Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Conference on Space Optics (ICSO)

How to choose the best QKD network technology: three different satellite based scenarios compared

Manuel Erhard, Armin Hochrainer, Matthias Fink, Johannes Handsteiner, Thomas Herbst, Thomas Scheidl

Published Jun 11, 2021• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum cryptography promises unconditionally secure communication. Today, there exists a vast array of different QKD protocols that claim to offer security. However, looking in more detail, many subtleties lead to different security levels, or in the worst-case to no security at all. Here, we introduce the most crucial QKD security properties, ranging from different attack schemes to actual implementation security considerations. We present three different QKD use-cases with different network topologies: one trusted-node-based scenario (BB84 decoy) and two trusted-node-free (entanglement-based BBM92 and twin-field QKD). Using our, in cooperation with the European Space Agency (ESA), in-house developed simulations package, we simulate all relevant performance parameters, including the expected finite secret-key-rate. Furthermore, we assess all simulated QKD protocols’ applicability to satellite-based QKD networks and identify essential technologies. Interestingly, not the single-photon detection modules are the key drivers in terms of secure-key-rate performance, but the optical sending and receiving telescopes.

DOI
10.1117/12.2599218

Related papers

Satellite QKD developments for secure communications

Agnes Ferenczi, Stefanie Häusler, Davide Orsucci +2 more

Quantum key distribution (QKD), the technology to generate distant secure keys for later usage in secure communication, has become a mature topic since the 1980s. While terrestrial QKD over fiber networks is suitable for short-distance urban networks, QKD via satellites promises to gap the distance requirement on a global scale that limits terrestrial QKD. Satellite QKD requires the exchange of quantum states between a satellite and multiple ground stations. The goal is then to facilitate shared secret keys between the ground stations, which can then be relayed to users near the ground stations. The satellite usually carries the quantum sources as its payload and sends them to the ground station via a downlink. The QKD protocol is heavily influenced by the choice of the quantum source, with typically one of two types: approximate single photon source (such as a weak laser) or an entangled source. Similarly, the ground station must be equipped to receive, measure and process the quantum signals sent by the satellite. Although there are also reverse schemes, where the satellite acts as the receiver and the ground station as the sender, these schemes are less explored due to higher noise in the uplink and less engineering experience. As with any system containing a high heterogeneity, many different implementation schemes lead to a variety of optimized use cases based on different criteria. Satellite QKD carries the further complication that it must be adapted to international standards. In this paper we present different satellite and ground station architectures that lean on the developments in the projects EAGLE-1, QUBE, QuNET, RoGloQuaN, addressing different protocols, sources, satellite sizes and telescope sizes. We also discuss the need for agility and configuration of components in a heterogeneous environment.

SPIE Quantum Technologies for Defence and Security•Oct 29, 2025•2 citations

Quantum Key Distribution in Optical Fiber and FreeSpace Networks: Protocols, Security Analysis, Implementation Challenges, and Emerging Directions

DIWAKAR SHRIVASTAVA, Poonam Singh, GAURAV SINGH +1 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) constitutes one of the most profound practical applications of quantum mechanics, enabling two parties to exchange cryptographic keys whose security is guaranteed by the fundamental laws of physics rather than the assumed computational hardness of mathematical problems. As quantum computing capabilities continue to advance, classical public-key infrastructure faces an existential threat, rendering QKD a critical component of post-quantum secure communication architectures. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of QKD spanning foundational protocols, rigorous security proofs, hardware implementation challenges, deployment experiences across metropolitan fiber networks, and recent satellite-based experiments. We analyze the BB84, E91, B92, SARG04, continuous-variable, measurement-device-independent (MDI-QKD), and twin-field (TF-QKD) protocols in depth, examining their security assumptions, achievable key rates, and practical limitations. Particular attention is given to side-channel vulnerabilities in realistic implementations, decoy-state methods for mitigating photon-number-splitting attacks, and finite-key security analysis. We review key performance benchmarks from commercial systems and discuss integration with classical network infrastructure. The paper concludes by identifying open challenges in quantum repeater development, satellite QKD scalability, and standardization efforts essential for large-scale deployment.

