Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Critical Phenomena in Topologically Disordered Systems

Manuel Schrauth

Published Jan 1, 2021• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Clearly, in nature, but also in technological applications, complex systems built in an entirely ordered and regular fashion are the exception rather than the rule. In this thesis we explore how critical phenomena are influenced by quenched spatial randomness. Specifically, we consider physical systems undergoing a continuous phase transition in the presence of topological disorder, where the underlying structure, on which the system evolves, is given by a non-regular, discrete lattice. We therefore endeavour to achieve a thorough understanding of the interplay between collective dynamics and quenched randomness. According to the intriguing concept of universality, certain laws emerge from collectively behaving many-body systems at criticality, almost regardless of the precise microscopic realization of interactions in those systems. As a consequence, vastly different phenomena show striking similarities at their respective phase transitions. In this dissertation we pursue the question of whether the universal properties of critical phenomena are preserved when the system is subjected to topological perturbations. For this purpose, we perform numerical simulations of several prototypical systems of statistical physics which show a continuous phase transition. In particular, the equilibrium spin-1/2 Ising model and its generalizations represent -- among other applications -- fairly natural approaches to model magnetism in solids, whereas the non-equilibrium contact process serves as a toy model for percolation in porous media and epidemic spreading. Finally, the Manna sandpile model is strongly related to the concept of self-organized criticality, where a complex dynamic system reaches a critical state without fine-tuning of external variables. Our results reveal that the prevailing understanding of the influence of topological randomness on critical phenomena is insufficient. In particular, by considering very specific and newly developed lattice structures, we are able to show that -- contrary to the popular opinion -- spatial correlations in the number of interacting neighbours are not a key measure for predicting whether disorder ultimately alters the behaviour of a given critical system.

DOI
10.25972/opus-23499

Related papers

Universality of continuous phase transitions on random Voronoi graphs

Manuel Schrauth, Jefferson S. E. Portela

The Voronoi construction is ubiquitous across the natural sciences and engineering. In statistical mechanics, however, only its dual, the Delaunay triangulation, has been considered in the investigation of critical phenomena. In this paper we set to fill this gap by studying three prominent systems of classical statistical mechanics, the equilibrium spin-1/2 Ising model, the nonequilibrium contact process, and the conserved stochastic sandpile model on two-dimensional random Voronoi graphs. Particular motivation comes from the fact that these graphs have vertices of constant coordination number, making it possible to isolate topological effects of quenched disorder from node-intrinsic coordination number disorder. Using large-scale numerical simulations and finite-size scaling techniques, we are able to demonstrate that all three systems belong to their respective clean universality classes. Therefore, quenched disorder introduced by the randomness of the lattice is irrelevant and does not influence the character of the phase transitions. We report the critical points to considerable precision and, for the Ising model, also the first correction-to-scaling exponent.

arXiv:1907.12494•Physical review. E•Dec 16, 2019•3 citations

Localization and Criticality in Non-crystalline Quantum Matter

Moein N. Ivaki

The concept of non-trivial electronic topology in condensed matter physics is crucial for understanding the electronic spectrum of solids and for tailoring various thermodynamic and transport properties, useful for real-world applications. Research on topological insulators and superconductors primarily utilizes the electronic band theory and symmetry classes of gapped quantum systems, with the existence of spectral or mobility gaps ensured even in the presence of impurities and defects. However, structural disorder, naturally manifested in materials such as glasses and amorphous solids, can significantly impact the critical properties of phase transitions in topological quantum matters. This dissertation systematically studies topological phase transitions in non-crystalline free-fermion systems via tight-binding quantum Hamiltonians on 2D random geometries. Leveraging various theoretical and experimentally accessible measures, we demonstrate the resilience of topological phases in non-crystalline systems against structural randomness, described by classical percolation theory, and characterize their unique critical behavior through finite-size scaling. We also extend the notion of amorphous topological states to non-integer dimensional random systems. We reveal that these 2D-embedded random fractals can admit well-defined thermodynamic topological phases with unconventional critical properties. We further study quantum dynamics in these random topological systems. By employing a family of discrete-time topological quantum walks on random percolation lattices, we address wavefunction propagation, superdiffusive quantum speedup, and localization transition by identifying the critical probabilities and timescales. Lastly, we introduce topological lattices with adjustable spatial correlation to investigate Landau levels and quantum oscillations in a low magnetic field regime.

