Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

COMMENT ON “EXPERIMENTAL DEMONSTRATION OF VIOLATIONS OF THE SECOND LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS FOR SMALL SYSTEMS AND SHORT TIME SCALES”

Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen, ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN

Published Feb 1, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In a recent paper Wang et al . [1] report for a colloidal system the entropy production in individual particle trajectories. Some of the trajectories have a negative production, and this is claimed to violate the second law. We stressed that the second law only demands the entropy production averaged over all trajectories to be positive, and this is the case for the data of Wang et al .

DOI
10.1142/9789811252143_0008

Related papers

COMMENT ON "EXPERIMENTAL DEMONSTRATION VIOLATIONS OF THE SECOND LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS FOR SMALL SYSTEMS AND SHORT TIME SCALES"

R. Mannella

Fluctuation and Noise Letters•Jun 1, 2005•1 citation

Entropy production as change in observational entropy

Philipp Strasberg

The second law of nonequilibrium thermodynamics within the open system paradigm (a small system coupled to one or multiple baths) is derived. This is done by showing positivity of entropy production for arbitrary Hamiltonian dynamics for a large class of initial states. Using the recently introduced notion of observational entropy, shortcomings of previous approaches are overcome. I apologize that the actual abstract of the manuscript is longer than the arXiv guidelines allow and therefore not displayed here.

arXiv:1906.09933•Jun 24, 2019•11 citations

Reply to "Comment on "On a new definition of quantum entropy""

Michele Campisi

The example provided in the comment [arXiv:0803.2241] concerns a situation where the system is initially at negative temperature. It is known that in such cases the Law of Entropy Decrease holds. Nevertheless, this does not challenge the validity of the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

arXiv:0804.1146•Apr 7, 2008•0 citations

Comment on "Extraction of work from a single thermal bath in the quantum regime"

Hal Tasaki

Recently Allahverdyan and Nieuwenhuizen (cond-mat/0006404) argued that the second law of thermodynamics may be violated in a quantum system as a "consequence of quantum coherence in the presence of the slightly off-equilibrium nature of the bath." By using a standard result about relative entropy, we prove rigorously that the second law is never violated (and, in particular, a perpetual motion of the second kind can never be realized) in quantum systems no matter how strong ``quantum coherence'' is or no matter how far one goes from equilibrium.

arXiv:cond-mat/0011099•Nov 7, 2000•2 citations

Irreversible work and Maxwell demon in terms of quantum thermodynamic force

B. Ahmadi, S. Salimi, A. S. Khorashad

The second law of classical equilibrium thermodynamics, based on the positivity of entropy production, asserts that any process occurs only in a direction that some information may be lost (flow out of the system) due to the irreversibility inside the system. However, any thermodynamic system can exhibit fluctuations in which negative entropy production may be observed. In particular, in stochastic quantum processes due to quantum correlations and also memory effects we may see the reversal energy flow (heat flow from the cold system to the hot system) and the backflow of information into the system that leads to the negativity of the entropy production which is an apparent violation of the Second Law. In order to resolve this apparent violation, we will try to properly extend the Second Law to quantum processes by incorporating information explicitly into the Second Law. We will also provide a thermodynamic operational meaning for the flow and backflow of information. Finally, it is shown that negative and positive entropy production can be described by a quantum thermodynamic force.

arXiv:1809.00611•Scientific Reports•Jan 27, 2021•20 citations

Bounds for Apparent Second-Law Violations in Quantum Trajectories

Domingos S. P. Salazar

Negative stochastic entropy production is commonly called an apparent violation of the second law. In general quantum-trajectory dynamics, however, the physical entropy production $σ$ need not obey a forward detailed fluctuation theorem. A general arbitrary-coupling formulation identifies a dynamical-asymmetry term $σ^\ast$ that completes it into $Ω=σ+σ^\ast$, whose mean is $\langleΩ\rangle=Σ+Σ^\ast$. We prove that the likelihood-ratio sign is optimal among reversal-odd trajectory observables and use this fact to transfer an established sharp fluctuation-theorem floor to the tie-corrected physical sign statistic $Π_σ=\Pr(σ<0)+\Pr(σ=0)/2$. When $\Pr(σ=0)=0$, the result reads $\Pr(σ<0)\ge[1-\langleΩ\rangle/g(\langleΩ\rangle)]/2$, where $g$ is the inverse of $a\mapsto a\tanh(a/2)$. The physical integral fluctuation theorem simultaneously suppresses large negative events, producing a quantitative ``frequent but mild'' law, while the sign imbalance lower-bounds the hidden mean $Σ^\ast$. We formulate the measured-record protocol explicitly and illustrate and numerically audit the tie-corrected theorem in random finite-coupling collision models and a coherently driven qubit interacting with thermal ancillas.