International Journal of Novel Research and Development•Apr 1, 2026•0 citations

Operational performance of finite-key entanglement-based satellite quantum key distribution

Jasminder S. Sidhu, Sarah E. McCarthy, Cameron Paterson +3 more

Establishing information-theoretically secure communication between arbitrary locations on Earth is a central goal of quantum networking, for which space-based distribution of quantum entanglement is a leading approach. Modelling and analysis of the performance of satellite entanglement pair distribution is therefore important for the architecture and design of future constellations and space systems. However, entanglement-based quantum key distribution in the absence of quantum repeaters, is especially prone to finite-key effects due to low coincident count rates compared to trusted-node single-path links. Quantifying these effects under realistic orbital conditions is therefore essential for the design of practical satellite quantum communication systems. Here, we develop a high-fidelity model of pair distribution from a low-Earth-orbit satellite that captures orbital dynamics, elevation-dependent loss, background noise, and extraneous detector effects. Integrating this with a finite-key security framework for the BBM92 protocol, we optimise the secret key length across different overpass geometries, orbital altitudes, and optical ground station (OGS) separations. We show that secure key generation remains feasible in early clear daytime conditions using baseline parameters representative of current technologies, while showing that modest system improvements could further extend daytime operation. Finally, we evaluate the annual secret key performance for representative intercity-scale OGS pairings. Our results provide quantitative performance bounds and practical design guidelines for near-term entanglement-based satellite QKD, enabling informed trade-offs between satellite payload complexity, ground infrastructure, and achievable secure key throughput.

quant-pharXiv:2602.11833•Feb 13, 2026•2 citations

Analysis of untrusted-node quantum key distribution from a geostationary satellite

Thomas Liege, Perrine Lognoné, Matteo Schiavon +4 more

Abstract In pursuit of a global quantum key distribution (QKD) network, a service based on untrusted nodes on geostationary satellites could offer wide coverage, continuous operation, and enhanced security compared to the trusted node alternative. Although this scenario has been studied for entanglement-based protocols, such an approach would require large-area telescopes both on the ground and in space. In this work, we analyze the performance of two QKD protocols well adapted to this scenario, namely twin-field (TF) and mode-pairing (MP) QKD, which exhibit high resilience to high-loss channels. Leveraging an in-depth simulation of communication channels corrected with adaptive optics, we assess the expected secret key rates for both protocols in a configuration involving two 50 cm telescopes on board the satellite and ground-based telescopes ranging from 20 cm to 1 m in aperture. Our results show that, in the best case and considering realistic detectors, it is possible to achieve secret key rates on the order of a few 100 bit s −1 for both TF and MP-QKD. We show, notably, that secret key generation is potentially feasible even with 20 cm ground telescopes, highlighting the high scalability potential of such a configuration.

arXiv:2507.23466•Quantum Science and Technology•Feb 6, 2026•1 citation

QKD

Ernst Piller, Hubert Schölnast

Abstract QKD (Quantum Key Distribution) promises information-theoretical security by using quantum states to generate shared cryptographic key material and to reveal eavesdropping attempts through unavoidable physical disturbances. The practical value of this promise depends not only on quantum technologies such as DV-QKD, CV-QKD, entanglement-based QKD, MDI-QKD, and Twin-Field QKD, but also on authentication, post-processing, implementation quality, and operational architecture. Fiber-optic, satellite, and free-space QKD each impose distinct limits on distance, key rate, trusted nodes, costs, and resistance to side-channel attacks.

SpringerBriefs in information security and cryptography•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Evaluation of integration concepts of Optical Ground Stations for satellite-based Quantum Key Distribution into a quantum network

Stefanie Häusler, Davide Orsucci, Andrew Reeves +1 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is a promising method to guarantee future-proof, information theoretic security. Since optical fibers have an exponential loss with distance, satellite-based QKD solutions are being developed in order to realize long-distance links. Therefore, Optical Ground Stations for QKD (QKD-OGS) need to be designed to enable quantum communication with satellites. Different link configurations will result in different integration options of the QKD-OGS in the terrestrial fiber network and therefore impact its performance. Applicable integration options must be identified and trade-off analysis conducted at the architecture, system and sub-system level. The reference scenario is a Low Earth Orbit (LEO) downlink configuration employing a decoy-state BB84 protocol with polarization encoded qubits at 1550 nm wavelength. The satellite acts as trusted node for implementation of the key distribution between two parties on ground. Furthermore, only direct connections from the satellite to the end-users are considered, i.e. the QKD-OGS does not serve as a trusted-node relay. This results in the selection of three main integration concepts: first, a free-space, end-user QKD-OGS which is located directly at the end-user where the quantum signal is measured directly behind the receiver telescope in free-space; second, a fiber-coupled, end-user QKD-OGS where the quantum signal is coupled into a single-mode fiber and guided to a co-located server room hosting the QKD Receiver system; third, a fiber-coupled, provider QKD-OGS, which reaches several end-users by using a local fiber network. In order to evaluate these three concepts, the comparison parameter is defined to be an estimated factor of suppliable end-users. The estimated comparison factor shows that the fiber-coupled, enduser QKD-OGS can supply 6.7 times more end users than the free-space, end-user QKD-OGS. The fiber-coupled, end-user QKD-OGS can supply 129.7 times more end-users than the free-space, end-user QKD-OGS.