•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

A Matter of Disorder: Monte Carlo Simulations of Phase Transitions in Strongly Disordered Systems

Marios Nikolaou

Phase transitions and their critical scaling properties, especially in systems with disorder, are important both for our theoretical understanding of our environment, but also for their practical use in applications and materials in our everyday life. This thesis presents results from finite size scaling analysis of critical phenomena in systems with disorder, using high-precision Monte Carlo simulations and state of the art numerical methods. Specifically, theoretical models suitable for simulations in the presence of uncorrelated or correlated disorder are studied. Uncorrelated strong disorder, as present in the two dimensional gauge glass model to study the vortex glass phase of high temperature superconductors in an applied magnetic field is shown to lack a finite temperature phase transition. Further, results from dynamic quantities, such as resistance and autocorrelation functions, indicate the existence of two distinct diverging correlation times, one associated with local relaxation and one associated with vortex phase slips. Correlated disorder is studied both in the superfluid transition of helium-4 and in the anisotropic critical scaling of a transverse Meissner-like transition in an experimental setup of a high temperature superconductor. For the superfluid helium transition, it is shown that the presence of fractally correlated disorder presumably alters the universality class of the pure model. Also, a comparison with experimental data suggests that the critical scaling theory describing the heat capacity of helium-4 may need to be modified in the presence of the disorder. In the case of superconductors, analyzing experimental data from resistance measurements in a system with columnar defects together with an anisotropy in the applied magnetic field, reveals a fully anisotropic scaling regime. Finally, a data analysis is presented from simulations of a charged particle gas system in three dimensions, where the normal Coulomb interaction between charges is changed into a logarithmic interaction. Previous work indicates the possibility of a transition similar to the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in certain two dimensional systems. On the contrary, our simulations seem to favor a system whose critical scaling behavior is consistent with a transition occurring only at zero critical temperature. Overall, disorder in the model systems studied leads to important modifications of the critical scaling properties of pure systems, and thereby also to possible changes of the corresponding universality classes. This results in interesting predictions with experimentally relevant consequences.

•Jan 1, 2007•3 citations

Understanding disordered systems through numerical simulation and algorithm development

Sean Michael Sweeney

Disordered systems arise in many physical contexts. Not all matter is uni- form, and impurities or heterogeneities can be modeled by fixed random disor- der. Numerous complex networks also possess fixed disorder, leading to appli- cations in transportation systems [1], telecommunications [2], social networks [3, 4], and epidemic modeling [5], to name a few. Due to their random nature and power law critical behavior, disordered systems are difficult to study analytically. Numerical simulation can help overcome this hurdle by allowing for the rapid computation of system states. In order to get precise statistics and extrapolate to the thermodynamic limit, large systems must be studied over many realizations. Thus, innovative al- gorithm development is essential in order reduce memory or running time requirements of simulations. This thesis presents a review of disordered systems, as well as a thorough study of two particular systems through numerical simulation, algorithm de- velopment and optimization, and careful statistical analysis of scaling proper- ties. Chapter 1 provides a thorough overview of disordered systems, the his- tory of their study in the physics community, and the development of tech- niques used to study them. Topics of quenched disorder, phase transitions, the renormalization group, criticality, and scale invariance are discussed. Several prominent models of disordered systems are also explained. Lastly, analysis techniques used in studying disordered systems are covered. In Chapter 2, minimal spanning trees on critical percolation clusters are studied, motivated in part by an analytic perturbation expansion by Jackson and Read [6] that I check against numerical calculations. This system has a direct mapping to the ground state of the strongly disordered spin glass [7]. We compute the path length fractal dimension of these trees in dimensions d = {2, 3, 4, 5} and find our results to be compatible with the analytic results suggested by Jackson and Read. In Chapter 3, the random bond Ising ferromagnet is studied, which is es- pecially useful since it serves as a prototype for more complicated disordered systems such as the random field Ising model and spin glasses. We investigate the effect that changing boundary spins has on the locations of domain walls in the interior of the random ferromagnet system. We provide an analytic proof that ground state domain walls in the two dimensional system are de- composable, and we map these domain walls to a shortest paths problem. By implementing a multiple-source shortest paths algorithm developed by Philip Klein [8], we are able to efficiently probe domain wall locations for all possible configurations of boundary spins. We consider lattices with uncorrelated dis- order, as well as disorder that is spatially correlated according to a power law. We present numerical results for the scaling exponent governing the probabil- ity that a domain wall can be induced that passes through a particular location in the system’s interior, and we compare these results to previous results on the directed polymer problem.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Effect of disorder on first-order phase transitions

