No interpretation of quantum mechanics can be wholly comprehended or validated before carefully investigating all of its details. I begin such an investigation of the present interpretation in the next chapter. But some of these details will prove rather intricate. The reader may need help in seeing the forest formed by the trees, and the skeptical reader may require encouragement before he or she agrees to enter its thickets. In this first chapter I therefore present a preliminary account of the basic ideas of the interpretation to be given, which may serve as a guide to what is to follow. Just as parts of a travel guide may seem puzzling before one actually visits the region described, so also parts of this chapter will likely seem much clearer when they are reread in the light of the rest of the book.
No interpretation of quantum mechanics can be wholly comprehended or validated before carefully investigating all of its details. I begin such an investigation of the present interpretation in the next chapter. But some of these details will prove rather intricate. The reader may need help in seeing the forest formed by the trees, and the skeptical reader may require encouragement before he or she agrees to enter its thickets. In this first chapter I therefore present a preliminary account of the basic ideas of the interpretation to be given, which may serve as a guide to what is to follow. Just as parts of a travel guide may seem puzzling before one actually visits the region described, so also parts of this chapter will likely seem much clearer when they are reread in the light of the rest of the book.
What is it about quantum mechanics that continues to make its interpretation so difficult and controversial? It is now more than 70 years after its inception and at least half a century since the verification of its predictions of physical phenomena that range from the motion of electrons in solids to the basic structure and properties of the atomic nucleus. After reading the first half of this book one could be forgiven for believing that it has been just our unwillingness or inability to understand properly what Niels Bohr said from the beginning, and to update these ideas in the light of later experience. The aim of the present book is to do just this: to restate the Copenhagen interpretation and to show us how it has been developed to take modern results and ideas into account.
In this monograph I present the basic structure of an interpretation of quantum mechanics. Chapter 1 outlines the central ideas behind the interpretation and illustrates them by means of examples: Subsequent chapters fill in the details of the interpretation. But it is important to begin by explaining what I take an interpretation of quantum mechanics to be, and why any further interpretation needs to be offered. After all, quantum mechanics (in some form) is by now both a foundation for much of contemporary physics and a veteran of more than sixty years of intermittent but sometimes intense reflection on its content and meaning. What more can be, or should be, said about the interpretation of this theory? Many physicists believe that no more needs to be said: that there is basically only one way of understanding quantum mechanics, due to Bohr, Heisenberg, Pauli, and others, and that the only remaining interpretative task is that of the physics teacher, who seeks to perfect ways of conveying this understanding to new generations of students. Sir Rudolf Peierls, one of the more lucid and distinguished of these physicists, even objects to the use of the familiar term ‘Copenhagen interpretation’ to refer to the way of understanding quantum mechanics due to Bohr, Heisenberg, Pauli, and others. Because this sounds as if there were several interpretations of quantum mechanics. There is only one. There is only one way in which you can understand quantum mechanics.[…]
This chapter sets the informal stage for the subject matter of the book. Section 1.1 presents in concise form what is typically taught as the basics in quantum physics courses around the world. Section 1.2 gives a short overview of the most important interpretations of these basic rules that were spawned by a century-long lack of clarity of the meaning of quantum mechanics. Section 1.3 gives an account of the deplorable tradition of quantum magic that resulted from this lack of clarity. Section 1.4, the final section, gives a preview of the coherent quantum physics proposed in this book as a solution to the problems of interpreting quantum physics.
Abstract The purpose of this book is to present an interpretation of quantum mechanics. But what are we talking about when we speak of “quantum mechanics?” Are we talking about a single theory or about many related theories? And what do we mean by “interpretation” here? In this chapter, I will address these questions in an introductory way. Of course, I do not intend to take part in the extensive discussions about what a scientific theory is, what is meant by interpreting a theory, in what situation we encounter equivalent theories, and many other questions related to or derived from these. My aim here is to present some preliminary ideas in a way that I hope will be sufficient to avoid misunderstandings in the following chapters. But, above all, I will state my position as to why, after so many years and so much literature on the subject, the interpretation of quantum mechanics deserves further discussion.
The title of this book brings to mind topics such as the Copenhagen Interpretation, Shrodinger's Cat, the EPR Paradox and Bell's Theorem. Certainly all of these are there, but there is much more. Starting with the Logic of Plato and Aristotle, the reader is guided through the Classical Philosophy of Knowledge. This is unfamiliar territory for most physicists; in fact I found the first four chapters (of a total of 16) quite difficult for someone untrained in philosophical discipline. Then comes a discussion of the formal logic of Mathematics - much more familiar ground this, to be enjoyed and savoured. Quite fascinating and original is the 'Orchard Analogy' in which the author invites us to imagine the Universe as a vast field sprinkled with countless trees representing all conceivable propositions. Some of these trees, the axioms, are the source of the water of Truth. The rules of logic determine a network of channels to carry water from tree to tree. This Truth will flow from the source (the axioms) to irrigate progressively the whole propositional field. Formal Physics enters at chapter 7, with a discussion of the concepts of Special and General Relativity and Quantum Theory. The Schrodinger Cat makes its appearance and is analysed in full in terms of Decoherence, which destroys quantum interference at macroscopic level. Again there are moments of light relief: I liked the classical example of non-commuting operators - the result is different when you boil potatoes and then crush, compared to crushing first and then boiling! Next comes our change of attitude towards `Physical Reality' in the context of Quantum Mechanics. The author argues that the counter-intuitive concepts of 'Quantum Reality' and the correlation of measurements of widely separated quantum systems are a fact of Nature, puzzling to 'common sense', but not at variance with logic. The final two chapters offer `some trails towards a Wide or Grand Realism' and a new Philosophy of Knowledge. Intelligibility and locality become `properties' valid at macroscopic level - the level of our senses. In summary I found that this book has broadened my awareness of some very deep philosophical concepts, and has given a new insight into topics such as Knowledge, Reality and Logic. I recommend it to all `natural philosophers' as a source of enjoyment and food for thought.
The interactive interpretation I have presented here leaves many interesting questions unresolved. In conclusion, I shall raise several such questions, and discuss their significance for the interpretation. These may be divided roughly into two kinds: Some are merely requests for a more complete development of the view expressed here, whereas others represent unresolved challenges to its adequacy as an interpretation of quantum mechanics. What these questions all have in common is that at the present time I cannot myself adequately answer them. I raise the questions here to commend them to others, as suggesting interesting topics for further research of a kind that holds out hope for an improved understanding of the quantum world, as well as of our current best theories of it.