Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Reflection Positivity in Heisenberg and Ice-Type Models

J.J.A.M. de Groot

Published Jan 1, 2020• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This thesis gives a thorough description of the mathematical tool called reflection positivity, which can be used to prove the occurrence of phase transitions in physical models. A major result, although already known, is a theorem that gives tractable conditions on the Hamiltonian such that the Boltzmann functional is reflection positive. In this thesis, the theorem is used to give conditions on free parameters in four different models, such that the model is reflection positive with respect to certain chosen reflections. The evaluated models are (a) the antiferromagnetic quantum Heisenberg model; (b) the spin ice model; (c) the 6-vertex model and (d) the 16-vertex model. For the Heisenberg model we found that for reflections in a reflection plane there are certain parameter values such that the Boltzmann functional is reflection positive, this is an already known and published result. For the spin ice model we found that for the spin invariant reflection there is no symmetry that yields a reflection positive Boltzmann functional, this is a new result. For both the 6-vertex and 16-vertex model we showed that, for certain energy values, the Boltzmann functional is reflection positive with respect to reflections in the diagonal, which are also new results. In the case of the 16-vertex model, this boils down to checking whether or not a matrix is positive semidefinite. Using this result we showed that energy values that allow for the existence of magnetic monopoles do not yield a reflection positive Boltzmann functional. A topic for further research is investigating the occurrence of phase transitions in the models that are shown to be reflection positive, for which chessboard estimates seem to be a promising approach. Furthermore, in this thesis it was not rigorously proved that the spin ice model with a spin inverting reflection gives a reflection positive Boltzmann functional for rotational symmetry or symmetry in a reflection plane. This is believed to be true, but does require further investigation.

Related papers

Strongly Correlated Electron Systems: Spin-Reflection Positivity and Some Rigorous Results

Shun-Qing Shen

Theory of spin-reflection positivity developed in recent years is reviewed. This theory makes use of symmetries in an electron system and theory of matrix to investigate the ground state properties. Existences of anti- and ferromagnetic long-range orders in itinerant electron systems, and of off-diagonal long-range order are two successful applications of the theory. In this article, the author attempt to summarize exact results proved by utilizing this theory and related topics. First a general theory and basic theorems are introduced. Second, based on the band structures of conduction electrons, existences of a singlet state with strongly antiferromagnetic correlation, a state with both anti- and ferromagnetic long-range orders, and a fully saturated ferromagnetic state are proved. The theory is applied to several of the main theoretical models for strongly correlated electron systems, such as the Heisenberg model, the Hubbard model, the Anderson model, the single- and multichannel Kondo model, and the generalized Hubbard model, and a series of rigorous results are found in these models. Third, it is proved that off-diagonal long-range order and charge-density wave exist in the ground states of the attractive Hubbard model and the generalized Hubbard model. A relation between pseudospin symmetry and the uniform density theorem is introduced. Fourth, the theory is applied successfully to explain experimental observations of oscillatory interlayer magnetic coupling in ultrathin magnetic films. Finally several unsolved problems are discussed. All results introduced in this article are mathematically exact.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Mar 30, 1998•46 citations

Reflection Positivity, Magnetic Lattice Laplacians and Emergent Phases in Lattice Fermionic Systems

Leonardo Goller

Emergent phenomena in interacting fermionic systems often arise as collective many-body effects whose formation can be understood by studying the interplay between geometry and symmetry. Understanding such phenomena from first principles remains one of the central challenges of Mathematical Physics, particularly in regimes where perturbative methods fail and non-trivial phases emerge through strongly correlated dynamics. This thesis investigates a class of lattice fermionic systems exhibiting \textit{Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking}, \textit{Flux ordering} and \textit{Topological Order}. Although the models considered belong to different physical frameworks, including Euclidean lattice field theories formulated in terms of Grassmann variables and Quantum Lattice Systems described by operators acting on Hilbert spaces, they share a common mathematical structure. In each case, geometric features encoded by lattice Dirac operators, magnetic fluxes, and discrete gauge fields interact with Reflection Positivity properties that allow for a rigorous non-perturbative analysis. A central role throughout the thesis is indeed played by \textit{Reflection Positivity} and one of its most striking consequences: the \textit{Chessboard Estimates}. These methods provide powerful tools for converting geometric information into quantitative bounds on energies, correlation functions, and phase stability. The first part of the thesis, based on \cite{fabbri2026chirallongrangeordereuclidean}, is devoted to lattice Gross–Neveu models in two dimensional Euclidean Spacetime. After a Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation, the fermionic theories are mapped to effective bosonic systems for which Reflection Positivity can be established. Combining Reflection Positivity methods with Peierls' Argument, we prove the existence of Chiral Long-Range Order for a class of lattice regularizations and obtain quantitative bounds relating the order parameter to the minimizers of the effective potential. The second part, based on \cite{GP}, focuses on fermions coupled to dynamical $\mathbb{Z}_2$-gauge fields. We prove the stability of the $\pi$-flux phase under gauging by showing that monopole excitations possess a strictly positive energy cost. These results imply the emergence of effective Dirac fermions at low energies and provide a rigorous characterization of the semimetallic phase of the model. Finally, we investigate the topological phase obtained by introducing a fermionic mass gap in the $\pi$-flux phase, following \cite{bachmann2026anyonspifluxphasefermionic}. We prove the existence of an almost four-fold degenerate low-energy sector on the torus, separated from the rest of the spectrum by a uniform gap, and construct quasi-local loop and string operators whose algebra exhibits the characteristic toric-code braiding phases. This provides a rigorous realization of topological order emerging from interacting fermions coupled to a dynamical gauge field. Taken together, these results illustrate how Reflection Positivity methods and spectral properties of the Magnetic Laplacian can be combined to obtain rigorous information on the phase diagram of interacting fermionic systems. They reveal a common mechanism underlying symmetry breaking, flux stabilization, and topological order across a variety of lattice models.

