Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Keio Engineering Reports

Physical theory of measuring process : a critical review

豊 榛葉, 充 福地, 亮 坂田

Published Feb 1, 1980• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

After a survey of the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics and von Neumann's approach to a measurement theory, the measurement theory of Daneri, Loinger and Prosperi is critically reviewed in regard in particular to their aims and assumptions. The review will lead us to see what is still desirable of a physical theory of measurement on quantum mechanical systems.

Related papers

Critical Review of Theory of Measurement in Quantum Mechanics

Shigeru Machida, Mikio Namiki

A critical review of the theory of measurement in quantum mechanics is presented first, which is focused on the recent controversy between the von Neumann-Wigner theory and the ergodic amplification theory. Making the point clear through discussions on the controversy, we then describe a new version of the Machida-Namiki-Araki theory, as a solution of the problem, in which the macroscopic nature of measuring apparatus is explicitly formulated in a continuous direct sum of many Hilbert spaces and the unitarity of S -matrix of elementary interaction processes between object and apparatus systems is maintained. Within the framework of their theory, it is explicitly shown that the reduction of wave packet takes place even in the negative result measurement.

Advanced series in applied physics•Jan 1, 1997•4 citations

On the Quantum Theory of Measurement

Gen-Ichiro Nagasaka

Since the formulation of measurement process by von Neumann, numerous attempts have been made to remove the various paradoxical aspects involved in the theory. The present exposition reveals that a serious linguistic confusion existed in the original formulation by von Neumann and no author has ever given serious considerations. A new approach to the problem is proposed which is based upon an interpretation of quantum mechanics basically in the spirit of Copenhagen Interpretation.

Kagaku tetsugaku•Jan 1, 1970•11 citations

Theory of large quantal systems and the quantum theory of measurement

T. F. Hill

The consistency problem of quantum mechanics may be resolved by regarding any measurement performed on an atomic system as essentially involving an interaction between the atomic system and a macroscopic measuring apparatus and the subsequent behaviour of the apparatus in producing a signal to indicate the result of the measurement. Of central importance in such an approach, therefore, is the study of large quantal systems. Along these lines, two approaches to the consistency problem have been provided; one, by the Italian group of Daneri, Loinger and Prosperi, based on a time-independent ergodic theory of large quantal systems; the other by the Belgian group of George, Prigogine and Rosenfeld, based on a time-dependent theory. In this thesis these two theories are compared and are shown to be equivalent.

•Jan 1, 1974•0 citations

Quantum Theoretical Concepts of Measurement: Part I

James L Park

The overall purpose of this paper is to clarify the physical meaning and epistemological status of the term ‘measurement’ as used in quantum theory. After a review of the essential logical structure of quantum physics. Part I presents interpretive discussions contrasting the quantal concepts observable and ensemble with their classical ancestors along the lines of Margenau's latency theory. Against this background various popular ideas concerning the nature of quantum measurement are critically surveyed. The analysis reveals that, in addition to internal mathematical difficulties, all the so-called quantum theories of measurement are grounded in unjustifiable, classical presuppositions.

Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 1968•36 citations

Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics: a critical survey

Michele Caponigro

This brief survey analyzes the epistemological implications about the role of observer in the interpretations of Quantum Mechanics. As we know, the goal of most interpretations of quantum mechanics is to avoid the apparent intrusion of the observer into the measurement process. In the same time, there are implicit and hidden assumptions about his role. In fact, most interpretations taking as ontic level one of these fundamental concepts as information, physical law and matter bring us to new problematical questions. We think, that no interpretation of the quantum theory can avoid this intrusion until we do not clarify the nature of observer.

