Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Springer eBooks

Reading Bohr: Physics and Philosophy

Arkady Plotnitsky

Published Jan 1, 2006• 57 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/1-4020-5254-5

Related papers

Niels Bohr’s Philosophy of Physics

Henry J. Folse

International Studies in Philosophy•Jan 1, 1990•17 citations

Bohr's relevance to philosophy and contemporary physics

Henrik Zinkernagel

Philosophy of Nature

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

Interpreting Bohr¿s philosophy realistically: A critical study of Folse¿s Bohr interpretation

Halley D. Sánchez

Diálogos (Río Piedras)•Jan 1, 1988•0 citations

To be is to measure: Bohr and the participatory conditions of objectivity

James Vafiadis

Abstract Niels Bohr is standardly read as an instrumentalist or a cautious anti-realist. By way of a rational reconstruction, I argue that his philosophy of experiment advances a transcendental account of the conditions under which physical properties can count as objective at all. On this view, complementarity constrains the forms of description through which physical properties become determinate and communicable. Existing transcendental readings stop at this point; I argue that his philosophy of experiment contains the resources to go further. Objectivity is not merely constituted by such conditions but physically enacted through the observer’s choice of experimental context. This means moving beyond representational and observer-independent forms of realism and adopting a participatory realism in which objectivity is reconceived as the intersubjective stability across observers who experiment (and thus experience) within a shared mode of possible experience. The slogan ‘to be is to measure’ is not defended as an ontological thesis but as shorthand for the claim that physical properties become determinate only within experimental contexts that embodied observers of a particular class enact and share.

Synthese•Oct 12, 2026•0 citations

COMPLEMENTARITY AS A MODEL FOR EAST-WEST INTEGRATIVE PHILOSOPHY

Robert Elliott Allinson

Recently it has been discovered that Niels Bohr, the father of quantum physics, was acquainted, at a young age, with the ancient Chinese philosophy of Lao-Tzu.New evidence has come to light from a letter written by Bohr himself, discovered in 1998, which is a reply to a letter of inquiry from a Svend Hugo Jiirgensen, a teacher from the Danish town of Aalborg.The teacher had sent Bohr a manuscript entitled 'Tuo Te Ching and the Idea of Complementarity'.Bohr's reply, dated 26 March 1958 begins, "I thank you for your letter and the enclosed little note about Tuo Te Ching, which I have read with great interest.I believe what you say about the old Chinese philosophy is in many ways quite to the point.In my youth I received a beautiful impression of it through Ernst Merller's book 'Oldmester', and at a visit to China twenty years ago I learned how highly the memory of Lao-Tzu is still valued."Since Merller's book was first published in 1909 (the year Bohr turned 24) and Bohr by his own account was in his youth, it is clear that his knowledge of Chinese philosophy preceded his discovery of the complementarity principle in physics ( 1927).While this does not conclusively prove that he learned his idea of complementarity from Chinese philosophy, it is nonetheless a document of great interest.In any event, it is clear that Bohr valued highly ancient Chinese philosophy.It was either instrumental or decisive for his complementarity principle in physics, which has proved invaluable as an explanatory principle for Western physics.What better proof is needed to illustrate that the "Chinese mind" is not "of a different order of humanity" than its accessibility through the medium of Danish language to a Western physicist?That the same Western physicist could then apply the idea of complementarity to understand the workings of the universe common to both Western and Chinese minds is a further demonstration that the Chinese mind is as universal in its application to reality as its Western counterpart.And what better evidence can be cited to show that the

Journal of Chinese Philosophy•Feb 10, 1998•13 citations

The Philosophy of Niels Bohr

Richard H. Schlagel

The Review of Metaphysics•Jan 1, 1988•0 citations
Abstract Niels Bohr is standardly read as an instrumentalist or a cautious anti-realist. By way of a rational reconstruction, I argue that his philosophy of experiment advances a transcendental account of the conditions under which physical properties can count as objective at all. On this view, complementarity constrains the forms of description through which physical properties become determinate and communicable. Existing transcendental readings stop at this point; I argue that his philosophy of experiment contains the resources to go further. Objectivity is not merely constituted by such conditions but physically enacted through the observer’s choice of experimental context. This means moving beyond representational and observer-independent forms of realism and adopting a participatory realism in which objectivity is reconceived as the intersubjective stability across observers who experiment (and thus experience) within a shared mode of possible experience. The slogan ‘to be is to measure’ is not defended as an ontological thesis but as shorthand for the claim that physical properties become determinate only within experimental contexts that embodied observers of a particular class enact and share.
Recently it has been discovered that Niels Bohr, the father of quantum physics, was acquainted, at a young age, with the ancient Chinese philosophy of Lao-Tzu.New evidence has come to light from a letter written by Bohr himself, discovered in 1998, which is a reply to a letter of inquiry from a Svend Hugo Jiirgensen, a teacher from the Danish town of Aalborg.The teacher had sent Bohr a manuscript entitled 'Tuo Te Ching and the Idea of Complementarity'.Bohr's reply, dated 26 March 1958 begins, "I thank you for your letter and the enclosed little note about Tuo Te Ching, which I have read with great interest.I believe what you say about the old Chinese philosophy is in many ways quite to the point.In my youth I received a beautiful impression of it through Ernst Merller's book 'Oldmester', and at a visit to China twenty years ago I learned how highly the memory of Lao-Tzu is still valued."Since Merller's book was first published in 1909 (the year Bohr turned 24) and Bohr by his own account was in his youth, it is clear that his knowledge of Chinese philosophy preceded his discovery of the complementarity principle in physics ( 1927).While this does not conclusively prove that he learned his idea of complementarity from Chinese philosophy, it is nonetheless a document of great interest.In any event, it is clear that Bohr valued highly ancient Chinese philosophy.It was either instrumental or decisive for his complementarity principle in physics, which has proved invaluable as an explanatory principle for Western physics.What better proof is needed to illustrate that the "Chinese mind" is not "of a different order of humanity" than its accessibility through the medium of Danish language to a Western physicist?That the same Western physicist could then apply the idea of complementarity to understand the workings of the universe common to both Western and Chinese minds is a further demonstration that the Chinese mind is as universal in its application to reality as its Western counterpart.And what better evidence can be cited to show that the