Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Branching in Relativistic Space-Times

Nuel Belnap, Thomas Müller, Tomasz Placek

Published Dec 16, 2021• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The chapter shows how local indeterminism underlying BST combines with relativistic space-times. First it defines particular BST structures in which histories are isomorphic to Minkowski space-times. It further argues that many general relativistic space-times are one-history structures of BST. It introduces the notion of non-Hausdorff differential manifolds and investigates if they can be interpreted modally, as structures of BST with multiple histories. It investigates bifurcating curves in non-Hausdorff manifolds, which are natural representations of alternative evolutions of point-like objects. As the required bifurcating curves are unlikely in General Relativity, whereas there are cases of indeterministic general relativistic space-times, the chapter concludes that General Relativity is globally indeterministic, but locally deterministic.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780190884314.003.0009

Related papers

Stochastically branching spacetime topology

Roy Douglas

Introduction In this chapter the modelling of spacetime is discussed, with the aim of maintaining a clear distinction between the local properties of a model and those attributes which are global. This separation of attributes (into local and global type) logically motivates the construction of the non-Hausdorff branched model for spacetime. Of course, much of the physical motivation for this construction is derived from the stochastic nature of quantum mechanics. The Many-World Interpretation is seen to be (at least, topologically) a consistent and complete interpretation of quantum mechanics. In any serious inquiry into the nature of spacetime (on either the quantum or cosmological level), mathematical models will be constructed which are in substantial agreement with the collective empiricism of experimental physics. If such a mathematical model is to be more than just a prescription for prediction, then it is necessary to give careful consideration to the appropriate level of mathematical generality of the model. Common sense, as well as the history of science, appear to indicate the need to maintain as general (i.e., unrestricted) a model as possible, constrained only by empirical data on one side, and the limits of our mathematical sophistication and imagination on the other. In the spirit of generalization, I will construct a model of the time parameter , which extends the usual concept of a time-line , and can be used to model spacetime locally, with the usual product structure of Minkowski spacetime. Our imagination will be constrained only by the mathematical discipline of topology and a clear view of all underlying assumptions.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 24, 1995•23 citations

Branching Space-Times: Theory and Applications

Nuel Belnap, Thomas Müller, Tomasz Placek

Abstract This book develops a rigorous theory of indeterminism as a local and modal concept. Its crucial insight is that our world contains events or processes with alternative, really possible outcomes. The theory aims at clarifying what this assumption involves, and it does it in two ways. First, it provides a mathematically rigorous framework for local and modal indeterminism. Second, we support that theory by spelling out the philosophically relevant consequences of this formulation and by showing its fruitful applications in metaphysics. To this end, we offer a formal analysis of modal correlations and of causation, which is applicable in indeterministic and non-local contexts as well. We also propose a rigorous theory of objective single-case probabilities, intended to represent degrees of possibility. In a third step, we link our theory to current physics, investigating how local and modal indeterminism relates to issues in the foundations of physics, in particular, quantum non-locality and spatio-temporal relativity. The book also ventures into the philosophy of time, showing how the theory’s resources can be used to explicate the dynamic concept of the past, present, and future based on local indeterminism.

•Dec 16, 2021•30 citations

Branching space-time, postprint January, 2003

Nue Belnap

``Branching space-time'' is a simple blend of relativity and indeterminism. Postulates and definitions rigorously describe the ``causal order'' relation between possible point events. The key postulate is a version of ``everything has a causal origin''; key defined terms include ``history'' and ``choice point.'' Some elementary but helpful facts are proved. Application is made to the status of causal contemporaries of indeterministic events, to how ``splitting'' of histories happens, to indeterminism without choice, and to Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen distant correlations.