arXiv:0811.3877•Prespacetime journal•Nov 24, 2008•2 citations

Von Neumann's theory of measurement

Rathindra Nath Sen

Von Neumann's theory of measurement in Quantum Mechanics was spelled out in the last chapter of his book, which was published in 1932. This book was highly mathematical for its time, and in 1939 London and Bauer provided a simplified account of the measurement theory part of it (London and Bauer, 1939). Von Neumann died in 1957. Thirty years after the publication of von Neumann's book, Wigner published a review containing his views on the shortcomings of von Neumann's theory, but omitting any discussion of its mathematical core, namely von Neumann's analysis of composite systems (Wigner, 1963). He also published a set of lecture notes entitled Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (Wigner, 1983) in which some of his concerns were spelled out in greater detail, and an article addressed ‘to an audience of non-physicists’ (Wigner, 1964). Wigner's own contributions to measurement theory were discussed by Shimony in a talk at the Wigner centennial conference (Shimony, 2002). The English translation of von Neumann's book was published in 1955.1 The account that follows is based on these sources.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 11, 2010•0 citations
After a survey of the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics and von Neumann's approach to a measurement theory, the measurement theory of Daneri, Loinger and Prosperi is critically reviewed in regard in particular to their aims and assumptions. The review will lead us to see what is still desirable of a physical theory of measurement on quantum mechanical systems.
A critical review of the theory of measurement in quantum mechanics is presented first, which is focused on the recent controversy between the von Neumann-Wigner theory and the ergodic amplification theory. Making the point clear through discussions on the controversy, we then describe a new version of the Machida-Namiki-Araki theory, as a solution of the problem, in which the macroscopic nature of measuring apparatus is explicitly formulated in a continuous direct sum of many Hilbert spaces and the unitarity of S -matrix of elementary interaction processes between object and apparatus systems is maintained. Within the framework of their theory, it is explicitly shown that the reduction of wave packet takes place even in the negative result measurement.
The consistency problem of quantum mechanics may be resolved by regarding any measurement performed on an atomic system as essentially involving an interaction between the atomic system and a macroscopic measuring apparatus and the subsequent behaviour of the apparatus in producing a signal to indicate the result of the measurement. Of central importance in such an approach, therefore, is the study of large quantal systems. Along these lines, two approaches to the consistency problem have been provided; one, by the Italian group of Daneri, Loinger and Prosperi, based on a time-independent ergodic theory of large quantal systems; the other by the Belgian group of George, Prigogine and Rosenfeld, based on a time-dependent theory. In this thesis these two theories are compared and are shown to be equivalent.
The overall purpose of this paper is to clarify the physical meaning and epistemological status of the term ‘measurement’ as used in quantum theory. After a review of the essential logical structure of quantum physics. Part I presents interpretive discussions contrasting the quantal concepts observable and ensemble with their classical ancestors along the lines of Margenau's latency theory. Against this background various popular ideas concerning the nature of quantum measurement are critically surveyed. The analysis reveals that, in addition to internal mathematical difficulties, all the so-called quantum theories of measurement are grounded in unjustifiable, classical presuppositions.
This brief survey analyzes the epistemological implications about the role of observer in the interpretations of Quantum Mechanics. As we know, the goal of most interpretations of quantum mechanics is to avoid the apparent intrusion of the observer into the measurement process. In the same time, there are implicit and hidden assumptions about his role. In fact, most interpretations taking as ontic level one of these fundamental concepts as information, physical law and matter bring us to new problematical questions. We think, that no interpretation of the quantum theory can avoid this intrusion until we do not clarify the nature of observer.
Von Neumann's theory of measurement in Quantum Mechanics was spelled out in the last chapter of his book, which was published in 1932. This book was highly mathematical for its time, and in 1939 London and Bauer provided a simplified account of the measurement theory part of it (London and Bauer, 1939). Von Neumann died in 1957. Thirty years after the publication of von Neumann's book, Wigner published a review containing his views on the shortcomings of von Neumann's theory, but omitting any discussion of its mathematical core, namely von Neumann's analysis of composite systems (Wigner, 1963). He also published a set of lecture notes entitled Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (Wigner, 1983) in which some of his concerns were spelled out in greater detail, and an article addressed ‘to an audience of non-physicists’ (Wigner, 1964). Wigner's own contributions to measurement theory were discussed by Shimony in a talk at the Wigner centennial conference (Shimony, 2002). The English translation of von Neumann's book was published in 1955.1 The account that follows is based on these sources.