Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Molecular Physics

Symmetry and isotropic coherence transfer: II. Multi spin calculations using a Young tableaux formulation

John Listerud, Steffen J. Glaser, Gary P. Drobny

Published Feb 20, 1993• 27 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A general treatment of spin dynamics during coherence transfer is presented as an example of a many-body problem under strong coupling. In a previous paper, coherence transfer by isotropic mixing (IM) between two coupled spins was examined. However, the greatest experimental interest in the technique of IM centers on the transfer of coherence between spins that are not directly coupled. The dynamics of coherence transfer in multiple spin systems are cast in a superoperator formulation, in which diagonalization of the mixing Liouvilian matrix allows derivation of the coherence transfer frequencies from the eigenvalues. Development of a particular basis of the spin density operator space facilitates diagonalization of the strong coupling Liouvillian. This basis is completely reduced with respect to rotation, permutation, and particle number. Treatment of the many-body aspect is based on an approach using the Young tableaux. The exact calculation of the dynamics of coherence transfer in a three spin system is accomplished using the tableaux method, and closed form solutions are compared with results obtained using numerical methods. The degree to which practical coherence transfer pulse sequences deviate from ideal isotropic mixing, and the effect that these deviations have on symmetry-induced selection rules is calculated numerically.

DOI
10.1080/00268979300100431

Related papers

Multiple-spin coherence transfer in linear Ising spin chains and beyond: Numerically optimized pulses and experiments

Manoj Nimbalkar, Robert Zeier, Jorge Luiz Neves +5 more

We study multiple-spin coherence transfers in linear Ising spin chains with nearest-neighbor couplings. These constitute a model for efficient information transfers in future quantum computing devices and for many multidimensional experiments for the assignment of complex spectra in nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. We complement prior analytic techniques for multiple-spin coherence transfers with a systematic numerical study where we obtain strong evidence that a certain analytically motivated family of restricted controls is sufficient for time optimality. In the case of a linear three-spin system, additional evidence suggests that prior analytic pulse sequences using this family of restricted controls are time optimal even for arbitrary local controls. In addition, we compare the pulse sequences for linear Ising spin chains to pulse sequences for more realistic spin systems with additional long-range couplings between nonadjacent spins. We experimentally implement the derived pulse sequences in three- and four-spin systems and demonstrate that they are applicable in realistic settings under relaxation and experimental imperfections---in particular---by deriving broadband pulse sequences which are robust with respect to frequency offsets.

arXiv:1110.5262•Physical Review A•Jan 24, 2012•28 citations

Combined use of translational and spin-rotational invariance for spin systems

Tjark Heitmann, Jürgen Schnack

Exact diagonalization and other numerical studies of quantum spin systems are notoriously limited by the exponential growth of the Hilbert space dimension with system size. A common and well-known practice to reduce this increasing computational effort is to take advantage of the translational symmetry ${C}_{N}$ in periodic systems. This represents a rather simple yet elegant application of the group theoretical symmetry projection operator technique. For isotropic exchange interactions, the spin-rotational symmetry $SU(2)$ can be used, where the Hamiltonian matrix is block structured according to the total spin and magnetization quantum numbers. Rewriting the Heisenberg Hamiltonian in terms of irreducible tensor operators allows for an efficient and highly parallelizable implementation to calculate its matrix elements recursively in the spin-coupling basis. When combining both ${C}_{N}$ and $SU(2)$, mathematically, the symmetry projection technique leads to ready-to-use formulas. However, the evaluation of these formulas is very demanding in both computation time and memory consumption, problems which are said to outweigh the benefits of the symmetry-reduced matrix shape. We show a way to minimize the computational effort for selected systems and present the largest numerically accessible cases.

arXiv:1902.02093•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 2, 2019•24 citations

