Panpsychism is often thought to be an obviously mistaken doctrine, because it is considered to be completely inconceivable how the elementary particles of physics could possibly have proto-mental properties. Pylkkänen points out that quantum theory implies that elementary particles are far more subtle and strange than most contemporary physicalist philosophers assume. He discusses David Bohm’s famous “pilot wave” theory which implies that, say, an electron is a particle guided by a field carrying active information, the latter of which can be seen as a primitive mind-like quality.
Panpsychism is often thought to be an obviously mistaken doctrine, because it is considered to be completely inconceivable how the elementary particles of physics could possibly have proto-mental properties. Pylkkänen points out that quantum theory implies that elementary particles are far more subtle and strange than most contemporary physicalist philosophers assume. He discusses David Bohm’s famous “pilot wave” theory which implies that, say, an electron is a particle guided by a field carrying active information, the latter of which can be seen as a primitive mind-like quality.
Many scholars and commentators claim that David Bohm was a panpsychist, for he stated that even elementary quantum particles exhibit a sort of rudimentary or primitive mind-like quality. Analysing in detail both Bohm’s pilot-wave theory and his works concerning the relation between mind and matter, this paper investigates whether it is accurate to consider Bohm a supporter of such a view. By putting some pressure and casting doubts on this generally accepted belief, I offer a new interpretation of Bohm’s views suggesting that panpsychism is not sufficient to faithfully represent his perspective about the link between the mental and physical sides of reality.
Perhaps more so than any other twentieth-century physicist, David Bohm was trying to develop an ontological interpretation for quantum theory, i.e. an interpretation which tells us what quantum theory says about the nature of reality. He is best known for presenting in 1952 an improved version of de Broglie’s ‘pilot-wave’ theory, which says that an electron is a particle always accompanied by a new type of quantum field or pilot wave which guides it. In later research Bohm realized that the pilot wave is not pushing and pulling the particle mechanically but rather contains information which guides the particle, analogously to the way radar waves guide a ship on autopilot. The postulation of such objective and active information to the quantum level is a radical metaphysical move which also opens a new way to understand how the material and mental sides of reality are related to each other. It might even make it easier to understand what phenomenal properties are and how they could play a causal role in the physical world. This paper provides an overview of not only the pilot-wave theory, but also Bohm’s other related frameworks, namely the implicate order and soma-significance. It is suggested that these views point to a new theory of the relation of consciousness and matter which we can call interactionist dual-aspect monism. This theory suggests, against illusionism, that phenomenal properties exist and, against idealism, that the world has a material aspect which exists independently of the human mind ‐ thus ‘real consciousness in a real world’.
Abstract The paper proposes that quantum theory implies a radically new notion of matter which has not been properly understood before David Bohm’s groundbreaking work. Bohm proposed that the fundamental particles of physics (such as electrons) are not merely pushed around mechanically by classical forces but are also able to respond to information. Information is thus assumed to be an objective commodity which can exist independently of the human mind and which actively guides or instructs physical processes. This notion of active information also applies in computational, biological and psychological phenomena, thus helping us to understand how the mental and the physical sides of reality are related. It may even help us to understand the nature of conscious experience. The latter part of the paper considers the deeper mathematical and physical background of quantum theory and suggests that we need to revise our basic assumptions about quantum objects, such as the role of the wave function.
Abstract The pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm has a special place in the history of contemporary physics, being it the very first alternative formulation of quantum mechanics. As is well-known, such a framework established itself as a leading interpretation of the quantum formalism in virtue of the solutions provided to the major technical and conceptual challenges affecting the orthodox view. The de Broglie-Bohm theory in fact not only solves the famous measurement problem, one of the most cogent issues faced by standard quantum mechanics, but also it clarifies the formal structure of the latter theory as a consequence of a consistent set of principles and an precise, unambiguous ontology. This volume aims to provide the reader with a discussion of the pilot-wave perspective which is as informative, comprehensive and accessible as possible, while at the same time clarifying confusions and misunderstandings that are unfortunately still common in literature despite the long history of this theoretical framework. The book features chapters about the various perspectives on the pilot-wave theory, its extensions to relativity and quantum field theory, and its experimental applications to various branches of physics, as for instance quantum electrodynamics, quantum chemistry, and quantum engineering. Moreover, the volume includes essays on the history and philosophy of de Broglie-Bohm theory in order to delineate its developments and the vicissitudes of its pioneers, as well as to understand the scientific image of the universe it provides.
