Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Presymmetry

H. Ekstein

Published Jan 25, 1967• 27 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Even in the presence of external fields, space-time symmetry implies nontrivial relations between observables at one time, i.e., kinematical relations. Symmetry operations at one time---translations, rotations, and (for Galilei symmetry) velocity shifts---can be performed on observation-producing and on state-producing instruments, regardless of the existence of an external field. Furthermore, it is possible to give an operational definition of every initial state intrinsically, i.e., regardless of the external field. The precise statement of this empirical fact explains, for example, why a particle in an external field has integral or half-integral eigenvalues of the spin, why a Hamiltonian exists even in the presence of a time-dependent external field, and why (for Galilei symmetry) the canonical commutation relations are still valid, although the full space-time symmetry from which these results can be derived has been destroyed. It is pointed out that the rigorous validity of kinematical relations, in spite of strong breaking of the underlying space-time symmetry, is analogous to the rigorous validity of equal-time current commutation rules, in spite of the breaking of the underlying $U(3)$ symmetry.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.153.1397

Related papers

Presymmetry. II

H. Ekstein

The association between laboratory procedures and self-adjoint operators (observables), usually implicit and allusive, is made explicit by the introduction of two collections of nonmathematical objects; the observation procedures and the state-preparing procedures. By a process of idealization and extrapolation from empirical facts, these two collections are turned into mathematical sets ("hardware spaces") with the structure of a star algebra $\mathcal{O}$ and a convex linear set $\mathcal{S}$, respectively. There is a many-one mapping from $\mathcal{O}$ into the space $\mathfrak{U}$ of observables (the operators on Hilbert space), and physical laws or solutions of equations of motion are embodied in the mapping $\ensuremath{\Phi}:\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathfrak{U}$. Certain material motions of observation instruments and state-preparing instruments induce automorphisms of the hardware spaces but in general, not automorphisms of $\mathfrak{U}$. An extension of space-time invariance theory to accelerations [$\mathbf{x}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathbf{x}+\ensuremath{\Sigma}{2}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}{(n!)}^{\ensuremath{-}1}{\mathbf{r}}_{n}{t}^{n}$], to external symmetry-breaking fields, and to subsystems under the influence of other subsystems becomes possible. The main results of this paper are a derivation of Newton's second law and of the gravitational equivalence principle for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics from invariance and causality principles.

Physical Review•Aug 25, 1969•44 citations

The basis of quantum mechanics' compatibility with relativity--whose impairment gives rise to the Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations

Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

Solitary-particle quantum mechanics' inherent compatibility with special relativity is implicit in Schroedinger's postulated wave-function rule for the operator quantization of the particle's canonical three-momentum, taken together with his famed time-dependent wave-function equation that analogously treats the operator quantization of its Hamiltonian. The resulting formally four-vector equation system assures proper relativistic covariance for any solitary-particle Hamiltonian operator which, together with its canonical three-momentum operator, is a Lorentz-covariant four-vector operator. This, of course, is always the case for the quantization of the Hamiltonian of a properly relativistic classical theory, so the strong correspondence principle definitely remains valid in the relativistic domain. Klein-Gordon theory impairs this four-vector equation by iterating and contracting it, thereby injecting extraneous negative-energy solutions that are not orthogonal to their positive-energy counterparts of the same momentum, thus destroying the basis of the quantum probability interpretation. Klein-Gordon theory, which thus depends on the square of the Hamiltonian operator, is as well thereby cut adrift from Heisenberg's equations of motion. Dirac theory confuses the space-time symmetry of the four-vector equation system with such symmetry for its time component alone, which it fatuously imposes, thereby breaching the strong correspondence principle for the free particle and imposing the starkly unphysical momentum-independence of velocity. Physically sensible alternatives, with external electromagnetic fields, to the Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations are derived, and the simple, elegant symmetry-based approach to antiparticles is pointed out.

arXiv:1005.2641•May 15, 2010•2 citations

Gauge invariance and time symmetry breaking

Roberto Assumpção

Employing an arbitrary velocity gauge transformation this contribution argues that the breaking of time symmetry is a natural consequence of irreversibility.

