Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

AN EXTENSION OF EINSTEIN'S TREATMENT OF SPONTANEOUS EMISSION

Albert Rose

Published Apr 1, 1989• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Einstein's detailed balance argument in which the concept of spontaneous emission was first introduced is used to demonstrate that spontaneous emission is a classical phenomenon and is not a consequence of zero point quanta as is widely believed. The average rates of photoinduced excitation and emission are also computed classically.

DOI
10.1142/9789814434188_0011

Related papers

Spontaneous emission revisited

Albert Rose

The cause of spontaneous emission is frequently assigned to the presence of zero-point energy in the radiation field. As such it would have no classical equivalent since zero-point energy does not exist classically. It is argued that spontaneous emission is not caused by zero-point energy but rather by an essentially classical interaction between the excited electron and its surrounding medium.

physica status solidi (a)•Sep 16, 1980•1 citation

Spontaneous emission of a small source of light

Jacques Moret‐Bailly

The usual computation of the spontaneous emission uses a mixture of classical and quantum postulates. A purely classical computation shows that a source of electromagnetic field absorbs light in the eigenmode it is able to emit. Thus in an excitation by an other mode, the component of this mode on the eigenmode is absorbed, while the remainder is scattered. This loss of energy does not apply to the zero point field which has its regular energy in the eigenmode, so that the zero point field seems more effective than the other fields for the stimulation of light emission.

arXiv:physics/0305109•May 26, 2003•0 citations

Classical Aspects of Spontaneous Emission

ALBERT ROSE

Spontaneous emission is frequently ascribed to the action of zero point vibrations on an excited electron. If this were so, there would be no classical parallel since classical media do not have zero point vibrations. In contrast to the model using zero point vibrations, it is shown that spontaneous emission by a moving electron in a solid can be accounted for in terms of a classical interaction between electron and solid. While the mechanism of the interaction is classical, the evaluation of its magnitude is subject to certain quantum constraints.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 1, 1989•0 citations

Spontaneous Emission Revisited

A. ROSE

The cause of spontaneous emission is frequently assigned to the presence of zero-point energy in the radiation field. As such it would have no classical equivalent since zero-point energy does not exist classically. It is argued that spontaneous emission is not caused by zero-point energy but rather by an essentially classical interaction between the excited electron and its surrounding medium. Die Ursache für die spontane Emission wird häufig in der Nullpunktsenergie des Strahlungsfeldes gesucht. Als solche hätte sie nichts Entsprechendes in der klassischen Physik, da es dort keine Nullpunktsenergie gibt. Es wird gezeigt, daß die spontane Emission nicht durch die Nullpunktsenergie hervorgerufen wird, sondern vielmehr durch eine ihrem Wesen nach klassische Wechselwirkung zwischen dem angeregten Elektron und dem umgebenden Medium.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 1, 1989•0 citations

Stimulated Emission

In this chapter the concepts of spontaneous emission, absorption, and stimulated emission are discussed in a quantitative manner. Blackbody radiation is analyzed in terms of both Planck’s and Einstein’s derivations. Using Einstein’s analysis the relationships between spontaneous emission, absorption, and stimulated emission are derived. Both classical and semi-classical treatments are presented for absorption and stimulated emission.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 12, 2017•0 citations

Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics

S. Haroche, Daniel Kleppner

Ever since Einstein demonstrated that spontaneous emission must occur if matter and radiation are to achieve thermal equilibrium, physicists have generally believed that excited atoms inevitably radiate. Spontaneous emission is so fundamental that it is usually regarded as an inherent property of matter. This view, however, overlooks the fact that spontaneous emission is not a property of an isolated atom but of an atom-vacuum system. The most distinctive feature of such emission, irreversibility, comes about because an infinity of vacuum states is available to the radiated photon. If these states are modified—for instance, by placing the excited atom between mirrors or in a cavity—spontaneous emission can be greatly inhibited or enhanced.

Physics Today•Jan 1, 1989•743 citations
Einstein's detailed balance argument in which the concept of spontaneous emission was first introduced is used to demonstrate that spontaneous emission is a classical phenomenon and is not a consequence of zero point quanta as is widely believed. The average rates of photoinduced excitation and emission are also computed classically.
The usual computation of the spontaneous emission uses a mixture of classical and quantum postulates. A purely classical computation shows that a source of electromagnetic field absorbs light in the eigenmode it is able to emit. Thus in an excitation by an other mode, the component of this mode on the eigenmode is absorbed, while the remainder is scattered. This loss of energy does not apply to the zero point field which has its regular energy in the eigenmode, so that the zero point field seems more effective than the other fields for the stimulation of light emission.
Spontaneous emission is frequently ascribed to the action of zero point vibrations on an excited electron. If this were so, there would be no classical parallel since classical media do not have zero point vibrations. In contrast to the model using zero point vibrations, it is shown that spontaneous emission by a moving electron in a solid can be accounted for in terms of a classical interaction between electron and solid. While the mechanism of the interaction is classical, the evaluation of its magnitude is subject to certain quantum constraints.
The cause of spontaneous emission is frequently assigned to the presence of zero-point energy in the radiation field. As such it would have no classical equivalent since zero-point energy does not exist classically. It is argued that spontaneous emission is not caused by zero-point energy but rather by an essentially classical interaction between the excited electron and its surrounding medium. Die Ursache für die spontane Emission wird häufig in der Nullpunktsenergie des Strahlungsfeldes gesucht. Als solche hätte sie nichts Entsprechendes in der klassischen Physik, da es dort keine Nullpunktsenergie gibt. Es wird gezeigt, daß die spontane Emission nicht durch die Nullpunktsenergie hervorgerufen wird, sondern vielmehr durch eine ihrem Wesen nach klassische Wechselwirkung zwischen dem angeregten Elektron und dem umgebenden Medium.
Ever since Einstein demonstrated that spontaneous emission must occur if matter and radiation are to achieve thermal equilibrium, physicists have generally believed that excited atoms inevitably radiate. Spontaneous emission is so fundamental that it is usually regarded as an inherent property of matter. This view, however, overlooks the fact that spontaneous emission is not a property of an isolated atom but of an atom-vacuum system. The most distinctive feature of such emission, irreversibility, comes about because an infinity of vacuum states is available to the radiated photon. If these states are modified—for instance, by placing the excited atom between mirrors or in a cavity—spontaneous emission can be greatly inhibited or enhanced.