Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Telfor Journal

Reliability testing, noise and error correction of real quantum computing devices

Ilias Galanis, Ilias Κ. Savvas, Andrey V. Chernov, Maria A. Butakova

Published Jan 1, 2021• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

From Pharmacology to Cryptography and from Geology to Astronomy are some of the scientific fields in which Quantum Computing potentially will take off and fly high. Big Quantum Computing vendors invest a large amount of money in improving the hardware and they claim that soon enough a quantum program will be hundreds of thousands of times faster than a typical one we know nowadays. But still the reliability of such systems is the main obstacle. In this work, the reliability of real quantum devices is tested and techniques of noise and error correction are presented while measurement error mitigation is explored. In addition, a well-known string matching algorithm (Bernstein-Vazirani) was applied to the real quantum computing device in order to measure its accuracy and reliability. Simulated environments were also used in order to evaluate the results. The results obtained, even if these were not 100% accurate, are very promising which proves that even these days a quantum computer working side by side with a typical one is reliable and especially when error mitigation techniques are applied.

DOI
10.5937/telfor2101041g

Related papers

Towards reliable quantum computation: mitigation and certification from NISQ to early fault-tolerance

James Alastair Casebourne Mills

The recent pace of experimental progress in quantum technologies suggests we may soon reach a time when quantum devices can be applied to solve problems of practical interest. Despite this, we are still far from being able to abstract away the effects of noise on quantum computation. The reliable execution of computations on current devices remains a significant challenge. This holds true both for computation with noisy physical qubits and for computation using the limited forms of error correction available on early fault-tolerant quantum devices. In this thesis, I propose methods for improving the reliability of quantum devices, as the field transitions from the regime of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices to that of early fault-tolerance. These span the topics of quantum error mitigation, quantum error correction and quantum certification. In the first instance, I propose methods for improving the performance of quantum devices affected by limited amounts of noise. Specifically, I present a method for mitigating the effects of time-dependent noise. This adapts a computational certification protocol called accreditation into a method for postselecting on weaker time-dependent noise behaviours. The method is analytically shown to lead to a provable reduction in errors for the case of depolarising noise, and demonstrated in experiments on superconducting hardware. I also present a method for mitigating the effects of photon loss in photonic quantum devices. Through a combination of analytical and numerical analysis, it is shown that there are wide regimes of photon loss for which this method outperforms postselection, the standard method of handling loss in photonic devices. Additionally, evidence is provided that the method enhances the performance of a quantum machine learning model known as a Quantum Circuit Born Machine in the presence of photon loss. Next, I introduce a framework for certifying the correctness of computations run on encoded logical qubits. This is sensitive to considerably more general forms of noise than is usually considered in quantum error correction. It can be applied to efficiently certify the correctness of quantum computations for large system sizes, beyond the capabilities of methods relying on classical simulation. In numerical experiments, the framework was applied to certify the accuracy of instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuit sampling and Trotterised Hamiltonian simulation. It can be used to efficiently assess whether quantum error mitigation may be usefully applied to a computation, to upper-bound the infidelity of the encoded logical state, and to extend the method of entropy density benchmarking to logical computation. The methods presented in this thesis contribute to the wider effort of building towards reliable quantum computation: both in the sense of reducing the effects of noise on computational output, and in the sense of certifying the correctness of computation beyond the capabilities of classical simulators. Only with reliable quantum computation can the full potential of this technology be realised.

•May 7, 2026•0 citations

Impact of Unreliable Devices on Stability of Quantum Computations

Samudra Dasgupta, Travis S. Humble

Noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices are valuable platforms for testing the tenets of quantum computing, but these devices are susceptible to errors arising from de-coherence, leakage, cross-talk, and other sources of noise. This raises concerns regarding the stability of results when using NISQ devices since strategies for mitigating errors generally require well-characterized and stationary error models. Here, we quantify the reliability of NISQ devices by assessing the necessary conditions for generating stable results within a given tolerance. We use similarity metrics derived from device characterization data to derive and validate bounds on the stability of a 5-qubit implementation of the Bernstein-Vazirani algorithm. Simulation experiments conducted with noise data from IBM washington, spanning January 2022 to April 2023, revealed that the reliability metric fluctuated between 41% and 92%. This variation significantly surpasses the maximum allowable threshold of 2.2% needed for stable outcomes. Consequently, the device proved unreliable for consistently reproducing the statistical mean in the context of the Bernstein-Vazirani circuit.

