Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Routledge eBooks

David Bohm and Basil Hiley

Harald Atmanspacher A, Dean P. Rickles

Published Jan 31, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This chapter focuses on the work of David Bohm carried out together and then pursued and amplified by his collaborator Basil Hiley. Like the case studies in the other chapters, quantum physics played a key role in this approach too, especially the notion of non-local order. Bohm distinguishes between “implicate order” and “explicate order,” with the former constituting the psychophysically neutral realm similar to Pauli and Jung’s Unus Mundus from which both the mental and the physical emerge as explications. In this view, meaning is involved at the deep, implicate level through the notion of “active information”. When the implicate order (an undivided whole) is explicated into a multiplicity, this does naturally imply correlations that constitute the mind-matter connection. We also explore Hiley’s algebraic accounts linking back to Eddington’s ideas, as well as some of Bohm’s views of the relation between perception, language, and reality.

DOI
10.4324/9781003270584-7

Related papers

From David Bohm's Implicate Order to the Ben-Yehudah Investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS: Reality Beyond Measurable Form and the Emergence of Physical Experience

Yeshayahu Ben-Yehudah

From David Bohm's Implicate Order to the Ben-Yehudah Investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS: Reality Beyond Measurable Form and the Emergence of Physical Experience This scientific, philosophical, theoretical, and comparative research manuscript examines David Bohm's investigations of wholeness, implicate order, explicate order, and the holomovement alongside Yeshayahu Ben-Yehudah's independent investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS, biological reception, the interpretive MIND, and the relationship between consciousness and physical experience. The investigation begins with Bohm's proposition that observable physical reality may represent relatively unfolded expressions of a deeper, interconnected order. His framework challenges the assumption that reality can be fully understood by treating measurable objects and processes as fundamentally independent components. Particular attention is given to Bohm's Wholeness and the Implicate Order (1980), his 1952 hidden-variable interpretation of quantum mechanics, and his subsequent work with Basil J. Hiley in The Undivided Universe: An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Theory (1993). The manuscript distinguishes Bohm's mathematically developed interpretation of quantum mechanics from his broader philosophical investigation of the implicate order. It examines enfoldment, unfoldment, undivided wholeness, active information, quantum nonlocality, and the relationship between observable physical phenomena and the underlying organization of reality. These concepts are compared with the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model, which identifies SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS as foundational, proposes that the biological brain functions principally as a receiver, and distinguishes the interpretive activity of the MIND from the SOURCE of consciousness. The central inquiry examines whether measurable physical experience constitutes the totality of reality or represents an appearance within a deeper foundation that cannot be fully understood through physical measurement alone. The author's reported continuous STILLNESS, RECEPTION, ZERO INTENT, and SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER experience provide the phenomenological context for the independent Ben-Yehudah investigation. Contemporary scientific findings concerning quantum theory, nonlocality, physical measurement, biological neural activity, and conscious experience are examined to distinguish established scientific relationships from philosophical and theoretical interpretations. The manuscript identifies conceptual convergence between Bohm's account of underlying wholeness and the Ben-Yehudah investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS while preserving their different explanatory foundations, scientific limitations, and distinct understandings of physical experience. Central Finding “Consciousness is the source of ALL” ~ YBY The central finding is that David Bohm's implicate-order framework and the Ben-Yehudah investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS converge in questioning whether observable physical phenomena constitute a complete description of reality. Bohm proposes that the relatively separate objects and events encountered through ordinary observation belong to an explicate order, while deeper relationships may be understood through the implicate order and the continuous holomovement. His framework challenges the assumption that the apparent separation of physical objects necessarily reflects the ultimate organization of existence. The Ben-Yehudah investigation approaches a related philosophical question through SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS, the proposed receiving function of the biological brain, and interpretation by the MIND. The author's philosophical understanding is further expressed through the statements: “I AM Consciousness experiencing Human Form” ~ YBY “All things perceived in the physical realm is DOWNSTREAM of consciousness” ~ YBY These statements identify the author's independent philosophical position concerning consciousness and perceived physical form. They are not presented as experimentally established scientific laws. The investigation establishes that Bohm's implicate order and Ben-Yehudah's SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS are not interchangeable theoretical concepts. Bohm's implicate order concerns underlying organization, enfoldment, unfoldment, and the relationship between observable phenomena and