•Jan 1, 2003•6 citations

Local Quantum Probabilities and Global Spacetime Histories

Eran Sinbar

The Born rule assigns probabilities to quantum measurement outcomes using only the local quantum amplitudes immediately before measurement. Yet the physical consequences of those outcomes may differ dramatically in their subsequent evolution, producing spacetime histories with very different entropies, information content, computational complexity, entanglement structure, and ultimately even spacetime curvature. These global properties appear to play no role in determining quantum probabilities. This paper argues that, viewed through the relativistic block-universe picture, this separation between local probability and global physical structure raises a natural conceptual question. The Many-Worlds Interpretation (MWI) preserves the complete branching structure of these histories, whereas collapse interpretations retain only a single realized history. The purpose of this paper is not to challenge the Born rule, but to highlight a conceptual asymmetry that may deserve further investigation.

•Aug 2, 2026•0 citations

Time flow, non-locality, and measurement in quantum mechanics

Storrs McCall

Does time flow? It will be shown in this chapter that if the spacetime structure of the world has a certain branched dynamic form, then time flows. In addition to the flow and direction of time, two issues in quantum mechanics, those of non-locality and the definition of ‘measurement’, are shown to be illuminated by the hypothesis that the world has the spatio-temporal form described. I call the form the branched model , and the interpretation of quantum mechanics to which it gives rise I call the branched interpretation . Objective time flow The branched model is a four-dimensional spacetime model in the shape of a tree, each branch of which is a complete Minkowski manifold in which are located objects and events. The trunk represents the past, the first branch point is the present, and the branches constitute the set of all physically possible futures. The scheme is shown in figure 1. Of the many possible futures which split off at the first branch point, one and only one is selected to become part of the past. The unselected branches vanish, so that the first branch point moves up the tree in a stochastic manner and the tree ‘grows’ by losing branches. This progressive branch attrition is what in the model constitutes the flow of time. Suppose for example that 1000 lottery tickets have been sold to 1000 different purchasers. Then at the time of the draw, assuming the procedure is completely fair, there will be at least 1000 different kinds of branch at the first branch point: branches on which A wins, branches on which B wins, etc.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 24, 1995•12 citations