Abstract Beyond the Quantum offers a panoramic rethink of quantum physics, with potentially revolutionary implications for cosmology, quantum gravity, and quantum technology. Properly understood, ‘pilot-wave theory’ provides a deeper foundation for quantum mechanics, while also going beyond it. First proposed in the 1920s by French aristocrat and physicist Louis de Broglie, and revived in the 1950s by American physicist David Bohm, the theory posits hidden particle motions we cannot currently see or control. The theory is usually regarded as merely an alternative account of the same physics we already know. In fact, pilot-wave theory implies a wealth of new and radical physics beyond the reach of quantum mechanics. Pilot-wave theory tells us that quantum physics is a special case of something broader and deeper. In more general ‘nonequilibrium’ conditions, Einstein’s relativity and Heisenberg’s uncertainty break down. Superluminal signalling becomes possible, and quantum particles can be clearly seen and controlled. This new physics could have left traces in the early universe, and it might be visible today in radiation from exploding primordial black holes. Harnessing this new physics would have transformative technological implications, in particular for communication, cryptography, and computing. Drawing intriguing parallels between the present era of quantum physics and past episodes of scientific confusion, this book tells the story of how pilot-wave theory was discovered and abandoned, revived and reconstructed, and how today it can pave the way to a new and radical physics beyond the quantum.
Bohmian Mechanics (Dürr et al. 1992) and the Pilot Wave theory (Valentini 1991) provide two opposite understandings of what guides the particles. On one hand there is a universal nomological wave-function (Dürr et al. 1997), which dictates the motion of the particles (the primitive ontology), on the other hand there is universal Ψ-field, which acts causally on the particle configuration. Both views have to face many challenges. Among them, the nomological interpretation has to account for how the law – the wave-function - is grounded in the primitive ontology (Esfeld 2013), while the causal interpretation has to solve the problem of how an entity in configuration space can be the cause of a motion in physical space (Esfeld et al. 2013). Considering now the problem of the nomological interpretation, the anchorage of the lawlike wave-function to the primitive ontology was provided by Esfeld, who recently proposed to ground the wave-function in a dispositional property instantiated by all the particles taken as a whole (Esfeld et al. 2013). However, two challenges come here: the first concerns the tension in deciding whether or not the dispositional property should be part of the primitive ontology, and the second concerns the weak explanatory power that the dispositionalist account can provide. The debate has led to an interesting structuralist account (Esfeld et al. 2015, Lam 2015), which is to regard the wave-function as a modal structure, which relates all the particles of the universe in a non-local fashion, hence explaining the dynamics of the particles. Regarding the problems of the causal interpretation, Valentini thinks of the Ψ- field not as concrete and as physical as an electromagnetic field, but as a ‘more abstract field’ (Valentini 1991): in fact, it lives in configuration space and for this reason it does not admit test particles. Moreover, he does not regard it as an efficient cause of the particle configuration, but as a formal cause, in an Aristotelian-Thomistic sense, in such a way that it should be considered as a guiding form. According to his Aristotelian view of formal cause, the motion is the fulfilling of what exists potentially, which is represented by the Ψ-field (Valentini 1991). The reason why the Ψ-field should be regarded as a real ‘guiding form’ is twofold: on one hand it is its form that determines the trajectories of the particles, on the other hand, its role is to storage formal information between the particles. After having analyzed both representations of the ‘Ψ’, as a modal structure in the first scenario, and as a formal cause in the second, I will claim that, if we hold Esfeld’s account of the universal wave-function in Bohmian Mechanics and the characterization by Valentini of the pilot wave, then the two views do not differ as much as it is normally thought, because in both the wave-function is regarded as a dynamical structure. This reconciliation is especially achieved if we consider that, being all the particles identical, both theories may be reformulated in a reduced-configuration space.