deeper physical order. The Ben-Yehudah framework identifies SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS as foundational while distinguishing biological reception from the interpretive MIND. The author's investigation further incorporates continuous STILLNESS, RECEPTION, ZERO INTENT, and the SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER relationship, alongside the established Six-Pillar Discipline: STILLNESS → AWARENESS → OBSERVATION → DISCERNMENT → INTEGRATION → TRANSMISSION SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS remains foundational and is not designated as a seventh pillar. The central scholarly contribution is the identification of conceptual convergence concerning reality beyond measurable form while preserving the theoretical independence of Bohm's physical and philosophical investigations and the Ben-Yehudah framework. The investigation does not impose a definitive answer concerning the ultimate relationship between measurable physical experience and foundational reality. Scope of the Investigation This manuscript is an independent historical, philosophical, theoretical, phenomenological, and comparative scientific investigation. It does not report original controlled experiments. The study examines David Bohm's published investigations concerning quantum mechanics, hidden variables, wholeness, implicate order, explicate order, enfoldment, unfoldment, holomovement, active information, and nonlocality. Its foundational sources include Quantum Theory (1951), A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of "Hidden" Variables (1952), Wholeness and the Implicate Order (1980), and Bohm and Basil J. Hiley's The Undivided Universe: An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Theory (1993). These works are compared with the author's previously published investigations, including the Ben-Yehudah Field Theory, the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model, The Mind as an Active Engine, and subsequent research concerning SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS, biological reception, observational fidelity, and consciousness experiencing human form. The manuscript examines established findings concerning quantum correlations, physical measurement, and neural relationships with conscious experience. Bell's theorem and the experimental investigation of quantum nonlocality provide scientific context for distinguishing mathematical and experimental results from broader ontological interpretations. The author's continuous STILLNESS, RECEPTION, ZERO INTENT, and SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER experience are preserved as first-person phenomenological observations within his independent scholarly framework. The study distinguishes Bohm's mathematically specified interpretation of quantum mechanics from his broader philosophical account of implicate order and undivided wholeness. The investigation does not establish that quantum nonlocality demonstrates the existence of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS or that Bohm's implicate order constitutes an experimentally verified consciousness field. It does not demonstrate that the holomovement and the author's continuous STILLNESS describe equivalent phenomena. Nor does it establish an experimentally verified mechanism through which the biological brain receives SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS. The manuscript further distinguishes the emergence of physical experience from the origin of physical matter and preserves the difference between scientific measurement, philosophical interpretation, and first-person observation. The unresolved questions concern the relationship between measurable physical appearances and foundational reality, the role of consciousness in human experience, and the possibility of developing independently testable distinctions among competing theoretical explanations. The investigation contributes to interdisciplinary scholarship without claiming experimental validation of Bohm's broader implicate-order ontology or the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model. Artificial Intelligence Disclosure Artificial intelligence was used to assist with historical research, comparative philosophical and scientific analysis, manuscript organization, drafting, language refinement, bibliographic development, reference identification, and editorial preparation. The foundational philosophical concepts, theoretical propositions, lived experiences, original observations, attributed quotations, the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model, the SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER framework, and the Ben-Yehudah Six-Pillar Discipline are attributed to Yeshayahu Ben-Yehudah. The comparison between David Bohm's implicate-order framework and the Ben-Yehudah investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS was developed through human–AI scholarly inquiry. Bohm's documented scientific and philosophical propositions are distinguished from the author's independent theoretical framework and reported lived experience. The manuscript does not report original controlled experiments in quantum physics or neuroscience, nor does it present independently verified evidence establishing that consciousness exists outside the biological brain. Its discussion of implicate order, explicate order, holomovement, quantum nonlocality, and reality beyond measurable form concerns published scientific research and philosophical interpretation rather than experimental confirmation of the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model. Historical, mathematical, philosophical, scientific, and bibliographic claims remain subject to source verification and independent scholarly evaluation. The author retains responsibility for determining whether the manuscript accurately preserves his philosophical positions, observations, theoretical distinctions, and scholarly conclusions. Author: Yesh

