Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physica Scripta

Reflection and refraction of photons

Imants Bersons, Rita Veilande, Ojārs Balcers

Published Feb 1, 2022• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Three linear equations are proposed as quantum-mechanical equations for the free propagating photons. The solution of these equations is the vector potential of the electromagnetic field and it is a product of the Gaussian functions for the transverse coordinates and the eigenfunction of the harmonic oscillator for the longitudinal coordinate. This solutions is used to describe the reflection and refraction of photons on the boundary between two dielectrics. The amplitude of the reflected field coincides with the Fresnel formulae for the plane waves, but the amplitude of the refracted field is different. These amplitudes are the probability’s amplitudes of reflection and refraction of photons—like in the quantum mechanics. The photons propagated from the first into the second medium increase (decrease) their transverse size in the plane of incidence, if the refraction index of the second medium is greater (smaller) than in the first medium. The increasing or decreasing grow when increasing the angle of incidence. The difference between the quantum mechanics of the particles with a mass and the photons, as well as the interpretation of the wave function of photons, is discussed.

DOI
10.1088/1402-4896/ac50c4

Related papers

One Dimensional Reflection/Refraction, Spatial Invariance and the Emergence of exp(ipx)

Francesco R. Ruggeri

A one dimensional reflection/refraction problem is by nature probabilistic because an incident photon either reflects or refracts with certain unknown probabilities. The problem is traditionally solved by matching the electric field and its derivative with respect to x at x=0, t=0 where the electric field for a photon follows from Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations and is given by Eo cos(-wt+kx) where p=hbar k. As such, this problem is treated “classically” We argue, however, that this is a quantum mechanical problem (the photon being a quantum particle). Furthermore, no information is needed about the form of the electric field. Reflection/refraction conserves energy. It also occurs at some x point which may be varied i.e. there is translational invariance. A conservation of energy equation may be immediately written. The first medium has an index of refraction n1=1 and the second n2<n1. The conservation of energy equation is: AA/c1 = BB/c1 + CC/c2 where AA, BB and CC are the incident, reflected and refracted intensities = energy per photon * speed * number of photons. AA etc. is written to show that the intensity is explicitly positive. If one considers A known, then B and C are two unknowns, but there is only one equation. Thus energy conservation is not the full reality or information of the problem. This problem may be mathematically solved by using a difference of squares which leads to two equations: (A+B) = C and p1 (A-B) = p2 C. These may be solved for B,C in terms of A. This, however, is not the most general solution in that it does not show invariance of x i.e. the point at which the index of refraction changes. In this note we investigate the consequences of including x in the solution and argue this leads to a kind of square-root probability function which together with its first derivative should be continuous at any x chosen to be the interface of the media. This leads to a solution of Aexp(ipx), instead of A (etc), which is the free particle wavefunction. Thus this wavefunction (or unusual probability) is a direct consequence of the spatial invariance in the problem, but ensures that no x dependence appears if one combines the two square-root probability equations to create an energy conservation equation which has nothing to do with x.

