Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks

Conclusions

Published Jul 7, 2017• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this part of the book, we have explored in a very elementary way the use of the number operator and its companions, the number amplitude operators, that correspond to creation and annihilation operators in QFT, to model some simple systems in which populations of people, goods, cash etc. vary in time, through being exchanged between different elements of the system as a whole. We have picked extremely simple systems with only a few agents to illustrate the principles involved. We have stressed a key property of this approach to be the existence of certain conservation rules. This is a really important aspect of the modeling and something that physicists always look for in dealing with physical systems, whether they be treated classically of by quantum methods. Whether the system involves galaxies or a few atoms, a physicist will insist that fundamental quantities like energy and momentum are conserved as the system evolves. This constraint is vital in deciding on the validity of the model. It is very easy to write lines of computer code with a perfectly correct set of equations, but which overall do not keep some conserved quantity constant. Models of isolated systems that do not constrain totals of energy and momentum to be fixed should certainly be deemed invalid. The reason is that it is possible to demonstrate mathematically that the accepted theories of physics conserve these quantities. Moreover, the conserved quantities tell physicists precisely what parameters they need to model. For example, physics tells us to measure and keep track of the product of mass times velocity (momentum) and one half times mass, times velocity squared (kinetic energy). Using mass times velocity cubed, for example, would be a waste of time, since it is not part of the great accounting process that controls motion in the universe. It is precisely these features of a physical system that tell the physicist that it is a waste of time thinking about a perpetual motion machine, or something that gives energy for nothing. In contrast, many non-physically based systems models have no all-enveloping theory that tells the modeler what parameters to choose for modeling. With the Lokta–Volterra model (LVM) for example, it seems intuitively obvious to pick the population values of rabbits and foxes and write an albeit ad hoc equation for their variation in time. But why not pick the population number squared? There is nothing to tell us not to. The same appears true of financial models. One picks income, or price or tax. Why not use some combination or some function of these quantities? There are no rules, apart from convention or intuition that constrains the choice of such variables. Why should this matter, well, it could lead to a prediction of something for nothing. The equivalent of a perpetual motion machine might then seem possible in finance or economics. Is continuous economic growth really possible? This may look as feasible as a perpetual motion machine did before the rules of physics were properly understood.

DOI
10.1142/9781786342782_0008

Related papers

Conclusion

Emmanuel E. Haven, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

This book had as its main objective to discuss how (quantum) physics concepts could be used in a relevant way in the modeling of a variety of economics/finance and psychology-based processes.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 17, 2013•0 citations

The Underlying Simplicity at the Subatomic Domain Can Describe the Diverse and Complex Universe - Where Matter and Energy are the Flipped Side of the Same Coin

The Quantum theory deals with the microscopic structure of the Universe that describes the finer details of nature at the subatomic domain.To a physicist, quantum mechanics is one of the three great pillars supporting our intuition of evocative, bewildering and fascinating natural World as we continuously struggle with the inescapable strangeness of the subatomic domain as if something strange is always afoot.It is well accepted fact that quantum mechanics is a physical theory that describes the way things behave at subatomic level which is quite dazzling in its precision and explanatory power.A test of quantum electrodynamics, the oldest and best understood of the modern quantum theory that involves measuring the way an electron behaves in the vicinity of a magnetic force. Many of the technological and social changes that have revolutionized our lives have actually risen out of the fundamental theoretical research carried out with only motivation to understand the World in a better way than ever. For example, the invention of transistor actually came with the fundamental theoretical research on the Uncertainty Principle which states that the uncertainty of the position of a particle times the uncertainty of its velocity is always a constant. If we double the certainty of the position of the particle, we have to make half the certainty of its velocity and vice versa. Quantum theory is perhaps the prime example of the infinitely esoteric in the sense that it describes a World in which a particle really can be in several places at once and it moves from one place to another by exploring the entire Universe simultaneously-the theory of simultaneity. The diverse and complex Universe is actually made of a few tiny particles according to the rules of quantum theory which is so simple that can be summarized on the back of an envelope. The more we understand about the elemental nature of the Universe, the simpler it looks. We have already discovered that everything in the diverse and complex Universe is nothing but the different assemblies of atoms, and the wide variety of atoms are constructed using the three building blocks at the sub-atomic domain i.e. subatomic particles: protons, neutrons and electrons. We have also discovered that protons and neutrons ate made up of combination of three entities called quarks. And that is where things stop as far as recent discovery is concerned. But the recent progress in particle physics inspiring the quest for the ultimate unified theory of physics that can describe everything in the Universe in one go. The discovery of Boson particle certainty will revolutionaries the Newton's mass concept and gravity into whole new looks. To an optimistic point of view, we must hope the best out of the progress in physics.

