Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics of Particles and Nuclei Letters

Does a Single Electron Have Wave Properties?

Vadim A. Bednyakov

Published Jul 1, 2021• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract An attempt is made to substantiate the absence of wave properties for a single electron. What is commonly called the corpuscular-wave duality or the wave properties of matter, which appear in the form of a diffraction pattern on the target of certain kind, is a result of the obligatory involvement of a large number of electrons in the diffraction process. In the context of quantum mechanics, a form of the diffraction pattern can be predicted using the rule of adding probability amplitudes, which, in the simplest case, are solutions to the Schrödinger equation for free particles. Therefore, the answer to the question posed in the title sounds something like this: a single electron has no wave properties; however, they become apparent whenever there are many electrons and a suitable target.

DOI
10.1134/s1547477121040038

Related papers

Matter Waves

Bernard d’Espagnat

This chapter discusses the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics in the context of matter. Classical physics identified matter with particles and radiation with "waves." Although this description accounted for a large number of very important facts, it became apparent around the turn of the century that other phenomena, such as blackbody radiation and photoelectric effect, are satisfactorily explained only if radiation is described in terms of particles. Sometime later the hypothesis that, conversely, matter has wave properties was proposed by Louis de Broglie and was confirmed by the Davisson-Germer experiment of electron diffraction. In this experiment and similar ones, an electron beam was passed through a regular lattice (crystal), and subsequently showed the well-known diffraction patterns that are characteristic of waves. These results confirmed the theoretical predictions that a monoenergetic electron beam should be described by a plane wave and that the wave vector k of the wave should be related to the momentum p of an individual electron.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

Duality of Light and Matter

Z. Ficek

Arguments about particles or waves gave way to a recognized need for both particles and waves in the description of radiation. The confusion over particle versus wave properties was resolved by Louis de Broglie. He postulated that since light has a dual wave–particle nature, matter also has this nature. The idea was to perform a diffraction experiment with electrons. An interference pattern was demonstrated not only with electrons, but also with many kinds of material particles like protons and neutrons. However, any attempt to observe an interference pattern with neutral atoms was found difficult by the fact that atoms carried no charge as electrons do and could not penetrate through condensate matter like neutrons. The de Broglie wavelength of an electron in the smallest orbit turns out to be exactly equal to the circumference of the orbit predicted by Bohr. The interpretation of the interference phenomenon becomes more subtle when the light beams are replaced by individual photons or particles.

•Mar 3, 2017•0 citations

Re-understanding of Wave-particle Duality

Chun Wang

The author has worked with high-resolution transmission electron microscope for many years, which provides the most direct evidence of wave-particle duality. This relates to Crookes and J. J. Thomson's cathode rays tubes to determine that electron beams are of particle nature. This also relates to Röntgen's discovery that when an electron beam in the cathode rays tube strikes the glass wall, it produces X-rays with extremely high penetrating power. This behavior is consistent with Maxwell-Lorentz’s electrodynamics that electromagnetic waves must be produced whenever electricity carriers alter their velocity. The wave-particle duality proposed by de Broglie refers to accelerated electron beam, rather than single electron. De Broglie emphasized that the crystallographic diffraction pattern produced by his electron beam was completely consistent with the crystallographic diffraction pattern of von Laue by X-rays, therefore, he proposed that electrons possess wave-particle duality. This is actually the selected area electron diffraction pattern in transmission microscope. It is X-rays, not the waves of the electrons themselves to produce diffraction pattern. He extended this to the wave-particle duality of all matter and light. Schrödinger directly introduced de Broglie's electron beam behavior into electron wave in atoms. It was just at this stage that illogical reasoning occurred, making the quantum theory increasingly difficult to understand.