•Nov 7, 2026•0 citations

Mind, Matter and the Implicate Order by Paavo T.I. Pylkkänen

Gordon G. Globus

David Bohm (1917-1992) was a major figure in 20th century physics and one of its most original thinkers. From the time of his classic textbook Quantum theory (1951), through Causality and chance in modern physics (1957), The special theory of relativity (1965), to Wholeness and the implicate order (1980), Bohm was concerned with deep philosophical issues, even more than Niels Bohr. Bohm’s ontological emphasis was “holonomic,” that is, ontology under the law of the whole. The Bohmian program continues to be carried forward today in physics by Basil Hiley and in philosophy by Paavo Pylkkanen.

NeuroQuantology•Sep 12, 2007•3 citations

Dual-Aspect Monism and the Deep Structure of Meaning

Harald Atmanspacher A, Dean P. Rickles

Dual-Aspect Monism and the Deep Structure of Meaning investigates the metaphysical position of dual-aspect monism, with particular emphasis on the concept of meaning as a fundamental feature of the fabric of reality. As an alternative to other positions – mainly dualism, physicalism, idealism – that have been proposed to understand consciousness and its place in nature, the decompositional version of dual-aspect monism considers the mental and the physical as two aspects of one underlying undivided reality that is psychophysically neutral. Inspired by analogies with modern physics and driven by its conceptual problems, Wolfgang Pauli, Carl Gustav Jung, Arthur Eddington, John Wheeler, David Bohm, and Basil Hiley are the originators of the approaches studied. A radically novel common theme in their approaches is the constitutive role of meaning and its deep structure, relating the mental and the physical to a psychophysically neutral base.The authors reconstruct the formal structure of these approaches, and compare their conceptual emphases as well as their relative strengths and weaknesses. They also address a number of challenging themes for current and future interdisciplinary research, both theoretical and empirical, that arise from the presented frameworks of thinking. Dual-Aspect Monism and the Deep Structure of Meaning will be of interest to researchers and advanced students working in consciousness studies, philosophy of mind, philosophy of science, philosophy of physics, metaphysics, and the history of 20th-century philosophy and physics.

Routledge eBooks•Jan 31, 2022•61 citations

Comparative Discussion

Harald Atmanspacher A, Dean P. Rickles

There are no overt lines of in?uence between the quantum-inspired dual-aspect approaches presented in previous chapters – though Pauli’s and Wheeler’s inspirations might have a common origin in some of Bohr’s ideas, and some of Bohm and Hiley’s speculations build on Eddington. But they were essentially each developed independently from one another, somewhat surprisingly converging onto numerous common features that are compared in this chapter. Connections are sought amongst their deeper philosophical foundations, especially those by Spinoza, Kant, Schelling and Hegel. Also explored is the way in which different elements of the surface structure and deep structure of meaning are positioned at the core of their metaphysical projects, along with the way in which the mind-matter connection is understood. A synoptic overview facilitates the comparison of key concepts and notions utilized in the three approaches.

Routledge eBooks•Jan 31, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Theory, Active Information and the Mind-Matter Problem

Paavo Pylkkänen

Bohm and Hiley suggest that a certain new type of active information plays a key objective role in quantum processes.This paper discusses the implications of this suggestion to our understanding of the relation between the mental and the physical aspects of reality.