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)•Feb 5, 2016•0 citations

Conclusions

Gerard ’t Hooft

The conclusion of Part I, the non-technical (or somewhat less technical) part of this book, is that a completely convincing model of our universe is lacking. This should be a model that shows how quantum mechanical behaviour, with all its mysteries and paradoxes, can emerge from a local, deterministic theory. Yet we also find that one can assume its existence to arrive at a picture of our quantum mechanical universe that makes perfect sense. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Fundamental theories of physics•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Is what we see a projection? Objects as the common part of two points of view, tested on a quantum-Darwinism model

Ugo Lanciano

Common introduction to all the records of this series. Already read it? Skip to the content of this record ↓ Mathematical Materiality (MM) in brief. Why are the laws of physics the same everywhere and at every instant, even though nothing forces matter to obey them? MM proposes an answer: the laws are not rules imposed on matter from the outside; rather, matter itself is made of mathematical relations. And mathematics cannot change: a relation binds two distinct terms everywhere and always. In logic, nothing exists on its own: to exist means to be in relation to another logical entity, and outside this web of relations nothing can exist, not even other universes. This reading is already compared with experimental measurements at two points. First, the ratio of dark to ordinary matter is read as 3√3 = 5.196; when left free in the fits, Planck and DESI DR2 data give 5.21–5.22 (as registered in record 2.44, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23329080). Second, the acceleration scale of galaxies is read as a₀ = cH₀/6, the same scale that appears in Verlinde's emergent gravity: the computed value is 1.09–1.18 × 10⁻¹⁰ m/s² against the measured value of 1.20 × 10⁻¹⁰ m/s² (record 2.46.1, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23506655). Both readings were formulated with the measurements already known; the tests to check them against future data are registered in the same records. MM also changes the picture of the world. Reality is not made of separate objects, each complete in itself, in empty space: it is a material structure whose nature is a logical description. The observer does not look at it from outside: it is inside it, and always finds the logical mirror of its own position in front of itself. The objects it sees are, necessarily, diffractions of its point of view: the parts into which its description divides, like a unit into fractions. But each object in turn exists in its own logical mirror, exactly like its observer. This is why things do not exist only when someone looks at them, and yet none exists on its own: every property of a thing is a link with its observer. For MM, this is the only rational answer to the opening question: if everything is made of the relations that the laws describe, nothing can escape the laws and no one has to enforce them. For this reason the universe behaves like a simulation without really being one. It follows exact rules, made of counts, everywhere and at every instant, but no machine runs them and no programmer wrote them: a structure of mathematical relations does not need to be computed in order to exist. Tegmark (2008) had already noted that such a simulation need not be run, while Vazza (2025) estimated that running it physically on a machine would require resources that the very laws of the universe do not allow. In the first logical nexus between space and time — which relativity describes together as a single spacetime — there is a non-local phase, made only of a pure logical distinction: space is not time. In this phase, between space and time there is no relation of quantitative calculation, only the logical entity they have in common, which is needed to make them exist with respect to each other: we shall call this entity their greatest common divisor (GCD), just as the numbers 3 and 5 have only 1 in common. "Non-local" here does not mean that something is confined far away or acts at a distance: it means that the non-local phase is in no place and at no instant, while being present in every phase of reality, in every place and at every instant (MM 2.72). This non-local phase manifests itself in entanglement: two distant systems, without anything physically travelling from one to the other, remain correlated more strongly than any explanation based on separate properties and on the absence of faster-than-light influences allows: this is the violation of Bell's inequalities. The local world arises when a relation is counted through this GCD: its multiples and its fractions form a matrix. Seen by an observer inside the system like us, the multiples, which follow one another in a chain that never reverses, appear as time; the fractions, which stand side by side, appear as space. When that same multiple is directly contained in the matrix of the point of observation, it turns into mass — that is, into concrete matter as we usually understand it. There is therefore a close link between time and mass, which physics also recognizes: every mass has its own rhythm, its Compton frequency mc²/h (MM 2.64.1). The observed objects, while being logically autonomous entities in their local relations, enter into relation with the observer through the logical diffraction of the observer's matrix. Where space and objects come from can be shown with a simple fraction. The whole is the GCD of the point of observation, the 1 from which every description starts. The denominator tells how many equal parts this 1 is divided into: they are the fractions side by side that appear as space, the grain with which the observer tells things apart. The numerator tells how many of those parts an object occupies: it is its size as seen from that point. The parts that