Engineering Open Access•Jan 6, 2026•0 citations

The wave properties of matter

P. Anthony Cox

This chapter examines the wave properties of matter. Early attempts to extend the quantum ideas to the theory of matter had some limited success, but did not progress very far. Another radical idea was required before a satisfactory theory could be developed. As light has both wave and particle properties, perhaps the same is true of 'ordinary' particles such as electrons. This bold suggestion was made by Louis de Broglie in 1923, and within a few years it had been confirmed experimentally. De Broglie's wave hypothesis formed the basis for Schrödinger's equation, which was found capable of predicting the allowed energy levels in atoms and molecules, and must be regarded as one of the most important mathematical equations of modern science. Before discussing these ideas, the chapter begins by considering the classical mechanics of particles, reviewing some simple concepts that form an essential background to the quantum theory of matter.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 25, 1996•0 citations

Could there be no wave-particle duality, but only waves?

Anne A. Kerslake

Here, the concept of a wave-particle duality is questioned. First, the experimental proofs existing, respectively, for particles and waves are examined. In the case of particles, no experimental evidence can be found which establishes them; it seems that particles have always been taken for granted. In the case of waves, considerable evidence has accumulated with results on diffraction, interference, and self-interference of larger and larger objects. Then an important remark is made concerning the fact that unlike particles, waves are not observation-dependent: waves existed before observation otherwise the patterns of diffraction or interference would not have been appearing; the wave nature does not depend on the making of a measurement, there is no measurement problem for waves. Consequently, since waves are not observation-dependent, if the objects are demonstrated to be waves, they are only waves. This fact, along with some other evidence, disagrees with the current interpretation of the Wheeler-type delayed-choice experiments, where the absence of interference is interpreted as a particle behavior. Finally, recent works regarding the de Broglie‐Bohm theory are presented, which lead to suggest a new wave-only version of this theory. It is concluded that a wave-only view might be worth considering instead of the wave-particle duality view which has prevailed so far.

