Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Routledge eBooks

Toward relational reality: from Einstein and Tagore to Gaudiya Vaishnava Vedanta

Partha Ghose

Published Jun 23, 2016• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Reality is a word that carries many meanings and subtlely nuanced concepts. In order to have some reliable understanding of what Einstein and Tagore could have meant when they talked about reality, it is necessary to glean their conceptions from a broad survey of their writings and utterances over many years. Tagore's view on reality was strongly epistemological in character. He was by no means an orthodox idealist, as he is often made out to be. The predominant view is that quantum reality is fundamentally different from classical reality. The uncontrollable effect of a measurement on a quantum system makes all observed phenomena intrinsically probabilistic in nature, and the distinction between the observer and the observed is blurred. The putative nonlocality of quantum mechanics is usually inferred from violations of Bell inequalities by entangled quantum states. However, there are many interpretations of quantum mechanics that do away with this controversial postulate, such as Everett's interpretation and its offspring.

DOI
10.4324/9781315543352-11

Related papers

Conceptualizing Reality: The Philosophical Implications of Relative-State Quantum Mechanics and Shankara?s Advaita Vedanta

Eric Haynie

Reality, and the pursuit of understanding it, is a fundamental core shared by both scientific inquiry and religious and spiritual belief. In the science of quantum mechanical theory, there has been a radical shift in the way that we recognize and conceptualize the reality of the world around us. A world once considered determinate and complete at the subatomic and constitutive level is now viewed as essentially probabilistic. Furthermore, the tenets of quantum theory introduced by Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg in their Copenhagen Interpretation assert that world is essentially unknowable in a complete and whole sense. Relative-State quantum mechanical theory, a contemporary topic of philosophical debate, is predicated on an ontology in which the breadth of reality is a unified, superposed wave function. Within the metaphysics of the Advaita Vedanta school of Hindu thought there exists a similar affirmation of fundamental unity. Shankara, the prominent figure in Advaita Vedantic thought, affirms that all has its being in Brahman, the Ultimate Reality. Both relative-state QMT and Shankara?s philosophy entail a dual-hierarchy of truth. Our own experiences and sense have their own truth, but pale in comparison to the truth of reality as it truly is. Each also describes reality in a way that is essentially unknowable through our sensory experience. This project explores the metaphysical claims that each of these philosophies makes. Furthermore, it analyses their intersections as a basis for pursuing a synthesis and reconciliation of science and religion.

•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

MĀYĀ AND MEASUREMENT: UNVEILING REALITY THROUGH VEDANTIC AND QUANTUM LENSES

Samirranjan Adhikari

This article investigates the compelling parallels between the Vedantic doctrine of Māyā—which describes the phenomenal world as an illusory projection obscuring the non-dual reality of Brahman—and foundational principles in quantum mechanics, particularly those related to measurement and the observer effect. Rooted in Advaita Vedānta, Māyā challenges the reliability of sensory experience and posits consciousness as the substratum of existence. Similarly, quantum theory reveals that the act of observation influences the behaviour of physical systems, as exemplified by wavefunction collapse and quantum indeterminacy. Through a comparative philosophical and scientific inquiry, this article examines how both traditions confront the nature of reality, the limitations of empirical knowledge, and the centrality of the observer. The study highlights convergences in ontological and epistemological concerns, suggesting that despite their methodological differences, Vedānta and quantum mechanics collectively invite a more integrated metaphysical framework for understanding reality.

Archives The Journal of the British Records Association•Oct 10, 2020•0 citations

Comparative Analysis of Upanishadic and Modern Quantum Physics Concepts: Exploring Parallels Between Advaita Vedanta and Quantum Physics

Shubhrajyotsna Aithal, Ramanathan Srinivasan

Purpose: The convergence of ancient metaphysical thought and modern scientific inquiry has increasingly drawn attention to the philosophical parallels between Advaita Vedanta, as expounded in the Upanishads, and modern quantum physics. Both systems, despite their distinct methodologies and epistemological foundations, challenge classical notions of reality, duality, and the role of the observer in the universe. This paper explores key parallels, focusing on concepts such as non-duality (Advaita), the observer effect, quantum entanglement, and the nature of consciousness. The Upanishadic idea of Brahman as the ultimate, indivisible reality aligns intriguingly with quantum physics' understanding of non-locality and the interconnectedness of particles. Methodology: In this paper, the exploratory qualitative research method is used. The relevant information is collected using keyword-based search in Google search engine, Google Scholar search engine, and AI-driven GPTs. This information is analysed and interpreted as per the objectives of the paper. Originality/ Values: The observer-dependent nature of quantum measurement resonates with the Upanishadic assertion that reality is shaped by consciousness (Chaitanya). By conducting a comparative analysis, this research aims to bridge the gap between spiritual philosophy and empirical science, offering new perspectives on the nature of existence, perception, and the fabric of reality. Results/Analysis: Ultimately, the convergence of Advaita Vedanta and quantum physics reminds us of the vast depths of reality that lie beyond our everyday perception. It invites us to approach life with humility, openness, and a willingness to embrace the unknown. Type of Paper: Exploratory Research.

