Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Progress of Theoretical Physics

Conflict between Matter and Field: An Analysis of the Difficulties of the Theory of Elementary Particles

Mituo Taketani

Published Oct 1, 1949• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1143/ptp.2.187

Related papers

Difficulties inherent in Sach's new theory of elementary matter

Darryl Letter

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Apr 1, 1973•1 citation

Fundamental Difficulties of a Theory of Particles

D. ter Haar

Princeton University Press eBooks•Dec 31, 1998•22 citations

The transformation mechanism between the wave nature and particle nature of an elementary particle

Shuming Wen

In quantum mechanics, the probabilistic interpretation, the complementarity principle (wave-particle duality), and the uncertainty principle form the foundation of the orthodox Copenhagen interpretation. However, this interpretation occasionally produces results that conflict with physical reasoning and intuition, leading to a long-standing debate that has persisted for nearly a century. Based on the conditions of action quantization and determinacy relations, this study reveals that the trajectory of an elementary particle forms a virtual line. At discrete points along this line, the particle exhibits particle-like properties, whereas in the regions between these points, the particle's existence cannot be detected. The most fundamental form of matter is the matter field. Its motion is wave-like and is described by a continuous wave equation and wave function over the entire spacetime domain. At specific spacetime points defined by xn =nh px and tn = nh E⁄ for n=1,2,3,…, the quantized matter field gives rise to the excitation and annihilation of elementary particles, indicating their discontinuous nature. This creation–annihilation process constitutes the wave motion of the matter field. The time and spatial scales associated with this process correspond to one period and one wavelength of the matter field wave, respectively. The Schrödinger equation, in this context, is understood as the non-relativistic equation of motion for a low-speed matter field. The eigenfunction of an elementary particle is, in essence, a wave function that describes the dynamic behavior of the matter field, encompassing the processes of its motion, as well as the generation and annihilation of the particle.

International Conference on Physics and Quantum Computing (ICPQC)•Aug 5, 2025•0 citations

Incompatibility of the quantum and relativity theories and a possible resolution

Mendel Sachs

This paper presents a comparison of the conceptual bases of the quantum theory and the theory of relativity, each considered as fundamental theories of elementary matter. From a study of the irreducible axiomatic bases of these respective approaches to elementary matter, it is concluded that they cannot peacefully co-exist because of logical incompatibility. Among the reasons discussed for this conclusion, one is the implication of the Hamiltonian form of quantum mechanics yielding an irreducible absolute frame of reference - that of the measuring apparatus - in the basic expression for the laws of elementary particles. This difficulty leads to logical inconsistency as well as a formulation of relativistic quantum field theory that is not demonstrably mathematically consistent. In spite of their logical incompatiability, it is argued that each of these theories logically requires the other, within its own framework. The conclusion is reached that, to make further progress in our understanding of elementary matter, it is necessary to abandon the axiomatic basis of one of these theories for the other, while keeping the formal structure of the abandoned theory as an accurate mathematical approximation (under special physical conditions) for a generalized form of the retained theory. An argument is presentedmore » for the author's retention of the theory of relativity as an authentic basis of elementary matter, and how its generalization is achieved by incorporating a fully (generally) covariant expression of the inertial manifestations of matter with its force manifestations.« less

Hadronic J.; (United States)•Aug 1, 1982•1 citation

An attempt in the theory of elementary particles

Takao Tati

Il Nuovo Cimento•Jul 1, 1956•5 citations

A new theory of elementary matter part III: A self-consistent field theory of electrodynamics and correspondence with quantum mechanics

Mendel Sachs

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 1972•8 citations
In quantum mechanics, the probabilistic interpretation, the complementarity principle (wave-particle duality), and the uncertainty principle form the foundation of the orthodox Copenhagen interpretation. However, this interpretation occasionally produces results that conflict with physical reasoning and intuition, leading to a long-standing debate that has persisted for nearly a century. Based on the conditions of action quantization and determinacy relations, this study reveals that the trajectory of an elementary particle forms a virtual line. At discrete points along this line, the particle exhibits particle-like properties, whereas in the regions between these points, the particle's existence cannot be detected. The most fundamental form of matter is the matter field. Its motion is wave-like and is described by a continuous wave equation and wave function over the entire spacetime domain. At specific spacetime points defined by xn =nh px and tn = nh E⁄ for n=1,2,3,…, the quantized matter field gives rise to the excitation and annihilation of elementary particles, indicating their discontinuous nature. This creation–annihilation process constitutes the wave motion of the matter field. The time and spatial scales associated with this process correspond to one period and one wavelength of the matter field wave, respectively. The Schrödinger equation, in this context, is understood as the non-relativistic equation of motion for a low-speed matter field. The eigenfunction of an elementary particle is, in essence, a wave function that describes the dynamic behavior of the matter field, encompassing the processes of its motion, as well as the generation and annihilation of the particle.
This paper presents a comparison of the conceptual bases of the quantum theory and the theory of relativity, each considered as fundamental theories of elementary matter. From a study of the irreducible axiomatic bases of these respective approaches to elementary matter, it is concluded that they cannot peacefully co-exist because of logical incompatibility. Among the reasons discussed for this conclusion, one is the implication of the Hamiltonian form of quantum mechanics yielding an irreducible absolute frame of reference - that of the measuring apparatus - in the basic expression for the laws of elementary particles. This difficulty leads to logical inconsistency as well as a formulation of relativistic quantum field theory that is not demonstrably mathematically consistent. In spite of their logical incompatiability, it is argued that each of these theories logically requires the other, within its own framework. The conclusion is reached that, to make further progress in our understanding of elementary matter, it is necessary to abandon the axiomatic basis of one of these theories for the other, while keeping the formal structure of the abandoned theory as an accurate mathematical approximation (under special physical conditions) for a generalized form of the retained theory. An argument is presentedmore » for the author's retention of the theory of relativity as an authentic basis of elementary matter, and how its generalization is achieved by incorporating a fully (generally) covariant expression of the inertial manifestations of matter with its force manifestations.« less