no object occupies appear as empty space: not a container that was there before, but divisions of the observer's 1. Full or empty, all the parts are fractions of the same 1: what makes them a single description is the non-local phase, which lies in no single part yet is present in all of them. And just as 3/8 and 6/16 have the same value, if the 1 is divided into parts half as large, the object occupies twice as many: its size is the ratio, which does not change. Mass, by contrast, does not lie in the fraction but in the multiple contained in the matrix of the point of observation: it is the count that repeats, the rhythm mentioned above. This reading also gives a reason for the limit of the speed of light, which in Einstein's relativity is instead taken as a starting principle. The speed of light is the fixed exchange rate between the multiples and the fractions of the same GCD, meaning how much space a single step of time is worth: exceeding it would mean, for some observer, covering space without counting time, and thus leaving the local world. Logic always starts from a logical relative, and this exchange rate has nothing absolute in itself either: it is a necessary relative which, inside the system, becomes an absolute hypothesis, the same for everyone and impossible to exceed. Outside the system, by contrast, it has no justification at all, because outside there is only non-existence: justifying something requires another term to relate it to, and out there there is none. Asking for a reason from outside is like asking what lies north of the North Pole. The same theoretical framework that reads space, time, mass and the observed objects also admits quantum mechanics. The non-local phase and the mirror-like logical reciprocity between the two ends of the nexus give a reason for the probabilistic behaviour of matter. When the mass of the observed object is large enough compared with that of the point of observation, it fixes the object in the matrix of the latter: for this reason we see it in one precise place and at one precise instant. When instead this ratio falls below a certain threshold, the principal GCD (that of the point of observation) and the GCD of the diffraction that generates the object are forced to become equal, and they reflect each other as in a mirror. At that point the object no longer occupies a single point of the spacetime generated by the observer, but spreads over several possible positions, and we observe it as probability. It is like having to describe the number 10 using only the number 1: the only way is to distribute the 1 into ten copies, one for each unit of the 10. The probability here is not that of a die: these copies add up like waves and can also cancel each other out. This adding up and cancelling out is called interference. It can be seen in the double-slit experiment: where the waves arrive in step the screen lights up, and where they arrive out of step they cancel each other and leave dark stripes, the "dark fringes". This is what separates quantum probability from the probability of someone who simply does not know: the possibilities of a hidden die only add up, they never cancel. In quantum mechanics the probability of finding the object at a point is given by the Born rule: it is the squared modulus of the amplitude of the wave at that point, and the larger the amplitude there, the more likely it is to find the object there. In MM this rule follows from counting the copies, under three stated hypotheses (MM 2.48.2). And the cancellations appear only if the copies carry a wave phase, that is, if, like waves, they can be at a crest or a trough and so cancel each other out. In MM, if what is observed at each place follows the Born rule, entanglement too has a ceiling, the same as in quantum mechanics. The correlations between two distant systems exceed those that any classical explanation allows, but not by as much as one likes: in the quantity measured in these experiments (CHSH), classical explanations reach at most 2, quantum mechanics 2√2, about 2.83 (Tsirelson's bound). Measurements so far are compatible with this ceiling (MM 2.48.2). It remains to be understood how far all this goes. Today we know that even objects made of thousands of atoms spread over several positions, and no experiment has yet found a mass beyond which an object stops doing so and returns to a single place. That the transition depends on mass is an idea close to that of the physicists Roger Penrose and Lajos Diósi, for whom, however, the time within which an object stops being in several positions depends only on the object itself, on its mass and on how that mass is distributed. In MM, by contrast, probabilistic behaviour arises from a ratio. The threshold is the point at which the two GCDs, the principal one

•Oct 24, 2026•3 citations

Brownian motion

A. O. Caldeira

In the two preceding chapters of this book we have analyzed many interesting physical phenomena in magnetic and superconducting systems which could adequately be described by phenomenological dynamical equations in terms of collective classical variables. One unavoidable consequence of this approach is that, as we are always dealing with variables that describe only part of the whole system, the interaction with the remaining degrees of freedom shows up through the presence of non-conservative terms which describe the relaxation of those variables to equilibrium. Those phenomenological equations are able to describe a very rich diversity of physical phenomena, in particular, those which can be studied in the context of quantum mechanics. Since these are genuine dynamical equations, there is no reason why they should be restricted to classical physics. However, as we do not yet know how to treat dissipative effects in quantum mechanics, we have deliberately neglected those terms when trying to describe quantum mechanical effects of our collective variables.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 20, 2014•0 citations