Poornaprajna International Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences (PIJBAS)•Mar 31, 2025•1 citation

Einstein and Tagore, Newton and Blake, Everett and Bohr: the dual nature of reality

Anthony Sudbery

There are two broad opposing classes of attitudes to reality (realist vs idealist, material vs mental) with corresponding attitudes to knowledge (objective vs subjective, scientific vs romantic). I argue that these attitudes can be compatible, and that quantum theory requires us to adopt both of them.

arXiv:1205.1479•May 7, 2012•1 citation

The stuff the world is made of: physics and reality

Diederik Aerts

Taking into account the results that we have been obtained during the last decade in the foundations of quantum mechanic we put forward a view on reality that we call the 'creation discovery view'. In this view it is made explicit that a measurement is an act of a macroscopic physical entity on a microphysical entity that entails the creation of new elements of reality as well as the detection of existing elements of reality. Within this view most of the quantum mechanical paradoxes are due to structural shortcomings of the standard quantum theory, which means that our analysis agrees with the claim made in the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paper, namely that standards quantum mechanics is an incomplete theory. This incompleteness is however not due to the absence of hidden variables but to the impossibility for standard quantum mechanics to describe separated quantum entities. Nonlocality appears as a genuine property of nature in our view and makes it necessary to reconsider the role of space in reality. Our proposal for a new interpretation for space makes it possible to put forward an new hypothesis for why it has not been possible to unify quantum mechanics and relativity theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107044•Jul 7, 2001•3 citations

Contextual Realism and the Real Meaning of Quantum Mechanics

François-Igor Pris

I suggest a contextual realist interpretation of Carlo Rovelli’s relational quantum mechanics. The principal point is a correct understanding of the concept of reality and taking into account the categorical distinction between the ideal and the real. Within my interpretation, consciousness of the observer does not play any metaphysical role. The proposed approach can also be understood as a return to the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, corrected within the framework of contextual realism. The contextual realism allows one to get rid of the metaphysical problems encountered by various interpretations of quantum mechanics, including the relational one. A wave function neither literally reflects an “exterior reality”, nor is it merely a predictive mathematical tool. In particular, an entangled wave function can be viewed as the formal cause of quantum correlations whose reality is contextual. The reduction of a wave function is not a real physical process. And there are no autonomous quantum events which would be different from the facts of their representation. The quantum measurement problem results from a confusion between the categories of the ideal and the real. It is dissolved logically. The quantum theory plays the role of a Wittgensteinian rule (norm), “measuring” physical reality within a language game of its application.

