Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

De Gruyter eBooks

8 Delayed-Choice Experiments and the Metaphysics of Entanglement

Published Jul 28, 2014• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Delayed-choice experiments in quantum mechanics are often taken to undermine a realistic interpretation of the quantum state.More specifically, Healey has recently argued that the phenomenon of delayed-choice entanglement swapping is incompatible with the view that entanglement is a physical relation between quantum systems.This paper argues against these claims.It first reviews two paradigmatic delayed-choice experiments and analyzes their metaphysical implications.It then applies the results of this analysis to the case of entanglement swapping, showing that such experiments pose no threat to realism about entanglement.

DOI
10.1515/9783110354409.137

Related papers

Delayed-choice entanglement swapping experiments: No evidence for timelike entanglement

Jørn Kløvfjell Mjelva

In recent years, there has been a growing interest in the possibility of temporal nonlocality, mirroring the spatial nonlocality supposedly evidenced by the Bell correlations. In this context, Glick (2019) has argued that timelike entanglement and temporal nonlocality is demonstrated in delayed-choice entanglement swapping (DCES) experiments, like that of Ma et al. (2012), Megidish et al. (2013) and Hensen et al. (2015). I will argue that a careful analysis of these experiments shows that they in fact display nothing more than "ordinary" spacelike entanglement, and that any purported timelike entanglement is an artefact of selection bias. Regardless any other reason one may have for challenging the assumption of temporal locality, timelike entanglement as evidenced by these experiments is not among them. I conclude by discussing what lessons on the nature of entanglement might be drawn from an examination of DCES experiments.

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A•May 22, 2024•3 citations

Delayed-choice gedanken experiments and their realizations

Xiao‐Song Ma, Johannes Kofler, Anton Zeilinger

Wave-particle duality lies at the root of quantum mechanics and is central in the description of interferences observed with elementary objects. In a delayed-choice experiment, the decision to observe the particle or wave character of a quantum system is delayed with respect to the time at which the system enters the interferometer. This paper reviews the history of the delayed-choice idea, introduced as a challenge to a realistic explanation of the wave-particle duality. It also describes recent experimental realizations of this idea and discusses intriguing extensions, such as the duality between separability and entanglement in multiple quantum systems.

arXiv:1407.2930•Reviews of Modern Physics•Mar 3, 2016•237 citations

Quantum teleportation and entanglement swapping viewed from different moving frames

Luiz Carlos Ryff

It is shown that quantum teleportation and entanglement swapping can be easily derived from Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen correlations and special relativity (SR). A recent proposal of entanglement swapping via delayed-choice experiment is discussed by means of a concrete example. Experiments in decoherence in high-Q cavities are briefly examined from the point of view of SR. It is argued that although decoherence can explain why we never see a Schrödinger ‘cat’ which is dead and alive at the same time, this approach apparently does little to explain the cat's ‘real’ state.

Journal of Modern Optics•Apr 1, 2001•1 citation

DELAYED-CHOICE ENTANGLEMENT SWAPPING AND THE RELATIONAL STRUCTURE OF PHYSICAL INFORMATION

Vidamor Cabannas

This article develops an expanded critical-propositional analysis of Xiao-song Ma, Stefan Zotter, Johannes Kofler, Rupert Ursin, Thomas Jennewein, Časlav Brukner, and Anton Zeilinger’s 2012 experiment, “Experimental Delayed-Choice Entanglement Swapping,” published in Nature Physics 8: 479–484, DOI 10.1038/nphys2294, in systematic dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO) formulated by Vidamor Cabannas and Denivaldo Silva. Ma et al. experimentally realized Asher Peres’s delayed-choice entanglement- swapping proposal by producing two entangled photon pairs and temporally delaying a randomly selected measurement on two of the photons until after the other two photons had already been detected. Victor’s later measurement could be configured either as a Bell-state measurement or as a separable-state measurement. Conditional sorting of the earlier records of Alice and Bob then yielded subensembles exhibiting either quantum entanglement or separable correlations. The experiment employed approximately 7 m optical paths for photons measured by Alice and Bob and approximately 104 m fiber delays for the photons sent to Victor. Victor’s measurement occurred about 485 ns after Alice’s and Bob’s detections, while his choice occurred between approximately 14 and 313 ns after those detections. The Bell-state configuration produced a reported fidelity of FBSM = 0.681 ± 0.034 and an entanglement-witness value of WBSM = −0.181 ± 0.034, whereas the separable-state configuration yielded a fidelity of FSSM = 0.421 ± 0.029 and a witness value of WSSM = 0.078 ± 0.029 (Ma et al. 2012). The article examines these results in relation to the Seven Absolute Truths of TO, with particular emphasis on the Fifth Absolute Truth, according to which an element requires relational observation or inclusion within the frequency of at least two other elements in order to possess logical existence. In TO, observation is not reducible to human consciousness; it is an objective relation among physical elements. The Ma experiment does not prove this universal modal proposition, but it offers an unusually relevant empirical domain in which physically meaningful classifications are dependent on multipartite relations rather than on isolated local records. The Fourth and Sixth Absolute Truths are likewise examined in relation to physical boundaries, interfaces, composition, and redistribution of entanglement. The Second Absolute Truth generates a productive tension with quantum indistinguishability, because TO attributes to every element its own exclusive field of individuation, whereas quantum optical interference presupposes operational indistinguishability among identical photons. Special attention is given to the TO concept of the transcendent element as knowledge or information generated in atomic relations and equivalent, within TO, to atomic radiation. Ma et al.’s experiment directly establishes an operational nexus among electromagnetic radiation, polarization information, physical correlations, measurement contexts, and recorded data, but it does not independently establish the stronger ontological identity between information and radiation proposed by TO. The article therefore distinguishes empirical consonance, operational compati- bility, ontological interpretation, and modal necessity. It argues that the scientifically strongest relation between Ma et al. and TO lies not in claiming confirmation of the entire theory but in constructing testable operational bridges, especially around relational observation, boundaries, physical information, non-simultaneity, and the dis- tinction between individual and relational properties. A TO-style appendix concludes the paper by formalizing possible operational bridges and research propositions for future empirical investigation. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; delayed-choice entanglement swapping; quantum entanglement; relational observation; information; photon; Bell-state measurement; modal ontology; non-simultaneity; transcendent element; quantum foundations.

