Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Advances in Mathematics of Communications

On ideal and weakly-ideal access structures

Reza Kaboli, Shahram Khazaei, Maghsoud Parviz

Published Jun 11, 2021• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For more than two decades, proving or refuting the following statement has remained a challenging open problem in the theory of secret sharing schemes (SSSs): every ideal access structure admits an ideal perfect multi-linear SSS. The class of group-characterizable (GC) SSSs include the multi-linear ones. Hence, if the above statement is true, then so is the following weaker statement: every ideal access structure admits an ideal perfect GC SSS. One contribution of this paper is to show that ideal SSSs are not necessarily GC. Our second contribution is to study the above two statements with respect to several variations of weakly-ideal access structures. Recently, Mejia and Montoya studied ideal access structures that admit ideal multi-linear schemes and provided a classification-like theorem for them. We additionally present some tools that are useful to extend their result.

DOI
10.3934/amc.2021017

Related papers

Ideal Hierarchical Secret Sharing Schemes

Oriol Farràs, Carles Padró

Hierarchical secret sharing is among the most natural generalizations of threshold secret sharing, and it has attracted a lot of attention since the invention of secret sharing until nowadays. Several constructions of ideal hierarchical secret sharing schemes have been proposed, but it was not known what access structures admit such a scheme. We solve this problem by providing a natural definition for the family of the hierarchical access structures and, more importantly, by presenting a complete characterization of the ideal hierarchical access structures, that is, the ones admitting an ideal secret sharing scheme. Our characterization is based on the well-known connection between ideal secret sharing schemes and matroids and, more specifically, on the connection between ideal multipartite secret sharing schemes and integer polymatroids. In particular, we prove that every hierarchical matroid port admits an ideal linear secret sharing scheme over every large enough finite field. Finally, we use our results to present a new proof for the existing characterization of the ideal weighted threshold access structures.

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jan 25, 2012•67 citations

Ideal and perfect multi-secret sharing schemes whose access structure are Q 3

Lv yingli, Xiaojun Xu, Zhang Xiao-feng +1 more

The characterization of access structure is one of the main open problems in secret sharing schemes. We are particularly interested in determining which Q 3 access structures can be realized and the requirement should be achieved even in the presence of an adversary who is able to corrupt some players in an ideal secret sharing scheme. The problems are studied in our paper. Above all, we present a concrete scheme that can meet all above requirements. In our scheme, it is not only a dynamic multi-secret and multi-use sharing protocol, but participants from access structure can recover the secret using their shares, while the same number of participants from adversary structure can't recover the secret using their shares, which is different from general access structure schemes. Moreover, in the whole dynamic process, the coefficients of polynomial and private secret shares always stay the same. Therefore, it enjoys high practical value.

•Aug 1, 2012•0 citations

A characterisation of ideal weighted secret sharing schemes

Ali M. Hameed, Arkadii M. Slinko

Abstract Beimel, Tassa and Weinreb [SIAM J. Discrete Math. 22 (2008), 360–397] and Farràs and Padró [Lecture Notes in Comput. Sci. 5978, Springer, 2010, 219–236] partially characterised access structures of ideal weighted secret sharing schemes in terms of the operation of composition. They proved that any weighted ideal access structure is a composition of indecomposable ones. Farràs and Padró gave a list of seven classes of access structures – one unipartite, three bipartite and three tripartite – to which all weighted ideal indecomposable access structures may belong. In this paper we determine exactly which access structures from those classes are indecomposable. We also determine which compositions of indecomposable weighted access structures are again weighted and obtain an if-and-only-if characterisation of ideal weighted secret sharing schemes. We use game-theoretic techniques to achieve this.

arXiv:1308.3763•Journal of Mathematical Cryptology•Oct 6, 2015•5 citations

Secret sharing and duality

László Csirmaz

Abstract Secret sharing is an important building block in cryptography. All explicit secret sharing schemes which are known to have optimal complexity are multi-linear, thus are closely related to linear codes. The dual of such a linear scheme, in the sense of duality of linear codes, gives another scheme for the dual access structure. These schemes have the same complexity, namely the largest share size relative to the secret size is the same. It is a long-standing open problem whether this fact is true in general: the complexity of any access structure is the same as the complexity of its dual. We give a partial answer to this question. An almost perfect scheme allows negligible errors, both in the recovery and in the independence. There exists an almost perfect ideal scheme on 174 participants whose complexity is strictly smaller than that of its dual.