Nothing, Zeno Paradoxes and Quantum Physics

Marcis P. Auzinsh

When the concept of Zero is analyzed, it is frequently related to another equally deep and complicated concept – Nothing. If in science, Zero is closely associated with mathematics, then Nothing is primarily related to the material world. The question of whether Nothing can be found in the real physical world is often discussed in relation to the vacuum which, at some point in the history of the development of physics, is thought about as an empty space. Nevertheless, theories of modern physics have demonstrated that even in a vacuum, when all the matter is evacuated from a certain region of space, and this region is isolated from ordinary fields – gravitation field, electromagnetic fields etc – there still remain physical fields called vacuum zero fluctuations that can not be removed in principle. These vacuum fields are properties of space. In this chapter I will analyze another physics theory – namely, Quantum Physics – and will consider its less discussed relations to the concept of Nothing. One of the very first Greek philosophers, Thales (624–548 BCE) from Miletus, declared that Something can not appear from Nothing and it can not disappear, turning into Nothing. This idea, in some aspects, was further developed by Zeno from Elea (495–430 BCE) when he created his paradoxes of motion. These paradoxes can be understood as an analysis of the possibility of infinite division of time and space intervals. When we come to Quantum Physics, the very first appearance of the idea of the smallest possible portion of energy, quantum, was stimulated by the analysis of the spectrum of radiation of heated body – black-body radiation. German physicist Max Planck (1858–1947) demonstrated in 1899 that if we assume that there exists a smallest portion of radiation energy that can not be further divided into smaller parts, we arrive at the description of spectrum of the black-body radiation that perfectly matches the observable reality. In contrast, if we assume that radiation energy can be divided an infinite number of times and there does not exist the smallest possible portion, we arrive at the radiation spectrum which is in a sharp contradiction with observable reality. This contradiction is so strong that it has acquired a special term – the ultraviolet catastrophe. Certain parallels in Zeno’s reasoning and approach used in Quantum Physics can clearly be seen and will be discussed. In the conclusion, I will briefly touch on a similar situation in another field of physics when at the other extreme, departure from the idea of the possibility of the infinitely large quantities, this time velocities of motion, gave birth to another theory of modern physics – Einstein’s theory of special relativity.