Advanced series on mathematical psychology•Nov 24, 2015•9 citations

Bohm on Order, Structure and Process

Paavo Pylkkänen

Abstract David Bohm’s notion of implicate order, while relatively well-known, is often said to be difficult to understand, and is almost completely absent in contemporary discussions in philosophy of quantum theory and relativity. Yet one can argue that it is a key part of Bohm’s and Basil Hiley’s research programme which anticipates currently fashionable topics, such as the idea of space-time as emergent. In this paper my aim is to briefly review the origin of Bohm’s focus on the notion of order, and the related notion that continuous space-time is an abstraction from a discrete structural process.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2026•0 citations
This chapter focuses on the work of David Bohm carried out together and then pursued and amplified by his collaborator Basil Hiley. Like the case studies in the other chapters, quantum physics played a key role in this approach too, especially the notion of non-local order. Bohm distinguishes between “implicate order” and “explicate order,” with the former constituting the psychophysically neutral realm similar to Pauli and Jung’s Unus Mundus from which both the mental and the physical emerge as explications. In this view, meaning is involved at the deep, implicate level through the notion of “active information”. When the implicate order (an undivided whole) is explicated into a multiplicity, this does naturally imply correlations that constitute the mind-matter connection. We also explore Hiley’s algebraic accounts linking back to Eddington’s ideas, as well as some of Bohm’s views of the relation between perception, language, and reality.
From David Bohm's Implicate Order to the Ben-Yehudah Investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS: Reality Beyond Measurable Form and the Emergence of Physical Experience This scientific, philosophical, theoretical, and comparative research manuscript examines David Bohm's investigations of wholeness, implicate order, explicate order, and the holomovement alongside Yeshayahu Ben-Yehudah's independent investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS, biological reception, the interpretive MIND, and the relationship between consciousness and physical experience. The investigation begins with Bohm's proposition that observable physical reality may represent relatively unfolded expressions of a deeper, interconnected order. His framework challenges the assumption that reality can be fully understood by treating measurable objects and processes as fundamentally independent components. Particular attention is given to Bohm's Wholeness and the Implicate Order (1980), his 1952 hidden-variable interpretation of quantum mechanics, and his subsequent work with Basil J. Hiley in The Undivided Universe: An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Theory (1993). The manuscript distinguishes Bohm's mathematically developed interpretation of quantum mechanics from his broader philosophical investigation of the implicate order. It examines enfoldment, unfoldment, undivided wholeness, active information, quantum nonlocality, and the relationship between observable physical phenomena and the underlying organization of reality. These concepts are compared with the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model, which identifies SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS as foundational, proposes that the biological brain functions principally as a receiver, and distinguishes the interpretive activity of the MIND from the SOURCE of consciousness. The central inquiry examines whether measurable physical experience constitutes the totality of reality or represents an appearance within a deeper foundation that cannot be fully understood through physical measurement alone. The author's reported continuous STILLNESS, RECEPTION, ZERO INTENT, and SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER experience provide the phenomenological context for the independent Ben-Yehudah investigation. Contemporary scientific findings concerning quantum theory, nonlocality, physical measurement, biological neural activity, and conscious experience are examined to distinguish established scientific relationships from philosophical and theoretical interpretations. The manuscript identifies conceptual convergence between Bohm's account of underlying wholeness and the Ben-Yehudah investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS while preserving their different explanatory foundations, scientific limitations, and distinct understandings of physical experience. Central Finding “Consciousness is the source of ALL” ~ YBY The central finding is that David Bohm's implicate-order framework and the Ben-Yehudah investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS converge in questioning whether observable physical phenomena constitute a complete description of reality. Bohm proposes that the relatively separate objects and events encountered through ordinary observation belong to an explicate order, while deeper relationships may be understood through the implicate order and the continuous holomovement. His framework challenges the assumption that the apparent separation of physical