Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Edinburgh University Press eBooks

9. On Herstein’s ‘Quanta and Corpuscles’

Ronny Desmet

Published Jan 7, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this chapter Ronny Desmet airs some disagreements with Gary Herstein’s earlier chapter on ‘Quanta and Corpuscles’, arguing for a more nuanced understanding of Bohr’s Copenhagen interpretation. He also notes that concept of continuity can be reasonably easily understood as the divisibility-indivisibility contrast, and that Lewis Ford’s temporal atomism thesis is note definitively dead, since Whitehead did change his mind from an idea of continuous becoming to one of atomic becoming

DOI
10.1515/9781474459426-013

Related papers

Reply to Desmet

Gary L. Herstein

In this short chapter, Gary Herstein replies to Ronny Desmet’s critique of his earlier chapter, arguing that his discussion of the fifth Solvay conference highlights the underestimated maelstrom of confusion in physics at the time, and that it is not clear that Bohr even understood or adequately responded to Einstein’s arguments, and that his interpretation is based on a wilful acceptance of incoherence at the base of reality. He also argues that Lewis Ford, not being a mathematician, was heavily ‘reading in’ the concept of temporal atomism into Whitehead’s philosophy without any clear understanding of Whitehead’s mathematical habits of thought.

Edinburgh University Press eBooks•Feb 1, 2020•0 citations

Puzzling over quantum mechanics

Alastair I. M. Rae

What is it about quantum mechanics that continues to make its interpretation so difficult and controversial? It is now more than 70 years after its inception and at least half a century since the verification of its predictions of physical phenomena that range from the motion of electrons in solids to the basic structure and properties of the atomic nucleus. After reading the first half of this book one could be forgiven for believing that it has been just our unwillingness or inability to understand properly what Niels Bohr said from the beginning, and to update these ideas in the light of later experience. The aim of the present book is to do just this: to restate the Copenhagen interpretation and to show us how it has been developed to take modern results and ideas into account.

Physics World•Feb 1, 1995•0 citations

Comparative Discussion

Harald Atmanspacher A, Dean P. Rickles

There are no overt lines of in?uence between the quantum-inspired dual-aspect approaches presented in previous chapters – though Pauli’s and Wheeler’s inspirations might have a common origin in some of Bohr’s ideas, and some of Bohm and Hiley’s speculations build on Eddington. But they were essentially each developed independently from one another, somewhat surprisingly converging onto numerous common features that are compared in this chapter. Connections are sought amongst their deeper philosophical foundations, especially those by Spinoza, Kant, Schelling and Hegel. Also explored is the way in which different elements of the surface structure and deep structure of meaning are positioned at the core of their metaphysical projects, along with the way in which the mind-matter connection is understood. A synoptic overview facilitates the comparison of key concepts and notions utilized in the three approaches.

Routledge eBooks•Jan 31, 2022•0 citations

8. Whitehead’s Highly Speculative Lectures on Quantum Theory

Ronny Desmet

Ronny Desmet endeavors in this chapter to examine Whitehead’s theory of quantum theory and primates as found in his Harvard lectures using Clerk Maxwell’s theory of electromagnetism as a starting point while refusing to abandon the idea of continuous space-time, using wave equations as his mathematical vehicle. The chapter contains sections detailing Whitehead’s alternative theory of gravitation, his paradigm of the electron as a complex organism, and his reaction to Niels Bohr’s model of the atom. The chapter concluded that Whitehead wanted a complete reconceptualisation of the atom in terms of atomic structures of vibrations, intending to leave behind all remnants of the materialistic theory in favour of an organic theory.

Edinburgh University Press eBooks•Jan 7, 2020•1 citation

An Examination of the Quantum Theories. IV

William Marias Malisoff

We pause in the process of exposition to note what continuity we may in the progress of the theories of discontinuity we have been discussing. The following trends are rather distinct: (1) the development of more and more general mathematical approaches, (2) a marked broadening of the field of experimental issues, and (3) an increasing attention to analysis of fundamental concepts, the philosophy of physics.

Philosophy of Science•Jul 1, 1935•0 citations

From quantum inseparability to semantic holism

S. Osnaghi

De l’inséparabilité quantique au holisme sémantique La thèse vise à montrer que la cohérence de l’interprétation instrumentaliste de la mécaniquequantique (sur laquelle les reconstructions logiques de la théorie, d’inspiration pragmatiste, s’appuient) ne peut pas être défendue sans remettre en cause la sémantique extensionnelle utilisée en logique classique. J’examine en particulier les arguments misen avant par Niels Bohr, en montrant que son analyse physique du processus de mesureest insuffisante pour assurer la cohérence de l’interprétation conditionnelle des probabilités quantiques qu’il adopte. Au lieu d’essayer de ‘compléter’ l’approche de Bohrpar un compte rendu plus exhaustif des processus physiques (telle la décohérence) quijouent un rôle dans l’observation, je suggère que le problème de la mesure découle d’unethéorie de la signification inadéquate. Je discute l’intérêt et les limites de la critiquebohrienne des présupposés représentationalistes inhérents à la description classique desphénomènes, et je conclus en formulant l’hypothèse que l’adoption d’une sémantiqueinférentialiste permettrait d’envisager à la fois la dissolution du problème de la mesureet la justification a priori des traits structuraux des probabilités quantiques (comme étantl’expression des relations conceptuelles présupposées par tout langage qui doit incluredes énoncés objectifs).

