Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

SPIE Conference on Quantum and Nonlinear Optics

Noise limits of polar-interferogram estimation at low light levels

Xin Liu, Mengmeng Zang, Ying Wang, Jun Dai, Wei Wang

Published Oct 8, 2021• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In many applications using light for practical purposes, the accuracy of optical experiment is limited most fundamentally by the finite amount of light utilized in the measurements. Special emphasis should be put on interferometry aimed at measuring the parameters of simple fringe patterns due to the following reasons. First, fringe parameter measurement provides a relatively well defined and tractable example of application of the theory. The desired parameters are easily defined, and methods for their measurement are readily devised based on common sense. Second, fringe parameter measurement is central to all problems involving coherence. The fundamental descriptors of light waves utilized in coherence theory are in fact measurable parameters of fringes. By examining the limitations to fringe parameter measurement, we are actually examining the limitations to the measurability of coherence itself. In this paper, fundamental limitations of estimating the amplitudes and phases of polar-interferograms recorded at low light levels are investigated. By modeling the receiver as a spatial array of photon-counting detectors, results are obtained that permit specification of the minimum number of photoevents required for estimation of fringe parameters to a given accuracy. Both a discrete Fourier-transform estimator and an optimum joint maximum-likelihood estimator are considered to specify the limiting performance of all unbiased estimators in terms of the collected light flux.

DOI
10.1117/12.2599838

Related papers

Performance bounds for high-light-level amplitude and intensity interferometry

Timothy J. Schulz, Neeraj K. Gupta

Amplitude interferometry and intensity interferometry are methods for processing the complex amplitude and the intensity, respectively, of an electromagnetic field to estimate the mutual intensity of the field at two spatial locations. Whereas complex amplitude measurements allow for the direct estimation of the mutual-intensity phase, intensity measurements do not. We consider applications for which the estimation of the magnitude or the squared magnitude of the mutual intensity is adequate, and we provide fundamental limits on the estimation accuracy of any unbiased estimator of the squared magnitude of the mutual intensity from coherent (complex amplitude) or incoherent (intensity) measurements. Our analysis is performed for the high-light-level (classical-noise-limit) case and quantifies the advantages of making the more difficult coherent measurements.

Journal of the Optical Society of America A•Jun 1, 1998•3 citations

Fundamental limits on estimation of polarization properties of quasi-monochromatic light

Jerzy Nowakowski, Anthony Carillo

In this paper we discuss the estimation of parameters describing polarized and partially polarized light when radiation is collected with a receiver consisting of an array of incoherent detectors and registering light levels after passage through an array of retardation plates and analyzers. The results obtained in semiclassical limit include Poisson photon statistics. We obtain fundamental limits on estimation of parameters of interest as a function of the number of photons available, and determine the value of a priori knowledge for achieving the desired estimation accuracy for both signal and background shot noise limited condition. The results presented are applicable to both active and passive systems where measurements of polarization signatures can improve detection and/or discrimination of targets, or when polarization coding is used to transmit information.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 13, 1993•0 citations

New strategies for phase estimation in quantum optics

Yang Gao

One important problem in quantum optics is to resolve an extremely small change of phase shift. The complementarity between photon number and phase sets an ultimate limit, the so-called Heisenberg limit, on the phase measurement sensitivity. The precise phase estimation has many technological applications, such as optical gyroscopes, gravitational wave detection, quantum imaging and sensing. In this thesis I show that the utilization of the parity measurement in the optical interferometry is actually applicable to a wide range of quantum entangled input states. Comparison of the performance of the various quantum states then can be made within such a unified output measurement scheme. Based on such a universal detection scheme, we present a comparison of the phase sensitivity reduction for various quantum states of light in the presence of photon loss. I also provide a simple condition that could be used to check whether an arbitrary state can achieve the Heisenberg limit independently of the detection scheme. It implies that the fidelity between the two output states with zero phase and minimal detectable phase applied respectively should significantly different from unity as the minimal phase shift scaling as 1/N, whereas the average number of input photons N goes to infinity. Next I give several measures to characterize the which-way information in the interference experiment. We define a new distinguishability associated with the fidelity between two density matrices to measure the which-way information. We demonstrate that the changes of mutual entropy as well as the entanglement of formation of the whole system, i.e. the physical system plus the which-way detector can also be used to describe the which-way information. With such quantities, we show that as the fringe visibility of the interference pattern gets larger, the less which-way information is obtained. Finally, I show that coherent light coupled with photon number resolving detectors can provide a super-resolution much below the Rayleigh diffraction limit, with sensitivity no worse than shot-noise in terms of the detected photon power. This scheme would have applications to laser radar, given the difficulty in making entangled states of light, as well as their susceptibility to atmospheric absorption.

