Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Ordering Ambiguity of Quantum Operators

Published Apr 1, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A big stumbling block in our attempts to obtain consistent quantized versions of classical theories is the problem of ordering of operators. In simple cases, for instance in flat spaces, the order of quantum operators does not matter. However, if a space is curved, then the momentum operator acts on the position dependent metric, and there occurs the ambiguity concerning the order of operators. Such ambiguity typically occurs in the expressions for a Hamilton operator in curved space. In this chapter we discuss and further develop the finding of Ref. [227].

DOI
10.1142/9789811217012_0009

Related papers

Ordering ambiguity versus representation

A de Souza Dutra

In this work we show that the ordering ambiguity on quantization depends on the representation choice. This property is then used to solve unambiguously some particular systems. Finally, we speculate on the consequences for more involved cases.

arXiv:0705.3247•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 7, 2005•24 citations

Quantum mechanics (QM): Path integrals in phase space

Jean Zinn‐Justin

Abstract In Chapter 2, a path integral representation of the quantum operator e-β H in the case of Hamiltonians H of the separable form p2/2m + V(q) has been constructed. Here, the construction is extended to Hamiltonians that are more general functions of phase space variables. This results in integrals over paths in phase space involving the action expressed in terms of the classical Hamiltonian H(p,q). However, it is shown that, in the general case, the path integral is not completely defined, and this reflects the problem that the classical Hamiltonian does not specify completely the quantum Hamiltonian, due to the problem of ordering quantum operators in products. When the Hamiltonian is a quadratic function of the momentum variables, the integral over momenta is Gaussian and can be performed. In the separable example, the path integral of Chapter 2 is recovered. In the case of the charged particle in a magnetic field a more general form is found, which is ambiguous, since a problem of operator ordering arises, and the ambiguity must be fixed. Hamiltonians that are general quadratic functions provide other important examples, which are analysed thoroughly. Such Hamiltonians appear in the quantization of the motion on Riemannian manifolds. There, the problem of ambiguities is even more severe. The problem is illustrated by the analysis of the quantization of the free motion on the sphere SN−1.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 15, 2021•0 citations

The Ordering Ambiguity

S. Habib Mazharimousavi

The kinetic energy operator of a quantum particle with position dependent mass and the associated ordering ambiguity is revisited. We introduce a new form of this operator which is a continues or discreet superposition of the acceptable values for the ordering parameters.

arXiv:1208.4628•Aug 22, 2012•1 citation

Covariant quantizations in plane and curved spaces

João Luis Meloni Assirati, Dmitri M Gitman

We present covariant quantization rules for nonsingular finite-dimensional classical theories with flat and curved configuration spaces. In the beginning, we construct a family of covariant quantizations in flat spaces and Cartesian coordinates. This family is parametrized by a function $$\omega (\theta )$$ , $$\theta \in (1,0)$$ , which describes an ambiguity of the quantization. We generalize this construction presenting covariant quantizations of theories with flat configuration spaces but already with arbitrary curvilinear coordinates. Then we construct a so-called minimal family of covariant quantizations for theories with curved configuration spaces. This family of quantizations is parametrized by the same function $$\omega (\theta ).$$ Finally, we describe a more wide family of covariant quantizations in curved spaces. This family is already parametrized by two functions, the previous one $$\omega (\theta )$$ and by an additional function $$\varTheta (x,\xi )$$ . The above mentioned minimal family is a part at $$\varTheta =1$$ of the wide family of quantizations. We study constructed quantizations in detail, proving their consistency and covariance. As a physical application, we consider a quantization of a non-relativistic particle moving in a curved space, discussing the problem of a quantum potential. Applying the covariant quantizations in flat spaces to an old problem of constructing quantum Hamiltonian in polar coordinates, we directly obtain a correct result.

