Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entropy

Uncertainty Relations in the Madelung Picture

Moise Bonilla–Licea, Dieter Schuch

Published Dec 23, 2021• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Madelung showed how the complex Schrödinger equation can be rewritten in terms of two real equations, one for the phase and one for the amplitude of the complex wave function, where both equations are not independent of each other, but coupled. Although these equations formally look like classical hydrodynamic equations, they contain all the information about the quantum system. Concerning the quantum mechanical uncertainties of position and momentum, however, this is not so obvious at first sight. We show how these uncertainties are related to the phase and amplitude of the wave function in position and momentum space and, particularly, that the contribution from the phase essentially depends on the position-momentum correlations. This will be illustrated explicitly using generalized coherent states as examples.

DOI
10.3390/e24010020

Related papers

Uncertainty Relations in the Madelung Picture Including a Dissipative Environment

Dieter Schuch, Moise Bonilla–Licea

In a recent paper, we have shown how in Madelung's hydrodynamic formulation of quantum mechanics, the uncertainties are related to the phase and amplitude of the complex wave function. Now we include a dissipative environment via a nonlinear modified Schrödinger equation. The effect of the environment is described by a complex logarithmic nonlinearity that vanishes on average. Nevertheless, there are various changes in the dynamics of the uncertainties originating from the nonlinear term. Again, this is illustrated explicitly using generalized coherent states as examples. With particular focus on the quantum mechanical contribution to the energy and the uncertainty product, connections can be made with the thermodynamic properties of the environment.

Entropy•Feb 8, 2023•3 citations

Hydrodynamical formulation of Wigner–Dunkl quantum mechanics

Muhammad Farchani Rosyid

The hydrodynamical form of Wigner–Dunkl quantum mechanics has been formulated. The main step to get such formulation was to derive a pair of Madelung-like equations (called Madelung–Wigner–Dunkl equations) from the Schrödinger equation appearing in Wigner–Dunkl quantum mechanics. Some aspects of both equations contained in the pair, i.e. the inhomogeneous continuity equation and the quantum Hamilton–Jacobi equation, have been investigated and discussed. With certain assumption, the relation between the expectation value of the quantum potential appearing in the quantum Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the so-called Fisher information has been derived. Then an uncertainty relation between momentum and position which may be tighter than the standard uncertainty relation has been derived by using Cramér–Rao inequality and Fisher information.

Modern Physics Letters A•Oct 10, 2023•1 citation

Coherent quantum states from classical oscillator amplitudes

J S Briggs, Alexander Eisfeld

In the first days of quantum mechanics Dirac pointed out an analogy between the time-dependent coefficients of an expansion of the Schr\"odinger equation and the classical position and momentum variables solving Hamilton's equations. Here it is shown that the analogy can be made an equivalence in that, in principle, systems of classical oscillators can be constructed whose position and momenta variables form time-dependent amplitudes which are identical to the complex quantum amplitudes of the coupled wave function of an $N$-level quantum system with real coupling matrix elements. Hence classical motion can reproduce quantum coherence.

arXiv:1104.4158•Physical Review A•May 15, 2012•47 citations

Complex Riccati equations as a link between different approaches for the description of dissipative and irreversible systems

Dieter Schuch

Quantum mechanics is essentially described in terms of complex quantities like wave functions. The interesting point is that phase and amplitude of the complex wave function are not independent of each other, but coupled by some kind of conservation law. This coupling exists in time-independent quantum mechanics and has a counterpart in its time-dependent form. It can be traced back to a reformulation of quantum mechanics in terms of nonlinear real Ermakov equations or equivalent complex nonlinear Riccati equations, where the quadratic term in the latter equation explains the origin of the phase-amplitude coupling. Since realistic physical systems are always in contact with some kind of environment this aspect is also taken into account. In this context, different approaches for describing open quantum systems, particularly effective ones, are discussed and compared. Certain kinds of nonlinear modifications of the Schrödinger equation are discussed as well as their interrelations and their relations to linear approaches via non-unitary transformations. The modifications of the aforementioned Ermakov and Riccati equations when environmental effects are included can be determined in the time-dependent case. From formal similarities conclusions can be drawn how the equations of time-independent quantum mechanics can be modified to also incluce the enviromental aspects.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 24, 2012•10 citations

Madelung Fluid Dynamics

Nicolae Mazilu, Maricel Agop, Ioan Mercheş

After the fundamental works of Erwin Schrödinger, Erwin Madelung came up with a physical interpretation of the wave function, from the point of view of the classical fluids’ dynamics. This chapter is concerned with Madelung’s physical interpretation. The Madelung fluid is one case illustrating how “the forces detemine the velocities”, however at a different level of statistics. The “complex phase” of the wave function is the mark of the solution of nonstationary equation. However, his justification for the existence of the essentially complex wave function can be recognized only as anecdotal. The nonstationary Schrödinger equation admits, besides the classical Galilei group proper, an extra set of symmetries that can be taken in a form involving just one space dimension and time. The Maxwellian form of electrodynamics shows that, as long as the time is classically considered i.e. as just a parameter of continuity this concept of local does not require any further consideration beyond in a given space position.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 12, 2019•0 citations

Conditional Values in Quantum Mechanics

Leon W. Cohen

We consider the local value of an operator for a given position or momentum and, more generally on the value of another arbitrary observable. We develop a general approach that is based on breaking up Aψ(x) as Aψ(x)ψ(x)=Aψ(x)ψ(x)R+iAψ(x)ψ(x)I where A is the operator whose local value we seek and ψ(x) is the position wave function. We show that the real part is related to the conditional value for a given position and the imaginary part is related to the standard deviation of the conditional value. We show that the uncertainty of an operator can be expressed in two parts that depend on the real and imaginary parts. In the case of the position representation, the expression for the uncertainty of an operator shows that there are two fundamental contributions, one due to the amplitude of the wave function and the other due to the phase. We obtain the equation of motion for the conditional values, and in particular, we generalize the Ehrenfest theorem by deriving a local version of the theorem. We give a number of examples, including the local value of momentum, kinetic energy, and Hamiltonian. We also discuss other approaches for obtaining a conditional value in quantum mechanics including using quasi-probability distributions and the characteristic function approach, among others.

