At a first sight, the description of a scattering experiment seems to be easy and unambiguous. A projectile, as for instance an electron or an ion, flies out of an accelerator with a given momentum p toward an atom or molecule, assumed to be at rest in the collision chamber, and interacts with it. This interaction might lead to different outcomes. For instance, the target might reach an excited bound state, or even loss an electron. These are only two examples of a myriad of options, which are usually called "channels". Thus, we can talk about the elastic channel, the excitation channel, the ionization channel, etc. Finally, one or some of the products of the collision are collected in order to investigate one of these channels.A closer look reveals that the description of any of these experiments is not quite as straight forward. More specifically, one major complication is that the Schrodinger equation is not analytically solvable for more than two mutually interacting particles, even when the underlying forces are precisely known. This is known as the few-body problem (FBP), which is formulated in the introduction to this book and theoretically discussed in other chapters. The FBP, in turn, is afflicted with an additional major complication which is usually overlooked. Addressing this drawback of the standard descriptions of the FBP is the main objective of the present chapter. Both the initial preparation of the projectiles and the final detection of the outgoing particles occur at macroscopic distances, and therefore it is assumed that they cannot have any effect on the scattering event, which occurs in a region of atomic dimensions. In other words, we might say that a scattering experiment is independent of its context. Furthermore, since both the beam of projectiles and the target gas can be described by pure quantum states, we are dealing with a purely coherent process.Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how each of us cope with uncertainties and broken paradigms), when we look deeper into this kind of experiments, we find out that they are trickier than expected. As we will discuss in the present chapter, all and every statement in the previous paragraph is false or at least doubtful. In what follows, we will discuss these issues, paying special attention to the assumption of coherence and lack of contextuality. But first, we will explore some basic ideas in very simple terms, which will pave the way for the discussion ahead.
At a first sight, the description of a scattering experiment seems to be easy and unambiguous. A projectile, as for instance an electron or an ion, flies out of an accelerator with a given momentum p toward an atom or molecule, assumed to be at rest in the collision chamber, and interacts with it. This interaction might lead to different outcomes. For instance, the target might reach an excited bound state, or even loss an electron. These are only two examples of a myriad of options, which are usually called "channels". Thus, we can talk about the elastic channel, the excitation channel, the ionization channel, etc. Finally, one or some of the products of the collision are collected in order to investigate one of these channels.A closer look reveals that the description of any of these experiments is not quite as straight forward. More specifically, one major complication is that the Schrodinger equation is not analytically solvable for more than two mutually interacting particles, even when the underlying forces are precisely known. This is known as the few-body problem (FBP), which is formulated in the introduction to this book and theoretically discussed in other chapters. The FBP, in turn, is afflicted with an additional major complication which is usually overlooked. Addressing this drawback of the standard descriptions of the FBP is the main objective of the present chapter. Both the initial preparation of the projectiles and the final detection of the outgoing particles occur at macroscopic distances, and therefore it is assumed that they cannot have any effect on the scattering event, which occurs in a region of atomic dimensions. In other words, we might say that a scattering experiment is independent of its context. Furthermore, since both the beam of projectiles and the target gas can be described by pure quantum states, we are dealing with a purely coherent process.Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how each of us cope with uncertainties and broken paradigms), when we look deeper into this kind of experiments, we find out that they are trickier than expected. As we will discuss in the present chapter, all and every statement in the previous paragraph is false or at least doubtful. In what follows, we will discuss these issues, paying special attention to the assumption of coherence and lack of contextuality. But first, we will explore some basic ideas in very simple terms, which will pave the way for the discussion ahead.
So far, we have dealt with one- and two-body systems in a variety of settings. These are quite simple, at least a priori, since the equations needed to solve one- and twoparticle scattering problems, as well as bound states, are usually easy enough to handle. The situation becomes much more intricate in the three-body problem, as we shall see in this chapter. Firstly, while two particles in free space can either scatter or bind together, three bodies have extra channels (for attractive interactions) corresponding to two bound particles scattering off a third. Moreover, the energies of these extra channels can be degenerate with those of three unbound particles, and the total momentum of a pair within the triplet is not conserved. Fortunately, we will see that getting our hands dirty with the three-body problem pays off, since there are a number of exotic phenomena associated with the quantum three-body problem, for both bound and scattering states. In this chapter, we introduce the formalism necessary to investigate the three-body problem and study in detail some of the most striking phenomenology known to date associated with, at least, the simplest interactions.
