Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Modern Physics B

Quantization of the momentum of an electromagnetic field in atoms and selection rules for optical transitions

S. A. Pyroha

Published Sep 6, 2021• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The existing methods for calculating the energy of stationary states relate it to the energy of the electron, considering it negative in the atom. Formally, choosing a point that corresponds to zero potential energy you can assign a negative value to the electron energy. However, this approach does not answer many other questions, for example, the actual value of the energy of stationary states is unknown, but only the difference in energies between stationary states is known; the concept of “minimum energy of the system” loses its meaning (choosing the origin of the energy reference, we replace the minimum with the maximum, or vice versa); the physical reason for the stability of stationary states is not clear; it is impossible to reveal the physical reason for the introduction of selection rules, since the Heisenberg uncertainty relations exclude the analysis of the transition mechanism, replacing it with the concept of a “quantum leap”. Let us show that the energy of stationary states is the energy of a spherical capacitor, the covers of which are spheres whose radii are equal to the radius of the nuclear and corresponding stationary state. The energy of the ground state in the hydrogen atom is 0.8563997 MeV. The presence of charges and a magnetic field presupposes the circulation of energy in the volume of the atom (the Poynting vector is not zero). Revealed quantization of the angular momentum of the electromagnetic field in stationary states is [Formula: see text]. The change in the angular momentum of the electromagnetic field during transitions between stationary states in atoms removes the physical grounds for introducing selection rules. The analysis shows that the Heisenberg uncertainty relations are not universal, and their application in each specific case must be justified.

DOI
10.1142/s0217979221502672

Related papers

Circulation of electromagnetic energy in atoms: Poynting’s vector

S. A. Pyroha

This paper proposes a fundamentally new approach to the study of stationary states in atoms, which is based on the analysis of the energy of electric and magnetic fields. The circulation of the electromagnetic field in the stationary states of the atom was discovered and the mechanism of optical transitions due to the continuous change of the circulating energy was clarified. The difference between circulating energy flows in the initial and final states is emitted (or absorbed) in the form of a quantum of light. A universal relation for determining the lifetime of excited states is proposed.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Mar 11, 2023•1 citation

Hydrogen and Hydrogenic Ions

Christopher W. Churchill

The energy structures and transition energies of single-electron atoms and ions are presented. Five Nobel Prizes in Physics were awarded for the theories discussed in this chapter. We first review the Bohr model, which was based on quantized angular momentum and classical circular orbits. The wave model of Schrödinger followed, in which spherical boundary conditions quantized polar and azimuthal standing waves. The energies were identical to Bohr’s, but transition selection rules dictated the change in angular momentum of the system during absorption and emission. Dirac incorporated electron spin and relativistic energies, resulting in energy shifts and fine structure splitting of the energy levels for non-zero angular momentum states. Feynman and Swinger incorporated quantization of the electric vector potential. This physics broke energy degeneracies in the Dirac model and correctly predicted the famous Lamb shift. In this chapter, each of these models are described in detail. The final full characterization of the energy levels and transitions are presented. The chapter ends with a discussion on isotope shifting and transitions to the continuum (ionization/recombination).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 17, 2025•0 citations

Spin and uncertainty in the interpretation of quantum mechanics

David Hestenes

A rigorous derivation of the Schrödinger theory from the Pauli (or Dirac) theory implies that the Schrödinger equation describes an electron in an eigenstate of spin. Furthermore, the ground-state kinetic energy is completely determined by the electron spin density. This can be explained by interpreting the spin as an orbital angular momentum, which is necessarily accompanied by a kinetic energy. Thus, the spin is a zero-point angular momentum associated with the zero-point energy of the electron. Since the dispersion in electron momentum is determined by the zero-point energy, the Heisenberg uncertainty relations for an electron can be interpreted as a property of the electronspin motion. The kinetic interpretation of spin and the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics can be jointly sustained by regarding the electron as a point particle. It follows that stationary electron states are sources of fluctuating electric fields. There is reason to believe that these fluctuating fields are responsible for the Van der Waals force and can be identified with electromagnetic vacuum field fluctuations. The kinetic interpretation of spin then implies that the Van der Waals forces are spin dependent. These ideas are not only consistent with the conventional mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics, they provide a more complete and coherent interpretation of many details in the formalism than does the alternative Copenhagen interpretation. They present some difficulties, however, which, if the kinetic interpretation of spin is correct, probably require some modification of quantum electrodynamics to be resolved.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1979•97 citations

Transitions

P. C. W. Davies, David S. Betts

In many practical cases a stationary system is perturbed in some way, inducing it to undergo transitions between the otherwise stationary states. Perhaps the best example concerns the radiative transitions of atomic electrons in which the disturbance of an external electromagnetic field causes the electrons to jump between energy levels, emitting or absorbing photons. Equation is a statement of the classical law of conservation of energy. The stimulated emission and absorption of radiation both have close classical analogues. If a simple harmonic oscillator is driven by a sinusoidal electromagnetic field it can gain or lose energy depending on phase angles. The existence of spontaneous emission implies that all excited states of electrical systems are unstable and will eventually decay to the ground state by photon emission. Quantum systems thus comply with the fundamental principle that physical systems tend to seek out their state of lowest energy and maximum entropy.

