(x)W1(x) which yields: -1/2m d/dx d/dx W1 + d/dx W1 d/dx Wo / Wo + b V(x) W1(x) = (E-Eo) W1(x) when inserted into the Schrodinger equation. The same <ni|Wk> projection results, as expected. For <ni|Wo>, however, we argue that <WoW1 | WoW1>=1 leads to a more direct and less tedious equation for evaluating this projection. We interpret the results which are based on eigenfunctions of Ho i.e. the Hamiltonian with bV(x) dropped. Finally, we compare the high energy quantum perturbed density with the classical (correspondence) principle i.e density = C/v(x) where v(x) is velocity. In the high energy classical limit, matters are not so simple because an expansion of the spatial density in positive powers of b is only valid away from the classical turning points. Near the turning points, a different power series in b holds and technically there is a region for which there is no power series as E-Vo and b(E1-V) are very similar in value.
In (1), standard quantum perturbation theory is developed using Vo(x)+bV(x), W(x)=Wo(x)+bn1(x)+bbn2(x)+... and E=Eo+E1b+bbE2+... where b is small. These values are inserted into the time-independent Schrodinger equation and terms with like order of b collected. Multiplying by Wo and integrating over x yields an expression for Ei. Multiplying by Wk(x) and integrating yields a projection of <ni | k> where Wk is the kth eigenfunction of -1/2m d/dxd/dx +Vo(x). The projection <ni|Wo> is determined using <W |W>=1 and retaining terms of b to the power i. Thus, many terms are dropped from <W|W> and the approach used in (1) is a little tedious as noted in that reference. In this note, we consider W(x)=Wo(x)W1(x) which yields: -1/2m d/dx d/dx W1 + d/dx W1 d/dx Wo / Wo + b V(x) W1(x) = (E-Eo) W1(x) when inserted into the Schrodinger equation. The same <ni|Wk> projection results, as expected. For <ni|Wo>, however, we argue that <WoW1 | WoW1>=1 leads to a more direct and less tedious equation for evaluating this projection. We interpret the results which are based on eigenfunctions of Ho i.e. the Hamiltonian with bV(x) dropped. Finally, we compare the high energy quantum perturbed density with the classical (correspondence) principle i.e density = C/v(x) where v(x) is velocity. In the high energy classical limit, matters are not so simple because an expansion of the spatial density in positive powers of b is only valid away from the classical turning points. Near the turning points, a different power series in b holds and technically there is a region for which there is no power series as E-Vo and b(E1-V) are very similar in value.
In some recent articles in the literature (1),(2) the Schrodinger equation: p*p/2m W(x) + V(x) W(x) = E W(x) ((1)) is replaced with an equation using a relativistic momentum operator: [sqrt(p*p + m*m) - m] W(x) + V(x)W(x) = E W(x) ((2)) The first operator on the LHS of ((2)) is then expanded in powers of 1/(m*m). Next, p is replaced with hbar/i d/dx (or gradient in 3D) and perturbation theory used. In this note, we consider p*p as being a conditional average given by: p*p= [Integral dp f(p) exp(ipx) p*p ] / [Integral dp f(p) exp(ipx)] ((3)) The denominator is the wavefunction W(x). This result should hold for the nonrelativistic case. In the relativistic case, p is replaced everywhere with prel where prel= p/ sqrt(1-p*p/(m*m)) prel*prel = Integral dprel p*p (1+ p*p/(m*m)) f(prel) exp(iprel x) ((4)) And W(x) = Integral dprel f(prel) exp(iprel x) ((5)) To first order, we argue that Integral dprel f(prel) exp(iprel x) = Integral dp f(p) exp(i p x), but Integral p*p f(prel) dprel exp(i prel x) contributes a term . For higher orders, even Integral dprel f(prel) exp(i prel x) contributes. Thus, we try to argue that one does not only have a change in the prel*prel operator, but one must consider changes of prel within Integral dprel f(prel) exp(iprel x) itself. Thus, perturbation theory may not be enough in such cases.