•Sep 25, 2026•0 citations

Reflection positivity and a refined index for 2d invertible phases

Nikita Sopenko

We analyze the validity of reflection positivity in the classification of invertible phases of quantum spin systems. We provide a mathematical model in which every 2d invertible state admits a reflection-positive representative. We prove that reflection positivity provides a canonical lift from the set of invertible phases to the set of invertible phases protected by a $\mathbb{Z}/N$-rotational symmetry. Using this, we define a refined version of the index recently introduced by the author. This refined version conjecturally provides a microscopic characterization of an invariant that coincides with the chiral central charge $c_-$ when conformal field theory effectively describes the boundary modes.

arXiv:2509.01711•Sep 1, 2025•12 citations

Quantum spin systems, probabilistic representations and phase transitions

Benjamin Lees

This thesis investigates properties of classical and quantum spin systems on lattices. These models have been widely studied due to their relevance to condensed matter physics. We identify the ground states of an antiferromagnetic RP2 model, these ground states are very di�erent from the ferromagnetic model and there was some disagreement over their structure, we settle this disagreement. Correlation inequalities are proved for the spin- 1/2 XY model and the ground state of the spin-1 XY model. This provides fresh results in a topic that had been stagnant and allows the proof of some new results, for example existence of some correlation functions in the thermodynamic limit. The occurrence of nematic order at low temperature in a quantum nematic model is proved using the method of reflection positivity and infrared bounds. Previous results on this nematic order were achieved indirectly via a probabilistic representation. This result is maintained in the presence of a small antiferromagnetic interaction, this case was not previously covered. Probabilistic representations for quantum spin systems are introduced and some consequences are presented. In particular, N´eel order is proved in a bilinear-biquadratic spin-1 system at low temperature. This result extends the famous result of Dyson, Lieb and Simon [35]. Dilute spin systems are introduced and the occurrence of a phase transition at low temperature characterised by preferential occupation of the even or odd sublattice of a cubic box is proved. This result is the first of its type for such a mixed classical and quantum system. A probabilistic representation of the spin-1 Bose-Hubbard model is also presented and some consequences are proved.

•Sep 14, 2026•0 citations

Reflection positivity and invertible topological phases

Daniel S. Freed, Michael J. Hopkins

We implement an extended version of reflection positivity (Wick-rotated unitarity) for invertible topological quantum field theories and compute the abelian group of deformation classes using stable homotopy theory. We apply these field theory considerations to lattice systems, assuming the existence and validity of low energy effective field theory approximations, and thereby produce a general formula for the group of Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) phases in terms of Thom's bordism spectra; the only input is the dimension and symmetry group. We provide computations for fermionic systems in physically relevant dimensions. Other topics include symmetry in quantum field theories, a relativistic 10-fold way, the homotopy theory of relativistic free fermions, and a topological spin-statistics theorem.