Arash Bellafard

Disorder is an inevitable part of any condensed matter system and therefore its study has always been of great importance. The effect of quenched randomness on a system that exhibits a continuous phase transition in the absence of any impurity has been studied in the past and the results are relatively well understood. However, the effect of quenched randomness on \\emph{first-order} phase transitions is still not well understood. In this dissertation, we study the effect of quenched bond-randomness on the classical and quantum first-order phase transitions.In Chapter 2, we study the effect of the disordered three-color Ashkin-Teller model, whose pure version undergoes a first-order phase transition. We show that the rounding of the first-order transition of the pure model due to the impurities is manifested as a critical point. We conclusively rule out that the model belongs to the universality class of the two-dimensional Ising model. Furthermore, we find that the exponents $\\beta$ and $\\nu$ vary with disorder and the four-spin coupling strength.In Chapter 3, we extend our study of the disordered three-color Ashkin-Teller model. Utilizing extensive cluster Monte Carlo simulations on large lattice sizes of up to $128 \\times 128$ spins, each of which is represented by three colors taking values $\\pm 1$, we show that the rounding of the first-order phase transition is an emergent criticality.We find that the critical exponents, $\\nu$ and $\\beta$, change as the strength of disorder or the four-spin coupling varies, and we show that the correlation length critical exponent violates the lower bound $2/D \\le \\nu$, where $D$ is the dimension of the system.In Chapter 4, we study the \\emph{quantum} three-color Ashkin--Teller model and show that the quantum critical point in $(1+1)$ dimension is an unusual one, with activated scaling at the critical point and Griffiths-McCoy phase away from it. We find that the behavior is similar to the transverse random field Ising model, even though the pure system has a first-order transition in this case.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Monte Carlo Simulations of a Lattice Gas with Logarithmic Interactions

Marios Nikolaou, Jack Lidmar, Mats Wallin

Phase transitions and their critical scaling properties, especially in systems with disorder, are important both for our theoretical understanding of our environment, but also for their practical use in applications and materials in our everyday life. This thesis presents results from finite size scaling analysis of critical phenomena in systems with disorder, using high-precision Monte Carlo simulations and state of the art numerical methods. Specifically, theoretical models suitable for simulations in the presence of uncorrelated or correlated disorder are studied. Uncorrelated strong disorder, as present in the two dimensional gauge glass model to study the vortex glass phase of high temperature superconductors in an applied magnetic field is shown to lack a finite temperature phase transition. Further, results from dynamic quantities, such as resistance and autocorrelation functions, indicate the existence of two distinct diverging correlation times, one associated with local relaxation and one associated with vortex phase slips. Correlated disorder is studied both in the superfluid transition of helium-4 and in the anisotropic critical scaling of a transverse Meissner-like transition in an experimental setup of a high temperature superconductor. For the superfluid helium transition, it is shown that the presence of fractally correlated disorder presumably alters the universality class of the pure model. Also, a comparison with experimental data suggests that the critical scaling theory describing the heat capacity of helium-4 may need to be modified in the presence of the disorder. In the case of superconductors, analyzing experimental data from resistance measurements in a system with columnar defects together with an anisotropy in the applied magnetic field, reveals a fully anisotropic scaling regime. Finally, a data analysis is presented from simulations of a charged particle gas system in three dimensions, where the normal Coulomb interaction between charges is changed into a logarithmic interaction. Previous work indicates the possibility of a transition similar to the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in certain two dimensional systems. On the contrary, our simulations seem to favor a system whose critical scaling behavior is consistent with a transition occurring only at zero critical temperature. Overall, disorder in the model systems studied leads to important modifications of the critical scaling properties of pure systems, and thereby also to possible changes of the corresponding universality classes. This results in interesting predictions with experimentally relevant consequences.