arXiv:2105.09472•ACM Transactions on Quantum Computing•Jul 29, 2024•50 citations

Constructing and Benchmarking Noise Models for Quantum Computing

Tom Weber

Context: The main obstacle of quantum computing on its way to scalability is the noisy nature of current hardware. Various types of errors lead to incorrect computational results,and measures such as quantum error mitigation are needed to counteract these errors. Many error mitigation techniques require a thorough understanding of the noise and its impact on computations. Therefore, accurate noise models are indispensable to facilitate meaningful quantum computing in the near future. They also enable realistic simulations of quantum devices. Since these devices are currently limited and quantum computing is expensive, researchers typically rely on simulations for testing their algorithms.Objective: In this thesis, we aim to construct a realistic noise model for quantum computing and optimise its model parameters. The model construction should build on the underlying physical processes, and the number of parameters should scale well with the system size. We also address the evaluation and comparison of different noise models by benchmarks using quantum circuits specific to real-world applications. Finally, we aim to develop useful graphical representations of noise models based on the existing quantum circuit model.Method: We present a benchmarking framework for quantum computing noise models and evaluate it based on benchmarking quality attributes from the literature. Moreover, we construct a quantum computing noise model and develop a training procedure for its parameters. We analyse the parameters of the trained noise model and the impact ofdifferent types of errors on computations. We benchmark the noise model with the above approach and compare it to a noise model provided by IBM’s software development kit Qiskit. Finally, we develop an extension of the quantum circuit model to represent noise channels.Result: The benchmarks performed in this thesis show that our noise model predicts noisy hardware behaviour of IBM’s ibmq_manila quantum device equally well as the Qiskit model, if not better, based on quantum circuits commonly used for variational quantum algorithms. Within the trained noise model, readout error has the most detrimental impact on computations. Our benchmarking approach satisfies relevant quality criteria by choosing suitable quantum circuits and objective functions to compare model predictionsto hardware data. Moreover, the quantum circuit model can be extended meaningfully by noise channels.Conclusion: Our benchmarking approach is suitable for evaluating and comparing quantum computing noise models. In future work, volumetric benchmarks should be performed for various noise models and application contexts. The parameter optimisation based on learning with training circuits yields accurate noise models and shows the importance of mitigating measurement error. Different optimisation algorithms and quantum circuits should be explored, and more types of noise should be incorporated into the noise model.

•Jan 12, 2026•0 citations

Advancements in Quantum Error Mitigation Strategies for Reliable Quantum Computing on IBM Simulators

L. Sherin Beevi, P. M. Joe Prathap, Sudhish Reddy D +2 more

We explore the field of quantum computing and specifically address the crucial problem of error reduction in the context of IBM simulators. Although quantum computing is a rapidly developing technology with great potential, its practical applications are severely hindered by its inherent error-proneness. We tackle this problem by introducing new developments in quantum error correction techniques designed for IBM simulators. In contrast to conventional methods that frequently depend on large matrices or pre-established error models; our technique presents a flexible and dynamic approach. By utilizing several variations of a main circuit, in which classically efficient gates are used in place of non-Clifford gates, we are able to discover the best compensation scheme from scratch for actual quantum systems. The suggested method exhibits great flexibility in handling different levels of noise and different kinds of noise, such as spatially and temporally correlated variations. It also effectively reduces errors on IBM quantum hardware as well as precisely emulated imperfect quantum computers. By offering a thorough investigation of sophisticated error mitigation techniques, this research advances the continuing quest for dependable quantum computations and opens up interesting new directions for improving both the accuracy and performance of quantum computing operations carried out on IBM simulators.

International Conference on Emerging Smart Computing and Informatics (ESCI)•Mar 5, 2024•6 citations

Quantum Error Control and Mitigation Strategies

Nathan Shammah

Abstract Quantum error control and mitigation techniques help improve how quantum computers handle errors, making algorithms run more efficiently despite noisy hardware. These strategies work at the software level and are built into programs before they run on quantum machines. Unlike quantum error correction, which actively detects and fixes errors during computation, error mitigation does not use real-time corrections but instead reduces the impact of errors after computations. Error mitigation can also help reduce the extra resources needed for full error correction. This chapter explains how these techniques relate to each other, provides an overview of key error mitigation methods and their limitations, and highlights leading academic and technological players in this field. It also covers current trends, such as integrating error-aware programming, benchmarking performance, and ensuring access to quantum hardware for testing. To advance quantum computing, it is recommended that research ecosystems support specialized centers and contribute to key strategic areas in the field.