arXiv:1705.09960•The European Physical Journal C•Jul 1, 2017•3 citations

On Ordering of Operators in Canonical Quantization in Curved Space

Эрнест Ахмеджанович Тагиров

Ambiguities arising in different approaches (canonical, quasiclassical, path integration) to quantization are discussed by an example of the mechanics of a point-like particle in the Riemannian space (the geodesic dynamics). A way to select a single rule of quantization is proposed by requirement of a consistency of the quantum mechanics' following from the canonical and quasiclassical approaches. This rule selects also a definition of the path integration. A geometric interpretation of the noncovariance of the canonical Hamilton operator of a particle with respect to the diffeomorphisms of the Riemannian configuration space is proposed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0101016•Jan 3, 2001•4 citations

New fundamental quantum mechanical operator-ordering identities for the coordinate and momentum operators

Hong-Yi Fan

Science China Physics Mechanics and Astronomy•Mar 25, 2012•19 citations
A big stumbling block in our attempts to obtain consistent quantized versions of classical theories is the problem of ordering of operators. In simple cases, for instance in flat spaces, the order of quantum operators does not matter. However, if a space is curved, then the momentum operator acts on the position dependent metric, and there occurs the ambiguity concerning the order of operators. Such ambiguity typically occurs in the expressions for a Hamilton operator in curved space. In this chapter we discuss and further develop the finding of Ref. [227].
Abstract In Chapter 2, a path integral representation of the quantum operator e-β H in the case of Hamiltonians H of the separable form p2/2m + V(q) has been constructed. Here, the construction is extended to Hamiltonians that are more general functions of phase space variables. This results in integrals over paths in phase space involving the action expressed in terms of the classical Hamiltonian H(p,q). However, it is shown that, in the general case, the path integral is not completely defined, and this reflects the problem that the classical Hamiltonian does not specify completely the quantum Hamiltonian, due to the problem of ordering quantum operators in products. When the Hamiltonian is a quadratic function of the momentum variables, the integral over momenta is Gaussian and can be performed. In the separable example, the path integral of Chapter 2 is recovered. In the case of the charged particle in a magnetic field a more general form is found, which is ambiguous, since a problem of operator ordering arises, and the ambiguity must be fixed. Hamiltonians that are general quadratic functions provide other important examples, which are analysed thoroughly. Such Hamiltonians appear in the quantization of the motion on Riemannian manifolds. There, the problem of ambiguities is even more severe. The problem is illustrated by the analysis of the quantization of the free motion on the sphere SN−1.
We present covariant quantization rules for nonsingular finite-dimensional classical theories with flat and curved configuration spaces. In the beginning, we construct a family of covariant quantizations in flat spaces and Cartesian coordinates. This family is parametrized by a function ω(θ)\omega (\theta )ω(θ) , θ∈(1,0)\theta \in (1,0)θ∈(1,0) , which describes an ambiguity of the quantization. We generalize this construction presenting covariant quantizations of theories with flat configuration spaces but already with arbitrary curvilinear coordinates. Then we construct a so-called minimal family of covariant quantizations for theories with curved configuration spaces. This family of quantizations is parametrized by the same function ω(θ).\omega (\theta ).ω(θ). Finally, we describe a more wide family of covariant quantizations in curved spaces. This family is already parametrized by two functions, the previous one ω(θ)\omega (\theta )ω(θ) and by an additional function Θ(x,ξ)\varTheta (x,\xi )Θ(x,ξ) . The above mentioned minimal family is a part at Θ=1\varTheta =1Θ=1 of the wide family of quantizations. We study constructed quantizations in detail, proving their consistency and covariance. As a physical application, we consider a quantization of a non-relativistic particle moving in a curved space, discussing the problem of a quantum potential. Applying the covariant quantizations in flat spaces to an old problem of constructing quantum Hamiltonian in polar coordinates, we directly obtain a correct result.
Ambiguities arising in different approaches (canonical, quasiclassical, path integration) to quantization are discussed by an example of the mechanics of a point-like particle in the Riemannian space (the geodesic dynamics). A way to select a single rule of quantization is proposed by requirement of a consistency of the quantum mechanics' following from the canonical and quasiclassical approaches. This rule selects also a definition of the path integration. A geometric interpretation of the noncovariance of the canonical Hamilton operator of a particle with respect to the diffeomorphisms of the Riemannian configuration space is proposed.