•Sep 21, 2026•0 citations

Metaphysical aspects

Richard A. Healey

As the previous chapter made clear, in the present interpretation quantum mechanics gives a rather specific account of EPR-type correlations and what underlies them. In the present chapter I argue that this account is genuinely explanatory (rather than merely an idle overlay on a simple description of the observed correlations), and that this constitutes a significant advantage of the present interpretation over certain rival interpretations, on which quantum mechanics is unable to offer an adequate explanation of the observed correlations. In order to make this argument it will prove necessary to examine the character of causal explanation in theoretical science, and in particular to develop a coherent metaphysics of a kind of holistic, nonseparable, causal explanation. I take the development of such a coherent metaphysics to constitute a significant task independent of the details of the present interpretation of quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics is a mine of metaphysical insights, and I hope here at least to have exposed a rich seam. The first task is to defend the adequacy of the present account of EPR-type correlations as at least a coherent description of what may underlie the observed correlations. I foresee three main challenges to its descriptive adequacy. The first is to claim that the account is incompatible with the relativistic requirement that there can be no direct causal connection between spacelike-separated events, and must therefore be rejected. A weaker version of this challenge is to claim that although the incompatibility just mentioned may not by itself entail rejection of the account, it does seriously undermine its claim to be genuinely explanatory.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 24, 1989•0 citations

On the interpretation of Delayed Choice Quantum Experiments

Padmanabhan Murali

Experimental realization of Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics continue to suggest inferences of action at a distance, action into the future or past as reported in Delayed choice Quantum entanglement experiments recently by Ma et al (2012). Is it possible to read through this and investigate through simple logic and experiments whether control of the past or future is possible? A set of experiments are suggested here to do the same whose results may be interesting. Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics principles Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (Einstein et al, 1935) were the first to suggest a Gedanken experiment which would suggest instant communication over a distance between particles which was against the principle of Special