Routledge eBooks•Apr 27, 2018•0 citations

The Quantum of Action and Atomic Models

Mituo Taketani, Masayuki Nagasaki

Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2001•0 citations

Quantization as Selection Rather than Eigenvalue Problem

P. Enders

The "quantum equation" should "carry the quantum conditions in itself" (Second Commun., p. 511); 2. There should be a special mathematical method for solving the stationary Schrödinger equation, which accounts for the non-classical character of the quantization problem, ie, which is different from the classical eigenvalue methods for calculating the (eigen)modes of strings, resonators and so on (ibid., p. 513);3. The derivation should uniquely decide, that the energy rather than the frequency values are discretized (ibid., pp.511, 519), since only the former means true quantization, while the latter corresponds to the classical discretization mentioned in requirement 2;4. The use of the classical expressions for the kinetic and potential energies should be justified (Fourth Commun., p. 113).Schrödinger's requirements 1 and 2 mean, that -contrary to the very title of the papersquantization is actually not an eigenvalue problem.For in the latter the discretization is imposed not by the differential equation itself, but by the boundary conditions, and this is the classical discretization for standing waves in organ pipes etc.I will fulfill all four requirements by treating quantization as a selection problem.The number of stationary states of a quantum system is smaller than that of a classical system [6].I will describe, (i), the selection of quantum systems out of the set of all mechanical systems and, (ii), the selection of their stationary states out of the continuum of classical stationary states.Earlier arguing [19][10] is improved and extended in several essential points. Elements of an Eulerian representation of classical mechanics Euler's axiomsLeonhard Euler [20][21][22][23][24][25] was the first to apply the calculus to all areas of mathematics and mechanics of his time, and he developed novel methods, such as the calculus of variations and topology.Moreover, he worked out an axiomatic of mechanics, where only Newton's Law (axiom) 1 concerning the conservation of stationary states is retained as an axiom, while Newton's Laws (axioms) 2 and 3 concerning the change of stationary states are treated as problems to be solved (for a detailed account, see [19][10][45]).This allows for introducing alternative equations of motion without loosing the contact to CM.The existence of stationary states is postulated in the following axioms (as in Newton's axioms, rotatory motion is not considered). Axiom E0: Every body is either resting or moving.This means, that the subsequent axioms E1 and E2 are not independent of each other; they exclude each other and, at once, they are in harmony with each other [22].

