Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IntechOpen eBooks

Discretization, the Road to Quantum Computing?

Jesús García López de Lacalle

Published Jul 30, 2021• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The main challenge we face in making quantum computing a reality is error control. For this reason it is necessary to study whether the hypotheses on which the threshold theorem has been proved capture all the characteristics of quantum errors. The extraordinary difficulties that we find to control quantum errors effectively together with the little progress in this endeavor, compared to the enormous effort deployed by the scientific community and by companies and governments, should make us reflect on the road map to quantum computing. In this work we analyze error control in quantum computing and suggest that discrete quantum computing models should be explored. In this sense, we present a concrete model but, above all, we propose that Quantum Physics should be taken one step further, in order to allow discretization of the quantum computing model.

DOI
10.5772/intechopen.98827

Related papers

QUANTUM ERROR CORRECTION AND FAULT-TOLERANT QUANTUM COMPUTING

Frank Gaitan, Ran Li

We review the theories of quantum error correction, and of fault-tolerant quantum computing, and show how these powerful tools are combined to prove the accuracy threshold theorem for a particular error model. One of the theorem's assumptions is the availability of a universal set of unencoded quantum gates whose error probabilities P e fall below a value known as the accuracy threshold P a . For many, P a ~ 10 -4 has become a rough estimate for the threshold so that quantum gates are anticipated to be approaching the accuracies needed for fault-tolerant quantum computing when P e < 10 -4 . We show how controllable quantum interference effects that arise during a type of non-adiabatic rapid passage can be used to produce a universal set of quantum gates whose error probabilities satisfy P e < 10 -4 . We close with a discussion of the current challenges facing an experimental implementation of this approach to reliable universal quantum computation.

•Nov 1, 2009•44 citations

Experimental Quantum Error Correction

Raymond Laflamme

The Achilles' heel of quantum information processors is the fragility of quantum states and processes. Without a method to control imperfection and imprecision of quantum devices, the probability that a quantum computation succeed will decrease exponentially in the number of gates it requires. In the last fifteen years, building on the discovery of quantum error correction, accuracy threshold theorems were proved showing that error can be controlled using a reasonable amount of resources as long as the error rate is smaller than a certain threshold. We thus have a scalable theory describing how to control quantum systems. The next step is to turn this theory into practice. I will give an overview of some of the progress towards the implmentation of quantum error correction around the world with a focus on results since the last Quantum Error Correction conference at USC. I will compare the various achievements and point towards what still need to be done to get robust quantum information processors.

APS•Feb 6, 2008•0 citations

Fault-tolerant quantum computation

Christophe Vuillot

Quantumcomputation is the modern version of Schrödinger’s cat experiment. It is backed up in principle by the theory and thinking about it can make people equally uncomfortable and excited. Besides, its practical realization seems so extremely challenging that some people even doubt it is possible. On the other hand, we are nowadays much closer to realizing quantum computation and in addition, it has much more implications than Schrödinger’s original cat experiment. One of the major difficulties in realizing quantum computation is the inevitable presence of noise in realistic quantum devices which makes the direct realization of quantum computers impossible. In order to protect quantum information and quantum processes against noise, quantum error correction and fault-tolerance have been devised. Although the gap between experiments and the requirements of fault-tolerance is still daunting, the field of quantum error correction and fault-tolerance extends and influences architectural decisions from the hardware to the ideal quantum programs that we want to run. That is why it has the potential to make or break the practicality of quantum computation and a lot of research effort goes into this field. In this thesis we investigate and improve several aspects of fault-tolerant schemes and quantum error correction. We implement an experiment which validates on a small device the usefulness of fault-tolerance for quantum computation. We investigate the advantages of harnessing quantum continuous degrees of freedom present in the lab to protect discrete quantum information in a scalable way. We establish a framework to analyze the fault-tolerant properties of code deformation techniques which are versatile techniques to process quantum information protected by an error correcting code. We also present some novel code deformation techniques with the potential to increase reliability. Finally we define a new class of quantum error correcting codes, quantum pin codes, with built in capabilities for fault-tolerant quantum gates. We give some practical constructions and show some protocols with interesting parameters. The roads towards universal and fault-tolerant quantum computation are still steep but research efforts are pushing in the right directions.