BRILL eBooks•Feb 28, 2024•0 citations
In this part of the book, we have explored in a very elementary way the use of the number operator and its companions, the number amplitude operators, that correspond to creation and annihilation operators in QFT, to model some simple systems in which populations of people, goods, cash etc. vary in time, through being exchanged between different elements of the system as a whole. We have picked extremely simple systems with only a few agents to illustrate the principles involved. We have stressed a key property of this approach to be the existence of certain conservation rules. This is a really important aspect of the modeling and something that physicists always look for in dealing with physical systems, whether they be treated classically of by quantum methods. Whether the system involves galaxies or a few atoms, a physicist will insist that fundamental quantities like energy and momentum are conserved as the system evolves. This constraint is vital in deciding on the validity of the model. It is very easy to write lines of computer code with a perfectly correct set of equations, but which overall do not keep some conserved quantity constant. Models of isolated systems that do not constrain totals of energy and momentum to be fixed should certainly be deemed invalid. The reason is that it is possible to demonstrate mathematically that the accepted theories of physics conserve these quantities. Moreover, the conserved quantities tell physicists precisely what parameters they need to model. For example, physics tells us to measure and keep track of the product of mass times velocity (momentum) and one half times mass, times velocity squared (kinetic energy). Using mass times velocity cubed, for example, would be a waste of time, since it is not part of the great accounting process that controls motion in the universe. It is precisely these features of a physical system that tell the physicist that it is a waste of time thinking about a perpetual motion machine, or something that gives energy for nothing. In contrast, many non-physically based systems models have no all-enveloping theory that tells the modeler what parameters to choose for modeling. With the Lokta–Volterra model (LVM) for example, it seems intuitively obvious to pick the population values of rabbits and foxes and write an albeit ad hoc equation for their variation in time. But why not pick the population number squared? There is nothing to tell us not to. The same appears true of financial models. One picks income, or price or tax. Why not use some combination or some function of these quantities? There are no rules, apart from convention or intuition that constrains the choice of such variables. Why should this matter, well, it could lead to a prediction of something for nothing. The equivalent of a perpetual motion machine might then seem possible in finance or economics. Is continuous economic growth really possible? This may look as feasible as a perpetual motion machine did before the rules of physics were properly understood.
The Quantum theory deals with the microscopic structure of the Universe that describes the finer details of nature at the subatomic domain.To a physicist, quantum mechanics is one of the three great pillars supporting our intuition of evocative, bewildering and fascinating natural World as we continuously struggle with the inescapable strangeness of the subatomic domain as if something strange is always afoot.It is well accepted fact that quantum mechanics is a physical theory that describes the way things behave at subatomic level which is quite dazzling in its precision and explanatory power.A test of quantum electrodynamics, the oldest and best understood of the modern quantum theory that involves measuring the way an electron behaves in the vicinity of a magnetic force. Many of the technological and social changes that have revolutionized our lives have actually risen out of the fundamental theoretical research carried out with only motivation to understand the World in a better way than ever. For example, the invention of transistor actually came with the fundamental theoretical research on the Uncertainty Principle which states that the uncertainty of the position of a particle times the uncertainty of its velocity is always a constant. If we double the certainty of the position of the particle, we have to make half the certainty of its velocity and vice versa. Quantum theory is perhaps the prime example of the infinitely esoteric in the sense that it describes a World in which a particle really can be in several places at once and it moves from one place to another by exploring the entire Universe simultaneously-the theory of simultaneity. The diverse and complex Universe is actually made of a few tiny particles according to the rules of quantum theory which is so simple that can be summarized on the back of an envelope. The more we understand about the elemental nature of the Universe, the simpler it looks. We have already discovered that everything in the diverse and complex Universe is nothing but the different assemblies of atoms, and the wide variety of atoms are constructed using the three building blocks at the sub-atomic domain i.e. subatomic particles: protons, neutrons and electrons. We have also discovered that protons and neutrons ate made up of combination of three entities called quarks. And that is where things stop as far as recent discovery is concerned. But the recent progress in particle physics inspiring the quest for the ultimate unified theory of physics that can describe everything in the Universe in one go. The discovery of Boson particle certainty will revolutionaries the Newton's mass concept and gravity into whole new looks. To an optimistic point of view, we must hope the best out of the progress in physics.
