Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Maximal localizability of photons

Arkadiusz Jadczyk, Bernard Jancewicz

Published Jan 1, 1973• 6 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We show that simple geometric requirements lead to a unique position operator for the photon. The different components of the position do not commute. We investigate also the problem of maximal localizability and we draw the conclusion that for every closed curve there is a photon state localized on this curve. Note: This paper was published in Bulletin de l’Academie Polonaise de Sciences, Serie des sciences math. astr. et phys., Vol XXI, No 5, 1972, pp. 477-483. The original paper has ”for every closed space-like curve there are exactly two independent photon states corresponding to helicities ±1 localized on this curve. ” The conclusion in this form is incorrect.

Related papers

The localization of photons

Scott E. Hoffmann

We propose a position operator for the photon. The components commute and commute with helicity, and the two operators form a complete set of commuting observables. However, the simultaneous eigenvectors of this position operator and helicity do not rotate locally. For a normalized wavepacket state vector, the position-helicity amplitudes give a complete characterization of the physical properties of the state vector, yet their moduli-squared have rotation properties that do not have a simple interpretation. Thus we call these pseudo-amplitudes. We show that there is a regime of wavepacket state vectors, those with a small fractional spread around an average momentum, where the position-helicity probability pseudo-densities rotate very nearly locally as scalar functions. This is just the regime that is needed to describe a scattering experiment involving photons. We consider other measures of localization for the photon, including those proposed by other authors. It is important to note that exactly the same problems arise if we try to characterize the state vector of a massive particle with spin by position and helicity. The problems are not the result of the masslessness of the photon but arise because of its limited helicity spectrum.

•Aug 31, 2019•0 citations

Loop coherent states and photon localizability

Edward R. Pike, Sarben Sarkar

Loop states in quantum optics and their 1-1 correspondence with states in Fock space are described. Owing to their natural encoding of geometrical information and close relation to coherent states it is proposed that a certain subclass of loop coherent states may be used as a probe for localization of photon states.

Quantum Optics Journal of the European Optical Society Part B•Aug 1, 1993•2 citations

A Comment on the "Photon position operator with commuting components" by Margaret Hawton

Arkadiusz Jadczyk, Agnieszka Matylda Schlichtinger

We show that the position operator with commuting components proposed by M. Hawton [M. Hawton, Phys. Rev. A {\bf 59}, 954 (1999)] and developed in subsequent papers, including the recent ones, does not have the properties required for a photon position operator. Depending on the exact interpretation of the results it either concerns a triplet of massless spin zero particles rather than the photon, or does not have the required covariance properties under space rotations.

arXiv:2203.14555•Mar 28, 2022•3 citations

Photon Position Operator and Localization of Photons inside a Waveguide

Zhiyong Wang, Cai-Dong Xiong, Ole Keller

In this article, we show that in the level of quantum mechanics, a photon position operator with commuting components can be obtained in a more natural way; in the level of quantum field theory, the photon position operator corresponds to the center of the photon number. It is most interesting for us to show that, a photon inside a waveguide can be localized in the same sense that a massive particle can be localized in free space, and just as that it is impossible to localize a massive particle with a greater precision than its Compton wavelength, one can also arrival at a similar conclusion: it is impossible to localize a photon inside a waveguide with a greater precision than its equivalent Compton wavelength, which owing to evanescent-wave or photon-tunneling phenomena.

arXiv:quant-ph/0511270•Nov 30, 2005•1 citation

The photon position operator (non-commuting) and its string-like eigenstates

Grzegorz Marcin Koczan

The paper provides three main definitions of the Cartesian photon position operator based on: boost generator, the transversality condition and the helicity operator. In each case, the correctness of the definition and Hermitianness of the operator in the domain of physical states are proven. All considered definitions lead to the same form of the Cartesian position operator in the domain of physical states. Radial photon position operators were also defined, but they turned out to be non-equivalent. Nevertheless, the most useful two radial operators turned out to be twin counterparts in the sense of the transformation to the helical representation, which is an alternative positional representation. The components of the photon position operator do not commute, but in analogy to the problem of eigenangular momentum, its eigenstates do exist. The eigenstates of the two components of the position operator (including the radial component) are called photon strings. Photon strings on a straight line and on a circle have been studied. The usual, previously known photon string states were named electric strings, but new magnetic strings were also introduced. Exact helical photon strings on a straight line, as well as hybrid helical photon strings on a circle, were also considered. On the other hand, infinitely short photon magnetic strings turned out to be flat photon vortices on planes with a normalization formula looks like as point-localized particles.