•Dec 16, 2019•2 citations

Quantum Error Correction and Fault Tolerant Quantum Computing

Frank Gaitan

It was once widely believed that quantum computation would never become a reality. However, the discovery of quantum error correction and the proof of the accuracy threshold theorem nearly ten years ago gave rise to extensive development and research aimed at creating a working, scalable quantum computer. Over a decade has passed since this monumental accomplishment yet no book-length pedagogical presentation of this important theory exists. Quantum Error Correction and Fault Tolerant Quantum Computing offers the first full-length exposition on the realization of a theory once thought impossible. It provides in-depth coverage on the most important class of codes discovered to date—quantum stabilizer codes. It brings together the central themes of quantum error correction and fault-tolerant procedures to prove the accuracy threshold theorem for a particular noise error model. The author also includes a derivation of well-known bounds on the parameters of quantum error correcting code. Packed with over 40 real-world problems, 35 field exercises, and 17 worked-out examples, this book is the essential resource for any researcher interested in entering the quantum field as well as for those who want to understand how the unexpected realization of quantum computing is possible.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 19, 2013•97 citations

Quantum Mechanics

Frank Gaitan

In Chapters 2-5 we gave a detailed presentation of the theory of quantum error correction and fault-tolerant quantum computing. The stage is finally set for a proof of the accuracy threshold theorem [2-9]. As pointed out in Chapter 1, this theorem spells out the conditions under which quantum computing can be done reliably using imperfect quantum gates and in the presence of noise. The proof presented in this chapter follows Ref. [6]. Section 6.1 addresses a number of preliminary topics. It explains why a concatenated quantum error correcting code (QECC) should be used to protect the computational data when fault-tolerance is an issue; it states the principal assumptions underlying the threshold calculations presented in Section 6.2; and finally, it closes with a statement of the accuracy threshold theorem. The proof of this theorem is taken up in Section 6.2. For the error model introduced in Section 6.1, the accuracy threshold is calculated for gates in the Clifford group N(Qn), storage registers, and the Toffoli gate. The calculations make explicit use of the recursive structure of a concatenated QECC and the fault-tolerant procedures introduced in Chapter 5. The theorem is proved by showing that all three cases yield non-zero threshold values.

CRC Press eBooks•Feb 7, 2008•0 citations

Level-Reduction and the Quantum Threshold Theorem

Panagiotis Aliferis

Computers have led society to the information age revolutionizing central aspects of our lives from production and communication to education and entertainment. There exist, however, important problems which are intractable with the computers available today and, experience teaches us, will remain so even with the more advanced computers we can envision for tomorrow. Quantum computers promise speedups to some of these important but classically intractable problems. Simulating physical systems, a problem of interest in a diverse range of areas from testing physical theories to understanding chemical reactions, and solving number factoring, a problem at the basis of cryptographic protocols that are used widely today on the internet, are examples of applications for which quantum computers, when built, will offer a great advantage over what is possible with classical computer technology. The construction of a quantum computer of sufficient scale to solve interesting problems is, however, especially challenging. The reason for this is that, by its very nature, operating a quantum computer will require the coherent control of the quantum state of a very large number of particles. Fortunately, the theory of quantum error correction and fault-tolerant quantum computation gives us confidence that such quantum states can be created, can be stored in memory and can also be manipulated provided the quantum computer can be isolated to a sufficient degree from sources of noise. One of the central results in the theory of fault-tolerant quantum computation, the quantum threshold theorem shows that a noisy quantum computer can accurately and efficiently simulate any ideal quantum computation provided that noise is weakly correlated and its strength is below a critical value known as the quantum accuracy threshold. This thesis provides a simpler and more transparent non-inductive proof of this theorem based on the concept of level reduction. This concept is also used in proving the quantum threshold theorem for coherent and leakage noise and for quantum computation by measurements. In addition, the proof provides a methodology which allows us to establish improved rigorous lower bounds on the value of the quantum accuracy threshold.