•Dec 22, 2014•0 citations
In this chapter Ronny Desmet airs some disagreements with Gary Herstein’s earlier chapter on ‘Quanta and Corpuscles’, arguing for a more nuanced understanding of Bohr’s Copenhagen interpretation. He also notes that concept of continuity can be reasonably easily understood as the divisibility-indivisibility contrast, and that Lewis Ford’s temporal atomism thesis is note definitively dead, since Whitehead did change his mind from an idea of continuous becoming to one of atomic becoming
In this short chapter, Gary Herstein replies to Ronny Desmet’s critique of his earlier chapter, arguing that his discussion of the fifth Solvay conference highlights the underestimated maelstrom of confusion in physics at the time, and that it is not clear that Bohr even understood or adequately responded to Einstein’s arguments, and that his interpretation is based on a wilful acceptance of incoherence at the base of reality. He also argues that Lewis Ford, not being a mathematician, was heavily ‘reading in’ the concept of temporal atomism into Whitehead’s philosophy without any clear understanding of Whitehead’s mathematical habits of thought.
What is it about quantum mechanics that continues to make its interpretation so difficult and controversial? It is now more than 70 years after its inception and at least half a century since the verification of its predictions of physical phenomena that range from the motion of electrons in solids to the basic structure and properties of the atomic nucleus. After reading the first half of this book one could be forgiven for believing that it has been just our unwillingness or inability to understand properly what Niels Bohr said from the beginning, and to update these ideas in the light of later experience. The aim of the present book is to do just this: to restate the Copenhagen interpretation and to show us how it has been developed to take modern results and ideas into account.
There are no overt lines of in?uence between the quantum-inspired dual-aspect approaches presented in previous chapters – though Pauli’s and Wheeler’s inspirations might have a common origin in some of Bohr’s ideas, and some of Bohm and Hiley’s speculations build on Eddington. But they were essentially each developed independently from one another, somewhat surprisingly converging onto numerous common features that are compared in this chapter. Connections are sought amongst their deeper philosophical foundations, especially those by Spinoza, Kant, Schelling and Hegel. Also explored is the way in which different elements of the surface structure and deep structure of meaning are positioned at the core of their metaphysical projects, along with the way in which the mind-matter connection is understood. A synoptic overview facilitates the comparison of key concepts and notions utilized in the three approaches.
Ronny Desmet endeavors in this chapter to examine Whitehead’s theory of quantum theory and primates as found in his Harvard lectures using Clerk Maxwell’s theory of electromagnetism as a starting point while refusing to abandon the idea of continuous space-time, using wave equations as his mathematical vehicle. The chapter contains sections detailing Whitehead’s alternative theory of gravitation, his paradigm of the electron as a complex organism, and his reaction to Niels Bohr’s model of the atom. The chapter concluded that Whitehead wanted a complete reconceptualisation of the atom in terms of atomic structures of vibrations, intending to leave behind all remnants of the materialistic theory in favour of an organic theory.
De l’inséparabilité quantique au holisme sémantique La thèse vise à montrer que la cohérence de l’interprétation instrumentaliste de la mécaniquequantique (sur laquelle les reconstructions logiques de la théorie, d’inspiration pragmatiste, s’appuient) ne peut pas être défendue sans remettre en cause la sémantique extensionnelle utilisée en logique classique. J’examine en particulier les arguments misen avant par Niels Bohr, en montrant que son analyse physique du processus de mesureest insuffisante pour assurer la cohérence de l’interprétation conditionnelle des probabilités quantiques qu’il adopte. Au lieu d’essayer de ‘compléter’ l’approche de Bohrpar un compte rendu plus exhaustif des processus physiques (telle la décohérence) quijouent un rôle dans l’observation, je suggère que le problème de la mesure découle d’unethéorie de la signification inadéquate. Je discute l’intérêt et les limites de la critiquebohrienne des présupposés représentationalistes inhérents à la description classique desphénomènes, et je conclus en formulant l’hypothèse que l’adoption d’une sémantiqueinférentialiste permettrait d’envisager à la fois la dissolution du problème de la mesureet la justification a priori des traits structuraux des probabilités quantiques (comme étantl’expression des relations conceptuelles présupposées par tout langage qui doit incluredes énoncés objectifs).