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations
Clearly, in nature, but also in technological applications, complex systems built in an entirely ordered and regular fashion are the exception rather than the rule. In this thesis we explore how critical phenomena are influenced by quenched spatial randomness. Specifically, we consider physical systems undergoing a continuous phase transition in the presence of topological disorder, where the underlying structure, on which the system evolves, is given by a non-regular, discrete lattice. We therefore endeavour to achieve a thorough understanding of the interplay between collective dynamics and quenched randomness. According to the intriguing concept of universality, certain laws emerge from collectively behaving many-body systems at criticality, almost regardless of the precise microscopic realization of interactions in those systems. As a consequence, vastly different phenomena show striking similarities at their respective phase transitions. In this dissertation we pursue the question of whether the universal properties of critical phenomena are preserved when the system is subjected to topological perturbations. For this purpose, we perform numerical simulations of several prototypical systems of statistical physics which show a continuous phase transition. In particular, the equilibrium spin-1/2 Ising model and its generalizations represent -- among other applications -- fairly natural approaches to model magnetism in solids, whereas the non-equilibrium contact process serves as a toy model for percolation in porous media and epidemic spreading. Finally, the Manna sandpile model is strongly related to the concept of self-organized criticality, where a complex dynamic system reaches a critical state without fine-tuning of external variables. Our results reveal that the prevailing understanding of the influence of topological randomness on critical phenomena is insufficient. In particular, by considering very specific and newly developed lattice structures, we are able to show that -- contrary to the popular opinion -- spatial correlations in the number of interacting neighbours are not a key measure for predicting whether disorder ultimately alters the behaviour of a given critical system.
The Voronoi construction is ubiquitous across the natural sciences and engineering. In statistical mechanics, however, only its dual, the Delaunay triangulation, has been considered in the investigation of critical phenomena. In this paper we set to fill this gap by studying three prominent systems of classical statistical mechanics, the equilibrium spin-1/2 Ising model, the nonequilibrium contact process, and the conserved stochastic sandpile model on two-dimensional random Voronoi graphs. Particular motivation comes from the fact that these graphs have vertices of constant coordination number, making it possible to isolate topological effects of quenched disorder from node-intrinsic coordination number disorder. Using large-scale numerical simulations and finite-size scaling techniques, we are able to demonstrate that all three systems belong to their respective clean universality classes. Therefore, quenched disorder introduced by the randomness of the lattice is irrelevant and does not influence the character of the phase transitions. We report the critical points to considerable precision and, for the Ising model, also the first correction-to-scaling exponent.
The concept of non-trivial electronic topology in condensed matter physics is crucial for understanding the electronic spectrum of solids and for tailoring various thermodynamic and transport properties, useful for real-world applications. Research on topological insulators and superconductors primarily utilizes the electronic band theory and symmetry classes of gapped quantum systems, with the existence of spectral or mobility gaps ensured even in the presence of impurities and defects. However, structural disorder, naturally manifested in materials such as glasses and amorphous solids, can significantly impact the critical properties of phase transitions in topological quantum matters. This dissertation systematically studies topological phase transitions in non-crystalline free-fermion systems via tight-binding quantum Hamiltonians on 2D random geometries. Leveraging various theoretical and experimentally accessible measures, we demonstrate the resilience of topological phases in non-crystalline systems against structural randomness, described by classical percolation theory, and characterize their unique critical behavior through finite-size scaling. We also extend the notion of amorphous topological states to non-integer dimensional random systems. We reveal that these 2D-embedded random fractals can admit well-defined thermodynamic topological phases with unconventional critical properties. We further study quantum dynamics in these random topological systems. By employing a family of discrete-time topological quantum walks on random percolation lattices, we address wavefunction propagation, superdiffusive quantum speedup, and localization transition by identifying the critical probabilities and timescales. Lastly, we introduce topological lattices with adjustable spatial correlation to investigate Landau levels and quantum oscillations in a low magnetic field regime.