International Journal of Philosophy•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations
Reality is a word that carries many meanings and subtlely nuanced concepts. In order to have some reliable understanding of what Einstein and Tagore could have meant when they talked about reality, it is necessary to glean their conceptions from a broad survey of their writings and utterances over many years. Tagore's view on reality was strongly epistemological in character. He was by no means an orthodox idealist, as he is often made out to be. The predominant view is that quantum reality is fundamentally different from classical reality. The uncontrollable effect of a measurement on a quantum system makes all observed phenomena intrinsically probabilistic in nature, and the distinction between the observer and the observed is blurred. The putative nonlocality of quantum mechanics is usually inferred from violations of Bell inequalities by entangled quantum states. However, there are many interpretations of quantum mechanics that do away with this controversial postulate, such as Everett's interpretation and its offspring.
Reality, and the pursuit of understanding it, is a fundamental core shared by both scientific inquiry and religious and spiritual belief. In the science of quantum mechanical theory, there has been a radical shift in the way that we recognize and conceptualize the reality of the world around us. A world once considered determinate and complete at the subatomic and constitutive level is now viewed as essentially probabilistic. Furthermore, the tenets of quantum theory introduced by Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg in their Copenhagen Interpretation assert that world is essentially unknowable in a complete and whole sense. Relative-State quantum mechanical theory, a contemporary topic of philosophical debate, is predicated on an ontology in which the breadth of reality is a unified, superposed wave function. Within the metaphysics of the Advaita Vedanta school of Hindu thought there exists a similar affirmation of fundamental unity. Shankara, the prominent figure in Advaita Vedantic thought, affirms that all has its being in Brahman, the Ultimate Reality. Both relative-state QMT and Shankara?s philosophy entail a dual-hierarchy of truth. Our own experiences and sense have their own truth, but pale in comparison to the truth of reality as it truly is. Each also describes reality in a way that is essentially unknowable through our sensory experience. This project explores the metaphysical claims that each of these philosophies makes. Furthermore, it analyses their intersections as a basis for pursuing a synthesis and reconciliation of science and religion.
This article investigates the compelling parallels between the Vedantic doctrine of Māyā—which describes the phenomenal world as an illusory projection obscuring the non-dual reality of Brahman—and foundational principles in quantum mechanics, particularly those related to measurement and the observer effect. Rooted in Advaita Vedānta, Māyā challenges the reliability of sensory experience and posits consciousness as the substratum of existence. Similarly, quantum theory reveals that the act of observation influences the behaviour of physical systems, as exemplified by wavefunction collapse and quantum indeterminacy. Through a comparative philosophical and scientific inquiry, this article examines how both traditions confront the nature of reality, the limitations of empirical knowledge, and the centrality of the observer. The study highlights convergences in ontological and epistemological concerns, suggesting that despite their methodological differences, Vedānta and quantum mechanics collectively invite a more integrated metaphysical framework for understanding reality.
Purpose: The convergence of ancient metaphysical thought and modern scientific inquiry has increasingly drawn attention to the philosophical parallels between Advaita Vedanta, as expounded in the Upanishads, and modern quantum physics. Both systems, despite their distinct methodologies and epistemological foundations, challenge classical notions of reality, duality, and the role of the observer in the universe. This paper explores key parallels, focusing on concepts such as non-duality (Advaita), the observer effect, quantum entanglement, and the nature of consciousness. The Upanishadic idea of Brahman as the ultimate, indivisible reality aligns intriguingly with quantum physics' understanding of non-locality and the interconnectedness of particles. Methodology: In this paper, the exploratory qualitative research method is used. The relevant information is collected using keyword-based search in Google search engine, Google Scholar search engine, and AI-driven GPTs. This information is analysed and interpreted as per the objectives of the paper. Originality/ Values: The observer-dependent nature of quantum measurement resonates with the Upanishadic assertion that reality is shaped by consciousness (Chaitanya). By conducting a comparative analysis, this research aims to bridge the gap between spiritual philosophy and empirical science, offering new perspectives on the nature of existence, perception, and the fabric of reality. Results/Analysis: Ultimately, the convergence of Advaita Vedanta and quantum physics reminds us of the vast depths of reality that lie beyond our everyday perception. It invites us to approach life with humility, openness, and a willingness to embrace the unknown. Type of Paper: Exploratory Research.
Taking into account the results that we have been obtained during the last decade in the foundations of quantum mechanic we put forward a view on reality that we call the 'creation discovery view'. In this view it is made explicit that a measurement is an act of a macroscopic physical entity on a microphysical entity that entails the creation of new elements of reality as well as the detection of existing elements of reality. Within this view most of the quantum mechanical paradoxes are due to structural shortcomings of the standard quantum theory, which means that our analysis agrees with the claim made in the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paper, namely that standards quantum mechanics is an incomplete theory. This incompleteness is however not due to the absence of hidden variables but to the impossibility for standard quantum mechanics to describe separated quantum entities. Nonlocality appears as a genuine property of nature in our view and makes it necessary to reconsider the role of space in reality. Our proposal for a new interpretation for space makes it possible to put forward an new hypothesis for why it has not been possible to unify quantum mechanics and relativity theory.
I suggest a contextual realist interpretation of Carlo Rovelli’s relational quantum mechanics. The principal point is a correct understanding of the concept of reality and taking into account the categorical distinction between the ideal and the real. Within my interpretation, consciousness of the observer does not play any metaphysical role. The proposed approach can also be understood as a return to the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, corrected within the framework of contextual realism. The contextual realism allows one to get rid of the metaphysical problems encountered by various interpretations of quantum mechanics, including the relational one. A wave function neither literally reflects an “exterior reality”, nor is it merely a predictive mathematical tool. In particular, an entangled wave function can be viewed as the formal cause of quantum correlations whose reality is contextual. The reduction of a wave function is not a real physical process. And there are no autonomous quantum events which would be different from the facts of their representation. The quantum measurement problem results from a confusion between the categories of the ideal and the real. It is dissolved logically. The quantum theory plays the role of a Wittgensteinian rule (norm), “measuring” physical reality within a language game of its application.