arXiv:1909.13663•Journal of Mathematical Cryptology•Nov 25, 2020•20 citations

Universally ideal secret-sharing schemes

Amos Beimel, Benny Chor

Given a set of parties {1, /spl middot//spl middot//spl middot/, n}, an access structure is a monotone collection of subsets of the parties. For a certain domain of secrets, a secret-sharing scheme for an access structure is a method for a dealer to distribute shares to the parties. These shares enable subsets in the access structure to reconstruct the secret, while subsets not in the access structure get no information about the secret. A secret-sharing scheme is ideal if the domains of the shares are the same as the domain of the secrets. An access structure is universally ideal if there exists an ideal secret-sharing scheme for it over every finite domain of secrets. An obvious necessary condition for an access structure to be universally ideal is to be ideal over the binary and ternary domains of secrets. The authors prove that this condition is also sufficient. They also show that being ideal over just one of the two domains does not suffice for universally ideal access structures. Finally, they give an exact characterization for each of these two conditions.>

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•May 1, 1994•113 citations

On Matroids and Nonideal Secret Sharing

Amos Beimel, Noam Livne

Secret-sharing schemes are a tool used in many cryptographic protocols. In these schemes, a dealer holding a secret string distributes shares to the parties such that only authorized subsets of participants can reconstruct the secret from their shares. The collection of authorized sets is called an access structure. An access structure is ideal if there is a secret-sharing scheme realizing it such that the shares are taken from the same domain as the secrets. Brickell and Davenport (Journal of Cryptology, 1991) have shown that ideal access structures are closely related to matroids. They give a necessary condition for an access structure to be ideal-the access structure must be induced by a matroid. Seymour (Journal of Combinatorial Theory B, 1992) has proved that the necessary condition is not sufficient: There exists an access structure induced by a matroid that does not have an ideal scheme. The research on access structures induced by matroids is continued in this work. The main result in this paper is strengthening the result of Seymour. It is shown that in any secret-sharing scheme realizing the access structure induced by the Vamos matroid with domain of the secrets of size k, the size of the domain of the shares is at least k + Omega(radic(k)). The second result considers nonideal secret-sharing schemes realizing access structures induced by matroids. It is proved that the fact that an access structure is induced by a matroid implies lower and upper bounds on the size of the domain of shares of subsets of participants even in nonideal schemes (as long as the shares are still relatively short). This generalized results of Brickell and Davenport for ideal schemes. Finally, an example of a nonideal access structure that is nearly ideal is presented.