arXiv:2309.12125•Sep 21, 2023•1 citation

Quantum mechanics of a photon

Hassan Babaei, Ali Mostafazadeh

A first-quantized free photon is a complex massless vector field A=(Aμ) whose field strength satisfies Maxwell’s equations in vacuum. We construct the Hilbert space H of the photon by endowing the vector space of the fields A in the temporal-Coulomb gauge with a positive-definite and relativistically invariant inner product. We give an explicit expression for this inner product, identify the Hamiltonian for the photon with the generator of time translations in H, determine the operators representing the momentum and the helicity of the photon, and introduce a chirality operator whose eigenfunctions correspond to fields having a definite sign of energy. We also construct a position operator for the photon whose components commute with each other and with the chirality and helicity operators. This allows for the construction of the localized states of the photon with a definite sign of energy and helicity. We derive an explicit formula for the latter and compute the corresponding electric and magnetic fields. These turn out to diverge not just at the point where the photon is localized but on a plane containing this point. We identify the axis normal to this plane with an associated symmetry axis and show that each choice of this axis specifies a particular position operator, a corresponding position basis, and a position representation of the quantum mechanics of a photon. In particular, we examine the position wave functions determined by such a position basis, elucidate their relationship with the Riemann-Silberstein and Landau-Peierls wave functions, and give an explicit formula for the probability density of the spatial localization of the photon.

arXiv:1608.06479•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 2017•27 citations
We show that simple geometric requirements lead to a unique position operator for the photon. The different components of the position do not commute. We investigate also the problem of maximal localizability and we draw the conclusion that for every closed curve there is a photon state localized on this curve. Note: This paper was published in Bulletin de l’Academie Polonaise de Sciences, Serie des sciences math. astr. et phys., Vol XXI, No 5, 1972, pp. 477-483. The original paper has ”for every closed space-like curve there are exactly two independent photon states corresponding to helicities ±1 localized on this curve. ” The conclusion in this form is incorrect.
We propose a position operator for the photon. The components commute and commute with helicity, and the two operators form a complete set of commuting observables. However, the simultaneous eigenvectors of this position operator and helicity do not rotate locally. For a normalized wavepacket state vector, the position-helicity amplitudes give a complete characterization of the physical properties of the state vector, yet their moduli-squared have rotation properties that do not have a simple interpretation. Thus we call these pseudo-amplitudes. We show that there is a regime of wavepacket state vectors, those with a small fractional spread around an average momentum, where the position-helicity probability pseudo-densities rotate very nearly locally as scalar functions. This is just the regime that is needed to describe a scattering experiment involving photons. We consider other measures of localization for the photon, including those proposed by other authors. It is important to note that exactly the same problems arise if we try to characterize the state vector of a massive particle with spin by position and helicity. The problems are not the result of the masslessness of the photon but arise because of its limited helicity spectrum.
In this article, we show that in the level of quantum mechanics, a photon position operator with commuting components can be obtained in a more natural way; in the level of quantum field theory, the photon position operator corresponds to the center of the photon number. It is most interesting for us to show that, a photon inside a waveguide can be localized in the same sense that a massive particle can be localized in free space, and just as that it is impossible to localize a massive particle with a greater precision than its Compton wavelength, one can also arrival at a similar conclusion: it is impossible to localize a photon inside a waveguide with a greater precision than its equivalent Compton wavelength, which owing to evanescent-wave or photon-tunneling phenomena.
The paper provides three main definitions of the Cartesian photon position operator based on: boost generator, the transversality condition and the helicity operator. In each case, the correctness of the definition and Hermitianness of the operator in the domain of physical states are proven. All considered definitions lead to the same form of the Cartesian position operator in the domain of physical states. Radial photon position operators were also defined, but they turned out to be non-equivalent. Nevertheless, the most useful two radial operators turned out to be twin counterparts in the sense of the transformation to the helical representation, which is an alternative positional representation. The components of the photon position operator do not commute, but in analogy to the problem of eigenangular momentum, its eigenstates do exist. The eigenstates of the two components of the position operator (including the radial component) are called photon strings. Photon strings on a straight line and on a circle have been studied. The usual, previously known photon string states were named electric strings, but new magnetic strings were also introduced. Exact helical photon strings on a straight line, as well as hybrid helical photon strings on a circle, were also considered. On the other hand, infinitely short photon magnetic strings turned out to be flat photon vortices on planes with a normalization formula looks like as point-localized particles.
A first-quantized free photon is a complex massless vector field A=(Aμ) whose field strength satisfies Maxwell’s equations in vacuum. We construct the Hilbert space H of the photon by endowing the vector space of the fields A in the temporal-Coulomb gauge with a positive-definite and relativistically invariant inner product. We give an explicit expression for this inner product, identify the Hamiltonian for the photon with the generator of time translations in H, determine the operators representing the momentum and the helicity of the photon, and introduce a chirality operator whose eigenfunctions correspond to fields having a definite sign of energy. We also construct a position operator for the photon whose components commute with each other and with the chirality and helicity operators. This allows for the construction of the localized states of the photon with a definite sign of energy and helicity. We derive an explicit formula for the latter and compute the corresponding electric and magnetic fields. These turn out to diverge not just at the point where the photon is localized but on a plane containing this point. We identify the axis normal to this plane with an associated symmetry axis and show that each choice of this axis specifies a particular position operator, a corresponding position basis, and a position representation of the quantum mechanics of a photon. In particular, we examine the position wave functions determined by such a position basis, elucidate their relationship with the Riemann-Silberstein and Landau-Peierls wave functions, and give an explicit formula for the probability density of the spatial localization of the photon.