Theory of scalar relaxation of the second kind. II

Nicholas C. Pyper

A previously presented [1] equation of motion of a reduced density matrix for a system of spins coupled to a second system of spins, the latter being strongly relaxed on account of their coupling to a thermal reservoir, is rederived without recourse to coarse-grained methods. It is shown that the procedure developed here, in contrast to the earlier approach [1], can be extended to corrections of fourth and higher orders in the strength of the coupling between the two groups of spins. The fourth-order terms are presented and applied to the 2A2B3X spin system, the expression derived being compared, for the first-order limit, with the result of an exact calculation. It is shown that the approach [1] becomes invalid in cases for which there is more than one eigenoperator of the Liouville operator appropriate to the rapidly relaxing spins whose eigenvalues are zero or very small. This is shown to occur when the rapidly relaxing group of spins possesses nuclear permutation symmetry and the relaxation of different spins in this group is strongly correlated. An equation of motion of the density matrix is derived for such cases and applied to the 2A3X3Y spin system.

Molecular Physics•Jan 1, 1971•17 citations

Density Operators and Matrices

The density matrix is a very convenient way to do calculations for a large number of spin systems and is developed from the fundamental ideas of quantum mechanics. The idea of pure and mixed states is introduced and used to develop an expression for the single-spin density matrix as it applies to NMR spectroscopy. Multiple-spin density matrices are produced by using the outer product of single-spin matrices and their commutation properties are examined. A very useful form of the scalar coupling density operator is developed and used, along with the chemical shift operator, to calculate the spectrum of a weakly coupled two-spin system. The density operator of spin-1 is explored briefly. Density matrix calculations in perturbed systems are investigated in preparation for relaxation calculations. Strong coupling is discussed and compared to the weak coupling approximation, using the full scalar coupling Hamiltonian and matrix diagonalization techniques.

Royal Society of Chemistry eBooks•Sep 12, 2025•0 citations

Multiple-quantum dynamics in NMR: A directed walk through Liouville space

Michael G. Munowitz, Alexander Pines, Michael Mehring

An approach to spin dynamics in systems with many degrees of freedom, based on a recognition of the constraints common to all large systems, is developed and used to study the excitation of multiple-quantum coherence under a nonsecular dipolar Hamiltonian. The exact equation of motion is replaced by a set of coupled rate equations whose exponential solutions reflect the severe damping expected when many closely spaced frequency components are superposed. In this model the evolution of multiple-quantum coherence under any bilinear Hamiltonian is treated as a succession of discrete hops in Liouville space, with each hop taking the system from a K-spin/n-quantum mode to a K′-spin/n′-quantum mode. In particular, for a pure double-quantum Hamiltonian the selection rules are ΔK=±1 and Δn=±2. The rate for each move depends on the number of Liouville states at the origin and destination, and on the total number of spins present. All rates are scaled uniformly by a factor dependent on the properties of the material, such as the dipolar linewidth, but otherwise the behavior predicted is universal for all sufficiently complicated systems. Results derived by this generic approach are compared to existing multiple-quantum data obtained from solids and liquid crystals.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 15, 1987•111 citations

Visualization of dynamics in coupled multi-spin systems

Jingyan Xu, Dmitry Budker, Danila A. Barskiy

Since the dawn of quantum mechanics, ways to visualize spins and their interactions have attracted the attention of researchers and philosophers of science. In this work we present a generalized measurement-based 3D-visualization approach for describing dynamics in strongly coupled spin ensembles. The approach brings together angular momentum probability surfaces (AMPS), Husimi Q functions, and DROPS (discrete representations of operators for spin systems) and finds particular utility when the total angular momentum basis is used for describing Hamiltonians. We show that, depending on the choice of a generalized measurement operator, the plotted surfaces either represent probabilities of finding the maximal projection of an angular momentum along any direction in space or represent measurable coherences between the states with different total angular momenta. Such effects are difficult to grasp by looking at (time-dependent) numerical values of density-matrix elements. The approach is complete in a sense that there is one-to-one correspondence between the plotted surfaces and the density matrix. Three examples of nuclear spin dynamics in two-spin systems are visualized: (i) a zero- to ultralow-field (ZULF) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiment in the presence of a magnetic field applied perpendicularly to the sensitive axis of the detector, (ii) interplay between chemical exchange and spin dynamics during high-field signal amplification by reversible exchange (SABRE), and (iii) a high-field spin-lock-induced crossing (SLIC) sequence, with the initial state being the singlet state between two spins. The presented visualization technique facilitates intuitive understanding of spin dynamics during complex experiments as exemplified here by the considered cases. Temporal sequences (“the movies”) of such surfaces show phenomena like interconversion of spin order between the coupled spins and are particularly relevant in ZULF NMR.