Springer eBooks•Dec 1, 2025•1 citation

Towards a layered architecture for error mitigation in quantum computation

José D. Guimarães, Carlos Tavares

In the past few years, the first commercially available quantum computers have emerged, in an early stage of development, the so-called Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. Although these devices are still very prone to errors of different natures, they also have shown to deal successfully with small computational problems. Nowadays, one of the challenges in quantum computation is exactly to be able to show that quantum computers are useful, whereby mitigating the effects of the faulty hardware is pivotal. Recently, a wide range of quantum error mitigation techniques have been proposed and successfully implemented, alternative to quantum error correction codes. Herein, we discuss several types of noise in a quantum computer and techniques available to mitigate them, as well as their limitations and conditions of applicability. We also suggest an hierarchy for them, towards the conception of a layered software framework of error mitigation techniques, and implement some of them in a quantum simulation of the Heisenberg model on an IBM quantum computer, improving the fidelity of the simulation by 2.8x.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Software (QSW)•Jul 1, 2022•4 citations
From Pharmacology to Cryptography and from Geology to Astronomy are some of the scientific fields in which Quantum Computing potentially will take off and fly high. Big Quantum Computing vendors invest a large amount of money in improving the hardware and they claim that soon enough a quantum program will be hundreds of thousands of times faster than a typical one we know nowadays. But still the reliability of such systems is the main obstacle. In this work, the reliability of real quantum devices is tested and techniques of noise and error correction are presented while measurement error mitigation is explored. In addition, a well-known string matching algorithm (Bernstein-Vazirani) was applied to the real quantum computing device in order to measure its accuracy and reliability. Simulated environments were also used in order to evaluate the results. The results obtained, even if these were not 100% accurate, are very promising which proves that even these days a quantum computer working side by side with a typical one is reliable and especially when error mitigation techniques are applied.
The recent pace of experimental progress in quantum technologies suggests we may soon reach a time when quantum devices can be applied to solve problems of practical interest. Despite this, we are still far from being able to abstract away the effects of noise on quantum computation. The reliable execution of computations on current devices remains a significant challenge. This holds true both for computation with noisy physical qubits and for computation using the limited forms of error correction available on early fault-tolerant quantum devices. In this thesis, I propose methods for improving the reliability of quantum devices, as the field transitions from the regime of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices to that of early fault-tolerance. These span the topics of quantum error mitigation, quantum error correction and quantum certification. In the first instance, I propose methods for improving the performance of quantum devices affected by limited amounts of noise. Specifically, I present a method for mitigating the effects of time-dependent noise. This adapts a computational certification protocol called accreditation into a method for postselecting on weaker time-dependent noise behaviours. The method is analytically shown to lead to a provable reduction in errors for the case of depolarising noise, and demonstrated in experiments on superconducting hardware. I also present a method for mitigating the effects of photon loss in photonic quantum devices. Through a combination of analytical and numerical analysis, it is shown that there are wide regimes of photon loss for which this method outperforms postselection, the standard method of handling loss in photonic devices. Additionally, evidence is provided that the method enhances the performance of a quantum machine learning model known as a Quantum Circuit Born Machine in the presence of photon loss. Next, I introduce a framework for certifying the correctness of computations run on encoded logical qubits. This is sensitive to considerably more general forms of noise than is usually considered in quantum error correction. It can be applied to efficiently certify the correctness of quantum computations for large system sizes, beyond the capabilities of methods relying on classical simulation. In numerical experiments, the framework was applied to certify the accuracy of instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuit sampling and Trotterised Hamiltonian simulation. It can be used to efficiently assess whether quantum error mitigation may be usefully applied to a computation, to upper-bound the infidelity of the encoded logical state, and to extend the method of entropy density benchmarking to logical computation. The methods presented in this thesis contribute to the wider effort of building towards reliable quantum computation: both in the sense of reducing the effects of noise on computational output, and in the sense of certifying the correctness of computation beyond the capabilities of classical simulators. Only with reliable quantum computation can the full potential of this technology be realised.
Noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices are valuable platforms for testing the tenets of quantum computing, but these devices are susceptible to errors arising from de-coherence, leakage, cross-talk, and other sources of noise. This raises concerns regarding the stability of results when using NISQ devices since strategies for mitigating errors generally require well-characterized and stationary error models. Here, we quantify the reliability of NISQ devices by assessing the necessary conditions for generating stable results within a given tolerance. We use similarity metrics derived from device characterization data to derive and validate bounds on the stability of a 5-qubit implementation of the Bernstein-Vazirani algorithm. Simulation experiments conducted with noise data from IBM washington, spanning January 2022 to April 2023, revealed that the reliability metric fluctuated between 41% and 92%. This variation significantly surpasses the maximum allowable threshold of 2.2% needed for stable outcomes. Consequently, the device proved unreliable for consistently reproducing the statistical mean in the context of the Bernstein-Vazirani circuit.