Civil War Book Review•May 31, 2010•0 citations

Bayesian estimation of quantum optical phase by photon counting

David Rimmer, William J. Fitzgerald

Single photon count distributions at the outputs of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer are highly dependent on the phase difference between the two arms of the apparatus, so photocount records can be used to estimate an unknown optical phase. Experimental results have shown that phase information can be inferred from the data even at low mean input intensities of ⪅10 photons. Here we consider the optimal Bayesian parameter estimate for the model used by a previous frequentist analysis. In the limit of high input intensity the observation is well-modelled as an intensity measurement of a classical wave in Gaussian measurement noise, however in the low intensity regime this simple model does not apply. It seems that no generally valid closed-form estimator for this problem exists without making the Gaussian approximation. Moreover the 2π radian ambiguity in phase estimates presents a problem in defining cost functions to compare estimator performance, and we consider two reasonable alternatives. We present a numerical study of the experiment along with a novel numerical approach to this problem which out-performs the existing estimators and with a squared error that approaches the Cramer-Rao lower bound previously derived in the literature, in the limit where that bound is valid.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 25, 2004•0 citations

Cramer–Rao Bound for Frequency Estimation of Spectral Interference and Its Shot Noise-Limited Behavior

Chengshuai Li, Yizheng Zhu

Interference frequency estimation is essential in spectral-domain interferometric sensing and imaging, and its performance determines system sensitivity. To date, an objective and practical criterion is still absent for the proper evaluation of fundamental sensitivity limit in a given system. Here, we report the derivation of Cramer-Rao bound (CRB) for unbiased estimators of spectral interference frequency, which imposes a theoretical limit on measurement sensitivity. Results based on a shot noise-limited model are presented. A more complete model, including dark and read noises, is also discussed and its approximate CRB is obtained. Poisson statistics were used in both cases. Asymptotic behaviors and simplified forms of CRB are studied for fringe visibility approaching 0 or 1. Further, we show that the current Fourier transform-based estimation algorithm achieves CRB only for low visibility, but is inferior by as much as √2 times for high visibility. This performance gap may potentially permit a sensitivity gain if better algorithms can be devised. Finally, we introduce a practical means to accurately estimate CRB from experimentally acquired spectral data. The results are verified in both simulation and experiments. Although spectral interference is discussed here, the same derivation can be applied to spatial or temporal interference as well, provided they can be similarly modelled.

IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics•Aug 31, 2016•14 citations

Tutorial: Maximum likelihood estimation in the context of an optical measurement

Anthony Vella

The method of maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) is a widely used statistical approach for estimating the values of one or more unknown parameters of a probabilistic model based on observed data. In this tutorial, I briefly review the mathematical foundations of MLE, then reformulate the problem for the measurement of a spatially-varying optical intensity distribution. In this context, the detection of each individual photon is treated as a random event, the outcome being the photon's location. A typical measurement consists of many detected photons, which accumulate to form a spatial intensity profile. Here, I show a straightforward derivation for the likelihood function and Fisher information matrix (FIM) associated with a measurement of multiple photons incident on a detector comprised of a discrete array of pixels. An estimate for the parameter(s) of interest may then be obtained by maximizing the likelihood function, while the FIM determines the uncertainty of the estimate. To illustrate these concepts, several simple examples are presented for the one- and two-parameter cases, revealing many interesting properties of the MLE formalism, as well as some practical considerations for optical experiments. Throughout these examples, connections are also drawn to optical applications of quantum weak measurements, including off-null ellipsometry and scatterometry.