Physics Essays•Jun 11, 2021•2 citations

The diffraction of electrons in gases

F. L. Arnot

Abstract The new wave mechanics has been eminently successful in correlating and accounting for the large amount of experimental data on the periodic properties of the atom. The applications of the new theory to aperiodic phenomena, though not nearly so numerous, have been attended with no less success; indeed, it is in these experiments on free electrons, in which diffraction patterns similar to those produced by beams of X-rays and light are obtained, that the wave nature of electrons is so clearly and objectively demonstrated. Such diffraction effects have been obtained by a number of investigators by scattering beams of homogeneous electrons in crystals, thin films and by a ruled grating. Similar effects are obtained when electrons are scattered by complex molecules, owing to the symmetrically situated nuclei in the molecular structure, and when α-particles are scattered by helium owing to interference between the waves of the scattered incident particles and recoiling helium nuclei.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Oct 1, 1931•77 citations
Abstract An attempt is made to substantiate the absence of wave properties for a single electron. What is commonly called the corpuscular-wave duality or the wave properties of matter, which appear in the form of a diffraction pattern on the target of certain kind, is a result of the obligatory involvement of a large number of electrons in the diffraction process. In the context of quantum mechanics, a form of the diffraction pattern can be predicted using the rule of adding probability amplitudes, which, in the simplest case, are solutions to the Schrödinger equation for free particles. Therefore, the answer to the question posed in the title sounds something like this: a single electron has no wave properties; however, they become apparent whenever there are many electrons and a suitable target.
This chapter discusses the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics in the context of matter. Classical physics identified matter with particles and radiation with "waves." Although this description accounted for a large number of very important facts, it became apparent around the turn of the century that other phenomena, such as blackbody radiation and photoelectric effect, are satisfactorily explained only if radiation is described in terms of particles. Sometime later the hypothesis that, conversely, matter has wave properties was proposed by Louis de Broglie and was confirmed by the Davisson-Germer experiment of electron diffraction. In this experiment and similar ones, an electron beam was passed through a regular lattice (crystal), and subsequently showed the well-known diffraction patterns that are characteristic of waves. These results confirmed the theoretical predictions that a monoenergetic electron beam should be described by a plane wave and that the wave vector k of the wave should be related to the momentum p of an individual electron.
Arguments about particles or waves gave way to a recognized need for both particles and waves in the description of radiation. The confusion over particle versus wave properties was resolved by Louis de Broglie. He postulated that since light has a dual wave–particle nature, matter also has this nature. The idea was to perform a diffraction experiment with electrons. An interference pattern was demonstrated not only with electrons, but also with many kinds of material particles like protons and neutrons. However, any attempt to observe an interference pattern with neutral atoms was found difficult by the fact that atoms carried no charge as electrons do and could not penetrate through condensate matter like neutrons. The de Broglie wavelength of an electron in the smallest orbit turns out to be exactly equal to the circumference of the orbit predicted by Bohr. The interpretation of the interference phenomenon becomes more subtle when the light beams are replaced by individual photons or particles.
The author has worked with high-resolution transmission electron microscope for many years, which provides the most direct evidence of wave-particle duality. This relates to Crookes and J. J. Thomson's cathode rays tubes to determine that electron beams are of particle nature. This also relates to Röntgen's discovery that when an electron beam in the cathode rays tube strikes the glass wall, it produces X-rays with extremely high penetrating power. This behavior is consistent with Maxwell-Lorentz’s electrodynamics that electromagnetic waves must be produced whenever electricity carriers alter their velocity. The wave-particle duality proposed by de Broglie refers to accelerated electron beam, rather than single electron. De Broglie emphasized that the crystallographic diffraction pattern produced by his electron beam was completely consistent with the crystallographic diffraction pattern of von Laue by X-rays, therefore, he proposed that electrons possess wave-particle duality. This is actually the selected area electron diffraction pattern in transmission microscope. It is X-rays, not the waves of the electrons themselves to produce diffraction pattern. He extended this to the wave-particle duality of all matter and light. Schrödinger directly introduced de Broglie's electron beam behavior into electron wave in atoms. It was just at this stage that illogical reasoning occurred, making the quantum theory increasingly difficult to understand.
This chapter examines the wave properties of matter. Early attempts to extend the quantum ideas to the theory of matter had some limited success, but did not progress very far. Another radical idea was required before a satisfactory theory could be developed. As light has both wave and particle properties, perhaps the same is true of 'ordinary' particles such as electrons. This bold suggestion was made by Louis de Broglie in 1923, and within a few years it had been confirmed experimentally. De Broglie's wave hypothesis formed the basis for Schrödinger's equation, which was found capable of predicting the allowed energy levels in atoms and molecules, and must be regarded as one of the most important mathematical equations of modern science. Before discussing these ideas, the chapter begins by considering the classical mechanics of particles, reviewing some simple concepts that form an essential background to the quantum theory of matter.
Here, the concept of a wave-particle duality is questioned. First, the experimental proofs existing, respectively, for particles and waves are examined. In the case of particles, no experimental evidence can be found which establishes them; it seems that particles have always been taken for granted. In the case of waves, considerable evidence has accumulated with results on diffraction, interference, and self-interference of larger and larger objects. Then an important remark is made concerning the fact that unlike particles, waves are not observation-dependent: waves existed before observation otherwise the patterns of diffraction or interference would not have been appearing; the wave nature does not depend on the making of a measurement, there is no measurement problem for waves. Consequently, since waves are not observation-dependent, if the objects are demonstrated to be waves, they are only waves. This fact, along with some other evidence, disagrees with the current interpretation of the Wheeler-type delayed-choice experiments, where the absence of interference is interpreted as a particle behavior. Finally, recent works regarding the de Broglie‐Bohm theory are presented, which lead to suggest a new wave-only version of this theory. It is concluded that a wave-only view might be worth considering instead of the wave-particle duality view which has prevailed so far.
Abstract The new wave mechanics has been eminently successful in correlating and accounting for the large amount of experimental data on the periodic properties of the atom. The applications of the new theory to aperiodic phenomena, though not nearly so numerous, have been attended with no less success; indeed, it is in these experiments on free electrons, in which diffraction patterns similar to those produced by beams of X-rays and light are obtained, that the wave nature of electrons is so clearly and objectively demonstrated. Such diffraction effects have been obtained by a number of investigators by scattering beams of homogeneous electrons in crystals, thin films and by a ruled grating. Similar effects are obtained when electrons are scattered by complex molecules, owing to the symmetrically situated nuclei in the molecular structure, and when α-particles are scattered by helium owing to interference between the waves of the scattered incident particles and recoiling helium nuclei.