Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Second Order Corrections to the Variational Approximation to Frolich's Polaron Model

John Reinhold Valainis

Published Sep 12, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Using Feynman's path integral variational principle with a general quadratic trial action, we obtain equations for the absorption function of Frolich's polaron model. We evaluate numerically this absorption function in several cases. To test the accuracy of the variational absorption function, we develop formulas for the second order corrections to the absorption function and evaluate these numerically. Rather than evaluating the correction directly in the double path integral formalism, we make analytic continuations in time which reduce the amount of labor involved in deriving the expressions for the corrections. The method of analytic continuation in time is generalized in such a way as to allow application of the variational principle to nonlinear transport problems and time dependent problems. Finally, we present the variational equations and the second order corrections to them for a somewhat more realistic model of an electron in a crystal.

DOI
10.7907/e8k0-8q33

Related papers

Direct path-integral treatment of the polaron problem

Arkady L. Kholodenko, Karl F. Freed

Direct evaluation of Feynman's functional integral for the polaron maps it into a standard type of many-body theory. The perturbation expansion is shown to be well controlled and does not require any renormalization. This perturbation expansion has the pleasing feature that $n\mathrm{th}$-order terms in the polaron coupling constant are obtained from $n\mathrm{th}$-order perturbation theory, whereas the traditional perturbation formulation in terms of creation and annihilation operators requires a $2n\mathrm{th}$-order perturbation calculation to generate the same results. In contrast to previous beliefs, the method is shown to enable the calculation of the polaron effective mass and relaxation time directly from the functional-integral expression. The ground-state energy is computed to second order in the polaron coupling constant to illustrate the use of the method and to establish agreement with previous perturbation treatments. In addition, we provide the first perturbation calculation of the polaron effective mass through second order in the coupling constant. Pad\'e approximants are shown to provide a vehicle for analytically extending the perturbation results into the region of intermediate and strong couplings, and the procedure yields reasonable agreement with variational calculations for values of the polaron coupling constant up to about $\ensuremath{\alpha}=10$. In addition, conditions are derived under which the original polaron action, used in the functional integral, reduces to some of the best variational trial actions utilized in the literature.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 15, 1983•23 citations

Path-Integral Solutions of the Fröhlich Hamiltonian

Ashok Chatterjee, Soma Mukhopadhyay

This chapter presents a brief introduction to the path-integral method before applying it to the polaron problem. The coupling theory is based on the path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics developed by Feynman in 1955. The path-integral formalism proves to be a useful tool for many field-theoretic problems. Feynman's path-integral method as applied by Feynman to determine the polaron effective mass has an intuitive rather than formal basis. The comparison revealed unequivocally the superiority of the Feynman model over the entire range of the coupling constant. Schultz also simulated the Feynman approximation by replacing the whole lattice with a second, fictitious particle harmonically bound to the electron by a spring of constant k. Thus, the Feynman's strong-coupling energy is better than the Landau-Pekar energy with the Gaussian trial function. The numerical results reported by Marshall and Mills show that the second-order correction to the Feynman result for the ground state energy is less than 2% for the entire coupling rang.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 9, 2018•0 citations

Theory of a Polaron at Finite Temperatures

Motohiko Saitoh

In order to calculate the effective mass and free energy of a polaron at finite temperatures, Feynman's path-integral formalism is generalized in the following two points: (a) the most general quadratic form is used to fully optimize the partition function, and (b) the new definition of the effective mass is introduced such that the effective mass is determined from the acceleration rate against the fictitious driving force which is incorporated in the original Lagrangian. The use of (a) leads to a non-linear integral equation which determines the best trial form. This non-linear integral equation is solved analytically for the Fröhlich polaron model to obtain the explicit expressions for the effective mass and free energy at finite temperatures.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Sep 1, 1980•70 citations

Fourier path integrals, partial averaging, and the polaron problem

Constantia Alexandrou, Wolfgang Fleischer, R. Rosenfelder

We evaluate the Fourier path integral for an optical polaron by the method of partial averaging. Higher Fourier coefficients are taken into account by averaging with Feynman's trial action, whereas the first N coefficients are treated explicitly by numerical integration. This method removes the Coulomb singularity in the effective action, yields lower bounds to the partition function, and systematically improves Feynman's variational results. We present numerical results for the exact ground-state energy for small and intermediate values of the coupling constant.

Physical Review Letters•Nov 19, 1990•28 citations

Variational Methods for Path Integral Scattering

Julien Carron

In this master thesis, a new approximation scheme to non-relativistic potential scattering is developed and discussed. The starting points are two exact path integral representations of the T-matrix, which permit the application of the Feynman-Jensen variational method. A simple Ansatz for the trial action is made, and, in both cases, the variational procedure singles out a particular one-particle classical equation of motion, given in integral form. While the first is real, in the second representation this trajectory is complex and evolves according to an effective, time dependent potential. Using a cumulant expansion, the first correction to the variational approximation is also evaluated. The high energy behavior of the approximation is investigated, and is shown to contain exactly the leading and next-to-leading order of the eikonal expansion, and parts of higher terms. Our results are then numerically tested in two particular situations where others approximations turned out to be unsatisfactory. Substantial improvements are found.