How wonderful that we have met with a paradox. Now we have some hope of making progress —Niels Bohr Probing an elementary or composite particle, an atom, an ion, a molecule, a cluster, or, for that matter any quantum system, involves studying how the target responds to a query – an investigation that is made using a probe that could be electromagnetic radiation (a photon or a beam of light that is incident on the target), or impinging the target with some particles, such as electrons, positrons, neutrons, α-particles, or composites of the same such as atoms, ions, and molecules. Typically, the investigation is called “spectroscopy” when the probe is electromagnetic radiation that is absorbed, scattered or reemitted by the target, which is the object of investigation. When the probe is some other particle, it is usually called “collisions.” The quantum mechanics of spectroscopy and collisions is, however, very closely and seamlessly related, as we shall uncover in this chapter. Niels Bohr's remark quoted above in the frame of a diagram depicting collisions signposts the fact that studies of quantum collisions have resulted in many landmark developments in physics. 10.1 Partial Wave Analysis, Faxen–Holstmark Equation for Potential Scattering Very commonly, quantum collisions are analyzed using what is called as partial wave analysis, which is a mathematical framework developed by Hilding Faxen and Johan Holtsmark in 1927 [1–4]. The Faxen–Holtsmark theory aims at investigating a target T using a monoenergetic incident beam of projectile particles P . Figures 10.1a–d schematically illustrate the scattering process. A monoenergetic beam of incident particles represented by a wavepacket in Fig. 10.1a enters an apparatus containing the target atoms. The polar axis of this coordinate frame is the Z -axis of a Cartesian coordinate system that is chosen to be along the direction of incidence of the probe particles – also referred to as projectiles. Information about the target is obtained from the interaction between the projectiles and the target. The probability of encounter between the incident and the target particles is of primary interest in the scattering formalism. A measure of the encounter probability is provided by the ratio The flux of the incident particles is where NP is the number of probing particles reaching the target per unit time , and S is the effective cross-sectional area of the incident beam that enters the apparatus through the collimator.
Most of our knowledge about the structure of matter and interaction between particles is derived from scattering experiments. From a theoretical point of view, scattering problems are concerned with the continuous (and positive) energy eigenvalues and unbound eigenfunctions of the Schro¨dinger equation. We have already encountered one-dimensional examples of scattering in Chapter 4, in the discussion of reflection and transmission of an incident particle with definite momentum from a potential step or barrier. In this chapter we consider scattering from a more formal point of view. We will confine our discussion to elastic scattering (scattering without loss or gain of energy by the projectile) from central potentials although many of the concepts and results are applicable to inelastic scattering.
In the last decade decoherence has become a very popular topic mainly due to the progress in experimental techniques which allow monitoring of the process of decoherence for single microscopic or mesoscopic systems. The other motivation is the rapid development of quantum information and quantum computation theory where decoherence is the main obstacle in the implementation of bold theoretical ideas. All that makes the second improved and extended edition of this book very timely. Despite the enormous efforts of many authors decoherence with its consequences still remains a rather controversial subject. It touches on, namely, the notoriously confusing issues of quantum measurement theory and interpretation of quantum mechanics. The existence of different points of view is reflected by the structure and content of the book. The first three authors (Joos, Zeh and Kiefer) accept the standard formalism of quantum mechanics but seem to reject orthodox Copenhagen interpretation, Giulini and Kupsch stick to both while Stamatescu discusses models which go beyond the standard quantum theory. Fortunately, most of the presented results are independent of the interpretation and the mathematical formalism is common for the (meta)physically different approaches. After a short introduction by Joos followed by a more detailed review of the basic concepts by Zeh, chapter 3 (the longest chapter) by Joos is devoted to the environmental decoherence. Here the author considers mostly rather `down to earth' and well-motivated mechanisms of decoherence through collisions with atoms or molecules and the processes of emission, absorption and scattering of photons. The issues of decoherence induced superselection rules and localization of objects including the possible explanation of the molecular structure are discussed in details. Many other topics are also reviewed in this chapter, e.g., the so-called Zeno effect, relationships between quantum chaos and decoherence, the role of decoherence in quantum information processing and even decoherence in the brain. The next chapter, written by Kiefer, is devoted to decoherence in quantum field theory and quantum gravity which is a much more speculative and less explored topic. Two complementary aspects are studied in this approach: decoherence of particle states by the quantum fields and decoherence of field states by the particles. Cosmological issues related to decoherence are discussed, not only within the standard Friedmann cosmology, but also using the elements of the theory of black holes, wormholes and strings. The relations between the formalism of consistent histories defined in terms of decoherence functionals and the environmental decoherence are discussed in chapter 5, also written by Kiefer. The Feynman--Vernon influence functional for the quantum open system is presented in detail as the first example of decoherence functional. Then the general theory is outlined together with possible interpretations including cosmological aspects. The next chapter by Giulini presents an overview of the superselection rules arising from physical symmetries and gauge transformations both for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics and quantum field theory. Critical discussion of kinematical superselection rules versus dynamical ones is illustrated by numerous examples like Galilei invariant quantum mechanics, quantum electrodynamics and quantum gravity. The introduction to the theory of quantum open systems and its applications to decoherence models is given in chapter 7 by Kupsch. Generalized master equations, Markovian approximation and a few Hamiltonian models relevant for decoherence are discussed. Some mathematical tools, e.g., complete positivity and entropy inequalities are also presented. The last chapter by Stamatescu is devoted to stochastic collapse models which can be interpreted either as certain representations of the dynamics of open quantum systems or as fundamental modifications of the Schr\"odinger equation. The final part of the book consists of remarks by Zeh on related concepts and methods and seven appendices. The broad spectrum, mathematically-friendly presentation, inclusion of the very recent developments and the extensive bibliography (about 550 references) make this book a valuable reference for all researchers, graduate and PhD students interested in the foundations of quantum mechanics, quantum open systems and quantum information. The relative independence of the chapters and numerous redundancies allow for selective reading, which is very helpful for newcomers to this field.