quant-pharXiv:2608.10118•Aug 12, 2026•0 citations
In a recent paper Wang et al . [1] report for a colloidal system the entropy production in individual particle trajectories. Some of the trajectories have a negative production, and this is claimed to violate the second law. We stressed that the second law only demands the entropy production averaged over all trajectories to be positive, and this is the case for the data of Wang et al .
The second law of nonequilibrium thermodynamics within the open system paradigm (a small system coupled to one or multiple baths) is derived. This is done by showing positivity of entropy production for arbitrary Hamiltonian dynamics for a large class of initial states. Using the recently introduced notion of observational entropy, shortcomings of previous approaches are overcome. I apologize that the actual abstract of the manuscript is longer than the arXiv guidelines allow and therefore not displayed here.
Recently Allahverdyan and Nieuwenhuizen (cond-mat/0006404) argued that the second law of thermodynamics may be violated in a quantum system as a "consequence of quantum coherence in the presence of the slightly off-equilibrium nature of the bath." By using a standard result about relative entropy, we prove rigorously that the second law is never violated (and, in particular, a perpetual motion of the second kind can never be realized) in quantum systems no matter how strong ``quantum coherence'' is or no matter how far one goes from equilibrium.
The second law of classical equilibrium thermodynamics, based on the positivity of entropy production, asserts that any process occurs only in a direction that some information may be lost (flow out of the system) due to the irreversibility inside the system. However, any thermodynamic system can exhibit fluctuations in which negative entropy production may be observed. In particular, in stochastic quantum processes due to quantum correlations and also memory effects we may see the reversal energy flow (heat flow from the cold system to the hot system) and the backflow of information into the system that leads to the negativity of the entropy production which is an apparent violation of the Second Law. In order to resolve this apparent violation, we will try to properly extend the Second Law to quantum processes by incorporating information explicitly into the Second Law. We will also provide a thermodynamic operational meaning for the flow and backflow of information. Finally, it is shown that negative and positive entropy production can be described by a quantum thermodynamic force.
Negative stochastic entropy production is commonly called an apparent violation of the second law. In general quantum-trajectory dynamics, however, the physical entropy production σσσ need not obey a forward detailed fluctuation theorem. A general arbitrary-coupling formulation identifies a dynamical-asymmetry term σ∗σ^\astσ∗ that completes it into Ω=σ+σ∗Ω=σ+σ^\astΩ=σ+σ∗, whose mean is ⟨Ω⟩=Σ+Σ∗\langleΩ\rangle=Σ+Σ^\ast⟨Ω⟩=Σ+Σ∗. We prove that the likelihood-ratio sign is optimal among reversal-odd trajectory observables and use this fact to transfer an established sharp fluctuation-theorem floor to the tie-corrected physical sign statistic Πσ=Pr⁡(σ<0)+Pr⁡(σ=0)/2Π_σ=\Pr(σ<0)+\Pr(σ=0)/2Πσ​=Pr(σ<0)+Pr(σ=0)/2. When Pr⁡(σ=0)=0\Pr(σ=0)=0Pr(σ=0)=0, the result reads Pr⁡(σ<0)≥[1−⟨Ω⟩/g(⟨Ω⟩)]/2\Pr(σ<0)\ge[1-\langleΩ\rangle/g(\langleΩ\rangle)]/2Pr(σ<0)≥[1−⟨Ω⟩/g(⟨Ω⟩)]/2, where ggg is the inverse of a↦atanh⁡(a/2)a\mapsto a\tanh(a/2)a↦atanh(a/2). The physical integral fluctuation theorem simultaneously suppresses large negative events, producing a quantitative ``frequent but mild'' law, while the sign imbalance lower-bounds the hidden mean Σ∗Σ^\astΣ∗. We formulate the measured-record protocol explicitly and illustrate and numerically audit the tie-corrected theorem in random finite-coupling collision models and a coherently driven qubit interacting with thermal ancillas.