Phase transitions and their critical scaling properties, especially in systems with disorder, are important both for our theoretical understanding of our environment, but also for their practical use in applications and materials in our everyday life. This thesis presents results from finite size scaling analysis of critical phenomena in systems with disorder, using high-precision Monte Carlo simulations and state of the art numerical methods. Specifically, theoretical models suitable for simulations in the presence of uncorrelated or correlated disorder are studied. Uncorrelated strong disorder, as present in the two dimensional gauge glass model to study the vortex glass phase of high temperature superconductors in an applied magnetic field is shown to lack a finite temperature phase transition. Further, results from dynamic quantities, such as resistance and autocorrelation functions, indicate the existence of two distinct diverging correlation times, one associated with local relaxation and one associated with vortex phase slips. Correlated disorder is studied both in the superfluid transition of helium-4 and in the anisotropic critical scaling of a transverse Meissner-like transition in an experimental setup of a high temperature superconductor. For the superfluid helium transition, it is shown that the presence of fractally correlated disorder presumably alters the universality class of the pure model. Also, a comparison with experimental data suggests that the critical scaling theory describing the heat capacity of helium-4 may need to be modified in the presence of the disorder. In the case of superconductors, analyzing experimental data from resistance measurements in a system with columnar defects together with an anisotropy in the applied magnetic field, reveals a fully anisotropic scaling regime. Finally, a data analysis is presented from simulations of a charged particle gas system in three dimensions, where the normal Coulomb interaction between charges is changed into a logarithmic interaction. Previous work indicates the possibility of a transition similar to the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in certain two dimensional systems. On the contrary, our simulations seem to favor a system whose critical scaling behavior is consistent with a transition occurring only at zero critical temperature. Overall, disorder in the model systems studied leads to important modifications of the critical scaling properties of pure systems, and thereby also to possible changes of the corresponding universality classes. This results in interesting predictions with experimentally relevant consequences.
Disordered systems arise in many physical contexts. Not all matter is uni- form, and impurities or heterogeneities can be modeled by fixed random disor- der. Numerous complex networks also possess fixed disorder, leading to appli- cations in transportation systems [1], telecommunications [2], social networks [3, 4], and epidemic modeling [5], to name a few. Due to their random nature and power law critical behavior, disordered systems are difficult to study analytically. Numerical simulation can help overcome this hurdle by allowing for the rapid computation of system states. In order to get precise statistics and extrapolate to the thermodynamic limit, large systems must be studied over many realizations. Thus, innovative al- gorithm development is essential in order reduce memory or running time requirements of simulations. This thesis presents a review of disordered systems, as well as a thorough study of two particular systems through numerical simulation, algorithm de- velopment and optimization, and careful statistical analysis of scaling proper- ties. Chapter 1 provides a thorough overview of disordered systems, the his- tory of their study in the physics community, and the development of tech- niques used to study them. Topics of quenched disorder, phase transitions, the renormalization group, criticality, and scale invariance are discussed. Several prominent models of disordered systems are also explained. Lastly, analysis techniques used in studying disordered systems are covered. In Chapter 2, minimal spanning trees on critical percolation clusters are studied, motivated in part by an analytic perturbation expansion by Jackson and Read [6] that I check against numerical calculations. This system has a direct mapping to the ground state of the strongly disordered spin glass [7]. We compute the path length fractal dimension of these trees in dimensions d = {2, 3, 4, 5} and find our results to be compatible with the analytic results suggested by Jackson and Read. In Chapter 3, the random bond Ising ferromagnet is studied, which is es- pecially useful since it serves as a prototype for more complicated disordered systems such as the random field Ising model and spin glasses. We investigate the effect that changing boundary spins has on the locations of domain walls in the interior of the random ferromagnet system. We provide an analytic proof that ground state domain walls in the two dimensional system are de- composable, and we map these domain walls to a shortest paths problem. By implementing a multiple-source shortest paths algorithm developed by Philip Klein [8], we are able to efficiently probe domain wall locations for all possible configurations of boundary spins. We consider lattices with uncorrelated dis- order, as well as disorder that is spatially correlated according to a power law. We present numerical results for the scaling exponent governing the probabil- ity that a domain wall can be induced that passes through a particular location in the system’s interior, and we compare these results to previous results on the directed polymer problem.
