Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Routledge eBooks

Quantum metaphysics and the foundations of spacetime

Vincent Lam, Laurie Letertre, Cristian Mariani

Published Aug 8, 2022• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The main research programs in quantum gravity tend to suggest in one way or another that most (if not all) spacetime structures are not fundamental. At the same time, work in quantum foundations highlights fundamental features that are in tension with any straightforward spacetime understanding. This paper aims to explore the little investigated but potentially fruitful links between these two fields.

DOI
10.4324/9781003219019-11

Related papers

The Dynamics of Quantum Gravity: The Missing Piece in the Spacetime Emergentist Account

Álvaro Mozota Frauca

Quantum gravity suggests that spacetime may not be fundamental, and it has been argued that we can understand a theory without a fundamental spacetime if we are able to claim that spacetime 'emerges' from some non-spatiotemporal entities. In this sense, strategies like functionalism have been deployed to claim that this emergence is possible and plausible, both in principle and in practice for current approaches to quantum gravity. In this article I argue that this analysis is incomplete, as it tends to overlook the way the dynamics of these theories is 'quantum' in a way that differs from standard quantum theory. The challenge for the emergentist (and for the quantum gravity theorist) is to give an interpretation not only to the kinematical and classical aspects of these theories, but to the dynamical and quantum ones, and to show how the spacetime roles can be fulfilled, if possible at all. Therefore, I argue that some current approaches to quantum gravity seem to fail to provide meaningful theories, that spacetime functionalism is of no help, and that the position of the spacetime emergentists is weakened, as they lack any example of a successful reduction of spacetime to some truly quantum non-spatiotemporal stuff.

arXiv:2606.31559•Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A•Jun 30, 2026•0 citations

Spacetime as an Emergent Causal Structure: A Quantum Mechanical Perspective

Changlong Wen

This paper explores the fundamental nature of spacetime from the perspective of emergent causal structures, rooted in quantum mechanical principles. We propose a theoretical framework that treats spacetime not as a pre-existing background, but as a collective phenomenon arising from the interaction of quantum causal relations. By analyzing the constraints of causality and quantum coherence, we derive key implications for the emergence of classical spacetime geometry and the limits of local realism. Our results suggest a new way to bridge quantum mechanics and gravitational theory, providing a foundation for future studies in quantum gravity and spacetime physics.

•Mar 11, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Theory

Ian D. Lawrie

Much of the remainder of this book will concern itself with those aspects of theoretical physics which seek to understand the nature of matter. Such understanding as we have has mainly been achieved by probing the structure of successively smaller constituents and, at least on the face of things, the regions of space and time we need to consider are far too small for spacetime curvature to be of any signicance. Many of our considerations will therefore be restricted to Minkowski or, as in the present chapter, Galilean spacetime. Paradoxically, however, it seems that gravity and the structure of space and time may have a vital role to play in our understanding of matter on the very smallest scales, and we shall see something of the ways in which this comes about in later chapters.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 27, 2012•0 citations

Quantum Theory

Ian D. Lawrie

Much of the remainder of this book will concern itself with those aspects of theoretical physics which seek to understand the nature of matter. Such understanding as we have has mainly been achieved by probing the structure of successively smaller constituents and, at least on the face of things, the regions of space and time we need to consider are far too small for spacetime curvature to be of any significance. Many of our considerations will therefore be restricted to Minkowski or, as in the present chapter, Galilean spacetime. Paradoxically, however, it seems that gravity and the structure of space and time may have a vital role to play in our understanding of matter on the very smallest scales, and we shall see something of the ways in which this comes about in later chapters.

Taylor & Francis eBooks•May 5, 2015•0 citations

The Emergence of Space and Time

Christian Wüthrich

Causal set theory starts out from a central result in general relativity according to which the causal structure determines, up to a so-called ‘conformal factor’, the geometry of a relativistic spacetime. Space and time, it seems, must be part and parcel of the ontology of any physical theory, of any theory with a credible claim to being a physical theory, that is. After all, physics is the science of the fundamental constitution of the material bodies, their motion in space and time, and indeed of space and time themselves. There are two areas in physics in which space or spacetime may emerge from something qualitatively rather different: wave function monism in quantum mechanics and quantum theories of gravity. The former case concerns a particular interpretative issue in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. The severity and the characteristics of the disappearance of spacetime differ from one approach to quantum gravity to another.

arXiv:1804.02184•Routledge eBooks•Mar 13, 2019•41 citations

Quantum Concepts in Space and Time

Roger Penrose, Christopher John Isham

Recent developments in quantum theory have focused attention on fundamental questions, in particular on whether it might be necessary to modify quantum mechanics to reconcile quantum gravity and general relativity. This book is based on a conference held in Oxford in the spring of 1984 to discuss quantum gravity. It brings together contributors who examine different aspects of the problem, including the experimental support for quantum mechanics, its strange and apparently paradoxical features, its underlying philosophy, and possible modifications to the theory.