InTech eBooks•Apr 3, 2013•3 citations
The existing methods for calculating the energy of stationary states relate it to the energy of the electron, considering it negative in the atom. Formally, choosing a point that corresponds to zero potential energy you can assign a negative value to the electron energy. However, this approach does not answer many other questions, for example, the actual value of the energy of stationary states is unknown, but only the difference in energies between stationary states is known; the concept of “minimum energy of the system” loses its meaning (choosing the origin of the energy reference, we replace the minimum with the maximum, or vice versa); the physical reason for the stability of stationary states is not clear; it is impossible to reveal the physical reason for the introduction of selection rules, since the Heisenberg uncertainty relations exclude the analysis of the transition mechanism, replacing it with the concept of a “quantum leap”. Let us show that the energy of stationary states is the energy of a spherical capacitor, the covers of which are spheres whose radii are equal to the radius of the nuclear and corresponding stationary state. The energy of the ground state in the hydrogen atom is 0.8563997 MeV. The presence of charges and a magnetic field presupposes the circulation of energy in the volume of the atom (the Poynting vector is not zero). Revealed quantization of the angular momentum of the electromagnetic field in stationary states is [Formula: see text]. The change in the angular momentum of the electromagnetic field during transitions between stationary states in atoms removes the physical grounds for introducing selection rules. The analysis shows that the Heisenberg uncertainty relations are not universal, and their application in each specific case must be justified.
This paper proposes a fundamentally new approach to the study of stationary states in atoms, which is based on the analysis of the energy of electric and magnetic fields. The circulation of the electromagnetic field in the stationary states of the atom was discovered and the mechanism of optical transitions due to the continuous change of the circulating energy was clarified. The difference between circulating energy flows in the initial and final states is emitted (or absorbed) in the form of a quantum of light. A universal relation for determining the lifetime of excited states is proposed.
The energy structures and transition energies of single-electron atoms and ions are presented. Five Nobel Prizes in Physics were awarded for the theories discussed in this chapter. We first review the Bohr model, which was based on quantized angular momentum and classical circular orbits. The wave model of Schrödinger followed, in which spherical boundary conditions quantized polar and azimuthal standing waves. The energies were identical to Bohr’s, but transition selection rules dictated the change in angular momentum of the system during absorption and emission. Dirac incorporated electron spin and relativistic energies, resulting in energy shifts and fine structure splitting of the energy levels for non-zero angular momentum states. Feynman and Swinger incorporated quantization of the electric vector potential. This physics broke energy degeneracies in the Dirac model and correctly predicted the famous Lamb shift. In this chapter, each of these models are described in detail. The final full characterization of the energy levels and transitions are presented. The chapter ends with a discussion on isotope shifting and transitions to the continuum (ionization/recombination).
A rigorous derivation of the Schrödinger theory from the Pauli (or Dirac) theory implies that the Schrödinger equation describes an electron in an eigenstate of spin. Furthermore, the ground-state kinetic energy is completely determined by the electron spin density. This can be explained by interpreting the spin as an orbital angular momentum, which is necessarily accompanied by a kinetic energy. Thus, the spin is a zero-point angular momentum associated with the zero-point energy of the electron. Since the dispersion in electron momentum is determined by the zero-point energy, the Heisenberg uncertainty relations for an electron can be interpreted as a property of the electronspin motion. The kinetic interpretation of spin and the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics can be jointly sustained by regarding the electron as a point particle. It follows that stationary electron states are sources of fluctuating electric fields. There is reason to believe that these fluctuating fields are responsible for the Van der Waals force and can be identified with electromagnetic vacuum field fluctuations. The kinetic interpretation of spin then implies that the Van der Waals forces are spin dependent. These ideas are not only consistent with the conventional mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics, they provide a more complete and coherent interpretation of many details in the formalism than does the alternative Copenhagen interpretation. They present some difficulties, however, which, if the kinetic interpretation of spin is correct, probably require some modification of quantum electrodynamics to be resolved.
In many practical cases a stationary system is perturbed in some way, inducing it to undergo transitions between the otherwise stationary states. Perhaps the best example concerns the radiative transitions of atomic electrons in which the disturbance of an external electromagnetic field causes the electrons to jump between energy levels, emitting or absorbing photons. Equation is a statement of the classical law of conservation of energy. The stimulated emission and absorption of radiation both have close classical analogues. If a simple harmonic oscillator is driven by a sinusoidal electromagnetic field it can gain or lose energy depending on phase angles. The existence of spontaneous emission implies that all excited states of electrical systems are unstable and will eventually decay to the ground state by photon emission. Quantum systems thus comply with the fundamental principle that physical systems tend to seek out their state of lowest energy and maximum entropy.
Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.
The "quantum equation" should "carry the quantum conditions in itself" (Second Commun., p. 511); 2. There should be a special mathematical method for solving the stationary Schrödinger equation, which accounts for the non-classical character of the quantization problem, ie, which is different from the classical eigenvalue methods for calculating the (eigen)modes of strings, resonators and so on (ibid., p. 513);3. The derivation should uniquely decide, that the energy rather than the frequency values are discretized (ibid., pp.511, 519), since only the former means true quantization, while the latter corresponds to the classical discretization mentioned in requirement 2;4. The use of the classical expressions for the kinetic and potential energies should be justified (Fourth Commun., p. 113).Schrödinger's requirements 1 and 2 mean, that -contrary to the very title of the papersquantization is actually not an eigenvalue problem.For in the latter the discretization is imposed not by the differential equation itself, but by the boundary conditions, and this is the classical discretization for standing waves in organ pipes etc.I will fulfill all four requirements by treating quantization as a selection problem.The number of stationary states of a quantum system is smaller than that of a classical system [6].I will describe, (i), the selection of quantum systems out of the set of all mechanical systems and, (ii), the selection of their stationary states out of the continuum of classical stationary states.Earlier arguing [19][10] is improved and extended in several essential points. Elements of an Eulerian representation of classical mechanics Euler's axiomsLeonhard Euler [20][21][22][23][24][25] was the first to apply the calculus to all areas of mathematics and mechanics of his time, and he developed novel methods, such as the calculus of variations and topology.Moreover, he worked out an axiomatic of mechanics, where only Newton's Law (axiom) 1 concerning the conservation of stationary states is retained as an axiom, while Newton's Laws (axioms) 2 and 3 concerning the change of stationary states are treated as problems to be solved (for a detailed account, see [19][10][45]).This allows for introducing alternative equations of motion without loosing the contact to CM.The existence of stationary states is postulated in the following axioms (as in Newton's axioms, rotatory motion is not considered). Axiom E0: Every body is either resting or moving.This means, that the subsequent axioms E1 and E2 are not independent of each other; they exclude each other and, at once, they are in harmony with each other [22].