Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Comment on “`Striped' rectangular rigid box with Hermitian and non-Hermitian PT symmetric potentials” [J. Math. Phys. 62, 102102 (2021)]

Francisco Marcelo Fernández

Published Mar 1, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We show that the two-dimensional quantum-mechanical model proposed by Kulkarni and Pathak [J. Math. Phys. 62, 102102 (2021)] is separable. Consequently, instead of solving a two-dimensional Schrödinger equation, it is sufficient to solve two one-dimensional eigenvalue equations, one of which is exactly solvable. The solution to the remaining equation can be given in terms of a transcendental equation.

DOI
10.1063/5.0082599

Related papers

Exactly solvable PT -symmetric models in two dimensions

Kaustubh S. Agarwal, Rajeev K. Pathak, Yogesh N. Joglekar

Non-Hermitian, $\\mathcal{PT}$ -symmetric Hamiltonians, experimentally realized in optical systems, accurately model the properties of open, bosonic systems with balanced, spatially separated gain and loss. We present a family of exactly solvable, two-dimensional, $\\mathcal{PT}$ potentials for a non-relativistic particle confined in a circular geometry. We show that the $\\mathcal{PT}$ -symmetry threshold can be tuned by introducing a second gain-loss potential or its Hermitian counterpart. Our results explicitly demonstrate that $\\mathcal{PT}$ breaking in two dimensions has a rich phase diagram, with multiple re-entrant $\\mathcal{PT}$ -symmetric phases.

•Nov 1, 2015•12 citations

Comment on ``PT-Symmetric versus Hermitian Formulations of Quantum Mechanics [hep-th/0511229]''

Mostafazadeh, Ali

We explain why the main conclusion of Bender et al, hep-th/0511229 [J. Phys. A 39 (2006) 1657] regarding the practical superiority of the non-Hermitian description of PT-symmetric quantum systems over their Hermitian description is not valid. Recalling the essential role played by the Hermitian description in the characterization and interpretation of the physical observables, we maintain that as far as the physical aspects of the theory are concerned the Hermitian description is not only unavoidable but also indispensable.

arXiv:hep-th/0603059•Mar 8, 2006•6 citations

Comment on: ‘PT-/non-PT-symmetric and non-Hermitian Hellmann potential: approximate bound and scattering states with any ℓ -values’

Paolo Amore, Francisco Marcelo Fernández

Abstract We carry out an analysis of the paper published in Arda and Sever (2014 Phys. Scr. 89 105204 ) and reveal several unclear points. In the first place, the derivation of the main equations does not appear to be correct. In the second place, the expression for the energy does not appear to yield the results reported by the authors. In the third place, they failed to indicate the references reporting the eigenvalues chosen for comparison. In the fourth place the eigenvalues reported by the authors do not show the same order as those of the Hellmann potential thus leading to a different underlying physics. What is more: the spectrum of the modified model is qualitatively different from the one supported by the Hellmann potential.

Physica Scripta•Jun 16, 2015•0 citations

Comment on ‘Numerical estimates of the spectrum for anharmonic PT symmetric potentials’

Paolo Amore, Francisco Marcelo Fernández

We show that the authors of the commented paper draw their conclusions from the eigenvalues of truncated Hamiltonian matrices that do not converge as the matrix dimension increases. In one of the studied examples the authors missed the real positive eigenvalues that already converge towards the exact eigenvalues of the non-Hermitian operator and focused their attention on the complex ones that do not. We also show that the authors misread Bender's argument about the eigenvalues of the harmonic oscillator with boundary conditions in the complex-$x$ plane (Rep. Prog. Phys. {\bf 70} (2007) 947).

arXiv:1209.6357•Physica Scripta•Mar 8, 2013•2 citations

Path Integral Solution of PT-/non-PT-Symmetric and non-Hermitian Morse Potential

Nalan Kandırmaz, R. Sever

Path integral solutions are obtained for the the PT-/non-PT-Symmetric and non-Hermitian Morse Potential. Energy eigenvalues and the corresponding wave functions are obtained.