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•May 29, 2008•20 citations
For more than two decades, proving or refuting the following statement has remained a challenging open problem in the theory of secret sharing schemes (SSSs): every ideal access structure admits an ideal perfect multi-linear SSS. The class of group-characterizable (GC) SSSs include the multi-linear ones. Hence, if the above statement is true, then so is the following weaker statement: every ideal access structure admits an ideal perfect GC SSS. One contribution of this paper is to show that ideal SSSs are not necessarily GC. Our second contribution is to study the above two statements with respect to several variations of weakly-ideal access structures. Recently, Mejia and Montoya studied ideal access structures that admit ideal multi-linear schemes and provided a classification-like theorem for them. We additionally present some tools that are useful to extend their result.
Hierarchical secret sharing is among the most natural generalizations of threshold secret sharing, and it has attracted a lot of attention since the invention of secret sharing until nowadays. Several constructions of ideal hierarchical secret sharing schemes have been proposed, but it was not known what access structures admit such a scheme. We solve this problem by providing a natural definition for the family of the hierarchical access structures and, more importantly, by presenting a complete characterization of the ideal hierarchical access structures, that is, the ones admitting an ideal secret sharing scheme. Our characterization is based on the well-known connection between ideal secret sharing schemes and matroids and, more specifically, on the connection between ideal multipartite secret sharing schemes and integer polymatroids. In particular, we prove that every hierarchical matroid port admits an ideal linear secret sharing scheme over every large enough finite field. Finally, we use our results to present a new proof for the existing characterization of the ideal weighted threshold access structures.
The characterization of access structure is one of the main open problems in secret sharing schemes. We are particularly interested in determining which Q 3 access structures can be realized and the requirement should be achieved even in the presence of an adversary who is able to corrupt some players in an ideal secret sharing scheme. The problems are studied in our paper. Above all, we present a concrete scheme that can meet all above requirements. In our scheme, it is not only a dynamic multi-secret and multi-use sharing protocol, but participants from access structure can recover the secret using their shares, while the same number of participants from adversary structure can't recover the secret using their shares, which is different from general access structure schemes. Moreover, in the whole dynamic process, the coefficients of polynomial and private secret shares always stay the same. Therefore, it enjoys high practical value.
Abstract Beimel, Tassa and Weinreb [SIAM J. Discrete Math. 22 (2008), 360–397] and Farràs and Padró [Lecture Notes in Comput. Sci. 5978, Springer, 2010, 219–236] partially characterised access structures of ideal weighted secret sharing schemes in terms of the operation of composition. They proved that any weighted ideal access structure is a composition of indecomposable ones. Farràs and Padró gave a list of seven classes of access structures – one unipartite, three bipartite and three tripartite – to which all weighted ideal indecomposable access structures may belong. In this paper we determine exactly which access structures from those classes are indecomposable. We also determine which compositions of indecomposable weighted access structures are again weighted and obtain an if-and-only-if characterisation of ideal weighted secret sharing schemes. We use game-theoretic techniques to achieve this.
Abstract Secret sharing is an important building block in cryptography. All explicit secret sharing schemes which are known to have optimal complexity are multi-linear, thus are closely related to linear codes. The dual of such a linear scheme, in the sense of duality of linear codes, gives another scheme for the dual access structure. These schemes have the same complexity, namely the largest share size relative to the secret size is the same. It is a long-standing open problem whether this fact is true in general: the complexity of any access structure is the same as the complexity of its dual. We give a partial answer to this question. An almost perfect scheme allows negligible errors, both in the recovery and in the independence. There exists an almost perfect ideal scheme on 174 participants whose complexity is strictly smaller than that of its dual.
Given a set of parties {1, /spl middot//spl middot//spl middot/, n}, an access structure is a monotone collection of subsets of the parties. For a certain domain of secrets, a secret-sharing scheme for an access structure is a method for a dealer to distribute shares to the parties. These shares enable subsets in the access structure to reconstruct the secret, while subsets not in the access structure get no information about the secret. A secret-sharing scheme is ideal if the domains of the shares are the same as the domain of the secrets. An access structure is universally ideal if there exists an ideal secret-sharing scheme for it over every finite domain of secrets. An obvious necessary condition for an access structure to be universally ideal is to be ideal over the binary and ternary domains of secrets. The authors prove that this condition is also sufficient. They also show that being ideal over just one of the two domains does not suffice for universally ideal access structures. Finally, they give an exact characterization for each of these two conditions.>
Secret-sharing schemes are a tool used in many cryptographic protocols. In these schemes, a dealer holding a secret string distributes shares to the parties such that only authorized subsets of participants can reconstruct the secret from their shares. The collection of authorized sets is called an access structure. An access structure is ideal if there is a secret-sharing scheme realizing it such that the shares are taken from the same domain as the secrets. Brickell and Davenport (Journal of Cryptology, 1991) have shown that ideal access structures are closely related to matroids. They give a necessary condition for an access structure to be ideal-the access structure must be induced by a matroid. Seymour (Journal of Combinatorial Theory B, 1992) has proved that the necessary condition is not sufficient: There exists an access structure induced by a matroid that does not have an ideal scheme. The research on access structures induced by matroids is continued in this work. The main result in this paper is strengthening the result of Seymour. It is shown that in any secret-sharing scheme realizing the access structure induced by the Vamos matroid with domain of the secrets of size k, the size of the domain of the shares is at least k + Omega(radic(k)). The second result considers nonideal secret-sharing schemes realizing access structures induced by matroids. It is proved that the fact that an access structure is induced by a matroid implies lower and upper bounds on the size of the domain of shares of subsets of participants even in nonideal schemes (as long as the shares are still relatively short). This generalized results of Brickell and Davenport for ideal schemes. Finally, an example of a nonideal access structure that is nearly ideal is presented.