Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Ising formulations of some graph-theoretic problems in psychological research: models and methods

Michael J. Brusco, Clintin P. Davis‐Stober, Douglas Steinley

Published Sep 1, 2020• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

It is well known that many NP-hard and NP-complete graph-theoretic problems can be formulated and solved as Ising spin models. We discuss several problems that have a particular history in mathematical psychology, most notably max-cut clustering, graph coloring, a linear ordering problem related to paired comparison ranking and directed acyclic graphs, and the problem of finding a minimum subset of points necessary to contain another point within a convex hull. New Ising spin models are presented for the latter two problems. In addition, we provide MATLAB software programs for obtaining solutions via enumeration of all spin ensembles (when computationally feasible) and simulated annealing. Although we are not advocating that the Ising spin model is the preferred approach for formulation and solution of graph-theoretic problems on conventional digital computers, it does provide a unifying framework for these problems. Moreover, recent progress in the development of quantum computing architecture has shown that Ising spin models can afford enormous improvements in algorithm efficiency when implemented on these platforms, which may ultimately lead to widespread use of the methodology in the future.

DOI
10.31234/osf.io/4udfw

Related papers

Quantum-Assisted Graph Clustering and Quadratic Unconstrained D-ary Optimisation

Sayantan Pramanik, M Girish Chandra

Of late, we are witnessing spectacular developments in Quantum Information Processing with the availability of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum devices of different architectures and various software development kits to work on quantum algorithms. Different problems, which are hard to solve by classical computation, but can be sped up (significantly in some cases) are also being populated. Leveraging these aspects, this paper examines unsupervised graph clustering by quantum algorithms or, more precisely, quantum-assisted algorithms. By carefully examining the two cluster Max-Cut problem within the framework of quantum Ising model, an extension has been worked out for max 3-cut with the identification of an appropriate Hamiltonian. Representative results, after carrying out extensive numerical evaluations, have been provided including a suggestion for possible futuristic implementation with qutrit devices. Further, extrapolation to more than 3 classes, which can be handled by qudits, of both annealer and gate-circuit varieties, has also been touched upon with some preliminary observations; quantum-assisted solving of Quadratic Unconstrained D-ary Optimisation is arrived at within this context. As an additional novelty, a qudit circuit to solve max-d cut through Quantum Approximate Optimization algorithm is systematically constructed.

arXiv:2004.02608•Apr 3, 2020•8 citations

On connection among quantum-inspired algorithms of the Ising model

Bowen Liu, Kaizhi Wang, Dongmei Xiao +1 more

Various combinatorial optimization NP-hard problems can be reduced to finding the minimizer of an Ising model, which is a discrete mathematical model. It is an intellectual challenge to develop some mathematical tools or algorithms for solving the Ising model. Over the past decades, some continuous approaches or algorithms have been proposed from physical, mathematical or computational views for optimizing the Ising model such as quantum annealing, the coherent Ising machine, simulated annealing, adiabatic Hamiltonian systems, etc.. However, the mathematical principle of these algorithms is far from being understood. In this paper, we reveal the mathematical mechanism of dynamical system algorithms for the Ising model by Morse theory and variational methods. We prove that the dynamical system algorithms can be designed to minimize a continuous function whose local minimum points give all the candidates of the Ising model and the global minimum gives the minimizer of Ising problem. Using this mathematical mechanism, we can easily understand several dynamical system algorithms of the Ising model such as the coherent Ising machine, the Kerr-nonlinear parametric oscillators and the simulated bifurcation algorithm. Furthermore, motivated by the works of C. Conley, we study transit and capture properties of the simulated bifurcation algorithm to explain its convergence by the low energy transit and capture in celestial mechanics. A detailed discussion on $2$-spin and $3$-spin Ising models is presented as application.