Disorder is an inevitable part of any condensed matter system and therefore its study has always been of great importance. The effect of quenched randomness on a system that exhibits a continuous phase transition in the absence of any impurity has been studied in the past and the results are relatively well understood. However, the effect of quenched randomness on \\emph{first-order} phase transitions is still not well understood. In this dissertation, we study the effect of quenched bond-randomness on the classical and quantum first-order phase transitions.In Chapter 2, we study the effect of the disordered three-color Ashkin-Teller model, whose pure version undergoes a first-order phase transition. We show that the rounding of the first-order transition of the pure model due to the impurities is manifested as a critical point. We conclusively rule out that the model belongs to the universality class of the two-dimensional Ising model. Furthermore, we find that the exponents beta\\betabeta and nu\\nunu vary with disorder and the four-spin coupling strength.In Chapter 3, we extend our study of the disordered three-color Ashkin-Teller model. Utilizing extensive cluster Monte Carlo simulations on large lattice sizes of up to 128times128128 \\times 128128times128 spins, each of which is represented by three colors taking values pm1\\pm 1pm1, we show that the rounding of the first-order phase transition is an emergent criticality.We find that the critical exponents, nu\\nunu and beta\\betabeta, change as the strength of disorder or the four-spin coupling varies, and we show that the correlation length critical exponent violates the lower bound 2/Dlenu2/D \\le \\nu2/Dlenu, where DDD is the dimension of the system.In Chapter 4, we study the \\emph{quantum} three-color Ashkin--Teller model and show that the quantum critical point in (1+1)(1+1)(1+1) dimension is an unusual one, with activated scaling at the critical point and Griffiths-McCoy phase away from it. We find that the behavior is similar to the transverse random field Ising model, even though the pure system has a first-order transition in this case.
Phase transitions and their critical scaling properties, especially in systems with disorder, are important both for our theoretical understanding of our environment, but also for their practical use in applications and materials in our everyday life. This thesis presents results from finite size scaling analysis of critical phenomena in systems with disorder, using high-precision Monte Carlo simulations and state of the art numerical methods. Specifically, theoretical models suitable for simulations in the presence of uncorrelated or correlated disorder are studied. Uncorrelated strong disorder, as present in the two dimensional gauge glass model to study the vortex glass phase of high temperature superconductors in an applied magnetic field is shown to lack a finite temperature phase transition. Further, results from dynamic quantities, such as resistance and autocorrelation functions, indicate the existence of two distinct diverging correlation times, one associated with local relaxation and one associated with vortex phase slips. Correlated disorder is studied both in the superfluid transition of helium-4 and in the anisotropic critical scaling of a transverse Meissner-like transition in an experimental setup of a high temperature superconductor. For the superfluid helium transition, it is shown that the presence of fractally correlated disorder presumably alters the universality class of the pure model. Also, a comparison with experimental data suggests that the critical scaling theory describing the heat capacity of helium-4 may need to be modified in the presence of the disorder. In the case of superconductors, analyzing experimental data from resistance measurements in a system with columnar defects together with an anisotropy in the applied magnetic field, reveals a fully anisotropic scaling regime. Finally, a data analysis is presented from simulations of a charged particle gas system in three dimensions, where the normal Coulomb interaction between charges is changed into a logarithmic interaction. Previous work indicates the possibility of a transition similar to the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in certain two dimensional systems. On the contrary, our simulations seem to favor a system whose critical scaling behavior is consistent with a transition occurring only at zero critical temperature. Overall, disorder in the model systems studied leads to important modifications of the critical scaling properties of pure systems, and thereby also to possible changes of the corresponding universality classes. This results in interesting predictions with experimentally relevant consequences.