Chapter 4 deals with Quantum Mechanical (QM) phenomena. The first section describes the first attempts at quantization of energy, momentum, angular momentum, etc. We start with Plank's solution to the black-body problem, introducing the concept of photons: discrete packets of electromagnetic energy. We show how Plank's description of black-body radiation is perfectly fit by the cosmic microwave radiation, providing the strongest evidence for the Big-Bang at the origin of the Universe. We then describe Bohr's solution to the paradoxical stability of atoms, introducing quantization of angular momentum (or action) and correctly predicting the energy levels of the hydrogen atom. We show how Einstein used Plank's idea to explain the photo-electric effect (an effect exploited in CCD cameras and solar cells) and how he used Bohr's understanding of energy levels in atoms to provide an intuitive explanation of Plank's law. Einstein insight opened the way to the field of spectroscopy and the development of the laser. In the second section, following the lead of Dirac, we show that QM is equivalent to Linear Algebra in the space of complex functions (which describe the state of the system). We show that Schrödinger's equation is a natural consequence of that description, once the relation between energy and frequency established by Plank (for photons) and de Broglie (for particles) is taken into account. In the context of the chiral ammonia molecule we discuss the queerness of QM which describes physical systems as superposition of states (such as left and right chirality state of a molecule, dead and alive cat). We show that this queerness is nonetheless supported by experiments and is behind much of our technology: masers and lasers, atomic clocks, semiconductors (diodes, transistors, etc.). In the following section we introduce the representation of operators in QM (the equivalent of matrices in linear algebra): momentum, position, energy, etc. which correspond to measurements on the system. We show that the non-commutability of some operators (common with matrix operations) leads to Heisenberg uncertainty principle: the position and momentum of a particle cannot be determined with absolute precision. We discuss the solution of Schrödinger's equation for free particles demonstrating their equivalence with EM phenomena: particles undergo refraction and diffraction, exemplifying the particle/wave duality inherent to QM systems. We discuss QM tunneling and its use in the Scanning Tunneling Microscope. In the following section we study Dirac's equation: the successful attempt by Dirac to unify QM with Einstein's relativity, with the resulting prediction of anti-particles and spin. We then solve for the energy levels of electrons in the hydrogen atom (from Schrödinger's equation) and show that the existence of spin profoundly affects the behavior of electrons in an atom: they cannot share the same energy level, a rule known as Pauli's exclusion principle. Pauli's principle is central to the understanding of the chemical properties of atoms and fully explains Mendeleev's periodic table of the elements. In the next section we discuss along with two exactly soluble systems (diatomic rotational and vibrational levels), various approximations used to study systems (e.g. molecules) for which there are no analytical solutions. In particular, we introduce Pauling's variational approach, Hückel molecular orbital theory and time independent perturbation theory. We apply those approaches to determine the energy levels in alkenes, in multi-electron atoms and in systems under constant electric or magnetic field (such as in Magnetic Resonance Imaging). In the last section we discuss time dependent perturbation theory. We use it to establish the rules allowing for transitions between energy levels and revisit Einstein description of absorption/emission phenomena.
Introduction While it might appear that the nineteenth-century physics presented in this chapter has no place in a topic as quantum mechanically oriented as atomic physics, this is simply not the case. The purpose of this first chapter is to try to convince the readers that the material learned in their early years of studying physics is not disjoint from modern topics, but in fact can provide a foundation for their further understanding. Other examples will occur later. The reader may be a bit surprised to see that the results of the classical description turn out to be so close to the quantum mechanical results. Where there are significant disagreements between classical and quantum descriptions, it is necessary to explain why these occur. The correspondence principle requires that in the limit of large quantum numbers the complete quantum mechanical description must agree with the classical one. It is always better to need fewer of these explanations and to be able to treat physics as a coherent whole instead of a collection of topics. The consequences of classical physics are intuitively familiar, and this is often most helpful in gaining deeper understanding. In fact, the approach taken in very many of the chapters in this book is to start with a purely classical description of a topic, and then transport it directly into the Schrödinger equation. Radiation from an accelerated charge, as treated here in the harmonic case, provides an ideal setting for such pedagogy. Even though classical mechanics is used in place of quantum mechanics, for the case of harmonic motion, the results are quite compatible. The early history of atomic physics contains many topics that are well worth reading about, especially the experimental facilities. For example, there were no electric motors, wire was not readily available, and making even a crude vacuum was an experimental tour de force. Very many textbooks have discussions of these topics, and so they will not be presented here. But the reader is warned that certain oft-repeated modern descriptions are simply wrong. Perhaps the most important notion to be gained from this chapter is that the classical description of a harmonically bound electron provides quite accurate results about the interaction between atoms and light. Of course, the utility of this description is limited because the classical harmonic oscillator has no internal structure, is infinitely deep, and has a continuous energy spectrum.