•Mar 28, 2007•8 citations
The main challenge we face in making quantum computing a reality is error control. For this reason it is necessary to study whether the hypotheses on which the threshold theorem has been proved capture all the characteristics of quantum errors. The extraordinary difficulties that we find to control quantum errors effectively together with the little progress in this endeavor, compared to the enormous effort deployed by the scientific community and by companies and governments, should make us reflect on the road map to quantum computing. In this work we analyze error control in quantum computing and suggest that discrete quantum computing models should be explored. In this sense, we present a concrete model but, above all, we propose that Quantum Physics should be taken one step further, in order to allow discretization of the quantum computing model.
We review the theories of quantum error correction, and of fault-tolerant quantum computing, and show how these powerful tools are combined to prove the accuracy threshold theorem for a particular error model. One of the theorem's assumptions is the availability of a universal set of unencoded quantum gates whose error probabilities P e fall below a value known as the accuracy threshold P a . For many, P a ~ 10 -4 has become a rough estimate for the threshold so that quantum gates are anticipated to be approaching the accuracies needed for fault-tolerant quantum computing when P e < 10 -4 . We show how controllable quantum interference effects that arise during a type of non-adiabatic rapid passage can be used to produce a universal set of quantum gates whose error probabilities satisfy P e < 10 -4 . We close with a discussion of the current challenges facing an experimental implementation of this approach to reliable universal quantum computation.
The Achilles' heel of quantum information processors is the fragility of quantum states and processes. Without a method to control imperfection and imprecision of quantum devices, the probability that a quantum computation succeed will decrease exponentially in the number of gates it requires. In the last fifteen years, building on the discovery of quantum error correction, accuracy threshold theorems were proved showing that error can be controlled using a reasonable amount of resources as long as the error rate is smaller than a certain threshold. We thus have a scalable theory describing how to control quantum systems. The next step is to turn this theory into practice. I will give an overview of some of the progress towards the implmentation of quantum error correction around the world with a focus on results since the last Quantum Error Correction conference at USC. I will compare the various achievements and point towards what still need to be done to get robust quantum information processors.
Quantumcomputation is the modern version of Schrödinger’s cat experiment. It is backed up in principle by the theory and thinking about it can make people equally uncomfortable and excited. Besides, its practical realization seems so extremely challenging that some people even doubt it is possible. On the other hand, we are nowadays much closer to realizing quantum computation and in addition, it has much more implications than Schrödinger’s original cat experiment. One of the major difficulties in realizing quantum computation is the inevitable presence of noise in realistic quantum devices which makes the direct realization of quantum computers impossible. In order to protect quantum information and quantum processes against noise, quantum error correction and fault-tolerance have been devised. Although the gap between experiments and the requirements of fault-tolerance is still daunting, the field of quantum error correction and fault-tolerance extends and influences architectural decisions from the hardware to the ideal quantum programs that we want to run. That is why it has the potential to make or break the practicality of quantum computation and a lot of research effort goes into this field. In this thesis we investigate and improve several aspects of fault-tolerant schemes and quantum error correction. We implement an experiment which validates on a small device the usefulness of fault-tolerance for quantum computation. We investigate the advantages of harnessing quantum continuous degrees of freedom present in the lab to protect discrete quantum information in a scalable way. We establish a framework to analyze the fault-tolerant properties of code deformation techniques which are versatile techniques to process quantum information protected by an error correcting code. We also present some novel code deformation techniques with the potential to increase reliability. Finally we define a new class of quantum error correcting codes, quantum pin codes, with built in capabilities for fault-tolerant quantum gates. We give some practical constructions and show some protocols with interesting parameters. The roads towards universal and fault-tolerant quantum computation are still steep but research efforts are pushing in the right directions.