arXiv:0903.0273•Mar 2, 2009•4 citations

Free Energy of the Fröhlich Polaron in Two and Three Dimensions

John Tatini Titantah, Carlo Pierleoni, Sergio Ciuchi

We present a novel path integral Monte Carlo scheme to solve the Fröhlich polaron model. At intermediate and strong electron-phonon couplings, the polaron self-trapping is properly taken into account at the level of an effective action obtained by a preaveraging procedure with a retarded trial action. We compute the free energy at several couplings and temperatures in three and two dimensions. Our results show that the accuracy of the Feynman variational upper bound for the free energy is always within a few percent. The method can be generalized to the N-polarons case.

arXiv:cond-mat/0010386•Physical Review Letters•Oct 30, 2001•26 citations
Using Feynman's path integral variational principle with a general quadratic trial action, we obtain equations for the absorption function of Frolich's polaron model. We evaluate numerically this absorption function in several cases. To test the accuracy of the variational absorption function, we develop formulas for the second order corrections to the absorption function and evaluate these numerically. Rather than evaluating the correction directly in the double path integral formalism, we make analytic continuations in time which reduce the amount of labor involved in deriving the expressions for the corrections. The method of analytic continuation in time is generalized in such a way as to allow application of the variational principle to nonlinear transport problems and time dependent problems. Finally, we present the variational equations and the second order corrections to them for a somewhat more realistic model of an electron in a crystal.
Direct evaluation of Feynman's functional integral for the polaron maps it into a standard type of many-body theory. The perturbation expansion is shown to be well controlled and does not require any renormalization. This perturbation expansion has the pleasing feature that nthn\mathrm{th}nth-order terms in the polaron coupling constant are obtained from nthn\mathrm{th}nth-order perturbation theory, whereas the traditional perturbation formulation in terms of creation and annihilation operators requires a 2nth2n\mathrm{th}2nth-order perturbation calculation to generate the same results. In contrast to previous beliefs, the method is shown to enable the calculation of the polaron effective mass and relaxation time directly from the functional-integral expression. The ground-state energy is computed to second order in the polaron coupling constant to illustrate the use of the method and to establish agreement with previous perturbation treatments. In addition, we provide the first perturbation calculation of the polaron effective mass through second order in the coupling constant. Pad\'e approximants are shown to provide a vehicle for analytically extending the perturbation results into the region of intermediate and strong couplings, and the procedure yields reasonable agreement with variational calculations for values of the polaron coupling constant up to about $\ensuremath{\alpha}=10$. In addition, conditions are derived under which the original polaron action, used in the functional integral, reduces to some of the best variational trial actions utilized in the literature.
This chapter presents a brief introduction to the path-integral method before applying it to the polaron problem. The coupling theory is based on the path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics developed by Feynman in 1955. The path-integral formalism proves to be a useful tool for many field-theoretic problems. Feynman's path-integral method as applied by Feynman to determine the polaron effective mass has an intuitive rather than formal basis. The comparison revealed unequivocally the superiority of the Feynman model over the entire range of the coupling constant. Schultz also simulated the Feynman approximation by replacing the whole lattice with a second, fictitious particle harmonically bound to the electron by a spring of constant k. Thus, the Feynman's strong-coupling energy is better than the Landau-Pekar energy with the Gaussian trial function. The numerical results reported by Marshall and Mills show that the second-order correction to the Feynman result for the ground state energy is less than 2% for the entire coupling rang.
In order to calculate the effective mass and free energy of a polaron at finite temperatures, Feynman's path-integral formalism is generalized in the following two points: (a) the most general quadratic form is used to fully optimize the partition function, and (b) the new definition of the effective mass is introduced such that the effective mass is determined from the acceleration rate against the fictitious driving force which is incorporated in the original Lagrangian. The use of (a) leads to a non-linear integral equation which determines the best trial form. This non-linear integral equation is solved analytically for the Fröhlich polaron model to obtain the explicit expressions for the effective mass and free energy at finite temperatures.
We evaluate the Fourier path integral for an optical polaron by the method of partial averaging. Higher Fourier coefficients are taken into account by averaging with Feynman's trial action, whereas the first N coefficients are treated explicitly by numerical integration. This method removes the Coulomb singularity in the effective action, yields lower bounds to the partition function, and systematically improves Feynman's variational results. We present numerical results for the exact ground-state energy for small and intermediate values of the coupling constant.
In this master thesis, a new approximation scheme to non-relativistic potential scattering is developed and discussed. The starting points are two exact path integral representations of the T-matrix, which permit the application of the Feynman-Jensen variational method. A simple Ansatz for the trial action is made, and, in both cases, the variational procedure singles out a particular one-particle classical equation of motion, given in integral form. While the first is real, in the second representation this trajectory is complex and evolves according to an effective, time dependent potential. Using a cumulant expansion, the first correction to the variational approximation is also evaluated. The high energy behavior of the approximation is investigated, and is shown to contain exactly the leading and next-to-leading order of the eikonal expansion, and parts of higher terms. Our results are then numerically tested in two particular situations where others approximations turned out to be unsatisfactory. Substantial improvements are found.
We present a novel path integral Monte Carlo scheme to solve the Fröhlich polaron model. At intermediate and strong electron-phonon couplings, the polaron self-trapping is properly taken into account at the level of an effective action obtained by a preaveraging procedure with a retarded trial action. We compute the free energy at several couplings and temperatures in three and two dimensions. Our results show that the accuracy of the Feynman variational upper bound for the free energy is always within a few percent. The method can be generalized to the N-polarons case.