Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Do Thermodynamic Entropy and Quantum Non-locality Have a Common Basis?

Jonathan J. Dickau

Published Mar 1, 2010• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Abstract. Both researchers and educators have expressed displeasure with the definition of entropy as a measure of disorder. Instead, it is argued by Leff, Lambert, and others that the increase of entropy can be far more accurately described using terms such as ‘dispersal of energy, ’ ‘spreading and sharing of energy, ’ and ‘spatial and temporal spreading. ’ In decoherence theory, a similar metaphor is used to describe the phenomena involved with quantum non-locality, superposition, and entanglement. Specifically the wavefunction of a quantum entity, such as a sub-atomic particle or photon is not seen to collapse but rather is transferred through interactions to a system and/or its environment. This suggests there may be a common basis for entropy and non-locality. I explore the idea that energy is motive and extensive by nature, and that all its forms of expression involve motion, action, and propagation, which clearly leads to its being spread and shared when unconstrained, among the available microstates of its local system and the larger environment. Thus a single description, focusing on this universal quality of energy, explains both 2 nd Law entropy and quantum non-locality.

Related papers

Exploring the Connections between Energy, Entropy and Quantum Non-locality

Jonathan J. Dickau

The notion that fundamental properties common to all energetic phenomena engender both thermodynamic entropy and quantum non-locality has been explored by the author in two previous papers, and a significant amount of research. This paper summarizes those results, including both ideas from those papers and more recent developments. The idea that entropy pertains to the dispersal – or spreading and sharing – of energy has been widely adopted in Chemistry texts, over the prior notion that entropy reflects disorder. However; the situation is very different in Physics where that question has been sidestepped by the adoption of a model based on information loss. The author believes it is time to re-visit this matter, as the tendency for energy to spread and be shared may be a fundamental property.

Prespacetime journal•Oct 31, 2010•0 citations

Does the Non-Locality of Quantum Phenomena Guarantee the Emergence of Entropy?

Jonathan J. Dickau

Abstract: Quantum-Mechanical objects and phenomena have a different nature, and follow a different set of rules, from their classical counterparts. Two interesting aspects are the superposition of states and the non-locality of objects and phenomena. A third aspect, that gives quantum-mechanical objects which have common roots a non-local connection, is quantum entanglement. This paper takes up the question of whether these three properties of quantum mechanical systems facilitate the action of entropy’s increase, in terms of creating a condition where energy is dispersing, or going from being localized to being more spread out over time. Quantum Mechanics gives each quantum entity the nature of a container or vehicle for both energy and information, some part of which is necessarily non-local. The author feels that quantum-mechanical systems take on aspects of computing engines, in this context. He discusses how the onset of chaos is possible with even the simplest calculational processes, how these processes also result in complexity building, and why both of these dynamics contribute to the character of entropy as observed in ordinary affairs, or with macroscopic systems.

•Sep 1, 2009•1 citation

Universal Foundations of Thermodynamics: Entropy and Energy Beyond Equilibrium and Without Extensivity

Gian Paolo Beretta

Thermodynamics is commonly presented as a theory of macroscopic systems in stable equilibrium, built upon assumptions of extensivity and scaling with system size. In this paper, we present a universal formulation of the elementary foundations of thermodynamics, in which entropy and energy are defined and employed beyond equilibrium and without assuming extensivity. The formulation applies to all systems -- large and small, with many or few particles -- and to all states, whether equilibrium or nonequilibrium, by relying on carefully stated operational definitions and existence principles rather than macroscopic idealizations. Key thermodynamic concepts, including adiabatic availability and available energy, are developed and illustrated using the energy-entropy diagram representation of nonequilibrium states, which provides geometric insight into irreversibility and the limits of work extraction for systems of any size. A substantial part of the paper is devoted to the analysis of entropy transfer in non-work interactions, leading to precise definitions of heat interactions and heat-and-diffusion interactions of central importance in mesoscopic continuum theories of nonequilibrium behavior in simple and complex solids and fluids. As a direct consequence of this analysis, Clausius inequalities and the Clausius statement of the second law are derived in forms explicitly extended to nonequilibrium processes. The resulting framework presents thermodynamics as a universal theory whose concepts apply uniformly to all systems, large and small, and provides a coherent foundation for both teaching and modern applications.

quant-pharXiv:2602.09986•Feb 11, 2026

A Mechanism of the Increase of Entropy in an Isolated Macroscopic System

Yoshihiro Nakato

The law of increase of entropy is one of the most important laws in science but no exact explanation has been given to the origin of it. Statistical thermodynamics only explains it by using Boltzmann’s statistical interpretation together with not sufficiently verified assumptions. This paper shows that the increase of entropy in an isolated macroscopic system can be reasonably explained with no assumption based on quantum mechanics if we take into account that microscopic particles such as electrons and atomic nuclei not only move in space but also have the basic quality of spontaneously spreading into every possible spatial position. The present work allows us to give a plausible definition to the entropy of an isolated system by using the Hamiltonian operator and a wave function of it and provides a firm basis for thermodynamics. It also gives a new physical meaning of entropy effective for further studies of irreversible processes in nature.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jan 8, 2021•1 citation

