Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

De Gruyter eBooks

Thomas–Reiche–Kuhn (TRK) sum rule for interacting photons

Salvatore Savasta, Omar Di Stefano, Franco Nori

Published May 25, 2021• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn (TRK) sum rule is a fundamental consequence of the position-momentum commutation relation for an atomic electron, and it provides an important constraint on the transitionmatrix elements for an atom. Here, we propose a TRK sum rule for electromagnetic fields which is valid even in the presence of very strong light- matter interactions and/or optical nonlinearities. While the standard TRK sum rule involves dipole matrix moments calculated between atomic energy levels (in the absence of interaction with the field), the sum rule here proposed involves expectation values of field operators calculated between general eigenstates of the interacting light-matter system. This sum rule provides constraints and guidance for the analysis of strongly interacting light-matter systems and can be used to test the validity of approximate effective Hamiltonians often used in quantum optics.

DOI
10.1515/9783110710687-037

Related papers

Thomas–Reiche–Kuhn (TRK) sum rule for interacting photons

Salvatore Savasta, Omar Di Stefano, Franco Nori

Abstract The Thomas–Reiche–Kuhn (TRK) sum rule is a fundamental consequence of the position–momentum commutation relation for an atomic electron, and it provides an important constraint on the transition matrix elements for an atom. Here, we propose a TRK sum rule for electromagnetic fields which is valid even in the presence of very strong light–matter interactions and/or optical nonlinearities. While the standard TRK sum rule involves dipole matrix moments calculated between atomic energy levels (in the absence of interaction with the field), the sum rule here proposed involves expectation values of field operators calculated between general eigenstates of the interacting light–matter system. This sum rule provides constraints and guidance for the analysis of strongly interacting light–matter systems and can be used to test the validity of approximate effective Hamiltonians often used in quantum optics.

arXiv:2002.02139•Nanophotonics•Nov 18, 2020•23 citations

The Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule for an atom of N equally spaced energy levels

C. Baxter

The Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule is determined for an atom consisting of an arbitrary number of discrete, equally spaced eigenenergy levels. This generalization is consistent with a two-level atom and with a usually seen form of the sum rule involving the atomic ground state, and resolves an apparent paradox reported elsewhere.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Dec 14, 1992•9 citations

Sum Rules for Atomic Transition Probabilities

John P. Vinti

Some new sum rules for atomic transition probabilities are developed; they are similar to the well-known rule of Kuhn, Reiche, and Thomas. They give, if unpolarized light is incident on any gaseous element in any given discrete energy level, the total absorption, excitation plus ionization, with various types of frequency weighting. The results are similar to those of Dirac and Harding, but are more general in that they apply to any discrete state of any atom, rather than to the ground state of hydrogen only. The method differs from that of Dirac and Harding.

Physical Review•Aug 15, 1932•49 citations

A sum rule for nonlinear optical susceptibilities

Luciana C Dávila Romero, Davıd L. Andrews

It is explicitly shown, for optical processes arbitrarily comprising two-, three- or four-photon interactions, that the sum over all matter states of any optical susceptibility is exactly zero. The result remains true even in frequency regions where damping is prominent. Using a quantum electrodynamical framework to render the photonic nature of the fundamental interactions, the result emerges in the form of a traceless operator in Hilbert space. The generality of the sum rule and its significance as a thermodynamic limit are discussed, and the applicability to real systems is assessed.

arXiv:physics/0305131•Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Nov 3, 2003•5 citations

Inhomogeneous spectral moment sum rules for the retarded Green function and self-energy of strongly correlated electrons or ultracold fermionic atoms in optical lattices

James K. Freericks, Volodymyr Turkowski

Spectral moment sum rules are presented for the inhomogeneous many-body problem described by the fermionic Falicov-Kimball or Hubbard models. These local sum rules allow for arbitrary hoppings, site energies, and interactions. They can be employed to quantify the accuracy of numerical solutions to the inhomogeneous many-body problem such as strongly correlated multilayered devices, ultracold atoms in an optical lattice with a trap potential, strongly correlated systems that are disordered, or systems with nontrivial spatial ordering such as a charge-density wave or a spin-density wave. We also show how the spectral moment sum rules determine the asymptotic behavior of the Green function, self-energy, and dynamical mean field when applied to the dynamical mean-field theory solution of the many-body problem. In particular, we illustrate in detail how one can dramatically reduce the number of Matsubara frequencies needed to solve the Falicov-Kimball model while still retaining high precision, and we sketch how one can incorporate these results into Hirsch-Fye quantum Monte Carlo solvers for the Hubbard (or more complicated) models. Since the solution of inhomogeneous problems is significantly more time consuming than periodic systems, efficient use of these sum rules can provide a dramatic speed up in the computational time required to solve the many-body problem. We also discuss how these sum rules behave in nonequilibrium situations as well, where the Hamiltonian has explicit time dependence due to a driving field or due to the time-dependent change in a parameter such as the interaction strength or the origin of the trap potential.