IEEE International Conference on Space Optical Systems and Applications (ICSOS)•Oct 11, 2023•9 citations
Quantum cryptography promises unconditionally secure communication. Today, there exists a vast array of different QKD protocols that claim to offer security. However, looking in more detail, many subtleties lead to different security levels, or in the worst-case to no security at all. Here, we introduce the most crucial QKD security properties, ranging from different attack schemes to actual implementation security considerations. We present three different QKD use-cases with different network topologies: one trusted-node-based scenario (BB84 decoy) and two trusted-node-free (entanglement-based BBM92 and twin-field QKD). Using our, in cooperation with the European Space Agency (ESA), in-house developed simulations package, we simulate all relevant performance parameters, including the expected finite secret-key-rate. Furthermore, we assess all simulated QKD protocols’ applicability to satellite-based QKD networks and identify essential technologies. Interestingly, not the single-photon detection modules are the key drivers in terms of secure-key-rate performance, but the optical sending and receiving telescopes.
Quantum key distribution (QKD), the technology to generate distant secure keys for later usage in secure communication, has become a mature topic since the 1980s. While terrestrial QKD over fiber networks is suitable for short-distance urban networks, QKD via satellites promises to gap the distance requirement on a global scale that limits terrestrial QKD. Satellite QKD requires the exchange of quantum states between a satellite and multiple ground stations. The goal is then to facilitate shared secret keys between the ground stations, which can then be relayed to users near the ground stations. The satellite usually carries the quantum sources as its payload and sends them to the ground station via a downlink. The QKD protocol is heavily influenced by the choice of the quantum source, with typically one of two types: approximate single photon source (such as a weak laser) or an entangled source. Similarly, the ground station must be equipped to receive, measure and process the quantum signals sent by the satellite. Although there are also reverse schemes, where the satellite acts as the receiver and the ground station as the sender, these schemes are less explored due to higher noise in the uplink and less engineering experience. As with any system containing a high heterogeneity, many different implementation schemes lead to a variety of optimized use cases based on different criteria. Satellite QKD carries the further complication that it must be adapted to international standards. In this paper we present different satellite and ground station architectures that lean on the developments in the projects EAGLE-1, QUBE, QuNET, RoGloQuaN, addressing different protocols, sources, satellite sizes and telescope sizes. We also discuss the need for agility and configuration of components in a heterogeneous environment.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) constitutes one of the most profound practical applications of quantum mechanics, enabling two parties to exchange cryptographic keys whose security is guaranteed by the fundamental laws of physics rather than the assumed computational hardness of mathematical problems. As quantum computing capabilities continue to advance, classical public-key infrastructure faces an existential threat, rendering QKD a critical component of post-quantum secure communication architectures. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of QKD spanning foundational protocols, rigorous security proofs, hardware implementation challenges, deployment experiences across metropolitan fiber networks, and recent satellite-based experiments. We analyze the BB84, E91, B92, SARG04, continuous-variable, measurement-device-independent (MDI-QKD), and twin-field (TF-QKD) protocols in depth, examining their security assumptions, achievable key rates, and practical limitations. Particular attention is given to side-channel vulnerabilities in realistic implementations, decoy-state methods for mitigating photon-number-splitting attacks, and finite-key security analysis. We review key performance benchmarks from commercial systems and discuss integration with classical network infrastructure. The paper concludes by identifying open challenges in quantum repeater development, satellite QKD scalability, and standardization efforts essential for large-scale deployment.