Magnetic Resonance•Aug 9, 2022•5 citations
A general treatment of spin dynamics during coherence transfer is presented as an example of a many-body problem under strong coupling. In a previous paper, coherence transfer by isotropic mixing (IM) between two coupled spins was examined. However, the greatest experimental interest in the technique of IM centers on the transfer of coherence between spins that are not directly coupled. The dynamics of coherence transfer in multiple spin systems are cast in a superoperator formulation, in which diagonalization of the mixing Liouvilian matrix allows derivation of the coherence transfer frequencies from the eigenvalues. Development of a particular basis of the spin density operator space facilitates diagonalization of the strong coupling Liouvillian. This basis is completely reduced with respect to rotation, permutation, and particle number. Treatment of the many-body aspect is based on an approach using the Young tableaux. The exact calculation of the dynamics of coherence transfer in a three spin system is accomplished using the tableaux method, and closed form solutions are compared with results obtained using numerical methods. The degree to which practical coherence transfer pulse sequences deviate from ideal isotropic mixing, and the effect that these deviations have on symmetry-induced selection rules is calculated numerically.
We study multiple-spin coherence transfers in linear Ising spin chains with nearest-neighbor couplings. These constitute a model for efficient information transfers in future quantum computing devices and for many multidimensional experiments for the assignment of complex spectra in nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. We complement prior analytic techniques for multiple-spin coherence transfers with a systematic numerical study where we obtain strong evidence that a certain analytically motivated family of restricted controls is sufficient for time optimality. In the case of a linear three-spin system, additional evidence suggests that prior analytic pulse sequences using this family of restricted controls are time optimal even for arbitrary local controls. In addition, we compare the pulse sequences for linear Ising spin chains to pulse sequences for more realistic spin systems with additional long-range couplings between nonadjacent spins. We experimentally implement the derived pulse sequences in three- and four-spin systems and demonstrate that they are applicable in realistic settings under relaxation and experimental imperfections---in particular---by deriving broadband pulse sequences which are robust with respect to frequency offsets.
Exact diagonalization and other numerical studies of quantum spin systems are notoriously limited by the exponential growth of the Hilbert space dimension with system size. A common and well-known practice to reduce this increasing computational effort is to take advantage of the translational symmetry CN{C}_{N}CN​ in periodic systems. This represents a rather simple yet elegant application of the group theoretical symmetry projection operator technique. For isotropic exchange interactions, the spin-rotational symmetry SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) can be used, where the Hamiltonian matrix is block structured according to the total spin and magnetization quantum numbers. Rewriting the Heisenberg Hamiltonian in terms of irreducible tensor operators allows for an efficient and highly parallelizable implementation to calculate its matrix elements recursively in the spin-coupling basis. When combining both CN{C}_{N}CN​ and SU(2)SU(2)SU(2), mathematically, the symmetry projection technique leads to ready-to-use formulas. However, the evaluation of these formulas is very demanding in both computation time and memory consumption, problems which are said to outweigh the benefits of the symmetry-reduced matrix shape. We show a way to minimize the computational effort for selected systems and present the largest numerically accessible cases.
A previously presented [1] equation of motion of a reduced density matrix for a system of spins coupled to a second system of spins, the latter being strongly relaxed on account of their coupling to a thermal reservoir, is rederived without recourse to coarse-grained methods. It is shown that the procedure developed here, in contrast to the earlier approach [1], can be extended to corrections of fourth and higher orders in the strength of the coupling between the two groups of spins. The fourth-order terms are presented and applied to the 2A2B3X spin system, the expression derived being compared, for the first-order limit, with the result of an exact calculation. It is shown that the approach [1] becomes invalid in cases for which there is more than one eigenoperator of the Liouville operator appropriate to the rapidly relaxing spins whose eigenvalues are zero or very small. This is shown to occur when the rapidly relaxing group of spins possesses nuclear permutation symmetry and the relaxation of different spins in this group is strongly correlated. An equation of motion of the density matrix is derived for such cases and applied to the 2A3X3Y spin system.