arXiv:1604.06527•Geometry & Topology•May 20, 2021•513 citations

On numerical methods in quantum spin systems

Dmitrii Kochkov

This thesis is focused on the application and development of numerical methods for studying quantum many- body spin systems. Part I sets the stage for research projects. In chapter 1, I go over major milestones in the field of frustrated magnetism, how it fits into a larger category of condensed matter physics, and recent developments that provide context for the research projects presented in part II. Chapters 2 3 provide the reader with necessary concepts in physics of phase transitions and numerical methods that are often employed when studying ground states of quantum many body systems. Part II focuses on the research projects carried out during my PhD research. In chapter 4 I present a machine-learning inspired method for solving quantum many body problems. This method addresses issues of representation of variational wave functions and their optimization. In chapter 5, I present a numerical study on the embedding of an exactly solvable point in a phase diagram of an extended Heisenberg model on a kagome lattice. Chapter 6 studies a quantum Heisenberg model on the stuffed honeycomb lattice. Phase transitions in quantum many body systems manifest themselves as a reorganization of low energy spectra of the system. They come in a variety of forms ranging from symmetry breaking transitions, where a local order parameter is formed and to topological phase transitions where the change of the ground state can be attributed to non-local changes in the entanglement patterns. In chapter 2, I review classic models studied in the context of frustrated magnetism and briefly go over the formulation of Landau symmetry breaking theory and common order parameters. The breakdown of Landau symmetry-breaking theory for topological phase transition is discussed using the example of Resonance Valence Bond (RVB) state, which serves as a qualitative exemplification of spin liquid phases. I discuss means of detecting phase transitions with a focus on methods that are applicable in a numerical setting. Chapter 3 presents elements of the numerical machinery that the rest of the thesis employs and builds upon. I discuss traditional trade-offs and provide rough metrics used for analysis of strengths and drawbacks of different approaches. Then I focus on Exact Diagonalization (ED) and Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) methods that are used in later chapters. In chapter 4, I describe the application of machine learning techniques to the variational approach to the quantum many body problem. I introduce Computational Graph States (CGS), a new class of variational wave functions based on the dataflow programming paradigm. The use of computational graphs makes composing new wave functions easy due to its modular structure. Automatic differentiation allows us to obtain efficient derivatives with respect to variational parameters automatically. We also develop a novel optimization scheme, Supervised Wave-function Optimization. It combines ideas of supervised learning and imaginary time evolution. Our method resolves a number of technical challenges and allows seamless optimization of complicated variational models. During the exploration process we constructed a new class of system size invariant model wave functions that can be trained on one system size and generalized to other system sizes with high accuracy. In chapter 5, we study the phase diagram of the kagome antiferromagnet in the J2, Jz plane, which corresponds to second nearest neighbor interactions and spin anisotropy. We report an exactly solvable point with macroscopic degeneracy at J2 = 0, Jz = −0.5 and show that many phases emanate from around this point. In addition, we find a previously unknown transition within the spin-liquid region suggesting a possibility of two distinct spin liquids. In chapter 6, we consider a Heisenberg model on the stuffed honeycomb lattice which interpolated between the triangular and honeycomb lattices. Using exact diagonalization we compute the phase diagram of this model. We find that for this model, the triangular lattice J1-J2 spin liquid region is extended to a larger domain that has lower symmetries than that of the triangular lattice. We perform a variational study of projected BCS wave functions which we directly compare to exact ground states on 36 site cluster as well as consider variational energies from larger system sizes. We argue that construction of symmetric states is essential to obtain good variational energies and give evidence that Dirac spin-liquid state is likely to characterize the spin liquid phase.