Context: The main obstacle of quantum computing on its way to scalability is the noisy nature of current hardware. Various types of errors lead to incorrect computational results,and measures such as quantum error mitigation are needed to counteract these errors. Many error mitigation techniques require a thorough understanding of the noise and its impact on computations. Therefore, accurate noise models are indispensable to facilitate meaningful quantum computing in the near future. They also enable realistic simulations of quantum devices. Since these devices are currently limited and quantum computing is expensive, researchers typically rely on simulations for testing their algorithms.Objective: In this thesis, we aim to construct a realistic noise model for quantum computing and optimise its model parameters. The model construction should build on the underlying physical processes, and the number of parameters should scale well with the system size. We also address the evaluation and comparison of different noise models by benchmarks using quantum circuits specific to real-world applications. Finally, we aim to develop useful graphical representations of noise models based on the existing quantum circuit model.Method: We present a benchmarking framework for quantum computing noise models and evaluate it based on benchmarking quality attributes from the literature. Moreover, we construct a quantum computing noise model and develop a training procedure for its parameters. We analyse the parameters of the trained noise model and the impact ofdifferent types of errors on computations. We benchmark the noise model with the above approach and compare it to a noise model provided by IBM’s software development kit Qiskit. Finally, we develop an extension of the quantum circuit model to represent noise channels.Result: The benchmarks performed in this thesis show that our noise model predicts noisy hardware behaviour of IBM’s ibmq_manila quantum device equally well as the Qiskit model, if not better, based on quantum circuits commonly used for variational quantum algorithms. Within the trained noise model, readout error has the most detrimental impact on computations. Our benchmarking approach satisfies relevant quality criteria by choosing suitable quantum circuits and objective functions to compare model predictionsto hardware data. Moreover, the quantum circuit model can be extended meaningfully by noise channels.Conclusion: Our benchmarking approach is suitable for evaluating and comparing quantum computing noise models. In future work, volumetric benchmarks should be performed for various noise models and application contexts. The parameter optimisation based on learning with training circuits yields accurate noise models and shows the importance of mitigating measurement error. Different optimisation algorithms and quantum circuits should be explored, and more types of noise should be incorporated into the noise model.
We explore the field of quantum computing and specifically address the crucial problem of error reduction in the context of IBM simulators. Although quantum computing is a rapidly developing technology with great potential, its practical applications are severely hindered by its inherent error-proneness. We tackle this problem by introducing new developments in quantum error correction techniques designed for IBM simulators. In contrast to conventional methods that frequently depend on large matrices or pre-established error models; our technique presents a flexible and dynamic approach. By utilizing several variations of a main circuit, in which classically efficient gates are used in place of non-Clifford gates, we are able to discover the best compensation scheme from scratch for actual quantum systems. The suggested method exhibits great flexibility in handling different levels of noise and different kinds of noise, such as spatially and temporally correlated variations. It also effectively reduces errors on IBM quantum hardware as well as precisely emulated imperfect quantum computers. By offering a thorough investigation of sophisticated error mitigation techniques, this research advances the continuing quest for dependable quantum computations and opens up interesting new directions for improving both the accuracy and performance of quantum computing operations carried out on IBM simulators.
Abstract Quantum error control and mitigation techniques help improve how quantum computers handle errors, making algorithms run more efficiently despite noisy hardware. These strategies work at the software level and are built into programs before they run on quantum machines. Unlike quantum error correction, which actively detects and fixes errors during computation, error mitigation does not use real-time corrections but instead reduces the impact of errors after computations. Error mitigation can also help reduce the extra resources needed for full error correction. This chapter explains how these techniques relate to each other, provides an overview of key error mitigation methods and their limitations, and highlights leading academic and technological players in this field. It also covers current trends, such as integrating error-aware programming, benchmarking performance, and ensuring access to quantum hardware for testing. To advance quantum computing, it is recommended that research ecosystems support specialized centers and contribute to key strategic areas in the field.
In the past few years, the first commercially available quantum computers have emerged, in an early stage of development, the so-called Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. Although these devices are still very prone to errors of different natures, they also have shown to deal successfully with small computational problems. Nowadays, one of the challenges in quantum computation is exactly to be able to show that quantum computers are useful, whereby mitigating the effects of the faulty hardware is pivotal. Recently, a wide range of quantum error mitigation techniques have been proposed and successfully implemented, alternative to quantum error correction codes. Herein, we discuss several types of noise in a quantum computer and techniques available to mitigate them, as well as their limitations and conditions of applicability. We also suggest an hierarchy for them, towards the conception of a layered software framework of error mitigation techniques, and implement some of them in a quantum simulation of the Heisenberg model on an IBM quantum computer, improving the fidelity of the simulation by 2.8x.