Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Application of the Rayleigh-Schrödinger Perturbation Theory to the Hydrogen Atom

Richard E. Trees

Published Jun 15, 1956• 38 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Wigner has calculated the ground-state energy of the hydrogen atom with second-order perturbation theory, the whole electrostatic potential being considered as the perturbation. Though his result is finite, it does not agree with the known energy for hydrogen. A fact implicit in the literature, but not usually appreciated in this connection, is pointed out---that if part of the electrostatic energy is retained in the zero-order problem, a correct result is obtained, even if the part of the energy retained is given a zero magnitude after the calculation is carried out. It is also shown that if the calculation is carried out in an Einstein hypersphere, the entire "electrostatic potential" can be regarded as the perturbation and the correct result is obtained. Perturbation theory leads to the exact energy eigenvalue in all approximations higher than the first, but the expansion of the eigenfunction converges slowly if the perturbation is made large.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.102.1553

Related papers

Application of the Rayleigh-Schrödinger Perturbation Theory to the Delta Function Potential

Saul T. Epstein

E. P. Wigner has shown that although there are reasons why one might hope to succeed, one cannot in fact derive the binding energy of the hydrogen atom by second-order perturbation theory applied to a free particle in a box. To further clarify the reasons for this failure we here consider the one-dimensional attractive delta function potential.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1960•9 citations

Convergent Schrödinger Perturbation Theory

Gerald Speisman

A formulation of Schr\"odinger perturbation theory is developed that gives a unified treatment of non-degenerate and degenerate cases, is unique, and has a nonzero radius of convergence under very general conditions. Two alternative procedures are given for finding perturbed eigenvectors, one of which is simpler for the nondegenerate case or for small finite degeneracy, the other simpler for infinite or large finite degeneracy. The low-order terms in the perturbation expansions of quantities used in applications are given. The perturbation theory formulated in this paper has the following advantages over the conventional Schr\"odinger and Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theories: (i) When the convergence criterion is satisfied, bounds on the error made in replacing an appropriate infinite perturbation series by its first $n$ terms can be obtained. (ii) For the case of degeneracy, the conventional Schr\"odinger perturbation theory can break down under conditions to which the convergence of the perturbation theory developed in this paper are insensitive. (iii) There is no implicit dependence on the eigenvalue, such as appears in the Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theory. (iv) For the case of degeneracy, statistical information about the distribution of certain eigenvalues can be obtained without finding the individual eigenvalues. (v) The theory is applicable to a wider class of problems than the conventional Schr\"odinger and Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theories.

Physical Review•Aug 15, 1957•27 citations

Approximation Methods

P. J. Shepherd

For only very few physical problems (e.g., the hydrogen-like atom and the harmonic oscillator) can the Schrödinger equation be solved exactly, and so methods of approximate solution must be used. This chapter begins by explaining how to solve the full time-independent Schrödinger equation for the “perturbed” stationary-state energies and the corresponding energy eigenfunctions, given that the solution of the time-independent Schrödinger equation is known. Time-dependent perturbation theory forms the basis of the theory of atomic, nuclear and solid state spectroscopy, and also for the theory of the dielectric permittivities and refractive indices of materials. The chapter discusses at length the time-independent perturbation theory for degenerate states. Perturbation theory is useful if there is a closely related problem that has been solved exactly. If this is not so, the variational method, which is especially useful for finding the ground-state energy and ground-state wave function of a system, may be used.

Wiley eBooks•Jan 10, 2013•0 citations

Multiple approaches to incorporating scattering states in non-degenerate perturbation theory

Don C. Colladay, John Eric Goff

The second-order perturbative Stark effect on the ground state of hydrogen is a typical example presented in many standard texts on quantum mechanics. Some texts miss the fact that the scattering states are significant contributors to the perturbative energy correction. The inclusion of scattering states has wider applicability than to just the Stark effect. An explicit calculation involving a finite-square well with a perturbation is used to illustrate the importance of including scattering states into the calculation. The second-order correction to the ground-state energy is obtained in three distinct ways. The first involves altering the problem by imposing additional boundary conditions at large distances to make the positive-energy spectrum discrete. The second makes use of the continuum scattering states directly. The third bypasses the use of scattering states by solving a differential equation for the first-order correction to the wave function.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 19, 2020•2 citations

Analysis on Perturbation of Ground State Energy for Anharmonic Oscillator and Helium Atom

Ruxu Shen

This paper discusses some practical problems in quantum mechanics, particularly finding solutions of the Schrödinger equation for some cases, as it is a pivotal part of this area. The article focuses on using perturbation theory to calculate the approximate ground state energy for both helium atom and quartic anharmonic oscillator. For the helium atom, conventional perturbation theory is used to solve for the approximate energy, whilst for the anharmonic oscillator, a slightly different approach, that is perturbation theory incorporating a parameter, is chosen to improve the precision of the approximation. The final relative errors for the ground state energy of helium atom model are, for the first order perturbation, , and for the second order, , and that for the anharmonic oscillator is . The study of perturbation theory gives insights into understandings of how it may be modified further to pursue a better level of precision. This facilitates development of new approximation techniques for solving quantum-mechanical issues.