arXiv:0907.1284•Physical Review B•Sep 22, 2009•15 citations

Theory of radiation forces and momenta for mobile atoms in light fields

V. E. Lembessis, M. Babiker, C. Baxter +1 more

A theory for a bound system of charges interacting with electromagnetic fields is developed, with special emphasis on the radiation-pressure effects imposed by the fields on the gross motion of the charges. The theory is particularly simple and transparent for the case of two opposite charges of finite mass M in the electric-dipole approximation. This enables a rigorous description to be given for the quantum electrodynamics of the problem with the various interaction terms affecting the gross motion being easily identified. Here, too, it becomes clear that, even in the dipole approximation, the conventional interaction term should be supplemented by the so-called R\"ontgen term. Besides ensuring the consistency of the theory for the overall (charges plus fields) system regarding conservation laws, the R\"ontgen term has dynamical consequences. This is established by explicit calculations of the expectation values of the mechanical momentum 〈MR\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}〉 and the radiation pressure force 〈MR\ifmmode\ddot\else\textasciidieresis\fi{}〉 on a two-level atom in the dipole approximation. Results of calculations are displayed for the case of a single light beam and for counterpropagating beams. The feasibility of experimentally observing the transverse force is explored. Generalizations of the well-known friction force arising in one-dimensional optical molasses are given and discussed.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1993•63 citations
The Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn (TRK) sum rule is a fundamental consequence of the position-momentum commutation relation for an atomic electron, and it provides an important constraint on the transitionmatrix elements for an atom. Here, we propose a TRK sum rule for electromagnetic fields which is valid even in the presence of very strong light- matter interactions and/or optical nonlinearities. While the standard TRK sum rule involves dipole matrix moments calculated between atomic energy levels (in the absence of interaction with the field), the sum rule here proposed involves expectation values of field operators calculated between general eigenstates of the interacting light-matter system. This sum rule provides constraints and guidance for the analysis of strongly interacting light-matter systems and can be used to test the validity of approximate effective Hamiltonians often used in quantum optics.
Abstract The Thomas–Reiche–Kuhn (TRK) sum rule is a fundamental consequence of the position–momentum commutation relation for an atomic electron, and it provides an important constraint on the transition matrix elements for an atom. Here, we propose a TRK sum rule for electromagnetic fields which is valid even in the presence of very strong light–matter interactions and/or optical nonlinearities. While the standard TRK sum rule involves dipole matrix moments calculated between atomic energy levels (in the absence of interaction with the field), the sum rule here proposed involves expectation values of field operators calculated between general eigenstates of the interacting light–matter system. This sum rule provides constraints and guidance for the analysis of strongly interacting light–matter systems and can be used to test the validity of approximate effective Hamiltonians often used in quantum optics.
Some new sum rules for atomic transition probabilities are developed; they are similar to the well-known rule of Kuhn, Reiche, and Thomas. They give, if unpolarized light is incident on any gaseous element in any given discrete energy level, the total absorption, excitation plus ionization, with various types of frequency weighting. The results are similar to those of Dirac and Harding, but are more general in that they apply to any discrete state of any atom, rather than to the ground state of hydrogen only. The method differs from that of Dirac and Harding.
It is explicitly shown, for optical processes arbitrarily comprising two-, three- or four-photon interactions, that the sum over all matter states of any optical susceptibility is exactly zero. The result remains true even in frequency regions where damping is prominent. Using a quantum electrodynamical framework to render the photonic nature of the fundamental interactions, the result emerges in the form of a traceless operator in Hilbert space. The generality of the sum rule and its significance as a thermodynamic limit are discussed, and the applicability to real systems is assessed.
Spectral moment sum rules are presented for the inhomogeneous many-body problem described by the fermionic Falicov-Kimball or Hubbard models. These local sum rules allow for arbitrary hoppings, site energies, and interactions. They can be employed to quantify the accuracy of numerical solutions to the inhomogeneous many-body problem such as strongly correlated multilayered devices, ultracold atoms in an optical lattice with a trap potential, strongly correlated systems that are disordered, or systems with nontrivial spatial ordering such as a charge-density wave or a spin-density wave. We also show how the spectral moment sum rules determine the asymptotic behavior of the Green function, self-energy, and dynamical mean field when applied to the dynamical mean-field theory solution of the many-body problem. In particular, we illustrate in detail how one can dramatically reduce the number of Matsubara frequencies needed to solve the Falicov-Kimball model while still retaining high precision, and we sketch how one can incorporate these results into Hirsch-Fye quantum Monte Carlo solvers for the Hubbard (or more complicated) models. Since the solution of inhomogeneous problems is significantly more time consuming than periodic systems, efficient use of these sum rules can provide a dramatic speed up in the computational time required to solve the many-body problem. We also discuss how these sum rules behave in nonequilibrium situations as well, where the Hamiltonian has explicit time dependence due to a driving field or due to the time-dependent change in a parameter such as the interaction strength or the origin of the trap potential.
A theory for a bound system of charges interacting with electromagnetic fields is developed, with special emphasis on the radiation-pressure effects imposed by the fields on the gross motion of the charges. The theory is particularly simple and transparent for the case of two opposite charges of finite mass M in the electric-dipole approximation. This enables a rigorous description to be given for the quantum electrodynamics of the problem with the various interaction terms affecting the gross motion being easily identified. Here, too, it becomes clear that, even in the dipole approximation, the conventional interaction term should be supplemented by the so-called R\"ontgen term. Besides ensuring the consistency of the theory for the overall (charges plus fields) system regarding conservation laws, the R\"ontgen term has dynamical consequences. This is established by explicit calculations of the expectation values of the mechanical momentum 〈MR\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}〉 and the radiation pressure force 〈MR\ifmmode\ddot\else\textasciidieresis\fi{}〉 on a two-level atom in the dipole approximation. Results of calculations are displayed for the case of a single light beam and for counterpropagating beams. The feasibility of experimentally observing the transverse force is explored. Generalizations of the well-known friction force arising in one-dimensional optical molasses are given and discussed.