objects necessarily reflects the ultimate organization of existence. The Ben-Yehudah investigation approaches a related philosophical question through SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS, the proposed receiving function of the biological brain, and interpretation by the MIND. The author's philosophical understanding is further expressed through the statements: “I AM Consciousness experiencing Human Form” ~ YBY “All things perceived in the physical realm is DOWNSTREAM of consciousness” ~ YBY These statements identify the author's independent philosophical position concerning consciousness and perceived physical form. They are not presented as experimentally established scientific laws. The investigation establishes that Bohm's implicate order and Ben-Yehudah's SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS are not interchangeable theoretical concepts. Bohm's implicate order concerns underlying organization, enfoldment, unfoldment, and the relationship between observable phenomena and deeper physical order. The Ben-Yehudah framework identifies SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS as foundational while distinguishing biological reception from the interpretive MIND. The author's investigation further incorporates continuous STILLNESS, RECEPTION, ZERO INTENT, and the SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER relationship, alongside the established Six-Pillar Discipline: STILLNESS → AWARENESS → OBSERVATION → DISCERNMENT → INTEGRATION → TRANSMISSION SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS remains foundational and is not designated as a seventh pillar. The central scholarly contribution is the identification of conceptual convergence concerning reality beyond measurable form while preserving the theoretical independence of Bohm's physical and philosophical investigations and the Ben-Yehudah framework. The investigation does not impose a definitive answer concerning the ultimate relationship between measurable physical experience and foundational reality. Scope of the Investigation This manuscript is an independent historical, philosophical, theoretical, phenomenological, and comparative scientific investigation. It does not report original controlled experiments. The study examines David Bohm's published investigations concerning quantum mechanics, hidden variables, wholeness, implicate order, explicate order, enfoldment, unfoldment, holomovement, active information, and nonlocality. Its foundational sources include Quantum Theory (1951), A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of "Hidden" Variables (1952), Wholeness and the Implicate Order (1980), and Bohm and Basil J. Hiley's The Undivided Universe: An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Theory (1993). These works are compared with the author's previously published investigations, including the Ben-Yehudah Field Theory, the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model, The Mind as an Active Engine, and subsequent research concerning SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS, biological reception, observational fidelity, and consciousness experiencing human form. The manuscript examines established findings concerning quantum correlations, physical measurement, and neural relationships with conscious experience. Bell's theorem and the experimental investigation of quantum nonlocality provide scientific context for distinguishing mathematical and experimental results from broader ontological interpretations. The author's continuous STILLNESS, RECEPTION, ZERO INTENT, and SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER experience are preserved as first-person phenomenological observations within his independent scholarly framework. The study distinguishes Bohm's mathematically specified interpretation of quantum mechanics from his broader philosophical account of implicate order and undivided wholeness. The investigation does not establish that quantum nonlocality demonstrates the existence of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS or that Bohm's implicate order constitutes an experimentally verified consciousness field. It does not demonstrate that the holomovement and the author's continuous STILLNESS describe equivalent phenomena. Nor does it establish an experimentally verified mechanism through which the biological brain receives SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS. The manuscript further distinguishes the emergence of physical experience from the origin of physical matter and preserves the difference between scientific measurement, philosophical interpretation, and first-person observation. The unresolved questions concern the relationship between measurable physical appearances and foundational reality, the role of consciousness in human experience, and the possibility of developing independently testable distinctions among competing theoretical explanations. The investigation contributes to interdisciplinary scholarship without claiming experimental validation of Bohm's broader implicate-order ontology or the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model. Artificial Intelligence Disclosure Artificial intelligence was used to assist with historical research, comparative philosophical and scientific