arXiv:0708.3525•Aug 27, 2007•0 citations

Quantum Graphs Built from Observables and Symmetries

Edward Yu. Bormashenko

A graph-theoretical framework for quantum mechanics is developed in which observables and symmetry operators are incorporated into a single complete bi-coloured graph. The proposed Symmetry/Observables Quantum Graph (SOQG) treats Hamiltonians, observables, conserved quantities, and unitary symmetry transformations on equal footing as operators acting on a common Hilbert space. The vertices of the graph represent operators, while the colours of the edges are determined by their commutation relations: commuting operators are connected by maroon edges and non-commuting operators by teal edges. The resulting structure constitutes a finite Ramsey graph that provides a combinatorial representation of operator compatibility. The formalism is applied to several representative quantum systems, including a particle in a central potential, a charged particle in a uniform magnetic field, and a particle in a homogeneous external field. In each case, monochromatic cliques identify maximal compatibility sectors containing both observables and symmetry operators, thereby revealing the interplay between conserved quantities and dynamical symmetries. It is further shown that coloured-graph automorphisms generally differ from the physical symmetry group of the underlying quantum system, leading to the notion of second-order graph symmetry. The SOQG is proved to be invariant under simultaneous unitary transformations of all operators and therefore represents intrinsic properties of the operator algebra rather than a particular Hilbert-space representation. The graph-theoretical structure is analysed using Ramsey theory and the Mantel–Turán extremal theorem, which provide rigorous conditions for the appearance of mutually compatible and mutually incompatible operator subsets. The framework is subsequently generalized to parameter-dependent Symmetry/Observables Quantum Graphs (PSOQGs), whose compatibility structure changes as external parameters modify the underlying commutation relations. For magnetic translation operators, the magnetic flux through the elementary translation cell induces a flux-controlled colour-switching transition between commuting and non-commuting compatibility sectors, accompanied by changes in the graph automorphism group. The proposed framework establishes a direct connection between operator theory, symmetry, graph theory, and extremal combinatorics, providing a new structural perspective on quantum systems.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

Invariant definition of relativistic spin states in classical and quantum theories with an external field

Vladimir A Bordovitsyn, I. M. Ternov

Theoretical and Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1984•2 citations

The Geometry of Quantum Mechanics: Hilbert Structure, Unitary Dynamics, Spin, Measurement, and the One-Particle Quantum Theory in Six-Throat Directed Spacetime

Ibrahim Mohammed Mussa

Paper XXII of the Six-Throat Directed Geometry program derives the mathematical structure of one-particle quantum mechanics from the directed spinor dynamics established on the regular closed six-throat spacetime. Starting from the conserved curved-spacetime Dirac current, the construction produces a positive and slice-independent inner product and its Hilbert-space completion. The corresponding geometric propagator is unitary and satisfies composition, inverse, and adjoint closure. Real physical observables are represented by self-adjoint operators with real spectra and orthogonal spectral resolutions. The compact global geometry yields an exact periodic commutator algebra, while the standard canonical position-momentum relation is recovered on regular local charts. The Robertson and Schrödinger-Robertson uncertainty relations then follow from the same Hilbert-space structure. The tetrad Clifford algebra generates the intrinsic spin-one-half representation, including the expected spin magnitude, the spinor sign reversal under a full two-pi rotation, and the rotational multiplets obtained by coupling orbital and intrinsic angular momentum. Detector-surface current is promoted from the direct Born-flux construction of Paper XXI to a general positive measurement structure described by a non-projective POVM and the trace probability rule. Density operators, purity, von Neumann entropy, conditional access states, and Kraus dephasing channels arise within the same measurement framework. The positive-energy Dirac branch reduces at low energy to Pauli dynamics and, when the spin-covariant terms commute appropriately, to the Schrödinger Hamiltonian. The same unitary framework yields the Liouville-von Neumann equation, the Heisenberg operator equation, and the Ehrenfest relations in the local directed potential. A forty-three-condition numerical closure audit satisfies all 43 declared conditions across the derived one-particle structure. Representative numerical results include Hilbert-product and unitary residuals at approximately machine precision, exact spin-one-half algebra to numerical precision, POVM completeness at machine precision, low-energy wave-packet infidelity of 3.16 × 10⁻¹⁰ for the stated audit configuration, and Schrödinger-Heisenberg expectation agreement at 5.66 × 10⁻¹⁷. The result is a single geometric chain from conserved spacetime flux to one-particle state space, unitary dynamics, observables, commutators, uncertainty, spin, measurement operators, statistical states, and the low-energy quantum equations. Composite systems, entanglement, exchange symmetry, quantum statistics, and variable-particle-number field theory remain subsequent structural layers and are not claimed as part of the present one-particle closure.