arXiv:1806.04503•Jun 8, 2018•6 citations
In many applications using light for practical purposes, the accuracy of optical experiment is limited most fundamentally by the finite amount of light utilized in the measurements. Special emphasis should be put on interferometry aimed at measuring the parameters of simple fringe patterns due to the following reasons. First, fringe parameter measurement provides a relatively well defined and tractable example of application of the theory. The desired parameters are easily defined, and methods for their measurement are readily devised based on common sense. Second, fringe parameter measurement is central to all problems involving coherence. The fundamental descriptors of light waves utilized in coherence theory are in fact measurable parameters of fringes. By examining the limitations to fringe parameter measurement, we are actually examining the limitations to the measurability of coherence itself. In this paper, fundamental limitations of estimating the amplitudes and phases of polar-interferograms recorded at low light levels are investigated. By modeling the receiver as a spatial array of photon-counting detectors, results are obtained that permit specification of the minimum number of photoevents required for estimation of fringe parameters to a given accuracy. Both a discrete Fourier-transform estimator and an optimum joint maximum-likelihood estimator are considered to specify the limiting performance of all unbiased estimators in terms of the collected light flux.
Amplitude interferometry and intensity interferometry are methods for processing the complex amplitude and the intensity, respectively, of an electromagnetic field to estimate the mutual intensity of the field at two spatial locations. Whereas complex amplitude measurements allow for the direct estimation of the mutual-intensity phase, intensity measurements do not. We consider applications for which the estimation of the magnitude or the squared magnitude of the mutual intensity is adequate, and we provide fundamental limits on the estimation accuracy of any unbiased estimator of the squared magnitude of the mutual intensity from coherent (complex amplitude) or incoherent (intensity) measurements. Our analysis is performed for the high-light-level (classical-noise-limit) case and quantifies the advantages of making the more difficult coherent measurements.
In this paper we discuss the estimation of parameters describing polarized and partially polarized light when radiation is collected with a receiver consisting of an array of incoherent detectors and registering light levels after passage through an array of retardation plates and analyzers. The results obtained in semiclassical limit include Poisson photon statistics. We obtain fundamental limits on estimation of parameters of interest as a function of the number of photons available, and determine the value of a priori knowledge for achieving the desired estimation accuracy for both signal and background shot noise limited condition. The results presented are applicable to both active and passive systems where measurements of polarization signatures can improve detection and/or discrimination of targets, or when polarization coding is used to transmit information.
One important problem in quantum optics is to resolve an extremely small change of phase shift. The complementarity between photon number and phase sets an ultimate limit, the so-called Heisenberg limit, on the phase measurement sensitivity. The precise phase estimation has many technological applications, such as optical gyroscopes, gravitational wave detection, quantum imaging and sensing. In this thesis I show that the utilization of the parity measurement in the optical interferometry is actually applicable to a wide range of quantum entangled input states. Comparison of the performance of the various quantum states then can be made within such a unified output measurement scheme. Based on such a universal detection scheme, we present a comparison of the phase sensitivity reduction for various quantum states of light in the presence of photon loss. I also provide a simple condition that could be used to check whether an arbitrary state can achieve the Heisenberg limit independently of the detection scheme. It implies that the fidelity between the two output states with zero phase and minimal detectable phase applied respectively should significantly different from unity as the minimal phase shift scaling as 1/N, whereas the average number of input photons N goes to infinity. Next I give several measures to characterize the which-way information in the interference experiment. We define a new distinguishability associated with the fidelity between two density matrices to measure the which-way information. We demonstrate that the changes of mutual entropy as well as the entanglement of formation of the whole system, i.e. the physical system plus the which-way detector can also be used to describe the which-way information. With such quantities, we show that as the fringe visibility of the interference pattern gets larger, the less which-way information is obtained. Finally, I show that coherent light coupled with photon number resolving detectors can provide a super-resolution much below the Rayleigh diffraction limit, with sensitivity no worse than shot-noise in terms of the detected photon power. This scheme would have applications to laser radar, given the difficulty in making entangled states of light, as well as their susceptibility to atmospheric absorption.
Single photon count distributions at the outputs of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer are highly dependent on the phase difference between the two arms of the apparatus, so photocount records can be used to estimate an unknown optical phase. Experimental results have shown that phase information can be inferred from the data even at low mean input intensities of ⪅10 photons. Here we consider the optimal Bayesian parameter estimate for the model used by a previous frequentist analysis. In the limit of high input intensity the observation is well-modelled as an intensity measurement of a classical wave in Gaussian measurement noise, however in the low intensity regime this simple model does not apply. It seems that no generally valid closed-form estimator for this problem exists without making the Gaussian approximation. Moreover the 2π radian ambiguity in phase estimates presents a problem in defining cost functions to compare estimator performance, and we consider two reasonable alternatives. We present a numerical study of the experiment along with a novel numerical approach to this problem which out-performs the existing estimators and with a squared error that approaches the Cramer-Rao lower bound previously derived in the literature, in the limit where that bound is valid.
Interference frequency estimation is essential in spectral-domain interferometric sensing and imaging, and its performance determines system sensitivity. To date, an objective and practical criterion is still absent for the proper evaluation of fundamental sensitivity limit in a given system. Here, we report the derivation of Cramer-Rao bound (CRB) for unbiased estimators of spectral interference frequency, which imposes a theoretical limit on measurement sensitivity. Results based on a shot noise-limited model are presented. A more complete model, including dark and read noises, is also discussed and its approximate CRB is obtained. Poisson statistics were used in both cases. Asymptotic behaviors and simplified forms of CRB are studied for fringe visibility approaching 0 or 1. Further, we show that the current Fourier transform-based estimation algorithm achieves CRB only for low visibility, but is inferior by as much as √2 times for high visibility. This performance gap may potentially permit a sensitivity gain if better algorithms can be devised. Finally, we introduce a practical means to accurately estimate CRB from experimentally acquired spectral data. The results are verified in both simulation and experiments. Although spectral interference is discussed here, the same derivation can be applied to spatial or temporal interference as well, provided they can be similarly modelled.
The method of maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) is a widely used statistical approach for estimating the values of one or more unknown parameters of a probabilistic model based on observed data. In this tutorial, I briefly review the mathematical foundations of MLE, then reformulate the problem for the measurement of a spatially-varying optical intensity distribution. In this context, the detection of each individual photon is treated as a random event, the outcome being the photon's location. A typical measurement consists of many detected photons, which accumulate to form a spatial intensity profile. Here, I show a straightforward derivation for the likelihood function and Fisher information matrix (FIM) associated with a measurement of multiple photons incident on a detector comprised of a discrete array of pixels. An estimate for the parameter(s) of interest may then be obtained by maximizing the likelihood function, while the FIM determines the uncertainty of the estimate. To illustrate these concepts, several simple examples are presented for the one- and two-parameter cases, revealing many interesting properties of the MLE formalism, as well as some practical considerations for optical experiments. Throughout these examples, connections are also drawn to optical applications of quantum weak measurements, including off-null ellipsometry and scatterometry.