The Concept of Entropic Time: A Preliminary Discussion

M. P. Vaughan

The deep connection between entropy and information is discussed in terms of both classical and quantum physics. The mechanism of information transfer between systems via entanglement is explored in the context of decoherence theory. The concept of entropic time is then introduced on the basis of information acquisition, which is argued to be effectively irreversible and consistent with both the Second Law of Thermodynamics and our psychological perception of time. This is distinguished from the notion of parametric time, which serves as the temporal parameter for the unitary evolution of a physical state in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. The interpretation of these ideas in terms of both subjective and objective collapse models is also discussed. It is shown that energy is conserved under subjective collapse schemes whereas, in general, under objective collapse it is not. This is consistent with the fact that the latter is inherently non-unitary and that energy conservation arises out of time symmetry in the first place.

arXiv:2011.00499•Nov 1, 2020•1 citation

Quantum Entropy and Energy States

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Shannon’s entropy: -k Sum over i P(i) ln(P(i)) is expressed in terms of P(i) the probability for state i. If entropy exists as a concept separated from the first law of thermodynamics with dWork=0, then it is not clear what set of states i should be taken in quantum mechanics. In classical statistical mechanics, each particle is automatically described by its position and momentum vectors for no internal motion. For example a pure energy eigenstate wavefunction Wn(x) may be written in terms of many different orthonormal mathematical basis sets e.g. Wn(x)= Sum over i bi phi(i)(x) with probabilities bi*bi. Thus one may create many types of entropy expressions using Shannon’s form without any other physical considerations. For example, W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) and one may create Sp which is usually done in the literature. In previous notes we have argued that Sn = Sp(n)+Sx(n). For a particle in a box with infinite potential walls, Sx(n)=Sx. The sum of the two entropies ensures that the parameter L (box size) vanishes so that a quantum adiabatic transformation is isentropic. Thus a consideration other than Shannon’s form has been used to obtain Sn=Sp(n)+Sx for a particle in a box. Furthermore one may argue Shannon’s form even for a pure state based on S=S1+S2 where 1 and 2 represent two systems. A question still remains: Why are Sx and Sp entropies used and not some other set? Furthermore for a system with several energy levels ei one might ask why -Sum over i P(ei)ln(P(ei)) is used as in (1)? In a previous note (2) we considered that Shannon’s form of entropy follows from dE= TdS (dWork=0) with dE=Sum over i ei dP(ei). Furthermore we argued that P(ei) = C(T)exp(-ei/T) is a solution, but so is C(T) exp(-ei/T) exp(Si) where Si=Sx,i + Sp,i for the pure bound state. In other words, specific states related to the physical situation are chosen and entropy constructed from dE=TdS to reflect this. In this note we argue that entropy may be less related to counting arrangements than to considering the issues involved in energy transfers within a system.

•Feb 22, 2022•0 citations
Abstract. Both researchers and educators have expressed displeasure with the definition of entropy as a measure of disorder. Instead, it is argued by Leff, Lambert, and others that the increase of entropy can be far more accurately described using terms such as ‘dispersal of energy, ’ ‘spreading and sharing of energy, ’ and ‘spatial and temporal spreading. ’ In decoherence theory, a similar metaphor is used to describe the phenomena involved with quantum non-locality, superposition, and entanglement. Specifically the wavefunction of a quantum entity, such as a sub-atomic particle or photon is not seen to collapse but rather is transferred through interactions to a system and/or its environment. This suggests there may be a common basis for entropy and non-locality. I explore the idea that energy is motive and extensive by nature, and that all its forms of expression involve motion, action, and propagation, which clearly leads to its being spread and shared when unconstrained, among the available microstates of its local system and the larger environment. Thus a single description, focusing on this universal quality of energy, explains both 2 nd Law entropy and quantum non-locality.
The notion that fundamental properties common to all energetic phenomena engender both thermodynamic entropy and quantum non-locality has been explored by the author in two previous papers, and a significant amount of research. This paper summarizes those results, including both ideas from those papers and more recent developments. The idea that entropy pertains to the dispersal – or spreading and sharing – of energy has been widely adopted in Chemistry texts, over the prior notion that entropy reflects disorder. However; the situation is very different in Physics where that question has been sidestepped by the adoption of a model based on information loss. The author believes it is time to re-visit this matter, as the tendency for energy to spread and be shared may be a fundamental property.
Abstract: Quantum-Mechanical objects and phenomena have a different nature, and follow a different set of rules, from their classical counterparts. Two interesting aspects are the superposition of states and the non-locality of objects and phenomena. A third aspect, that gives quantum-mechanical objects which have common roots a non-local connection, is quantum entanglement. This paper takes up the question of whether these three properties of quantum mechanical systems facilitate the action of entropy’s increase, in terms of creating a condition where energy is dispersing, or going from being localized to being more spread out over time. Quantum Mechanics gives each quantum entity the nature of a container or vehicle for both energy and information, some part of which is necessarily non-local. The author feels that quantum-mechanical systems take on aspects of computing engines, in this context. He discusses how the onset of chaos is possible with even the simplest calculational processes, how these processes also result in complexity building, and why both of these dynamics contribute to the character of entropy as observed in ordinary affairs, or with macroscopic systems.
Thermodynamics is commonly presented as a theory of macroscopic systems in stable equilibrium, built upon assumptions of extensivity and scaling with system size. In this paper, we present a universal formulation of the elementary foundations of thermodynamics, in which entropy and energy are defined and employed beyond equilibrium and without assuming extensivity. The formulation applies to all systems -- large and small, with many or few particles -- and to all states, whether equilibrium or nonequilibrium, by relying on carefully stated operational definitions and existence principles rather than macroscopic idealizations. Key thermodynamic concepts, including adiabatic availability and available energy, are developed and illustrated using the energy-entropy diagram representation of nonequilibrium states, which provides geometric insight into irreversibility and the limits of work extraction for systems of any size. A substantial part of the paper is devoted to the analysis of entropy transfer in non-work interactions, leading to precise definitions of heat interactions and heat-and-diffusion interactions of central importance in mesoscopic continuum theories of nonequilibrium behavior in simple and complex solids and fluids. As a direct consequence of this analysis, Clausius inequalities and the Clausius statement of the second law are derived in forms explicitly extended to nonequilibrium processes. The resulting framework presents thermodynamics as a universal theory whose concepts apply uniformly to all systems, large and small, and provides a coherent foundation for both teaching and modern applications.
The law of increase of entropy is one of the most important laws in science but no exact explanation has been given to the origin of it. Statistical thermodynamics only explains it by using Boltzmann’s statistical interpretation together with not sufficiently verified assumptions. This paper shows that the increase of entropy in an isolated macroscopic system can be reasonably explained with no assumption based on quantum mechanics if we take into account that microscopic particles such as electrons and atomic nuclei not only move in space but also have the basic quality of spontaneously spreading into every possible spatial position. The present work allows us to give a plausible definition to the entropy of an isolated system by using the Hamiltonian operator and a wave function of it and provides a firm basis for thermodynamics. It also gives a new physical meaning of entropy effective for further studies of irreversible processes in nature.
The deep connection between entropy and information is discussed in terms of both classical and quantum physics. The mechanism of information transfer between systems via entanglement is explored in the context of decoherence theory. The concept of entropic time is then introduced on the basis of information acquisition, which is argued to be effectively irreversible and consistent with both the Second Law of Thermodynamics and our psychological perception of time. This is distinguished from the notion of parametric time, which serves as the temporal parameter for the unitary evolution of a physical state in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. The interpretation of these ideas in terms of both subjective and objective collapse models is also discussed. It is shown that energy is conserved under subjective collapse schemes whereas, in general, under objective collapse it is not. This is consistent with the fact that the latter is inherently non-unitary and that energy conservation arises out of time symmetry in the first place.
Shannon’s entropy: -k Sum over i P(i) ln(P(i)) is expressed in terms of P(i) the probability for state i. If entropy exists as a concept separated from the first law of thermodynamics with dWork=0, then it is not clear what set of states i should be taken in quantum mechanics. In classical statistical mechanics, each particle is automatically described by its position and momentum vectors for no internal motion. For example a pure energy eigenstate wavefunction Wn(x) may be written in terms of many different orthonormal mathematical basis sets e.g. Wn(x)= Sum over i bi phi(i)(x) with probabilities bi*bi. Thus one may create many types of entropy expressions using Shannon’s form without any other physical considerations. For example, W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) and one may create Sp which is usually done in the literature. In previous notes we have argued that Sn = Sp(n)+Sx(n). For a particle in a box with infinite potential walls, Sx(n)=Sx. The sum of the two entropies ensures that the parameter L (box size) vanishes so that a quantum adiabatic transformation is isentropic. Thus a consideration other than Shannon’s form has been used to obtain Sn=Sp(n)+Sx for a particle in a box. Furthermore one may argue Shannon’s form even for a pure state based on S=S1+S2 where 1 and 2 represent two systems. A question still remains: Why are Sx and Sp entropies used and not some other set? Furthermore for a system with several energy levels ei one might ask why -Sum over i P(ei)ln(P(ei)) is used as in (1)? In a previous note (2) we considered that Shannon’s form of entropy follows from dE= TdS (dWork=0) with dE=Sum over i ei dP(ei). Furthermore we argued that P(ei) = C(T)exp(-ei/T) is a solution, but so is C(T) exp(-ei/T) exp(Si) where Si=Sx,i + Sp,i for the pure bound state. In other words, specific states related to the physical situation are chosen and entropy constructed from dE=TdS to reflect this. In this note we argue that entropy may be less related to counting arrangements than to considering the issues involved in energy transfers within a system.