•Sep 30, 2026•0 citations
Even in the presence of external fields, space-time symmetry implies nontrivial relations between observables at one time, i.e., kinematical relations. Symmetry operations at one time---translations, rotations, and (for Galilei symmetry) velocity shifts---can be performed on observation-producing and on state-producing instruments, regardless of the existence of an external field. Furthermore, it is possible to give an operational definition of every initial state intrinsically, i.e., regardless of the external field. The precise statement of this empirical fact explains, for example, why a particle in an external field has integral or half-integral eigenvalues of the spin, why a Hamiltonian exists even in the presence of a time-dependent external field, and why (for Galilei symmetry) the canonical commutation relations are still valid, although the full space-time symmetry from which these results can be derived has been destroyed. It is pointed out that the rigorous validity of kinematical relations, in spite of strong breaking of the underlying space-time symmetry, is analogous to the rigorous validity of equal-time current commutation rules, in spite of the breaking of the underlying U(3)U(3)U(3) symmetry.
The association between laboratory procedures and self-adjoint operators (observables), usually implicit and allusive, is made explicit by the introduction of two collections of nonmathematical objects; the observation procedures and the state-preparing procedures. By a process of idealization and extrapolation from empirical facts, these two collections are turned into mathematical sets ("hardware spaces") with the structure of a star algebra O\mathcal{O}O and a convex linear set S\mathcal{S}S, respectively. There is a many-one mapping from O\mathcal{O}O into the space U\mathfrak{U}U of observables (the operators on Hilbert space), and physical laws or solutions of equations of motion are embodied in the mapping $\ensuremath{\Phi}:\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathfrak{U}$. Certain material motions of observation instruments and state-preparing instruments induce automorphisms of the hardware spaces but in general, not automorphisms of U\mathfrak{U}U. An extension of space-time invariance theory to accelerations [$\mathbf{x}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathbf{x}+\ensuremath{\Sigma}{2}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}{(n!)}^{\ensuremath{-}1}{\mathbf{r}}_{n}{t}^{n}$], to external symmetry-breaking fields, and to subsystems under the influence of other subsystems becomes possible. The main results of this paper are a derivation of Newton's second law and of the gravitational equivalence principle for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics from invariance and causality principles.
Solitary-particle quantum mechanics' inherent compatibility with special relativity is implicit in Schroedinger's postulated wave-function rule for the operator quantization of the particle's canonical three-momentum, taken together with his famed time-dependent wave-function equation that analogously treats the operator quantization of its Hamiltonian. The resulting formally four-vector equation system assures proper relativistic covariance for any solitary-particle Hamiltonian operator which, together with its canonical three-momentum operator, is a Lorentz-covariant four-vector operator. This, of course, is always the case for the quantization of the Hamiltonian of a properly relativistic classical theory, so the strong correspondence principle definitely remains valid in the relativistic domain. Klein-Gordon theory impairs this four-vector equation by iterating and contracting it, thereby injecting extraneous negative-energy solutions that are not orthogonal to their positive-energy counterparts of the same momentum, thus destroying the basis of the quantum probability interpretation. Klein-Gordon theory, which thus depends on the square of the Hamiltonian operator, is as well thereby cut adrift from Heisenberg's equations of motion. Dirac theory confuses the space-time symmetry of the four-vector equation system with such symmetry for its time component alone, which it fatuously imposes, thereby breaching the strong correspondence principle for the free particle and imposing the starkly unphysical momentum-independence of velocity. Physically sensible alternatives, with external electromagnetic fields, to the Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations are derived, and the simple, elegant symmetry-based approach to antiparticles is pointed out.