The Relativity of Branching

Guido Bacciagaluppi

Abstract This chapter argues different ways branching fits within Minkowski spacetime are merely different descriptions of an invariant notion of branching and are due to the relativity of simultaneity. The argument fits in the wider framework of Everett branches as real patterns and is both developed in the abstract setting of the (generalized) histories formalism and discussed comparing the concrete examples of hypersurface-dependent branching and of branching along the forward lightcone. It formulates the latter in terms of branching spacetime, suggesting this is a way in which spacetime can emerge from the universal wave function, and makes tentative connections with causal set theory. The proposed view is compatible with both the Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 26, 2026•0 citations
Abstract The chapter shows how local indeterminism underlying BST combines with relativistic space-times. First it defines particular BST structures in which histories are isomorphic to Minkowski space-times. It further argues that many general relativistic space-times are one-history structures of BST. It introduces the notion of non-Hausdorff differential manifolds and investigates if they can be interpreted modally, as structures of BST with multiple histories. It investigates bifurcating curves in non-Hausdorff manifolds, which are natural representations of alternative evolutions of point-like objects. As the required bifurcating curves are unlikely in General Relativity, whereas there are cases of indeterministic general relativistic space-times, the chapter concludes that General Relativity is globally indeterministic, but locally deterministic.
Introduction In this chapter the modelling of spacetime is discussed, with the aim of maintaining a clear distinction between the local properties of a model and those attributes which are global. This separation of attributes (into local and global type) logically motivates the construction of the non-Hausdorff branched model for spacetime. Of course, much of the physical motivation for this construction is derived from the stochastic nature of quantum mechanics. The Many-World Interpretation is seen to be (at least, topologically) a consistent and complete interpretation of quantum mechanics. In any serious inquiry into the nature of spacetime (on either the quantum or cosmological level), mathematical models will be constructed which are in substantial agreement with the collective empiricism of experimental physics. If such a mathematical model is to be more than just a prescription for prediction, then it is necessary to give careful consideration to the appropriate level of mathematical generality of the model. Common sense, as well as the history of science, appear to indicate the need to maintain as general (i.e., unrestricted) a model as possible, constrained only by empirical data on one side, and the limits of our mathematical sophistication and imagination on the other. In the spirit of generalization, I will construct a model of the time parameter , which extends the usual concept of a time-line , and can be used to model spacetime locally, with the usual product structure of Minkowski spacetime. Our imagination will be constrained only by the mathematical discipline of topology and a clear view of all underlying assumptions.
Abstract This book develops a rigorous theory of indeterminism as a local and modal concept. Its crucial insight is that our world contains events or processes with alternative, really possible outcomes. The theory aims at clarifying what this assumption involves, and it does it in two ways. First, it provides a mathematically rigorous framework for local and modal indeterminism. Second, we support that theory by spelling out the philosophically relevant consequences of this formulation and by showing its fruitful applications in metaphysics. To this end, we offer a formal analysis of modal correlations and of causation, which is applicable in indeterministic and non-local contexts as well. We also propose a rigorous theory of objective single-case probabilities, intended to represent degrees of possibility. In a third step, we link our theory to current physics, investigating how local and modal indeterminism relates to issues in the foundations of physics, in particular, quantum non-locality and spatio-temporal relativity. The book also ventures into the philosophy of time, showing how the theory’s resources can be used to explicate the dynamic concept of the past, present, and future based on local indeterminism.
``Branching space-time'' is a simple blend of relativity and indeterminism. Postulates and definitions rigorously describe the ``causal order'' relation between possible point events. The key postulate is a version of ``everything has a causal origin''; key defined terms include ``history'' and ``choice point.'' Some elementary but helpful facts are proved. Application is made to the status of causal contemporaries of indeterministic events, to how ``splitting'' of histories happens, to indeterminism without choice, and to Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen distant correlations.
The Born rule assigns probabilities to quantum measurement outcomes using only the local quantum amplitudes immediately before measurement. Yet the physical consequences of those outcomes may differ dramatically in their subsequent evolution, producing spacetime histories with very different entropies, information content, computational complexity, entanglement structure, and ultimately even spacetime curvature. These global properties appear to play no role in determining quantum probabilities. This paper argues that, viewed through the relativistic block-universe picture, this separation between local probability and global physical structure raises a natural conceptual question. The Many-Worlds Interpretation (MWI) preserves the complete branching structure of these histories, whereas collapse interpretations retain only a single realized history. The purpose of this paper is not to challenge the Born rule, but to highlight a conceptual asymmetry that may deserve further investigation.
Does time flow? It will be shown in this chapter that if the spacetime structure of the world has a certain branched dynamic form, then time flows. In addition to the flow and direction of time, two issues in quantum mechanics, those of non-locality and the definition of ‘measurement’, are shown to be illuminated by the hypothesis that the world has the spatio-temporal form described. I call the form the branched model , and the interpretation of quantum mechanics to which it gives rise I call the branched interpretation . Objective time flow The branched model is a four-dimensional spacetime model in the shape of a tree, each branch of which is a complete Minkowski manifold in which are located objects and events. The trunk represents the past, the first branch point is the present, and the branches constitute the set of all physically possible futures. The scheme is shown in figure 1. Of the many possible futures which split off at the first branch point, one and only one is selected to become part of the past. The unselected branches vanish, so that the first branch point moves up the tree in a stochastic manner and the tree ‘grows’ by losing branches. This progressive branch attrition is what in the model constitutes the flow of time. Suppose for example that 1000 lottery tickets have been sold to 1000 different purchasers. Then at the time of the draw, assuming the procedure is completely fair, there will be at least 1000 different kinds of branch at the first branch point: branches on which A wins, branches on which B wins, etc.
Abstract This chapter argues different ways branching fits within Minkowski spacetime are merely different descriptions of an invariant notion of branching and are due to the relativity of simultaneity. The argument fits in the wider framework of Everett branches as real patterns and is both developed in the abstract setting of the (generalized) histories formalism and discussed comparing the concrete examples of hypersurface-dependent branching and of branching along the forward lightcone. It formulates the latter in terms of branching spacetime, suggesting this is a way in which spacetime can emerge from the universal wave function, and makes tentative connections with causal set theory. The proposed view is compatible with both the Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures.