Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Which Version of Quantum Mechanics is the Right One

Jiří Souček

Published May 1, 2015• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this article we consider four versions of quantum mechanics (QM), which form four different theories and which have the same experimental consequences (one of them is the standard QM). We consider six fundamental problems as criteria for the evaluation of these theories. The most successful is the modified QM introduced in [1] and described in the axiomatic form in [2], which solves all six problems. The least successful is the standard QM, which does not solve any of considered problems. (It seems that the standard QM is unable to solve any of these problems.) Other two theories solve some of problems and did not solve some other problems. On the base of this result we recommend to abandon the standard QM and to accept the modified QM as the right QM, since both variants have the same experimental content and the differences rest only in theoretical considerations.

Related papers

- The Conceptual Problems of Quantum Mechanics

Alastair I. M. Rae, Jim Napolitano

The previous chapters contain many examples of the successful application of quantum mechanics to the solution of real physical problems. These represent only a small sample of the wide range of experimental results, spanning just about all areas of physics and chemistry and beyond, that have been successfully explained by quantum theory. So far at least, no quantum-mechanical prediction has been experimentally falsified. Despite these successes, however, many scientists have considered the basic conceptual framework of the subject to be unsatisfactory, and repeated attempts have been made to reinterpret quantum mechanics, or even replace it with a different theory whose philosophical and conceptual basis could be considered more acceptable. In the present chapter we shall explain the reasons for this dissatisfaction and outline some of the reinterpretations and alternative approaches that have been devised. Inevitably many of the questions that arise in this area are matters of opinion rather than fact and, for this reason, some physicists consider that they belong more properly to the realm of philosophy than of physics. However, the conceptual basis of quantum mechanics is so fundamental to our whole understanding of the nature of the physical universe that it should surely be important for physicists to understand the nature of the problems involved, if nothing else.1,2 16.1 THE CONCEPTUAL PROBLEMS In this section we outline some of the main areas of difficulty with a view to more detailed discussion later in the chapter.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2015•0 citations

THE MEASUREMENT PROBLEM IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

修三 小川

Since the establishment of quantum mechanics in the 20s of this century, the controversial discussions 1 have ever continued about its basis, that is the measurement problem of quantum mechanics. Strangely those discussions are prevailed mainly in the circle of theoretical group, while the experimental physicists who are directly concerned with the measurement, indifferently to the discussion have performed their study works, showing firmly the validity of quantum theory. This curious affair seems to be stemmed from the situation that the discussions overlooked by basing on what quantum theoretic ground the experimental equipments are installed, its sure operations are examined and the obtained results are explained, etc. In this talk 2 we shall aim to make clear the relation between the experiment and the structure of quantum mechanics, and to present some epistemological considerations on the quantum mechanics.

•Feb 1, 2001•2 citations

Methodological Criteria for the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Paolo Rocchi

Abstract Over a dozen constructions have been proposed to untangle the foundations of quantum mechanics (QM). The authors have spent a lot of energy in establishing formal solutions but, to the best of my knowledge, have not carefully examined the methodological problems that arise before beginning a theoretical construct in QM. This paper argues on the following methodological obstacles: 1. The definitional and computational formulas. 2. The different theories of probability. We have also tried to solve problems 1 and 2, but the complete illustration of this attempt exceeds an article’s length, so this paper is limited to presenting 1 and 2, and discussing the intellectual and formal assumptions that should be necessary to unify the theories of probability.

•Sep 2, 2023•0 citations

Tensorial quantum mechanics

Christian DE RONDE, Raimundo Fernández Mouján, César Massri

In July 1925, exactly one century ago, Werner Heisenberg created Quantum Mechanics (QM) as an invariant-operational formalism by taking as a standpoint the intensive patterns that had been already observed by experimentalists in the lab. One of the few drawbacks of this proposal was the impossibility to conceptualize it in classical terms. Attempting to restore a somewhat classical spatiotemporal representation, six months later, Erwin Schrödinger would present a formalism grounded on a wave equation in configuration space. Taking as a standpoint Schrödinger’s wave mechanics together with the methodological guide of Bohr and logical positivists, Dirac would present in 1930 an axiomatic re-formulation of the theory of quanta that would become known as the “standard” version of QM (SQM). This new version of the theory, that is still today taught in physics classrooms all around the world, would become accepted regardless of its inconsistent narrative as a “recipe” intended (but unable) to predict (binary) measurement outcomes. After pointing out some of the many problems of SQM, in this work we propose to go back to Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics (and also to his understanding of physical theories). We will argue that his matrix mechanics, as an operationally-invariant standpoint, opens the door to a tensorial enlargement of the mathematical formalism capable to account for new phenomena.

Scientific Reports•Apr 2, 2026•0 citations

Formulations of Quantum Mechanics

There have been two different approaches to quantum mechanics. The first follows its historical emergence and begins with the failure of classical mechanics in giving correct explanation to atomic and molecular phenomena such as atomic spectra, black-body radiation and photoelectric effect. In this way one appreciates the necessity of replacing the fundamental classical mechanical equations by the Schroedinger equation in wave mechanics leading to quantization of energy. In the second approach quantum mechanics is treated as a new subject with its own set of experimentally justifiable postulates. We follow this second approach.

World Scientific series in contemporary chemical physics•Jul 1, 1996•0 citations

The Restoration of Locality: the Axiomatic Formulation of the Modified Quantum Mechanics

Jiří Souček

From the dichotomy nonlocality vs which is the consequence of Bell Inequalities (BI) we shall choose the non-realism. We shall present here the modified Quantum Mechanics (modQM) in the axiomatic form. ModQM was introduced in [5] and we shall show its non-realism in the description of an internal measurement process. ModQM allows the restoration of locality, since BI cannot be derived in it. In modQM it is possible to solve: the measurement problem, the collapse problem, the problem of a local model for EPR correlations (see[5]). ModQM is a unique explicit realization of non-realism in QM. ModQM should be preferred as an alternative to the standard QM mainly since it restores the locality.

•Mar 1, 2015•2 citations
In this article we consider four versions of quantum mechanics (QM), which form four different theories and which have the same experimental consequences (one of them is the standard QM). We consider six fundamental problems as criteria for the evaluation of these theories. The most successful is the modified QM introduced in [1] and described in the axiomatic form in [2], which solves all six problems. The least successful is the standard QM, which does not solve any of considered problems. (It seems that the standard QM is unable to solve any of these problems.) Other two theories solve some of problems and did not solve some other problems. On the base of this result we recommend to abandon the standard QM and to accept the modified QM as the right QM, since both variants have the same experimental content and the differences rest only in theoretical considerations.
The previous chapters contain many examples of the successful application of quantum mechanics to the solution of real physical problems. These represent only a small sample of the wide range of experimental results, spanning just about all areas of physics and chemistry and beyond, that have been successfully explained by quantum theory. So far at least, no quantum-mechanical prediction has been experimentally falsified. Despite these successes, however, many scientists have considered the basic conceptual framework of the subject to be unsatisfactory, and repeated attempts have been made to reinterpret quantum mechanics, or even replace it with a different theory whose philosophical and conceptual basis could be considered more acceptable. In the present chapter we shall explain the reasons for this dissatisfaction and outline some of the reinterpretations and alternative approaches that have been devised. Inevitably many of the questions that arise in this area are matters of opinion rather than fact and, for this reason, some physicists consider that they belong more properly to the realm of philosophy than of physics. However, the conceptual basis of quantum mechanics is so fundamental to our whole understanding of the nature of the physical universe that it should surely be important for physicists to understand the nature of the problems involved, if nothing else.1,2 16.1 THE CONCEPTUAL PROBLEMS In this section we outline some of the main areas of difficulty with a view to more detailed discussion later in the chapter.
Since the establishment of quantum mechanics in the 20s of this century, the controversial discussions 1 have ever continued about its basis, that is the measurement problem of quantum mechanics. Strangely those discussions are prevailed mainly in the circle of theoretical group, while the experimental physicists who are directly concerned with the measurement, indifferently to the discussion have performed their study works, showing firmly the validity of quantum theory. This curious affair seems to be stemmed from the situation that the discussions overlooked by basing on what quantum theoretic ground the experimental equipments are installed, its sure operations are examined and the obtained results are explained, etc. In this talk 2 we shall aim to make clear the relation between the experiment and the structure of quantum mechanics, and to present some epistemological considerations on the quantum mechanics.
Abstract Over a dozen constructions have been proposed to untangle the foundations of quantum mechanics (QM). The authors have spent a lot of energy in establishing formal solutions but, to the best of my knowledge, have not carefully examined the methodological problems that arise before beginning a theoretical construct in QM. This paper argues on the following methodological obstacles: 1. The definitional and computational formulas. 2. The different theories of probability. We have also tried to solve problems 1 and 2, but the complete illustration of this attempt exceeds an article’s length, so this paper is limited to presenting 1 and 2, and discussing the intellectual and formal assumptions that should be necessary to unify the theories of probability.
In July 1925, exactly one century ago, Werner Heisenberg created Quantum Mechanics (QM) as an invariant-operational formalism by taking as a standpoint the intensive patterns that had been already observed by experimentalists in the lab. One of the few drawbacks of this proposal was the impossibility to conceptualize it in classical terms. Attempting to restore a somewhat classical spatiotemporal representation, six months later, Erwin Schrödinger would present a formalism grounded on a wave equation in configuration space. Taking as a standpoint Schrödinger’s wave mechanics together with the methodological guide of Bohr and logical positivists, Dirac would present in 1930 an axiomatic re-formulation of the theory of quanta that would become known as the “standard” version of QM (SQM). This new version of the theory, that is still today taught in physics classrooms all around the world, would become accepted regardless of its inconsistent narrative as a “recipe” intended (but unable) to predict (binary) measurement outcomes. After pointing out some of the many problems of SQM, in this work we propose to go back to Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics (and also to his understanding of physical theories). We will argue that his matrix mechanics, as an operationally-invariant standpoint, opens the door to a tensorial enlargement of the mathematical formalism capable to account for new phenomena.
There have been two different approaches to quantum mechanics. The first follows its historical emergence and begins with the failure of classical mechanics in giving correct explanation to atomic and molecular phenomena such as atomic spectra, black-body radiation and photoelectric effect. In this way one appreciates the necessity of replacing the fundamental classical mechanical equations by the Schroedinger equation in wave mechanics leading to quantization of energy. In the second approach quantum mechanics is treated as a new subject with its own set of experimentally justifiable postulates. We follow this second approach.
From the dichotomy nonlocality vs which is the consequence of Bell Inequalities (BI) we shall choose the non-realism. We shall present here the modified Quantum Mechanics (modQM) in the axiomatic form. ModQM was introduced in [5] and we shall show its non-realism in the description of an internal measurement process. ModQM allows the restoration of locality, since BI cannot be derived in it. In modQM it is possible to solve: the measurement problem, the collapse problem, the problem of a local model for EPR correlations (see[5]). ModQM is a unique explicit realization of non-realism in QM. ModQM should be preferred as an alternative to the standard QM mainly since it restores the locality.