arXiv:2012.01156•Communications in Mathematical Sciences•Jan 1, 2023•4 citations

Computational complexity continuum within Ising formulation of NP problems

Kirill P. Kalinin, Natalia G. Berloff

Abstract A promising approach to achieve computational supremacy over the classical von Neumann architecture explores classical and quantum hardware as Ising machines. The minimisation of the Ising Hamiltonian is known to be NP-hard problem yet not all problem instances are equivalently hard to optimise. Given that the operational principles of Ising machines are suited to the structure of some problems but not others, we propose to identify computationally simple instances with an ‘optimisation simplicity criterion’. Neuromorphic architectures based on optical, photonic, and electronic systems can naturally operate to optimise instances satisfying this criterion, which are therefore often chosen to illustrate the computational advantages of new Ising machines. As an example, we show that the Ising model on the Möbius ladder graph is ‘easy’ for Ising machines. By rewiring the Möbius ladder graph to random 3-regular graphs, we probe an intermediate computational complexity between P and NP-hard classes with several numerical methods. Significant fractions of polynomially simple instances are further found for a wide range of small size models from spin glasses to maximum cut problems. A compelling approach for distinguishing easy and hard instances within the same NP-hard class of problems can be a starting point in developing a standardised procedure for the performance evaluation of emerging physical simulators and physics-inspired algorithms.

arXiv:2008.00466•Communications Physics•Jan 12, 2022•64 citations

Quantum Computing, Ising Formulation, and the Traveling Salesman Problem

Omer Gurevich, Maor Matityahu, Tal Mor

Ising formulation is important for many NP problems (Lucas, 2014). This formulation enables implementing novel quantum computing methods including Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm and Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE). Here, we investigate closely the traveling salesman problem (TSP). First, we present some non-trivial issues related to Ising model view versus a realistic salesman. Then, focusing on VQE we discuss and clarify the use of: a.-- Conventional VQE and how it is relevant as a novel SAT-solver; b.-- Qubit efficiency and its importance in the Noisy Intermediate Scale Quantum-era; and c.-- the relevance and importance of a novel approach named Discrete Quantum Exhaustive Search (Alfassi, Meirom, and Mor, 2024), for enhancing VQE and other methods using mutually unbiased bases. The approach we present here in details can potentially be extended for analyzing approximating and solving various other NP complete problems. Our approach can also be extended beyond the Ising model and beyond the class NP, for example to the class Quantum Merlin Arthur (QMA) of problems, relevant for quantum chemistry and for general spin problems.

quant-pharXiv:2512.24308•Dec 31, 2025•1 citation

Approximation Meets Quantum: A Parameterized Framework for Large-Scale Graph Coloring

Rahul Pitale, Kapil Tajane, Prashant Ahire +4 more

Graph coloring is a well-known combinatorial optimization problem with broad applications in network security, scheduling, and register allocation. Being an NP-hard problem, exact solutions for large instances are computationally infeasible, calling for other solution strategies. In this study, parameterized and approximation methods to tackle the graph coloring problem are investigated. While approximation algorithms yield near-optimal solutions with theoretical guarantees of performance that are well-suited for large-scale applications, parameterized algorithms utilize graph-specific structural properties to manage constrained instances efficiently. We examine the trade-offs in these approaches, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses. In addition, we introduce a hybrid approach that combines both parameterized and approximation methods to best optimize computational resources and balance accuracy versus feasibility. Furthermore, we discuss the newly realized potential of quantum computing—specifically quantum annealing and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA)—to speed up graph coloring by leveraging quantum parallelism and state superposition. Such quantum-based techniques represent a promising line of attack for breaking up large and hard instances that overwhelm classical approaches. Future research will aim to tighten approximation guarantees, create quantum-augmented hybrid models, and test theoretical results against real-world datasets.