•Apr 3, 2023•0 citations

OPTICAL BEAMS AS QUANTUM MODELS

Franco Gori

The differential equation governing, within the paraxial regime, the propagation of an optical field through a medium with variable refractive index is formally identical to the time-dependent Schroedinger equation for a particle in two dimensions. In particular, the wave function of the particle plays the role of the transverse disturbance of the optical field, the potential acts as the modulation of the refractive index, and time evolution is replaced by the propagation along the longitudinal coordinate. An interesting consequence of such analogy is that well known propagation features of light in some media can afford a model for the time evolution of quantum wavefunctions of a particle within the corresponding potential. Finding the stationary states of a given potential, for instance, turns out to be equivalent to finding the propagation modes in a suitably chosen guiding structure. The simplest case is that of an optical beam propagating inside a homogeneous medium and it corresponds to a free particle on a plane evolving in time. Well, the time evolution of the particle wavefunction can be predicted, starting from its expression at the starting time, using a propagator that can be immediately derived from the Fresnel integral. Yet, it is not difficult to conceive, by suitably superposing eigenstates of the energy of the free particle, a wavefunction whose squared modulus does not change with time, in perfect analogy with an optical nondiffracting Bessel beam. A slightly less trivial case is that of the propagation inside an optical fibre having parabolic refractive index. It is known that the modes of such a fibre are Hermite-Gaussian modes, whose width is determined by the parameter governing the refractive index variation. The quantum analog is a two-dimensional harmonic oscillator, whose energy eigenstates are, of course, the same Hermite-Gaussian functions, and this is, actually, even better known. But the optical analogy allows us also to predict behaviors of the quantum particle that are not completely trivial. It is the case, for instance, of a fundamental Gaussian beam that is injected into the fiber off axis. If the width of the Gausian is chosen as that of the propagation modes of the fiber, the beam will propagate inside the fibre without changing its width, but its center will oscillate around the axis of the fiber. This is due to the “lens-like” effect of a fiber with parabolic refractive index. This corresponds to a coherent state of the harmonic oscillator. Due to the same effect, if we inject off-axis a Gaussian beam with a different spot size, then the beam not only oscillates around the axis, but also changes its width, passing periodically from smaller to larger values of the spot size. This corresponds to a squeezed state of the harmonic oscillator. Further significant cases can be considered, such as those pertinent to optical waveguides, that correspond to potential wells for the quantum particle. Even in such cases, classical results concerning the propagation of the optical fields can help to solve analogous quantum problems, as far as the determination of the stationary states and of the energy eigenvalues, and the time evolution of the system is concerned. Finally, starting from the above analogy, a correspondence between partially coherent beams and mixed quantum states can be established. It stems from the equivalence between the cross-spectral density function, defined within the second-order coherence theory, and the density matrix, used to describe quantum mixed states. Results obtained in the field of the partial coherence optics, such as those pertinent to the well-known Gaussian Schell-model sources, can be easily transposed into the quantum realm. Note from Publisher: This article contains the abstract only.

•Aug 1, 2004•0 citations

The Wave–Particle Nature of Light

Pierre‐Richard Dahoo, Philippe Pougnet, Abdelkhalak El Hami

Light behaves like a wave or a particle. Various terms are used to describe the luminous phenomena found in nature: light, electromagnetic waves or photons. A mathematical description of light in wave optics theory requires that the associated wave function be a solution to the propagation equation. The wave propagation equation is usually valid for describing a monochromatic wave. The Maxwell equations show that light is a transverse electromagnetic wave, which can be split in two linearly independent components corresponding to light polarization. In the quantum mechanics (QM) theory, the electromagnetic field is quantized as a sum of independent harmonic oscillators. Quantum electrodynamics (QED) theory is applied to describe the electromagnetic interactions between charged particles and an electromagnetic field. Using the Coulomb gauge, the electromagnetic field is expressed as a sum of independent oscillators. In the classical approach, the electromagnetic field is completely defined by its amplitude and phase.

Wiley eBooks•Aug 30, 2016•0 citations

The Laws of Reflection and Refraction of Light Waves within the Framework of a New Interpretation of Ballistic Photons