A graph-theoretical framework for quantum mechanics is developed in which observables and symmetry operators are incorporated into a single complete bi-coloured graph. The proposed Symmetry/Observables Quantum Graph (SOQG) treats Hamiltonians, observables, conserved quantities, and unitary symmetry transformations on equal footing as operators acting on a common Hilbert space. The vertices of the graph represent operators, while the colours of the edges are determined by their commutation relations: commuting operators are connected by maroon edges and non-commuting operators by teal edges. The resulting structure constitutes a finite Ramsey graph that provides a combinatorial representation of operator compatibility. The formalism is applied to several representative quantum systems, including a particle in a central potential, a charged particle in a uniform magnetic field, and a particle in a homogeneous external field. In each case, monochromatic cliques identify maximal compatibility sectors containing both observables and symmetry operators, thereby revealing the interplay between conserved quantities and dynamical symmetries. It is further shown that coloured-graph automorphisms generally differ from the physical symmetry group of the underlying quantum system, leading to the notion of second-order graph symmetry. The SOQG is proved to be invariant under simultaneous unitary transformations of all operators and therefore represents intrinsic properties of the operator algebra rather than a particular Hilbert-space representation. The graph-theoretical structure is analysed using Ramsey theory and the Mantel–Turán extremal theorem, which provide rigorous conditions for the appearance of mutually compatible and mutually incompatible operator subsets. The framework is subsequently generalized to parameter-dependent Symmetry/Observables Quantum Graphs (PSOQGs), whose compatibility structure changes as external parameters modify the underlying commutation relations. For magnetic translation operators, the magnetic flux through the elementary translation cell induces a flux-controlled colour-switching transition between commuting and non-commuting compatibility sectors, accompanied by changes in the graph automorphism group. The proposed framework establishes a direct connection between operator theory, symmetry, graph theory, and extremal combinatorics, providing a new structural perspective on quantum systems.
Paper XXII of the Six-Throat Directed Geometry program derives the mathematical structure of one-particle quantum mechanics from the directed spinor dynamics established on the regular closed six-throat spacetime. Starting from the conserved curved-spacetime Dirac current, the construction produces a positive and slice-independent inner product and its Hilbert-space completion. The corresponding geometric propagator is unitary and satisfies composition, inverse, and adjoint closure. Real physical observables are represented by self-adjoint operators with real spectra and orthogonal spectral resolutions. The compact global geometry yields an exact periodic commutator algebra, while the standard canonical position-momentum relation is recovered on regular local charts. The Robertson and Schrödinger-Robertson uncertainty relations then follow from the same Hilbert-space structure. The tetrad Clifford algebra generates the intrinsic spin-one-half representation, including the expected spin magnitude, the spinor sign reversal under a full two-pi rotation, and the rotational multiplets obtained by coupling orbital and intrinsic angular momentum. Detector-surface current is promoted from the direct Born-flux construction of Paper XXI to a general positive measurement structure described by a non-projective POVM and the trace probability rule. Density operators, purity, von Neumann entropy, conditional access states, and Kraus dephasing channels arise within the same measurement framework. The positive-energy Dirac branch reduces at low energy to Pauli dynamics and, when the spin-covariant terms commute appropriately, to the Schrödinger Hamiltonian. The same unitary framework yields the Liouville-von Neumann equation, the Heisenberg operator equation, and the Ehrenfest relations in the local directed potential. A forty-three-condition numerical closure audit satisfies all 43 declared conditions across the derived one-particle structure. Representative numerical results include Hilbert-product and unitary residuals at approximately machine precision, exact spin-one-half algebra to numerical precision, POVM completeness at machine precision, low-energy wave-packet infidelity of 3.16 × 10⁻¹⁰ for the stated audit configuration, and Schrödinger-Heisenberg expectation agreement at 5.66 × 10⁻¹⁷. The result is a single geometric chain from conserved spacetime flux to one-particle state space, unitary dynamics, observables, commutators, uncertainty, spin, measurement operators, statistical states, and the low-energy quantum equations. Composite systems, entanglement, exchange symmetry, quantum statistics, and variable-particle-number field theory remain subsequent structural layers and are not claimed as part of the present one-particle closure.