Asian Conference on Innovation in Technology (ASIANCON)•Aug 22, 2025•0 citations

Efficient Ising Model Mapping to Solving Slot Placement Problem

Sho Kanamaru, Daisuke Oku, Masashi Tawada +5 more

Ising model-based computation has attracted attention as it can obtain better solutions of various combinatorial optimization problems at high speed by mapping the problems to natural phenomena. A slot placement problem is one of the combinatorial optimization problems which plays an important role in the optimal logic-block placement as well as optimal delivery decisions but it is known as an NP-hard problem. Solving it efficiently is one of the largest challenges. In this paper, we propose an efficient Ising model mapping to solve the slot placement problem and an interpretation method for the obtained Ising solutions to satisfy the slot-placement constraints. First, we propose slot-placement constraint terms that minimize the energy function or Hamiltonian of the Ising model when satisfying the slot-placement constraints. Secondly, we propose an objective function term in the energy function that minimizes the total weighted wiring length between items to be placed to the slots. In Ising model-based computations, the final spin states cannot necessarily satisfy the slot-placement constraints, which gives one of the largest differences from the conventional computations. Hence we newly propose an interpretation method for the obtained Ising solutions to satisfy the slot-placement constraints. On a fully-connected annealing machine, we could obtain feasible solutions with almost the same accuracy as the simulated annealing for slot placement problem with two orders of magnitude faster.