In a previous note (1), we argued that W(x+dx)= W(x) exp(i dx ) where = - i d/dx lnW mimicking the behaviour of exp(ipx) for a free quantum particle. In this note, we consider that for the conditional probability P(p/x)= a(p) exp(ipx)/W(x), a shift from x to x+dx leads to: P(p/ x+dx) = P(p/x) exp(i dx (p- ) ) = P(p/x)(1+ idx (p- )). We note that in shifting from x to x+dx the overall sum of probability should not change, so P(p / x+dx)= P(p/x) + P(p/x) g(p,x). If one assumes that g(p,x) is a function of p alone, the simplest solution is p- . If one considers Sum over p pp/2m P(p/x+dx) = Sum over p pp/2m P(p/x) = delta KE ave then this should be equal to Force(x) dx. We also consider classical hydrodynamical equations and compare these with modified equations applying to the bound state quantum situation. The two sets of equations are very similar with density in the classical case being replaced with W(x)exp(-iEt), the wavefunction, and E energy or V(x) (potential) terms replaced with 2E or 2V (i.e. also 2Force). In a previous note, we had considered hydrodynamical equations with the restriction 2m=1 which is too strong. Here any m (mass) may be used.
A review of perturbation theory Most quantum mechanics problems are not solvable in closed form with analytical techniques. To extend our repertoire beyond just particle-in-a-box, a number of approximation techniques have been developed. A large class of these fall under the heading of “perturbation theory”, in which we consider our system to obey Hamiltonian H that may be written as H = H 0 + λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , (A.1) where H 0 is an exactly solvable Hamiltonian, λ is a small parameter, and the other terms may therefore be taken as small corrections. These notes are a quick review of how to deal with systems that obey such Hamiltonians. We'll be using Dirac notation and the Schrödinger formalism, in which the states are time-dependent. We begin with time-independent perturbation theory, and will then move on to consider time-dependent problems. For now, we'll only deal with single-particle problems, too. Time-independent We're going to use the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and look for the energy eigenvalues and eigenstates of H . First, suppose that our unperturbed problem, H 0 |ψ 0 〉 = E 0 |ψ 0 〉 (A.2) may be solved exactly, giving an energy eigenvalue spectrum E 0 j with corresponding eigenstates |ψ 0 j 〉. Remember, because H 0 is a Hermitian operator, its eigenvalues are real, and its eigenvectors |ψ 0 j 〉 form a complete set. The strategy we're going to take is straightforward. We're going to assume that our perturbative corrections to the Hamiltonian, λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , lead to corresponding perturbative corrections to the eigenvalues and eigenstates. That is, E j = E 0 j + λ E 1 j + λ 2 E 2 j + … , |ψ j 〉 = |ψ 0 j 〉 + λ|ψ 1 j 〉 + λ 2 |ψ 2 j 〉 + ….
In bound state quantum mechanics, one has statistical observables (based on P(x) where P is probability) such as spatial density d(x), potential energy density V(x)d(x) and kinetic energy density .5mv(x)v(x) d(x), where v(x) is the classical velocity obtained from .5mv(x)v(x) + V(x) = E. (Kinetic energy density can also be written as -1/2m W(x) d/dx d/dx W(x) where W(x) is the wavefunction). The energy of a state can be obtained by integrating these statistical observables i.e. Integral dx d(x) V(x) + Integral dx d(x) .5mv(x)v(x) = E. If one performs this integration for two different states, one may calculate the energy difference. This begs the question: why does quantum mechanics deal with conditional probabilities such as P(p/x) directly related to W(x)? The issue perhaps begins with the appearance of V(x) and E in the time independent Schrodinger equation. Kinetic energy (not kinetic energy density) should appear and be somehow linked to some motion. A question arises as to why the energy density is proportional to the spatial density i.e. Energy density = E d(x)? This is directly linked to the time-independent Schrodinger equation, but one may try to argue that classical energy conservation .5mv(x)v(x) + V(x) = E at each point x should hold in quantum mechanics with .5mv(x)v(x) equal to Sum over p p*p/2m P(p/x) where P(p/x) = fp exp(ipx)/W(x). If one, however, considers excited states written as Wn(x)= Wo(x)Hn(x) where Wo(x) is the ground state wavefunction, one finds that: -1/2m d/dx d/dx Hn(x) - 1/m [d/dx Wo(x)]/Wo(x) [d/dx Hn(x)] = E1 Hn(x) ((1)) In other words, an eigenvalue equation appears again with no V(x) present. If one assumes Hn(x) has physical meaning (i.e. is related to a phonon or photon), then ((1)) may suggest there is a physical principle in place, i.e. the idea that one must have a “constant” energy at each point x. Here E1 is strictly kinetic energy (although not all of it). This “principle” has consequences as it restricts the values of E1 (i.e. discrete eigenvalues) and leads often to a periodic Hn(x) which has direct effect on kinetic energy density and potential energy density. Thus, having Hn(x) interact with Wo(x) to produce a constant energy E1 times Hn(x) does affect kinetic and energy densities at each x point, just not kinetic energy itself (it is constant i.e. E1). The purpose of this note is to examine this possible principle behind quantum mechanics.