The density matrix is a very convenient way to do calculations for a large number of spin systems and is developed from the fundamental ideas of quantum mechanics. The idea of pure and mixed states is introduced and used to develop an expression for the single-spin density matrix as it applies to NMR spectroscopy. Multiple-spin density matrices are produced by using the outer product of single-spin matrices and their commutation properties are examined. A very useful form of the scalar coupling density operator is developed and used, along with the chemical shift operator, to calculate the spectrum of a weakly coupled two-spin system. The density operator of spin-1 is explored briefly. Density matrix calculations in perturbed systems are investigated in preparation for relaxation calculations. Strong coupling is discussed and compared to the weak coupling approximation, using the full scalar coupling Hamiltonian and matrix diagonalization techniques.
An approach to spin dynamics in systems with many degrees of freedom, based on a recognition of the constraints common to all large systems, is developed and used to study the excitation of multiple-quantum coherence under a nonsecular dipolar Hamiltonian. The exact equation of motion is replaced by a set of coupled rate equations whose exponential solutions reflect the severe damping expected when many closely spaced frequency components are superposed. In this model the evolution of multiple-quantum coherence under any bilinear Hamiltonian is treated as a succession of discrete hops in Liouville space, with each hop taking the system from a K-spin/n-quantum mode to a K′-spin/n′-quantum mode. In particular, for a pure double-quantum Hamiltonian the selection rules are ΔK=±1 and Δn=±2. The rate for each move depends on the number of Liouville states at the origin and destination, and on the total number of spins present. All rates are scaled uniformly by a factor dependent on the properties of the material, such as the dipolar linewidth, but otherwise the behavior predicted is universal for all sufficiently complicated systems. Results derived by this generic approach are compared to existing multiple-quantum data obtained from solids and liquid crystals.
Since the dawn of quantum mechanics, ways to visualize spins and their interactions have attracted the attention of researchers and philosophers of science. In this work we present a generalized measurement-based 3D-visualization approach for describing dynamics in strongly coupled spin ensembles. The approach brings together angular momentum probability surfaces (AMPS), Husimi Q functions, and DROPS (discrete representations of operators for spin systems) and finds particular utility when the total angular momentum basis is used for describing Hamiltonians. We show that, depending on the choice of a generalized measurement operator, the plotted surfaces either represent probabilities of finding the maximal projection of an angular momentum along any direction in space or represent measurable coherences between the states with different total angular momenta. Such effects are difficult to grasp by looking at (time-dependent) numerical values of density-matrix elements. The approach is complete in a sense that there is one-to-one correspondence between the plotted surfaces and the density matrix. Three examples of nuclear spin dynamics in two-spin systems are visualized: (i) a zero- to ultralow-field (ZULF) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiment in the presence of a magnetic field applied perpendicularly to the sensitive axis of the detector, (ii) interplay between chemical exchange and spin dynamics during high-field signal amplification by reversible exchange (SABRE), and (iii) a high-field spin-lock-induced crossing (SLIC) sequence, with the initial state being the singlet state between two spins. The presented visualization technique facilitates intuitive understanding of spin dynamics during complex experiments as exemplified here by the considered cases. Temporal sequences (“the movies”) of such surfaces show phenomena like interconversion of spin order between the coupled spins and are particularly relevant in ZULF NMR.