It was once widely believed that quantum computation would never become a reality. However, the discovery of quantum error correction and the proof of the accuracy threshold theorem nearly ten years ago gave rise to extensive development and research aimed at creating a working, scalable quantum computer. Over a decade has passed since this monumental accomplishment yet no book-length pedagogical presentation of this important theory exists. Quantum Error Correction and Fault Tolerant Quantum Computing offers the first full-length exposition on the realization of a theory once thought impossible. It provides in-depth coverage on the most important class of codes discovered to date—quantum stabilizer codes. It brings together the central themes of quantum error correction and fault-tolerant procedures to prove the accuracy threshold theorem for a particular noise error model. The author also includes a derivation of well-known bounds on the parameters of quantum error correcting code. Packed with over 40 real-world problems, 35 field exercises, and 17 worked-out examples, this book is the essential resource for any researcher interested in entering the quantum field as well as for those who want to understand how the unexpected realization of quantum computing is possible.
In Chapters 2-5 we gave a detailed presentation of the theory of quantum error correction and fault-tolerant quantum computing. The stage is finally set for a proof of the accuracy threshold theorem [2-9]. As pointed out in Chapter 1, this theorem spells out the conditions under which quantum computing can be done reliably using imperfect quantum gates and in the presence of noise. The proof presented in this chapter follows Ref. [6]. Section 6.1 addresses a number of preliminary topics. It explains why a concatenated quantum error correcting code (QECC) should be used to protect the computational data when fault-tolerance is an issue; it states the principal assumptions underlying the threshold calculations presented in Section 6.2; and finally, it closes with a statement of the accuracy threshold theorem. The proof of this theorem is taken up in Section 6.2. For the error model introduced in Section 6.1, the accuracy threshold is calculated for gates in the Clifford group N(Qn), storage registers, and the Toffoli gate. The calculations make explicit use of the recursive structure of a concatenated QECC and the fault-tolerant procedures introduced in Chapter 5. The theorem is proved by showing that all three cases yield non-zero threshold values.
Computers have led society to the information age revolutionizing central aspects of our lives from production and communication to education and entertainment. There exist, however, important problems which are intractable with the computers available today and, experience teaches us, will remain so even with the more advanced computers we can envision for tomorrow. Quantum computers promise speedups to some of these important but classically intractable problems. Simulating physical systems, a problem of interest in a diverse range of areas from testing physical theories to understanding chemical reactions, and solving number factoring, a problem at the basis of cryptographic protocols that are used widely today on the internet, are examples of applications for which quantum computers, when built, will offer a great advantage over what is possible with classical computer technology. The construction of a quantum computer of sufficient scale to solve interesting problems is, however, especially challenging. The reason for this is that, by its very nature, operating a quantum computer will require the coherent control of the quantum state of a very large number of particles. Fortunately, the theory of quantum error correction and fault-tolerant quantum computation gives us confidence that such quantum states can be created, can be stored in memory and can also be manipulated provided the quantum computer can be isolated to a sufficient degree from sources of noise. One of the central results in the theory of fault-tolerant quantum computation, the quantum threshold theorem shows that a noisy quantum computer can accurately and efficiently simulate any ideal quantum computation provided that noise is weakly correlated and its strength is below a critical value known as the quantum accuracy threshold. This thesis provides a simpler and more transparent non-inductive proof of this theorem based on the concept of level reduction. This concept is also used in proving the quantum threshold theorem for coherent and leakage noise and for quantum computation by measurements. In addition, the proof provides a methodology which allows us to establish improved rigorous lower bounds on the value of the quantum accuracy threshold.