arXiv:0812.2614•Dec 14, 2008•1 citation

A Qubit Algorithm for Simulating the Nonlinear Schroedinger Equation

Connor Simpson

Recent work in mathematical physics and nonlinear optics has shown that Hamiltonians that are non-Hermitian but still symmetric under parity and time reversal can describe eigenstates of a system with real eigenvalues. Other research has also showed that the nonlinear Schrodinger equation can be generalized to describe PT-symmetric systems, which generates novel solutions not described by its Hermitian equivalent. The Hermitian form of the nonlinear Schroedinger equation can also be extended to describe a particular case of the general PT-symmetric NLS, suggesting a connection between the two. I attempted to generate a unitary operator that will be useful for unitary quantum algorithms describing a coupled set of nonlinear Schroedinger equations and the PT-symmetric version of the NLS.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
We show that the two-dimensional quantum-mechanical model proposed by Kulkarni and Pathak [J. Math. Phys. 62, 102102 (2021)] is separable. Consequently, instead of solving a two-dimensional Schrödinger equation, it is sufficient to solve two one-dimensional eigenvalue equations, one of which is exactly solvable. The solution to the remaining equation can be given in terms of a transcendental equation.
Non-Hermitian, mathcalPT\\mathcal{PT}mathcalPT -symmetric Hamiltonians, experimentally realized in optical systems, accurately model the properties of open, bosonic systems with balanced, spatially separated gain and loss. We present a family of exactly solvable, two-dimensional, mathcalPT\\mathcal{PT}mathcalPT potentials for a non-relativistic particle confined in a circular geometry. We show that the mathcalPT\\mathcal{PT}mathcalPT -symmetry threshold can be tuned by introducing a second gain-loss potential or its Hermitian counterpart. Our results explicitly demonstrate that mathcalPT\\mathcal{PT}mathcalPT breaking in two dimensions has a rich phase diagram, with multiple re-entrant mathcalPT\\mathcal{PT}mathcalPT -symmetric phases.
We explain why the main conclusion of Bender et al, hep-th/0511229 [J. Phys. A 39 (2006) 1657] regarding the practical superiority of the non-Hermitian description of PT-symmetric quantum systems over their Hermitian description is not valid. Recalling the essential role played by the Hermitian description in the characterization and interpretation of the physical observables, we maintain that as far as the physical aspects of the theory are concerned the Hermitian description is not only unavoidable but also indispensable.
Abstract We carry out an analysis of the paper published in Arda and Sever (2014 Phys. Scr. 89 105204 ) and reveal several unclear points. In the first place, the derivation of the main equations does not appear to be correct. In the second place, the expression for the energy does not appear to yield the results reported by the authors. In the third place, they failed to indicate the references reporting the eigenvalues chosen for comparison. In the fourth place the eigenvalues reported by the authors do not show the same order as those of the Hellmann potential thus leading to a different underlying physics. What is more: the spectrum of the modified model is qualitatively different from the one supported by the Hellmann potential.
We show that the authors of the commented paper draw their conclusions from the eigenvalues of truncated Hamiltonian matrices that do not converge as the matrix dimension increases. In one of the studied examples the authors missed the real positive eigenvalues that already converge towards the exact eigenvalues of the non-Hermitian operator and focused their attention on the complex ones that do not. We also show that the authors misread Bender's argument about the eigenvalues of the harmonic oscillator with boundary conditions in the complex-xxx plane (Rep. Prog. Phys. {\bf 70} (2007) 947).
Recent work in mathematical physics and nonlinear optics has shown that Hamiltonians that are non-Hermitian but still symmetric under parity and time reversal can describe eigenstates of a system with real eigenvalues. Other research has also showed that the nonlinear Schrodinger equation can be generalized to describe PT-symmetric systems, which generates novel solutions not described by its Hermitian equivalent. The Hermitian form of the nonlinear Schroedinger equation can also be extended to describe a particular case of the general PT-symmetric NLS, suggesting a connection between the two. I attempted to generate a unitary operator that will be useful for unitary quantum algorithms describing a coupled set of nonlinear Schroedinger equations and the PT-symmetric version of the NLS.