Clarendon Press eBooks•Jan 1, 1986•748 citations
The main research programs in quantum gravity tend to suggest in one way or another that most (if not all) spacetime structures are not fundamental. At the same time, work in quantum foundations highlights fundamental features that are in tension with any straightforward spacetime understanding. This paper aims to explore the little investigated but potentially fruitful links between these two fields.
Quantum gravity suggests that spacetime may not be fundamental, and it has been argued that we can understand a theory without a fundamental spacetime if we are able to claim that spacetime 'emerges' from some non-spatiotemporal entities. In this sense, strategies like functionalism have been deployed to claim that this emergence is possible and plausible, both in principle and in practice for current approaches to quantum gravity. In this article I argue that this analysis is incomplete, as it tends to overlook the way the dynamics of these theories is 'quantum' in a way that differs from standard quantum theory. The challenge for the emergentist (and for the quantum gravity theorist) is to give an interpretation not only to the kinematical and classical aspects of these theories, but to the dynamical and quantum ones, and to show how the spacetime roles can be fulfilled, if possible at all. Therefore, I argue that some current approaches to quantum gravity seem to fail to provide meaningful theories, that spacetime functionalism is of no help, and that the position of the spacetime emergentists is weakened, as they lack any example of a successful reduction of spacetime to some truly quantum non-spatiotemporal stuff.
This paper explores the fundamental nature of spacetime from the perspective of emergent causal structures, rooted in quantum mechanical principles. We propose a theoretical framework that treats spacetime not as a pre-existing background, but as a collective phenomenon arising from the interaction of quantum causal relations. By analyzing the constraints of causality and quantum coherence, we derive key implications for the emergence of classical spacetime geometry and the limits of local realism. Our results suggest a new way to bridge quantum mechanics and gravitational theory, providing a foundation for future studies in quantum gravity and spacetime physics.
Much of the remainder of this book will concern itself with those aspects of theoretical physics which seek to understand the nature of matter. Such understanding as we have has mainly been achieved by probing the structure of successively smaller constituents and, at least on the face of things, the regions of space and time we need to consider are far too small for spacetime curvature to be of any signicance. Many of our considerations will therefore be restricted to Minkowski or, as in the present chapter, Galilean spacetime. Paradoxically, however, it seems that gravity and the structure of space and time may have a vital role to play in our understanding of matter on the very smallest scales, and we shall see something of the ways in which this comes about in later chapters.
Much of the remainder of this book will concern itself with those aspects of theoretical physics which seek to understand the nature of matter. Such understanding as we have has mainly been achieved by probing the structure of successively smaller constituents and, at least on the face of things, the regions of space and time we need to consider are far too small for spacetime curvature to be of any significance. Many of our considerations will therefore be restricted to Minkowski or, as in the present chapter, Galilean spacetime. Paradoxically, however, it seems that gravity and the structure of space and time may have a vital role to play in our understanding of matter on the very smallest scales, and we shall see something of the ways in which this comes about in later chapters.
Causal set theory starts out from a central result in general relativity according to which the causal structure determines, up to a so-called ‘conformal factor’, the geometry of a relativistic spacetime. Space and time, it seems, must be part and parcel of the ontology of any physical theory, of any theory with a credible claim to being a physical theory, that is. After all, physics is the science of the fundamental constitution of the material bodies, their motion in space and time, and indeed of space and time themselves. There are two areas in physics in which space or spacetime may emerge from something qualitatively rather different: wave function monism in quantum mechanics and quantum theories of gravity. The former case concerns a particular interpretative issue in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. The severity and the characteristics of the disappearance of spacetime differ from one approach to quantum gravity to another.
Recent developments in quantum theory have focused attention on fundamental questions, in particular on whether it might be necessary to modify quantum mechanics to reconcile quantum gravity and general relativity. This book is based on a conference held in Oxford in the spring of 1984 to discuss quantum gravity. It brings together contributors who examine different aspects of the problem, including the experimental support for quantum mechanics, its strange and apparently paradoxical features, its underlying philosophy, and possible modifications to the theory.