Entropy•Sep 30, 2024•1 citation
Madelung showed how the complex Schrödinger equation can be rewritten in terms of two real equations, one for the phase and one for the amplitude of the complex wave function, where both equations are not independent of each other, but coupled. Although these equations formally look like classical hydrodynamic equations, they contain all the information about the quantum system. Concerning the quantum mechanical uncertainties of position and momentum, however, this is not so obvious at first sight. We show how these uncertainties are related to the phase and amplitude of the wave function in position and momentum space and, particularly, that the contribution from the phase essentially depends on the position-momentum correlations. This will be illustrated explicitly using generalized coherent states as examples.
In a recent paper, we have shown how in Madelung's hydrodynamic formulation of quantum mechanics, the uncertainties are related to the phase and amplitude of the complex wave function. Now we include a dissipative environment via a nonlinear modified Schrödinger equation. The effect of the environment is described by a complex logarithmic nonlinearity that vanishes on average. Nevertheless, there are various changes in the dynamics of the uncertainties originating from the nonlinear term. Again, this is illustrated explicitly using generalized coherent states as examples. With particular focus on the quantum mechanical contribution to the energy and the uncertainty product, connections can be made with the thermodynamic properties of the environment.
The hydrodynamical form of Wigner–Dunkl quantum mechanics has been formulated. The main step to get such formulation was to derive a pair of Madelung-like equations (called Madelung–Wigner–Dunkl equations) from the Schrödinger equation appearing in Wigner–Dunkl quantum mechanics. Some aspects of both equations contained in the pair, i.e. the inhomogeneous continuity equation and the quantum Hamilton–Jacobi equation, have been investigated and discussed. With certain assumption, the relation between the expectation value of the quantum potential appearing in the quantum Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the so-called Fisher information has been derived. Then an uncertainty relation between momentum and position which may be tighter than the standard uncertainty relation has been derived by using Cramér–Rao inequality and Fisher information.
In the first days of quantum mechanics Dirac pointed out an analogy between the time-dependent coefficients of an expansion of the Schr\"odinger equation and the classical position and momentum variables solving Hamilton's equations. Here it is shown that the analogy can be made an equivalence in that, in principle, systems of classical oscillators can be constructed whose position and momenta variables form time-dependent amplitudes which are identical to the complex quantum amplitudes of the coupled wave function of an NNN-level quantum system with real coupling matrix elements. Hence classical motion can reproduce quantum coherence.
Quantum mechanics is essentially described in terms of complex quantities like wave functions. The interesting point is that phase and amplitude of the complex wave function are not independent of each other, but coupled by some kind of conservation law. This coupling exists in time-independent quantum mechanics and has a counterpart in its time-dependent form. It can be traced back to a reformulation of quantum mechanics in terms of nonlinear real Ermakov equations or equivalent complex nonlinear Riccati equations, where the quadratic term in the latter equation explains the origin of the phase-amplitude coupling. Since realistic physical systems are always in contact with some kind of environment this aspect is also taken into account. In this context, different approaches for describing open quantum systems, particularly effective ones, are discussed and compared. Certain kinds of nonlinear modifications of the Schrödinger equation are discussed as well as their interrelations and their relations to linear approaches via non-unitary transformations. The modifications of the aforementioned Ermakov and Riccati equations when environmental effects are included can be determined in the time-dependent case. From formal similarities conclusions can be drawn how the equations of time-independent quantum mechanics can be modified to also incluce the enviromental aspects.
After the fundamental works of Erwin Schrödinger, Erwin Madelung came up with a physical interpretation of the wave function, from the point of view of the classical fluids’ dynamics. This chapter is concerned with Madelung’s physical interpretation. The Madelung fluid is one case illustrating how “the forces detemine the velocities”, however at a different level of statistics. The “complex phase” of the wave function is the mark of the solution of nonstationary equation. However, his justification for the existence of the essentially complex wave function can be recognized only as anecdotal. The nonstationary Schrödinger equation admits, besides the classical Galilei group proper, an extra set of symmetries that can be taken in a form involving just one space dimension and time. The Maxwellian form of electrodynamics shows that, as long as the time is classically considered i.e. as just a parameter of continuity this concept of local does not require any further consideration beyond in a given space position.
We consider the local value of an operator for a given position or momentum and, more generally on the value of another arbitrary observable. We develop a general approach that is based on breaking up Aψ(x) as Aψ(x)ψ(x)=Aψ(x)ψ(x)R+iAψ(x)ψ(x)I where A is the operator whose local value we seek and ψ(x) is the position wave function. We show that the real part is related to the conditional value for a given position and the imaginary part is related to the standard deviation of the conditional value. We show that the uncertainty of an operator can be expressed in two parts that depend on the real and imaginary parts. In the case of the position representation, the expression for the uncertainty of an operator shows that there are two fundamental contributions, one due to the amplitude of the wave function and the other due to the phase. We obtain the equation of motion for the conditional values, and in particular, we generalize the Ehrenfest theorem by deriving a local version of the theorem. We give a number of examples, including the local value of momentum, kinetic energy, and Hamiltonian. We also discuss other approaches for obtaining a conditional value in quantum mechanics including using quasi-probability distributions and the characteristic function approach, among others.