•Feb 1, 2015•0 citations
Delayed-choice experiments in quantum mechanics are often taken to undermine a realistic interpretation of the quantum state.More specifically, Healey has recently argued that the phenomenon of delayed-choice entanglement swapping is incompatible with the view that entanglement is a physical relation between quantum systems.This paper argues against these claims.It first reviews two paradigmatic delayed-choice experiments and analyzes their metaphysical implications.It then applies the results of this analysis to the case of entanglement swapping, showing that such experiments pose no threat to realism about entanglement.
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in the possibility of temporal nonlocality, mirroring the spatial nonlocality supposedly evidenced by the Bell correlations. In this context, Glick (2019) has argued that timelike entanglement and temporal nonlocality is demonstrated in delayed-choice entanglement swapping (DCES) experiments, like that of Ma et al. (2012), Megidish et al. (2013) and Hensen et al. (2015). I will argue that a careful analysis of these experiments shows that they in fact display nothing more than "ordinary" spacelike entanglement, and that any purported timelike entanglement is an artefact of selection bias. Regardless any other reason one may have for challenging the assumption of temporal locality, timelike entanglement as evidenced by these experiments is not among them. I conclude by discussing what lessons on the nature of entanglement might be drawn from an examination of DCES experiments.
Wave-particle duality lies at the root of quantum mechanics and is central in the description of interferences observed with elementary objects. In a delayed-choice experiment, the decision to observe the particle or wave character of a quantum system is delayed with respect to the time at which the system enters the interferometer. This paper reviews the history of the delayed-choice idea, introduced as a challenge to a realistic explanation of the wave-particle duality. It also describes recent experimental realizations of this idea and discusses intriguing extensions, such as the duality between separability and entanglement in multiple quantum systems.
It is shown that quantum teleportation and entanglement swapping can be easily derived from Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen correlations and special relativity (SR). A recent proposal of entanglement swapping via delayed-choice experiment is discussed by means of a concrete example. Experiments in decoherence in high-Q cavities are briefly examined from the point of view of SR. It is argued that although decoherence can explain why we never see a Schrödinger ‘cat’ which is dead and alive at the same time, this approach apparently does little to explain the cat's ‘real’ state.
This article develops an expanded critical-propositional analysis of Xiao-song Ma, Stefan Zotter, Johannes Kofler, Rupert Ursin, Thomas Jennewein, Časlav Brukner, and Anton Zeilinger’s 2012 experiment, “Experimental Delayed-Choice Entanglement Swapping,” published in Nature Physics 8: 479–484, DOI 10.1038/nphys2294, in systematic dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO) formulated by Vidamor Cabannas and Denivaldo Silva. Ma et al. experimentally realized Asher Peres’s delayed-choice entanglement- swapping proposal by producing two entangled photon pairs and temporally delaying a randomly selected measurement on two of the photons until after the other two photons had already been detected. Victor’s later measurement could be configured either as a Bell-state measurement or as a separable-state measurement. Conditional sorting of the earlier records of Alice and Bob then yielded subensembles exhibiting either quantum entanglement or separable correlations. The experiment employed approximately 7 m optical paths for photons measured by Alice and Bob and approximately 104 m fiber delays for the photons sent to Victor. Victor’s measurement occurred about 485 ns after Alice’s and Bob’s detections, while his choice occurred between approximately 14 and 313 ns after those detections. The Bell-state configuration produced a reported fidelity of FBSM = 0.681 ± 0.034 and an entanglement-witness value of WBSM = −0.181 ± 0.034, whereas the separable-state configuration yielded a fidelity of FSSM = 0.421 ± 0.029 and a witness value of WSSM = 0.078 ± 0.029 (Ma et al. 2012). The article examines these results in relation to the Seven Absolute Truths of TO, with particular emphasis on the Fifth Absolute Truth, according to which an element requires relational observation or inclusion within the frequency of at least two other elements in order to possess logical existence. In TO, observation is not reducible to human consciousness; it is an objective relation among physical elements. The Ma experiment does not prove this universal modal proposition, but it offers an unusually relevant empirical domain in which physically meaningful classifications are dependent on multipartite relations rather than on isolated local records. The Fourth and Sixth Absolute Truths are likewise examined in relation to physical boundaries, interfaces, composition, and redistribution of entanglement. The Second Absolute Truth generates a productive tension with quantum indistinguishability, because TO attributes to every element its own exclusive field of individuation, whereas quantum optical interference presupposes operational indistinguishability among identical photons. Special attention is given to the TO concept of the transcendent element as knowledge or information generated in atomic relations and equivalent, within TO, to atomic radiation. Ma et al.’s experiment directly establishes an operational nexus among electromagnetic radiation, polarization information, physical correlations, measurement contexts, and recorded data, but it does not independently establish the stronger ontological identity between information and radiation proposed by TO. The article therefore distinguishes empirical consonance, operational compati- bility, ontological interpretation, and modal necessity. It argues that the scientifically strongest relation between Ma et al. and TO lies not in claiming confirmation of the entire theory but in constructing testable operational bridges, especially around relational observation, boundaries, physical information, non-simultaneity, and the dis- tinction between individual and relational properties. A TO-style appendix concludes the paper by formalizing possible operational bridges and research propositions for future empirical investigation. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; delayed-choice entanglement swapping; quantum entanglement; relational observation; information; photon; Bell-state measurement; modal ontology; non-simultaneity; transcendent element; quantum foundations.
As the previous chapter made clear, in the present interpretation quantum mechanics gives a rather specific account of EPR-type correlations and what underlies them. In the present chapter I argue that this account is genuinely explanatory (rather than merely an idle overlay on a simple description of the observed correlations), and that this constitutes a significant advantage of the present interpretation over certain rival interpretations, on which quantum mechanics is unable to offer an adequate explanation of the observed correlations. In order to make this argument it will prove necessary to examine the character of causal explanation in theoretical science, and in particular to develop a coherent metaphysics of a kind of holistic, nonseparable, causal explanation. I take the development of such a coherent metaphysics to constitute a significant task independent of the details of the present interpretation of quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics is a mine of metaphysical insights, and I hope here at least to have exposed a rich seam. The first task is to defend the adequacy of the present account of EPR-type correlations as at least a coherent description of what may underlie the observed correlations. I foresee three main challenges to its descriptive adequacy. The first is to claim that the account is incompatible with the relativistic requirement that there can be no direct causal connection between spacelike-separated events, and must therefore be rejected. A weaker version of this challenge is to claim that although the incompatibility just mentioned may not by itself entail rejection of the account, it does seriously undermine its claim to be genuinely explanatory.
Experimental realization of Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics continue to suggest inferences of action at a distance, action into the future or past as reported in Delayed choice Quantum entanglement experiments recently by Ma et al (2012). Is it possible to read through this and investigate through simple logic and experiments whether control of the past or future is possible? A set of experiments are suggested here to do the same whose results may be interesting. Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics principles Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (Einstein et al, 1935) were the first to suggest a Gedanken experiment which would suggest instant communication over a distance between particles which was against the principle of Special