International Conference on Consumer Electronics•Jan 1, 2019•15 citations
It is well known that many NP-hard and NP-complete graph-theoretic problems can be formulated and solved as Ising spin models. We discuss several problems that have a particular history in mathematical psychology, most notably max-cut clustering, graph coloring, a linear ordering problem related to paired comparison ranking and directed acyclic graphs, and the problem of finding a minimum subset of points necessary to contain another point within a convex hull. New Ising spin models are presented for the latter two problems. In addition, we provide MATLAB software programs for obtaining solutions via enumeration of all spin ensembles (when computationally feasible) and simulated annealing. Although we are not advocating that the Ising spin model is the preferred approach for formulation and solution of graph-theoretic problems on conventional digital computers, it does provide a unifying framework for these problems. Moreover, recent progress in the development of quantum computing architecture has shown that Ising spin models can afford enormous improvements in algorithm efficiency when implemented on these platforms, which may ultimately lead to widespread use of the methodology in the future.
Of late, we are witnessing spectacular developments in Quantum Information Processing with the availability of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum devices of different architectures and various software development kits to work on quantum algorithms. Different problems, which are hard to solve by classical computation, but can be sped up (significantly in some cases) are also being populated. Leveraging these aspects, this paper examines unsupervised graph clustering by quantum algorithms or, more precisely, quantum-assisted algorithms. By carefully examining the two cluster Max-Cut problem within the framework of quantum Ising model, an extension has been worked out for max 3-cut with the identification of an appropriate Hamiltonian. Representative results, after carrying out extensive numerical evaluations, have been provided including a suggestion for possible futuristic implementation with qutrit devices. Further, extrapolation to more than 3 classes, which can be handled by qudits, of both annealer and gate-circuit varieties, has also been touched upon with some preliminary observations; quantum-assisted solving of Quadratic Unconstrained D-ary Optimisation is arrived at within this context. As an additional novelty, a qudit circuit to solve max-d cut through Quantum Approximate Optimization algorithm is systematically constructed.
Various combinatorial optimization NP-hard problems can be reduced to finding the minimizer of an Ising model, which is a discrete mathematical model. It is an intellectual challenge to develop some mathematical tools or algorithms for solving the Ising model. Over the past decades, some continuous approaches or algorithms have been proposed from physical, mathematical or computational views for optimizing the Ising model such as quantum annealing, the coherent Ising machine, simulated annealing, adiabatic Hamiltonian systems, etc.. However, the mathematical principle of these algorithms is far from being understood. In this paper, we reveal the mathematical mechanism of dynamical system algorithms for the Ising model by Morse theory and variational methods. We prove that the dynamical system algorithms can be designed to minimize a continuous function whose local minimum points give all the candidates of the Ising model and the global minimum gives the minimizer of Ising problem. Using this mathematical mechanism, we can easily understand several dynamical system algorithms of the Ising model such as the coherent Ising machine, the Kerr-nonlinear parametric oscillators and the simulated bifurcation algorithm. Furthermore, motivated by the works of C. Conley, we study transit and capture properties of the simulated bifurcation algorithm to explain its convergence by the low energy transit and capture in celestial mechanics. A detailed discussion on 222-spin and 333-spin Ising models is presented as application.
Abstract A promising approach to achieve computational supremacy over the classical von Neumann architecture explores classical and quantum hardware as Ising machines. The minimisation of the Ising Hamiltonian is known to be NP-hard problem yet not all problem instances are equivalently hard to optimise. Given that the operational principles of Ising machines are suited to the structure of some problems but not others, we propose to identify computationally simple instances with an ‘optimisation simplicity criterion’. Neuromorphic architectures based on optical, photonic, and electronic systems can naturally operate to optimise instances satisfying this criterion, which are therefore often chosen to illustrate the computational advantages of new Ising machines. As an example, we show that the Ising model on the Möbius ladder graph is ‘easy’ for Ising machines. By rewiring the Möbius ladder graph to random 3-regular graphs, we probe an intermediate computational complexity between P and NP-hard classes with several numerical methods. Significant fractions of polynomially simple instances are further found for a wide range of small size models from spin glasses to maximum cut problems. A compelling approach for distinguishing easy and hard instances within the same NP-hard class of problems can be a starting point in developing a standardised procedure for the performance evaluation of emerging physical simulators and physics-inspired algorithms.
Ising formulation is important for many NP problems (Lucas, 2014). This formulation enables implementing novel quantum computing methods including Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm and Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE). Here, we investigate closely the traveling salesman problem (TSP). First, we present some non-trivial issues related to Ising model view versus a realistic salesman. Then, focusing on VQE we discuss and clarify the use of: a.-- Conventional VQE and how it is relevant as a novel SAT-solver; b.-- Qubit efficiency and its importance in the Noisy Intermediate Scale Quantum-era; and c.-- the relevance and importance of a novel approach named Discrete Quantum Exhaustive Search (Alfassi, Meirom, and Mor, 2024), for enhancing VQE and other methods using mutually unbiased bases. The approach we present here in details can potentially be extended for analyzing approximating and solving various other NP complete problems. Our approach can also be extended beyond the Ising model and beyond the class NP, for example to the class Quantum Merlin Arthur (QMA) of problems, relevant for quantum chemistry and for general spin problems.
Graph coloring is a well-known combinatorial optimization problem with broad applications in network security, scheduling, and register allocation. Being an NP-hard problem, exact solutions for large instances are computationally infeasible, calling for other solution strategies. In this study, parameterized and approximation methods to tackle the graph coloring problem are investigated. While approximation algorithms yield near-optimal solutions with theoretical guarantees of performance that are well-suited for large-scale applications, parameterized algorithms utilize graph-specific structural properties to manage constrained instances efficiently. We examine the trade-offs in these approaches, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses. In addition, we introduce a hybrid approach that combines both parameterized and approximation methods to best optimize computational resources and balance accuracy versus feasibility. Furthermore, we discuss the newly realized potential of quantum computing—specifically quantum annealing and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA)—to speed up graph coloring by leveraging quantum parallelism and state superposition. Such quantum-based techniques represent a promising line of attack for breaking up large and hard instances that overwhelm classical approaches. Future research will aim to tighten approximation guarantees, create quantum-augmented hybrid models, and test theoretical results against real-world datasets.
Ising model-based computation has attracted attention as it can obtain better solutions of various combinatorial optimization problems at high speed by mapping the problems to natural phenomena. A slot placement problem is one of the combinatorial optimization problems which plays an important role in the optimal logic-block placement as well as optimal delivery decisions but it is known as an NP-hard problem. Solving it efficiently is one of the largest challenges. In this paper, we propose an efficient Ising model mapping to solve the slot placement problem and an interpretation method for the obtained Ising solutions to satisfy the slot-placement constraints. First, we propose slot-placement constraint terms that minimize the energy function or Hamiltonian of the Ising model when satisfying the slot-placement constraints. Secondly, we propose an objective function term in the energy function that minimizes the total weighted wiring length between items to be placed to the slots. In Ising model-based computations, the final spin states cannot necessarily satisfy the slot-placement constraints, which gives one of the largest differences from the conventional computations. Hence we newly propose an interpretation method for the obtained Ising solutions to satisfy the slot-placement constraints. On a fully-connected annealing machine, we could obtain feasible solutions with almost the same accuracy as the simulated annealing for slot placement problem with two orders of magnitude faster.