analysis, manuscript organization, drafting, language refinement, bibliographic development, reference identification, and editorial preparation. The foundational philosophical concepts, theoretical propositions, lived experiences, original observations, attributed quotations, the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model, the SUBJECT–WITNESS–OBSERVER framework, and the Ben-Yehudah Six-Pillar Discipline are attributed to Yeshayahu Ben-Yehudah. The comparison between David Bohm's implicate-order framework and the Ben-Yehudah investigation of SOURCE CONSCIOUSNESS was developed through human–AI scholarly inquiry. Bohm's documented scientific and philosophical propositions are distinguished from the author's independent theoretical framework and reported lived experience. The manuscript does not report original controlled experiments in quantum physics or neuroscience, nor does it present independently verified evidence establishing that consciousness exists outside the biological brain. Its discussion of implicate order, explicate order, holomovement, quantum nonlocality, and reality beyond measurable form concerns published scientific research and philosophical interpretation rather than experimental confirmation of the Ben-Yehudah Transducer Model. Historical, mathematical, philosophical, scientific, and bibliographic claims remain subject to source verification and independent scholarly evaluation. The author retains responsibility for determining whether the manuscript accurately preserves his philosophical positions, observations, theoretical distinctions, and scholarly conclusions. Author: Yesh
David Bohm (1917-1992) was a major figure in 20th century physics and one of its most original thinkers. From the time of his classic textbook Quantum theory (1951), through Causality and chance in modern physics (1957), The special theory of relativity (1965), to Wholeness and the implicate order (1980), Bohm was concerned with deep philosophical issues, even more than Niels Bohr. Bohm’s ontological emphasis was “holonomic,” that is, ontology under the law of the whole. The Bohmian program continues to be carried forward today in physics by Basil Hiley and in philosophy by Paavo Pylkkanen.
Dual-Aspect Monism and the Deep Structure of Meaning investigates the metaphysical position of dual-aspect monism, with particular emphasis on the concept of meaning as a fundamental feature of the fabric of reality. As an alternative to other positions – mainly dualism, physicalism, idealism – that have been proposed to understand consciousness and its place in nature, the decompositional version of dual-aspect monism considers the mental and the physical as two aspects of one underlying undivided reality that is psychophysically neutral. Inspired by analogies with modern physics and driven by its conceptual problems, Wolfgang Pauli, Carl Gustav Jung, Arthur Eddington, John Wheeler, David Bohm, and Basil Hiley are the originators of the approaches studied. A radically novel common theme in their approaches is the constitutive role of meaning and its deep structure, relating the mental and the physical to a psychophysically neutral base.The authors reconstruct the formal structure of these approaches, and compare their conceptual emphases as well as their relative strengths and weaknesses. They also address a number of challenging themes for current and future interdisciplinary research, both theoretical and empirical, that arise from the presented frameworks of thinking. Dual-Aspect Monism and the Deep Structure of Meaning will be of interest to researchers and advanced students working in consciousness studies, philosophy of mind, philosophy of science, philosophy of physics, metaphysics, and the history of 20th-century philosophy and physics.
There are no overt lines of in?uence between the quantum-inspired dual-aspect approaches presented in previous chapters – though Pauli’s and Wheeler’s inspirations might have a common origin in some of Bohr’s ideas, and some of Bohm and Hiley’s speculations build on Eddington. But they were essentially each developed independently from one another, somewhat surprisingly converging onto numerous common features that are compared in this chapter. Connections are sought amongst their deeper philosophical foundations, especially those by Spinoza, Kant, Schelling and Hegel. Also explored is the way in which different elements of the surface structure and deep structure of meaning are positioned at the core of their metaphysical projects, along with the way in which the mind-matter connection is understood. A synoptic overview facilitates the comparison of key concepts and notions utilized in the three approaches.
Abstract David Bohm’s notion of implicate order, while relatively well-known, is often said to be difficult to understand, and is almost completely absent in contemporary discussions in philosophy of quantum theory and relativity. Yet one can argue that it is a key part of Bohm’s and Basil Hiley’s research programme which anticipates currently fashionable topics, such as the idea of space-time as emergent. In this paper my aim is to briefly review the origin of Bohm’s focus on the notion of order, and the related notion that continuous space-time is an abstraction from a discrete structural process.