Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Mathematics

The Superiority of Quantum Strategy in 3-Player Prisoner’s Dilemma

Zhiyuan Dong, Ai‐Guo Wu

Published Jun 21, 2021• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, we extend the quantum game theory of Prisoner’s Dilemma to the N-player case. The final state of quantum game theory of N-player Prisoner’s Dilemma is derived, which can be used to investigate the payoff of each player. As demonstration, two cases (2-player and 3-player) are studied to illustrate the superiority of quantum strategy in the game theory. Specifically, the non-unique entanglement parameter is found to maximize the total payoff, which oscillates periodically. Finally, the optimal strategic set is proved to depend on the selection of initial states.

DOI
10.3390/math9121443

Related papers

Communication aspects of a three-player Prisoner's Dilemma quantum game

Muhammad Asif Ramzan, Majid Khan

We present a quantization scheme for a three-player Prisoner's Dilemma game. It is shown that entanglement plays a dominant role in the three-player quantum game. Four different types of payoffs are identified on the basis of different combinations of initial state and measurement basis entanglement parameters. A relation among these different payoffs is also established. We also study the communication aspects of the three-player game. By exploiting different combinations of initial state and measurement basis entanglement parameters, we establish a relationship for the information shared among the parties. It is seen that the strategies of the players act as carriers of information in quantum games.

arXiv:0902.4760•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 25, 2008•8 citations

The Strategic Form of Quantum Prisoners' Dilemma

Ahmad Nawaz

In a normal form, prisoners' dilemma (PD) is represented by a payoff matrix showing players' strategies and payoffs. To obtain the distinguishing trait and strategic form of PD, certain constraints are imposed on the elements of its payoff matrix. We quantize PD by a generalized quantization scheme to analyze its strategic behavior in the quantum domain. The game starts with a general entangled state of the form and the measurement for payoffs is performed in entangled and product bases. We show that for both measurements, there exist respective cutoff values of entanglement of the initial quantum state up to which the strategic form of the game remains intact. Beyond these cutoffs the quantized PD behaves like the chicken game (CG) up to another cutoff value. For the measurement in the entangled basis the dilemma is resolved for sinξ > 1/7 with Q ⊗ Q as a Nash Equilibrium (NE). However, the quantized game behaves like PD when sinξ > 1/3; whereas in the range 1/7 < sinξ < 1/3 it behaves like CG with Q ⊗ Q as an NE. For the measurement in the product basis the quantized PD behaves like classical PD for with D ⊗ D as an NE. In region , the quantized PD behaves like classical CG with C ⊗ D and D ⊗ C as NEs.

arXiv:1307.6541•Chinese Physics Letters•May 1, 2013•13 citations

How Quantum Prisoner’s Dilemma Can Support Negotiations

M. Szopa

Decision-making by the two negotiating parties is simulated by a prisoner's dilemma game.The game is formulated in a quantum manner, where players strategies are unitary transformations of qubits built over the basis of opposite decision options.Quantum strategies are correlated through the mechanism of quantum entanglement and the result of the game is obtained by the collapse of the resulting transformed state.The range of strategies allowed for quantum players is richer than in case of a classical game and therefore the result of the game can be better optimized.On the other hand, the quantum game is save against eavesdropping and the players can be assured that this type of quantum arbitration is fair.We show that quantum prisoner's dilemma has more favorable Nash equilibria than its classical analog and they are close to the Pareto optimal solutions.Some economical examples of utilizing quantum game Nash equilibria are proposed.

Optimum Economic Studies•Jan 1, 2014•7 citations

Unique Solution to the Quantum Prisoner’s Dilemma Game

Ahmed S. Elgazzar

A quantized version of the prisoner’s dilemma game based on the Marinatto–Weber quantization scheme is introduced. A four-qubit-basis initial entangled quantum state is assumed. Two domains for Nash equilibria are observed in terms of the degree of entanglement of the game. Each Nash equilibrium point is found to be Pareto optimal in its corresponding domain. Therefore, there is a unique solution to the game dilemma in each domain of the entanglement parameter. The maximally entangled limit is studied, and the players’ payoffs are found to equal the average of the payoff matrix independently of their choices. Consequently, any combination of players’ choices is a solution to the dilemma of the game. The nonentangled limits are also studied and found to coincide with the classical mixed-strategy game. Our results are equivalent to those of the noisy schemes of the quantum prisoner’s dilemma game. In our scheme, entanglement can be interpreted as a noise.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Feb 1, 2019•11 citations

The Effect on The Expected Payoff of Corrupted Three-player Quantum Prisoner's Dilemma

Nie Jing

The Prisoner's Dilemma plays a very important part in the game theory.It is related to economics,political science,sociology,philosophy,ethnics,etc.when study in such field quantized the Prisoner's Dilemma and found that the payoffs for the players are better than that in the classical game.Then,people developed the two-player Quantum Prisoner's Dilemma into multiplayer quantum game.Also,they found that the quantum game does better than classical game.But now,the quantum advantage arising in a simplified multiplayer quantum game is found to be disadvantage when the game's qubit source is corrupted.

Journal of Southwest China Normal University•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Implementing quantum prisoner dilemma via different classes of entangled and separable states

A. T. M. Makram-Allah, Mahmoud Youssef Abd‐Rabbou, NASSER METWALLY

The possibility of implementing the prisoner’s dilemma game using different classes of initial states between the players is discussed. Different behaviors of the payoffs have been exhibited, may it increase, decrease or be fixed. These behaviors depend on the used initial state either maximum/partial entangled, the chosen entangling gate, and the strategies employed by each player. The increased payoff is displayed when the players adopt different defect strategies, while the fixed payoff is shown when both players apply the same defect strategy. The maximum bounds of the payoff can be attained if the players initially share a maximum entangled state. The maximum/minimum fixed payoff depends on the used entangling gate, where the maximum one is shown if the players send their final states to entangling gate. It is shown that, the nature of the payoff, whether stationary, increasing or decreasing is contingent upon the polarization of the initial state and the used defect strategy. However, if both states are polarized on the same axis direction, the predicted maximum payoff is smaller than that obtained if the initial state is polarized in different polarization of the same axis. Therefore, the initial state settings, entangling parameter and the choice of the defect strategy can be used as control tools to maximize/minimize the obtained payoff.