Highlights in Science Engineering and Technology•May 23, 2025•0 citations

Analytic Treatment of the Coulomb Potential in the Path Integral Formalism by Exact Summation of a Perturbation Expansion

Marc J. Goovaerts, J. T. Devreese

A straightforward analytical calculation of the s-like energy spectrum of the hydrogen atom is performed entirely within Feynman's path integral formalism. For this purpose the integral transform W = ∫d3rβK(rβ,0), where K(rβ,0) is the density matrix of the hydrogen atom written as a path integral, is calculated by means of the exact summation of a ``modified'' perturbation expansion (W is expanded as a power series in β with β = 1/kT). Performing this summation is equivalent to solving a problem of moments with infinite moments. For a wide class of potentials the perturbation expansion for W converges faster than the power-series expansion for the exponential function (for the Coulomb potential the convergence rate of both expansions is the same). It is shown how the complete energy spectrum can be obtained by this method. It is also illustrated how the wavefunctions might be obtained by transforming W.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 1972•38 citations
Wigner has calculated the ground-state energy of the hydrogen atom with second-order perturbation theory, the whole electrostatic potential being considered as the perturbation. Though his result is finite, it does not agree with the known energy for hydrogen. A fact implicit in the literature, but not usually appreciated in this connection, is pointed out---that if part of the electrostatic energy is retained in the zero-order problem, a correct result is obtained, even if the part of the energy retained is given a zero magnitude after the calculation is carried out. It is also shown that if the calculation is carried out in an Einstein hypersphere, the entire "electrostatic potential" can be regarded as the perturbation and the correct result is obtained. Perturbation theory leads to the exact energy eigenvalue in all approximations higher than the first, but the expansion of the eigenfunction converges slowly if the perturbation is made large.
A formulation of Schr\"odinger perturbation theory is developed that gives a unified treatment of non-degenerate and degenerate cases, is unique, and has a nonzero radius of convergence under very general conditions. Two alternative procedures are given for finding perturbed eigenvectors, one of which is simpler for the nondegenerate case or for small finite degeneracy, the other simpler for infinite or large finite degeneracy. The low-order terms in the perturbation expansions of quantities used in applications are given. The perturbation theory formulated in this paper has the following advantages over the conventional Schr\"odinger and Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theories: (i) When the convergence criterion is satisfied, bounds on the error made in replacing an appropriate infinite perturbation series by its first nnn terms can be obtained. (ii) For the case of degeneracy, the conventional Schr\"odinger perturbation theory can break down under conditions to which the convergence of the perturbation theory developed in this paper are insensitive. (iii) There is no implicit dependence on the eigenvalue, such as appears in the Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theory. (iv) For the case of degeneracy, statistical information about the distribution of certain eigenvalues can be obtained without finding the individual eigenvalues. (v) The theory is applicable to a wider class of problems than the conventional Schr\"odinger and Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theories.
For only very few physical problems (e.g., the hydrogen-like atom and the harmonic oscillator) can the Schrödinger equation be solved exactly, and so methods of approximate solution must be used. This chapter begins by explaining how to solve the full time-independent Schrödinger equation for the “perturbed” stationary-state energies and the corresponding energy eigenfunctions, given that the solution of the time-independent Schrödinger equation is known. Time-dependent perturbation theory forms the basis of the theory of atomic, nuclear and solid state spectroscopy, and also for the theory of the dielectric permittivities and refractive indices of materials. The chapter discusses at length the time-independent perturbation theory for degenerate states. Perturbation theory is useful if there is a closely related problem that has been solved exactly. If this is not so, the variational method, which is especially useful for finding the ground-state energy and ground-state wave function of a system, may be used.
The second-order perturbative Stark effect on the ground state of hydrogen is a typical example presented in many standard texts on quantum mechanics. Some texts miss the fact that the scattering states are significant contributors to the perturbative energy correction. The inclusion of scattering states has wider applicability than to just the Stark effect. An explicit calculation involving a finite-square well with a perturbation is used to illustrate the importance of including scattering states into the calculation. The second-order correction to the ground-state energy is obtained in three distinct ways. The first involves altering the problem by imposing additional boundary conditions at large distances to make the positive-energy spectrum discrete. The second makes use of the continuum scattering states directly. The third bypasses the use of scattering states by solving a differential equation for the first-order correction to the wave function.
This paper discusses some practical problems in quantum mechanics, particularly finding solutions of the Schrödinger equation for some cases, as it is a pivotal part of this area. The article focuses on using perturbation theory to calculate the approximate ground state energy for both helium atom and quartic anharmonic oscillator. For the helium atom, conventional perturbation theory is used to solve for the approximate energy, whilst for the anharmonic oscillator, a slightly different approach, that is perturbation theory incorporating a parameter, is chosen to improve the precision of the approximation. The final relative errors for the ground state energy of helium atom model are, for the first order perturbation, , and for the second order, , and that for the anharmonic oscillator is . The study of perturbation theory gives insights into understandings of how it may be modified further to pursue a better level of precision. This facilitates development of new approximation techniques for solving quantum-mechanical issues.
A straightforward analytical calculation of the s-like energy spectrum of the hydrogen atom is performed entirely within Feynman's path integral formalism. For this purpose the integral transform W = ∫d3rβK(rβ,0), where K(rβ,0) is the density matrix of the hydrogen atom written as a path integral, is calculated by means of the exact summation of a ``modified'' perturbation expansion (W is expanded as a power series in β with β = 1/kT). Performing this summation is equivalent to solving a problem of moments with infinite moments. For a wide class of potentials the perturbation expansion for W converges faster than the power-series expansion for the exponential function (for the Coulomb potential the convergence rate of both expansions is the same). It is shown how the complete energy spectrum can be obtained by this method. It is also illustrated how the wavefunctions might be obtained by transforming W.