Establishing information-theoretically secure communication between arbitrary locations on Earth is a central goal of quantum networking, for which space-based distribution of quantum entanglement is a leading approach. Modelling and analysis of the performance of satellite entanglement pair distribution is therefore important for the architecture and design of future constellations and space systems. However, entanglement-based quantum key distribution in the absence of quantum repeaters, is especially prone to finite-key effects due to low coincident count rates compared to trusted-node single-path links. Quantifying these effects under realistic orbital conditions is therefore essential for the design of practical satellite quantum communication systems. Here, we develop a high-fidelity model of pair distribution from a low-Earth-orbit satellite that captures orbital dynamics, elevation-dependent loss, background noise, and extraneous detector effects. Integrating this with a finite-key security framework for the BBM92 protocol, we optimise the secret key length across different overpass geometries, orbital altitudes, and optical ground station (OGS) separations. We show that secure key generation remains feasible in early clear daytime conditions using baseline parameters representative of current technologies, while showing that modest system improvements could further extend daytime operation. Finally, we evaluate the annual secret key performance for representative intercity-scale OGS pairings. Our results provide quantitative performance bounds and practical design guidelines for near-term entanglement-based satellite QKD, enabling informed trade-offs between satellite payload complexity, ground infrastructure, and achievable secure key throughput.
Abstract In pursuit of a global quantum key distribution (QKD) network, a service based on untrusted nodes on geostationary satellites could offer wide coverage, continuous operation, and enhanced security compared to the trusted node alternative. Although this scenario has been studied for entanglement-based protocols, such an approach would require large-area telescopes both on the ground and in space. In this work, we analyze the performance of two QKD protocols well adapted to this scenario, namely twin-field (TF) and mode-pairing (MP) QKD, which exhibit high resilience to high-loss channels. Leveraging an in-depth simulation of communication channels corrected with adaptive optics, we assess the expected secret key rates for both protocols in a configuration involving two 50 cm telescopes on board the satellite and ground-based telescopes ranging from 20 cm to 1 m in aperture. Our results show that, in the best case and considering realistic detectors, it is possible to achieve secret key rates on the order of a few 100 bit s −1 for both TF and MP-QKD. We show, notably, that secret key generation is potentially feasible even with 20 cm ground telescopes, highlighting the high scalability potential of such a configuration.
Abstract QKD (Quantum Key Distribution) promises information-theoretical security by using quantum states to generate shared cryptographic key material and to reveal eavesdropping attempts through unavoidable physical disturbances. The practical value of this promise depends not only on quantum technologies such as DV-QKD, CV-QKD, entanglement-based QKD, MDI-QKD, and Twin-Field QKD, but also on authentication, post-processing, implementation quality, and operational architecture. Fiber-optic, satellite, and free-space QKD each impose distinct limits on distance, key rate, trusted nodes, costs, and resistance to side-channel attacks.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is a promising method to guarantee future-proof, information theoretic security. Since optical fibers have an exponential loss with distance, satellite-based QKD solutions are being developed in order to realize long-distance links. Therefore, Optical Ground Stations for QKD (QKD-OGS) need to be designed to enable quantum communication with satellites. Different link configurations will result in different integration options of the QKD-OGS in the terrestrial fiber network and therefore impact its performance. Applicable integration options must be identified and trade-off analysis conducted at the architecture, system and sub-system level. The reference scenario is a Low Earth Orbit (LEO) downlink configuration employing a decoy-state BB84 protocol with polarization encoded qubits at 1550 nm wavelength. The satellite acts as trusted node for implementation of the key distribution between two parties on ground. Furthermore, only direct connections from the satellite to the end-users are considered, i.e. the QKD-OGS does not serve as a trusted-node relay. This results in the selection of three main integration concepts: first, a free-space, end-user QKD-OGS which is located directly at the end-user where the quantum signal is measured directly behind the receiver telescope in free-space; second, a fiber-coupled, end-user QKD-OGS where the quantum signal is coupled into a single-mode fiber and guided to a co-located server room hosting the QKD Receiver system; third, a fiber-coupled, provider QKD-OGS, which reaches several end-users by using a local fiber network. In order to evaluate these three concepts, the comparison parameter is defined to be an estimated factor of suppliable end-users. The estimated comparison factor shows that the fiber-coupled, enduser QKD-OGS can supply 6.7 times more end users than the free-space, end-user QKD-OGS. The fiber-coupled, end-user QKD-OGS can supply 129.7 times more end-users than the free-space, end-user QKD-OGS.