Valentyn Alexeevich Nastasenko

The work relates to the fundamentals of quantum physics and photonics, in particular to the formation of processes of reflection, refraction and absorption of waves of ballistic photons. The study of these problems is an important and urgent task for understanding the foundations of the material world, which has not yet been fully resolved. An important property of ballistic photons is their motion in a straight line, which can be curved under the action of physical fields on the photons and the parameters of the medium of their motion. However, if external factors remain constant, their motion continues in a straight line, which allows us to apply the laws of geometric optics to them. The fundamentals of the geometric wave laws of reflection and refraction of light are laid down of the Young and Fresnel. However, they used sinusoidal waves similar to transverse waves in the of musical strings, which contradicts the motion of spherical waves of ballistic photons. Elimination of these shortcomings is the main goal of the work, and its scientific novelty is the substantiation and development of new geometric models of light motion. Research Methods: Since this work has the level of scientific discovery, for finding which strict methods have not yet been created, therefore, general principles of development of the theory of scientific knowledge were used, based on the laws of dialectics and consistency with the basic laws of physics. The author's research methodology was also used, based on the transition to the initial quantum level of the material world. New Results of the Work and their Discussion: It is shown that the first point of contact of photon waves lies on the unified normal to their spherical surface and the contact surface. This shifts the real normal of wave reflection relative to the traditional normal from the point of intersection of the axis of the tube of incident waves with the surface of reflection by the value of -Δ = λmax sin α. The real axis of reflection of spherical waves is associated with the crests most distant from the initial point of their reflection. When photon waves are refractional, their total deviation is formed from the last point of their incidence on the refraction surface. This shifts the real point of the normal of wave refraction relative to the traditional normal from the point of intersection of the axis of the tube of incident waves with the surface of reflection by the value of +Δ = λmax sin α. Geometric models of all these processes at different angles of incidence of photon waves are developed and their simplified schemes are given. Conclusions: The proposed models and schemes of reflection and refraction of spherical photon waves significantly clarify and change previously known schemes and do not contradict the real laws of physics and optics, therefore they have the level of scientific discoveries and should replace previously known processes and schemes.

Journal of Physics & Optics Sciences•Feb 18, 2025•1 citation

Transmittance and reflectance formulations: a typical isomorphism between the rectangular potential-barrier in quantum mechanics and the dielectric slab in electromagnetic-optics

Belkacem Meziane

Abstract The main intent of this paper is to demonstrate that the theoretical formulations of the reflectance and transmittance characteristics of an initially free quantum particle, heading towards some restricted region of space, inside which it undergoes the effect of an electric-potential-barrier, are isomorphic to those of an incident plane- and linearly-polarized electromagnetic wave, which propagates towards and through a homogeneous dielectric slab.

European Journal of Physics•Feb 9, 2018•1 citation

On the first quantization and quantum diversity of photons

Boris N. Chichkov

Quantum theory of photons based on the first quantization technique, similar to that used by Schrödinger in the formulation of quantum mechanics, is considered. First, scalar quantum mechanics of photons operating with the photon wave functions is discussed. Using the first quantization, the wave equation, the Schrödinger-like equations, and the Dirac equation for photons are derived. Then, vector quantum mechanics of photons is introduced, which defines the electromagnetic vector fields. Using the first quantization, the Maxwell equations for photons in a magneto-dielectric medium are obtained. Because the photon’s electric and magnetic fields satisfy the Maxwell equations, all that is known about the classical optical fields can be directly transferred to photons demonstrating their quantum diversity. Relationships between the scalar and vector quantum mechanics of photons and between the Dirac and Maxwell equations are analyzed. To describe the propagation of photons in dispersive media, modified Maxwell equations are introduced.