In a previous note, the nonrelativistic bound state wavefunction W(x) was written as Wo(x)W1(x) with Wo(x) being the ground state wavefunction. W1(x) satisfies an eigenvalue equation, similar to the Schrodinger equation, but with the potential term replaced with a coupling term: -1/2m d/dx d/dx W1(x) - 1/m d/dx W1(x) [ d/dx Wo(x)/Wo(x) ] = (E-Eo) W1 (x) ((1)) Mathematically, ((1)) may be compared to the hypergeometric differential equation and solutions found for the Schrodinger if coefficients meet certain criteria. A similar approach applies to the Klein Gordon and Dirac equations In this note, we wish to examine possible physical significance of Wo(x)W1(x). In addition, we wish to obtain an equation, analogous to ((1)) for both the Klein Gordon and Dirac equations to compare the coupling terms.
In this note, we consider the Hamiltonian 1/2m (p-e/c A)(p-e/c A) W = E W ((1)) in the situation where there is no magnetic field even though A(x) still exists. Thus, if there is no force, one might expect to have a free particle which satisfies -1/2m d/dx d/dx W = E W and yields a free particle spatial density. Thus, one might guess the solution to ((1)) should be a free particle wavefunction exp(ikx) with perhaps a phase added. Such a phase does not affect spatial density W*W. One may solve ((1)) using the assumption that d/dx A(x) = 0 (used in the literature (1)) to find: W= Wfree(x) exp(ie/hbar c Integral x1=0 to x A(x1)dx1). Thus, one treats this phase as if one had exp(i K x) where K=A(x). A second derivative d/dx brings down i A(x) again. In previous notes, we suggested that a potential is stochastic and may be written as: V(x)= Sum over k V(k) exp(ikx). If one expands the terms in ((1)) and uses d/dx A =0, one obtains a momentum dependent potential. This potential should be physical, we argue, because it applies to cases where there is a magnetic field as well as to the case here where there is not. Thus, the potential should give hits of the form V(k) exp(ikx) as well as couple to d/dx W. In other words, we argue these hits are real whether or not average force is zero. The effect of such hits is to create a momentum distribution at each x: P(p/x) = a(p) exp(ipx) / W(x). There is forward and backward motion, but the average kinetic energy(x) + V(x)= E at each point where: kinetic energy(x) = [Sum over p p*p/2m a(p) exp(ipx)]/W(x). Given that average kinetic energy should be p*p/2m for a free particle (if the potential yields no hits), one may consider a phase exp(i K(x) x) multiplied by Wfree(x) i.e. exp(ipx) . This seems to imply a shifted velocity i.e. a local collective velocity of K(x) where K(x) happens to equal A(x) in this case. Matters, however, seem to be more complicated as we consider a microscopic coupling of exp(ikx) terms from both Wfree(x) and exp(i Bohm Aharonov) phase just as there may be a coupling between W=WoW1 where Wo(x) is the ground state and W1(x) represents the effects of an interacting substance (e.g. a photon or phonon).