The conclusion of Part I, the non-technical (or somewhat less technical) part of this book, is that a completely convincing model of our universe is lacking. This should be a model that shows how quantum mechanical behaviour, with all its mysteries and paradoxes, can emerge from a local, deterministic theory. Yet we also find that one can assume its existence to arrive at a picture of our quantum mechanical universe that makes perfect sense. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Common introduction to all the records of this series. Already read it? Skip to the content of this record ↓ Mathematical Materiality (MM) in brief. Why are the laws of physics the same everywhere and at every instant, even though nothing forces matter to obey them? MM proposes an answer: the laws are not rules imposed on matter from the outside; rather, matter itself is made of mathematical relations. And mathematics cannot change: a relation binds two distinct terms everywhere and always. In logic, nothing exists on its own: to exist means to be in relation to another logical entity, and outside this web of relations nothing can exist, not even other universes. This reading is already compared with experimental measurements at two points. First, the ratio of dark to ordinary matter is read as 3√3 = 5.196; when left free in the fits, Planck and DESI DR2 data give 5.21–5.22 (as registered in record 2.44, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23329080). Second, the acceleration scale of galaxies is read as a₀ = cH₀/6, the same scale that appears in Verlinde's emergent gravity: the computed value is 1.09–1.18 × 10⁻¹⁰ m/s² against the measured value of 1.20 × 10⁻¹⁰ m/s² (record 2.46.1, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23506655). Both readings were formulated with the measurements already known; the tests to check them against future data are registered in the same records. MM also changes the picture of the world. Reality is not made of separate objects, each complete in itself, in empty space: it is a material structure whose nature is a logical description. The observer does not look at it from outside: it is inside it, and always finds the logical mirror of its own position in front of itself. The objects it sees are, necessarily, diffractions of its point of view: the parts into which its description divides, like a unit into fractions. But each object in turn exists in its own logical mirror, exactly like its observer. This is why things do not exist only when someone looks at them, and yet none exists on its own: every property of a thing is a link with its observer. For MM, this is the only rational answer to the opening question: if everything is made of the relations that the laws describe, nothing can escape the laws and no one has to enforce them. For this reason the universe behaves like a simulation without really being one. It follows exact rules, made of counts, everywhere and at every instant, but no machine runs them and no programmer wrote them: a structure of mathematical relations does not need to be computed in order to exist. Tegmark (2008) had already noted that such a simulation need not be run, while Vazza (2025) estimated that running it physically on a machine would require resources that the very laws of the universe do not allow. In the first logical nexus between space and time — which relativity describes together as a single spacetime — there is a non-local phase, made only of a pure logical distinction: space is not time. In this phase, between space and time there is no relation of quantitative calculation, only the logical entity they have in common, which is needed to make them exist with respect to each other: we shall call this entity their greatest common divisor (GCD), just as the numbers 3 and 5 have only 1 in common. "Non-local" here does not mean that something is confined far away or acts at a distance: it means that the non-local phase is in no place and at no instant, while being present in every phase of reality, in every place and at every instant (MM 2.72). This non-local phase manifests itself in entanglement: two distant systems, without anything physically travelling from one to the other, remain correlated more strongly than any explanation based on separate properties and on the absence of faster-than-light influences allows: this is the violation of Bell's inequalities. The local world arises when a relation is counted through this GCD: its multiples and its fractions form a matrix. Seen by an observer inside the system like us, the multiples, which follow one another in a chain that never reverses, appear as time; the fractions, which stand side by side, appear as space. When that same multiple is directly contained in the matrix of the point of observation, it turns into mass — that is, into concrete matter as we usually understand it. There is therefore a close link between time and mass, which physics also recognizes: every mass has its own rhythm, its Compton frequency mc²/h (MM 2.64.1). The observed objects, while being logically autonomous entities in their local relations, enter into relation with the observer through the logical diffraction of the observer's matrix. Where space and objects come from can be shown with a simple fraction. The whole is the GCD of the point of observation, the 1 from which every description starts. The denominator tells how many equal parts this 1 is divided into: they are the fractions side by side that appear as space, the grain with which the observer tells things apart. The numerator tells how many of those parts an object occupies: it is its size as seen from that point. The parts that no object occupies appear as empty space: not a container that was there before, but divisions of the observer's 1. Full or empty, all the parts are fractions of the same 1: what makes them a single description is the non-local phase, which lies in no single part yet is present in all of them. And just as 3/8 and 6/16 have the same value, if the 1 is divided into parts half as large, the object occupies twice as many: its size is the ratio, which does not change. Mass, by contrast, does not lie in the fraction but in the multiple contained in the matrix of the point of observation: it is the count that repeats, the rhythm mentioned above. This reading also gives a reason for the limit of the speed of light, which in Einstein's relativity is instead taken as a starting principle. The speed of light is the fixed exchange rate between the multiples and the fractions of the same GCD, meaning how much space a single step of time is worth: exceeding it would mean, for some observer, covering space without counting time, and thus leaving the local world. Logic always starts from a logical relative, and this exchange rate has nothing absolute in itself either: it is a necessary relative which, inside the system, becomes an absolute hypothesis, the same for everyone and impossible to exceed. Outside the system, by contrast, it has no justification at all, because outside there is only non-existence: justifying something requires another term to relate it to, and out there there is none. Asking for a reason from outside is like asking what lies north of the North Pole. The same theoretical framework that reads space, time, mass and the observed objects also admits quantum mechanics. The non-local phase and the mirror-like logical reciprocity between the two ends of the nexus give a reason for the probabilistic behaviour of matter. When the mass of the observed object