arXiv:2505.08369•Advanced Photonics•Aug 18, 2025•2 citations
Abstract Three linear equations are proposed as quantum-mechanical equations for the free propagating photons. The solution of these equations is the vector potential of the electromagnetic field and it is a product of the Gaussian functions for the transverse coordinates and the eigenfunction of the harmonic oscillator for the longitudinal coordinate. This solutions is used to describe the reflection and refraction of photons on the boundary between two dielectrics. The amplitude of the reflected field coincides with the Fresnel formulae for the plane waves, but the amplitude of the refracted field is different. These amplitudes are the probability’s amplitudes of reflection and refraction of photons—like in the quantum mechanics. The photons propagated from the first into the second medium increase (decrease) their transverse size in the plane of incidence, if the refraction index of the second medium is greater (smaller) than in the first medium. The increasing or decreasing grow when increasing the angle of incidence. The difference between the quantum mechanics of the particles with a mass and the photons, as well as the interpretation of the wave function of photons, is discussed.
A one dimensional reflection/refraction problem is by nature probabilistic because an incident photon either reflects or refracts with certain unknown probabilities. The problem is traditionally solved by matching the electric field and its derivative with respect to x at x=0, t=0 where the electric field for a photon follows from Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations and is given by Eo cos(-wt+kx) where p=hbar k. As such, this problem is treated “classically” We argue, however, that this is a quantum mechanical problem (the photon being a quantum particle). Furthermore, no information is needed about the form of the electric field. Reflection/refraction conserves energy. It also occurs at some x point which may be varied i.e. there is translational invariance. A conservation of energy equation may be immediately written. The first medium has an index of refraction n1=1 and the second n2<n1. The conservation of energy equation is: AA/c1 = BB/c1 + CC/c2 where AA, BB and CC are the incident, reflected and refracted intensities = energy per photon * speed * number of photons. AA etc. is written to show that the intensity is explicitly positive. If one considers A known, then B and C are two unknowns, but there is only one equation. Thus energy conservation is not the full reality or information of the problem. This problem may be mathematically solved by using a difference of squares which leads to two equations: (A+B) = C and p1 (A-B) = p2 C. These may be solved for B,C in terms of A. This, however, is not the most general solution in that it does not show invariance of x i.e. the point at which the index of refraction changes. In this note we investigate the consequences of including x in the solution and argue this leads to a kind of square-root probability function which together with its first derivative should be continuous at any x chosen to be the interface of the media. This leads to a solution of Aexp(ipx), instead of A (etc), which is the free particle wavefunction. Thus this wavefunction (or unusual probability) is a direct consequence of the spatial invariance in the problem, but ensures that no x dependence appears if one combines the two square-root probability equations to create an energy conservation equation which has nothing to do with x.
The differential equation governing, within the paraxial regime, the propagation of an optical field through a medium with variable refractive index is formally identical to the time-dependent Schroedinger equation for a particle in two dimensions. In particular, the wave function of the particle plays the role of the transverse disturbance of the optical field, the potential acts as the modulation of the refractive index, and time evolution is replaced by the propagation along the longitudinal coordinate. An interesting consequence of such analogy is that well known propagation features of light in some media can afford a model for the time evolution of quantum wavefunctions of a particle within the corresponding potential. Finding the stationary states of a given potential, for instance, turns out to be equivalent to finding the propagation modes in a suitably chosen guiding structure. The simplest case is that of an optical beam propagating inside a homogeneous medium and it corresponds to a free particle on a plane evolving in time. Well, the time evolution of the particle wavefunction can be predicted, starting from its expression at the starting time, using a propagator that can be immediately derived from the Fresnel integral. Yet, it is not difficult to conceive, by suitably superposing eigenstates of the energy of the free particle, a wavefunction whose squared modulus does not change with time, in perfect analogy with an optical nondiffracting Bessel beam. A slightly less trivial case is that of the propagation inside an optical fibre having parabolic refractive index. It is known that the modes of such a fibre are Hermite-Gaussian modes, whose width is determined by the parameter governing the refractive index variation. The quantum analog is a two-dimensional harmonic oscillator, whose energy eigenstates are, of course, the same Hermite-Gaussian functions, and this is, actually, even better known. But the optical analogy allows us also to predict behaviors of the quantum particle that are not completely trivial. It is the case, for instance, of a fundamental Gaussian beam that is injected into the fiber off axis. If the width of the Gausian is chosen as that of the propagation modes of the fiber, the beam will propagate inside the fibre without changing its width, but its center will oscillate around the axis of the fiber. This is due to the “lens-like” effect of a fiber with parabolic refractive index. This corresponds to a coherent state of the harmonic oscillator. Due to the same effect, if we inject off-axis a Gaussian beam with a different spot size, then the beam not only