Modern Physics Letters A•Jul 18, 2025•2 citations
In this paper, we extend the quantum game theory of Prisoner’s Dilemma to the N-player case. The final state of quantum game theory of N-player Prisoner’s Dilemma is derived, which can be used to investigate the payoff of each player. As demonstration, two cases (2-player and 3-player) are studied to illustrate the superiority of quantum strategy in the game theory. Specifically, the non-unique entanglement parameter is found to maximize the total payoff, which oscillates periodically. Finally, the optimal strategic set is proved to depend on the selection of initial states.
We present a quantization scheme for a three-player Prisoner's Dilemma game. It is shown that entanglement plays a dominant role in the three-player quantum game. Four different types of payoffs are identified on the basis of different combinations of initial state and measurement basis entanglement parameters. A relation among these different payoffs is also established. We also study the communication aspects of the three-player game. By exploiting different combinations of initial state and measurement basis entanglement parameters, we establish a relationship for the information shared among the parties. It is seen that the strategies of the players act as carriers of information in quantum games.
In a normal form, prisoners' dilemma (PD) is represented by a payoff matrix showing players' strategies and payoffs. To obtain the distinguishing trait and strategic form of PD, certain constraints are imposed on the elements of its payoff matrix. We quantize PD by a generalized quantization scheme to analyze its strategic behavior in the quantum domain. The game starts with a general entangled state of the form and the measurement for payoffs is performed in entangled and product bases. We show that for both measurements, there exist respective cutoff values of entanglement of the initial quantum state up to which the strategic form of the game remains intact. Beyond these cutoffs the quantized PD behaves like the chicken game (CG) up to another cutoff value. For the measurement in the entangled basis the dilemma is resolved for sinξ > 1/7 with Q ⊗ Q as a Nash Equilibrium (NE). However, the quantized game behaves like PD when sinξ > 1/3; whereas in the range 1/7 < sinξ < 1/3 it behaves like CG with Q ⊗ Q as an NE. For the measurement in the product basis the quantized PD behaves like classical PD for with D ⊗ D as an NE. In region , the quantized PD behaves like classical CG with C ⊗ D and D ⊗ C as NEs.
Decision-making by the two negotiating parties is simulated by a prisoner's dilemma game.The game is formulated in a quantum manner, where players strategies are unitary transformations of qubits built over the basis of opposite decision options.Quantum strategies are correlated through the mechanism of quantum entanglement and the result of the game is obtained by the collapse of the resulting transformed state.The range of strategies allowed for quantum players is richer than in case of a classical game and therefore the result of the game can be better optimized.On the other hand, the quantum game is save against eavesdropping and the players can be assured that this type of quantum arbitration is fair.We show that quantum prisoner's dilemma has more favorable Nash equilibria than its classical analog and they are close to the Pareto optimal solutions.Some economical examples of utilizing quantum game Nash equilibria are proposed.
A quantized version of the prisoner’s dilemma game based on the Marinatto–Weber quantization scheme is introduced. A four-qubit-basis initial entangled quantum state is assumed. Two domains for Nash equilibria are observed in terms of the degree of entanglement of the game. Each Nash equilibrium point is found to be Pareto optimal in its corresponding domain. Therefore, there is a unique solution to the game dilemma in each domain of the entanglement parameter. The maximally entangled limit is studied, and the players’ payoffs are found to equal the average of the payoff matrix independently of their choices. Consequently, any combination of players’ choices is a solution to the dilemma of the game. The nonentangled limits are also studied and found to coincide with the classical mixed-strategy game. Our results are equivalent to those of the noisy schemes of the quantum prisoner’s dilemma game. In our scheme, entanglement can be interpreted as a noise.
The Prisoner's Dilemma plays a very important part in the game theory.It is related to economics,political science,sociology,philosophy,ethnics,etc.when study in such field quantized the Prisoner's Dilemma and found that the payoffs for the players are better than that in the classical game.Then,people developed the two-player Quantum Prisoner's Dilemma into multiplayer quantum game.Also,they found that the quantum game does better than classical game.But now,the quantum advantage arising in a simplified multiplayer quantum game is found to be disadvantage when the game's qubit source is corrupted.
The possibility of implementing the prisoner’s dilemma game using different classes of initial states between the players is discussed. Different behaviors of the payoffs have been exhibited, may it increase, decrease or be fixed. These behaviors depend on the used initial state either maximum/partial entangled, the chosen entangling gate, and the strategies employed by each player. The increased payoff is displayed when the players adopt different defect strategies, while the fixed payoff is shown when both players apply the same defect strategy. The maximum bounds of the payoff can be attained if the players initially share a maximum entangled state. The maximum/minimum fixed payoff depends on the used entangling gate, where the maximum one is shown if the players send their final states to entangling gate. It is shown that, the nature of the payoff, whether stationary, increasing or decreasing is contingent upon the polarization of the initial state and the used defect strategy. However, if both states are polarized on the same axis direction, the predicted maximum payoff is smaller than that obtained if the initial state is polarized in different polarization of the same axis. Therefore, the initial state settings, entangling parameter and the choice of the defect strategy can be used as control tools to maximize/minimize the obtained payoff.