is large enough compared with that of the point of observation, it fixes the object in the matrix of the latter: for this reason we see it in one precise place and at one precise instant. When instead this ratio falls below a certain threshold, the principal GCD (that of the point of observation) and the GCD of the diffraction that generates the object are forced to become equal, and they reflect each other as in a mirror. At that point the object no longer occupies a single point of the spacetime generated by the observer, but spreads over several possible positions, and we observe it as probability. It is like having to describe the number 10 using only the number 1: the only way is to distribute the 1 into ten copies, one for each unit of the 10. The probability here is not that of a die: these copies add up like waves and can also cancel each other out. This adding up and cancelling out is called interference. It can be seen in the double-slit experiment: where the waves arrive in step the screen lights up, and where they arrive out of step they cancel each other and leave dark stripes, the "dark fringes". This is what separates quantum probability from the probability of someone who simply does not know: the possibilities of a hidden die only add up, they never cancel. In quantum mechanics the probability of finding the object at a point is given by the Born rule: it is the squared modulus of the amplitude of the wave at that point, and the larger the amplitude there, the more likely it is to find the object there. In MM this rule follows from counting the copies, under three stated hypotheses (MM 2.48.2). And the cancellations appear only if the copies carry a wave phase, that is, if, like waves, they can be at a crest or a trough and so cancel each other out. In MM, if what is observed at each place follows the Born rule, entanglement too has a ceiling, the same as in quantum mechanics. The correlations between two distant systems exceed those that any classical explanation allows, but not by as much as one likes: in the quantity measured in these experiments (CHSH), classical explanations reach at most 2, quantum mechanics 2√2, about 2.83 (Tsirelson's bound). Measurements so far are compatible with this ceiling (MM 2.48.2). It remains to be understood how far all this goes. Today we know that even objects made of thousands of atoms spread over several positions, and no experiment has yet found a mass beyond which an object stops doing so and returns to a single place. That the transition depends on mass is an idea close to that of the physicists Roger Penrose and Lajos Diósi, for whom, however, the time within which an object stops being in several positions depends only on the object itself, on its mass and on how that mass is distributed. In MM, by contrast, probabilistic behaviour arises from a ratio. The threshold is the point at which the two GCDs, the principal one
In the two preceding chapters of this book we have analyzed many interesting physical phenomena in magnetic and superconducting systems which could adequately be described by phenomenological dynamical equations in terms of collective classical variables. One unavoidable consequence of this approach is that, as we are always dealing with variables that describe only part of the whole system, the interaction with the remaining degrees of freedom shows up through the presence of non-conservative terms which describe the relaxation of those variables to equilibrium. Those phenomenological equations are able to describe a very rich diversity of physical phenomena, in particular, those which can be studied in the context of quantum mechanics. Since these are genuine dynamical equations, there is no reason why they should be restricted to classical physics. However, as we do not yet know how to treat dissipative effects in quantum mechanics, we have deliberately neglected those terms when trying to describe quantum mechanical effects of our collective variables.
When the concept of Zero is analyzed, it is frequently related to another equally deep and complicated concept – Nothing. If in science, Zero is closely associated with mathematics, then Nothing is primarily related to the material world. The question of whether Nothing can be found in the real physical world is often discussed in relation to the vacuum which, at some point in the history of the development of physics, is thought about as an empty space. Nevertheless, theories of modern physics have demonstrated that even in a vacuum, when all the matter is evacuated from a certain region of space, and this region is isolated from ordinary fields – gravitation field, electromagnetic fields etc – there still remain physical fields called vacuum zero fluctuations that can not be removed in principle. These vacuum fields are properties of space. In this chapter I will analyze another physics theory – namely, Quantum Physics – and will consider its less discussed relations to the concept of Nothing. One of the very first Greek philosophers, Thales (624–548 BCE) from Miletus, declared that Something can not appear from Nothing and it can not disappear, turning into Nothing. This idea, in some aspects, was further developed by Zeno from Elea (495–430 BCE) when he created his paradoxes of motion. These paradoxes can be understood as an analysis of the possibility of infinite division of time and space intervals. When we come to Quantum Physics, the very first appearance of the idea of the smallest possible portion of energy, quantum, was stimulated by the analysis of the spectrum of radiation of heated body – black-body radiation. German physicist Max Planck (1858–1947) demonstrated in 1899 that if we assume that there exists a smallest portion of radiation energy that can not be further divided into smaller parts, we arrive at the description of spectrum of the black-body radiation that perfectly matches the observable reality. In contrast, if we assume that radiation energy can be divided an infinite number of times and there does not exist the smallest possible portion, we arrive at the radiation spectrum which is in a sharp contradiction with observable reality. This contradiction is so strong that it has acquired a special term – the ultraviolet catastrophe. Certain parallels in Zeno’s reasoning and approach used in Quantum Physics can clearly be seen and will be discussed. In the conclusion, I will briefly touch on a similar situation in another field of physics when at the other extreme, departure from the idea of the possibility of the infinitely large quantities, this time velocities of motion, gave birth to another theory of modern physics – Einstein’s theory of special relativity.