oscillates around the axis, but also changes its width, passing periodically from smaller to larger values of the spot size. This corresponds to a squeezed state of the harmonic oscillator. Further significant cases can be considered, such as those pertinent to optical waveguides, that correspond to potential wells for the quantum particle. Even in such cases, classical results concerning the propagation of the optical fields can help to solve analogous quantum problems, as far as the determination of the stationary states and of the energy eigenvalues, and the time evolution of the system is concerned. Finally, starting from the above analogy, a correspondence between partially coherent beams and mixed quantum states can be established. It stems from the equivalence between the cross-spectral density function, defined within the second-order coherence theory, and the density matrix, used to describe quantum mixed states. Results obtained in the field of the partial coherence optics, such as those pertinent to the well-known Gaussian Schell-model sources, can be easily transposed into the quantum realm. Note from Publisher: This article contains the abstract only.
Light behaves like a wave or a particle. Various terms are used to describe the luminous phenomena found in nature: light, electromagnetic waves or photons. A mathematical description of light in wave optics theory requires that the associated wave function be a solution to the propagation equation. The wave propagation equation is usually valid for describing a monochromatic wave. The Maxwell equations show that light is a transverse electromagnetic wave, which can be split in two linearly independent components corresponding to light polarization. In the quantum mechanics (QM) theory, the electromagnetic field is quantized as a sum of independent harmonic oscillators. Quantum electrodynamics (QED) theory is applied to describe the electromagnetic interactions between charged particles and an electromagnetic field. Using the Coulomb gauge, the electromagnetic field is expressed as a sum of independent oscillators. In the classical approach, the electromagnetic field is completely defined by its amplitude and phase.
The work relates to the fundamentals of quantum physics and photonics, in particular to the formation of processes of reflection, refraction and absorption of waves of ballistic photons. The study of these problems is an important and urgent task for understanding the foundations of the material world, which has not yet been fully resolved. An important property of ballistic photons is their motion in a straight line, which can be curved under the action of physical fields on the photons and the parameters of the medium of their motion. However, if external factors remain constant, their motion continues in a straight line, which allows us to apply the laws of geometric optics to them. The fundamentals of the geometric wave laws of reflection and refraction of light are laid down of the Young and Fresnel. However, they used sinusoidal waves similar to transverse waves in the of musical strings, which contradicts the motion of spherical waves of ballistic photons. Elimination of these shortcomings is the main goal of the work, and its scientific novelty is the substantiation and development of new geometric models of light motion. Research Methods: Since this work has the level of scientific discovery, for finding which strict methods have not yet been created, therefore, general principles of development of the theory of scientific knowledge were used, based on the laws of dialectics and consistency with the basic laws of physics. The author's research methodology was also used, based on the transition to the initial quantum level of the material world. New Results of the Work and their Discussion: It is shown that the first point of contact of photon waves lies on the unified normal to their spherical surface and the contact surface. This shifts the real normal of wave reflection relative to the traditional normal from the point of intersection of the axis of the tube of incident waves with the surface of reflection by the value of -Δ = λmax sin α. The real axis of reflection of spherical waves is associated with the crests most distant from the initial point of their reflection. When photon waves are refractional, their total deviation is formed from the last point of their incidence on the refraction surface. This shifts the real point of the normal of wave refraction relative to the traditional normal from the point of intersection of the axis of the tube of incident waves with the surface of reflection by the value of +Δ = λmax sin α. Geometric models of all these processes at different angles of incidence of photon waves are developed and their simplified schemes are given. Conclusions: The proposed models and schemes of reflection and refraction of spherical photon waves significantly clarify and change previously known schemes and do not contradict the real laws of physics and optics, therefore they have the level of scientific discoveries and should replace previously known processes and schemes.
Quantum theory of photons based on the first quantization technique, similar to that used by Schrödinger in the formulation of quantum mechanics, is considered. First, scalar quantum mechanics of photons operating with the photon wave functions is discussed. Using the first quantization, the wave equation, the Schrödinger-like equations, and the Dirac equation for photons are derived. Then, vector quantum mechanics of photons is introduced, which defines the electromagnetic vector fields. Using the first quantization, the Maxwell equations for photons in a magneto-dielectric medium are obtained. Because the photon’s electric and magnetic fields satisfy the Maxwell equations, all that is known about the classical optical fields can be directly transferred to photons demonstrating their quantum diversity. Relationships between the scalar and vector quantum mechanics of photons and between the Dirac and Maxwell equations are analyzed. To describe the propagation of photons in dispersive media, modified Maxwell equations are introduced.