•May 2, 2019•0 citations
This thesis gives a thorough description of the mathematical tool called reflection positivity, which can be used to prove the occurrence of phase transitions in physical models. A major result, although already known, is a theorem that gives tractable conditions on the Hamiltonian such that the Boltzmann functional is reflection positive. In this thesis, the theorem is used to give conditions on free parameters in four different models, such that the model is reflection positive with respect to certain chosen reflections. The evaluated models are (a) the antiferromagnetic quantum Heisenberg model; (b) the spin ice model; (c) the 6-vertex model and (d) the 16-vertex model. For the Heisenberg model we found that for reflections in a reflection plane there are certain parameter values such that the Boltzmann functional is reflection positive, this is an already known and published result. For the spin ice model we found that for the spin invariant reflection there is no symmetry that yields a reflection positive Boltzmann functional, this is a new result. For both the 6-vertex and 16-vertex model we showed that, for certain energy values, the Boltzmann functional is reflection positive with respect to reflections in the diagonal, which are also new results. In the case of the 16-vertex model, this boils down to checking whether or not a matrix is positive semidefinite. Using this result we showed that energy values that allow for the existence of magnetic monopoles do not yield a reflection positive Boltzmann functional. A topic for further research is investigating the occurrence of phase transitions in the models that are shown to be reflection positive, for which chessboard estimates seem to be a promising approach. Furthermore, in this thesis it was not rigorously proved that the spin ice model with a spin inverting reflection gives a reflection positive Boltzmann functional for rotational symmetry or symmetry in a reflection plane. This is believed to be true, but does require further investigation.
Theory of spin-reflection positivity developed in recent years is reviewed. This theory makes use of symmetries in an electron system and theory of matrix to investigate the ground state properties. Existences of anti- and ferromagnetic long-range orders in itinerant electron systems, and of off-diagonal long-range order are two successful applications of the theory. In this article, the author attempt to summarize exact results proved by utilizing this theory and related topics. First a general theory and basic theorems are introduced. Second, based on the band structures of conduction electrons, existences of a singlet state with strongly antiferromagnetic correlation, a state with both anti- and ferromagnetic long-range orders, and a fully saturated ferromagnetic state are proved. The theory is applied to several of the main theoretical models for strongly correlated electron systems, such as the Heisenberg model, the Hubbard model, the Anderson model, the single- and multichannel Kondo model, and the generalized Hubbard model, and a series of rigorous results are found in these models. Third, it is proved that off-diagonal long-range order and charge-density wave exist in the ground states of the attractive Hubbard model and the generalized Hubbard model. A relation between pseudospin symmetry and the uniform density theorem is introduced. Fourth, the theory is applied successfully to explain experimental observations of oscillatory interlayer magnetic coupling in ultrathin magnetic films. Finally several unsolved problems are discussed. All results introduced in this article are mathematically exact.
Emergent phenomena in interacting fermionic systems often arise as collective many-body effects whose formation can be understood by studying the interplay between geometry and symmetry. Understanding such phenomena from first principles remains one of the central challenges of Mathematical Physics, particularly in regimes where perturbative methods fail and non-trivial phases emerge through strongly correlated dynamics. This thesis investigates a class of lattice fermionic systems exhibiting \textit{Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking}, \textit{Flux ordering} and \textit{Topological Order}. Although the models considered belong to different physical frameworks, including Euclidean lattice field theories formulated in terms of Grassmann variables and Quantum Lattice Systems described by operators acting on Hilbert spaces, they share a common mathematical structure. In each case, geometric features encoded by lattice Dirac operators, magnetic fluxes, and discrete gauge fields interact with Reflection Positivity properties that allow for a rigorous non-perturbative analysis. A central role throughout the thesis is indeed played by \textit{Reflection Positivity} and one of its most striking consequences: the \textit{Chessboard Estimates}. These methods provide powerful tools for converting geometric information into quantitative bounds on energies, correlation functions, and phase stability. The first part of the thesis, based on \cite{fabbri2026chirallongrangeordereuclidean}, is devoted to lattice Gross–Neveu models in two dimensional Euclidean Spacetime. After a Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation, the fermionic theories are mapped to effective bosonic systems for which Reflection Positivity can be established. Combining Reflection Positivity methods with Peierls' Argument, we prove the existence of Chiral Long-Range Order for a class of lattice regularizations and obtain quantitative bounds relating the order parameter to the minimizers of the effective potential. The second part, based on \cite{GP}, focuses on fermions coupled to dynamical Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-gauge fields. We prove the stability of the π\piπ-flux phase under gauging by showing that monopole excitations possess a strictly positive energy cost. These results imply the emergence of effective Dirac fermions at low energies and provide a rigorous characterization of the semimetallic phase of the model. Finally, we investigate the topological phase obtained by introducing a fermionic mass gap in the π\piπ-flux phase, following \cite{bachmann2026anyonspifluxphasefermionic}. We prove the existence of an almost four-fold degenerate low-energy sector on the torus, separated from the rest of the spectrum by a uniform gap, and construct quasi-local loop and string operators whose algebra exhibits the characteristic toric-code braiding phases. This provides a rigorous realization of topological order emerging from interacting fermions coupled to a dynamical gauge field. Taken together, these results illustrate how Reflection Positivity methods and spectral properties of the Magnetic Laplacian can be combined to obtain rigorous information on the phase diagram of interacting fermionic systems. They reveal a common mechanism underlying symmetry breaking, flux stabilization, and topological order across a variety of lattice models.
We analyze the validity of reflection positivity in the classification of invertible phases of quantum spin systems. We provide a mathematical model in which every 2d invertible state admits a reflection-positive representative. We prove that reflection positivity provides a canonical lift from the set of invertible phases to the set of invertible phases protected by a Z/N\mathbb{Z}/NZ/N-rotational symmetry. Using this, we define a refined version of the index recently introduced by the author. This refined version conjecturally provides a microscopic characterization of an invariant that coincides with the chiral central charge c−c_-c−​ when conformal field theory effectively describes the boundary modes.
This thesis investigates properties of classical and quantum spin systems on lattices. These models have been widely studied due to their relevance to condensed matter physics. We identify the ground states of an antiferromagnetic RP2 model, these ground states are very di�erent from the ferromagnetic model and there was some disagreement over their structure, we settle this disagreement. Correlation inequalities are proved for the spin- 1/2 XY model and the ground state of the spin-1 XY model. This provides fresh results in a topic that had been stagnant and allows the proof of some new results, for example existence of some correlation functions in the thermodynamic limit. The occurrence of nematic order at low temperature in a quantum nematic model is proved using the method of reflection positivity and infrared bounds. Previous results on this nematic order were achieved indirectly via a probabilistic representation. This result is maintained in the presence of a small antiferromagnetic interaction, this case was not previously covered. Probabilistic representations for quantum spin systems are introduced and some consequences are presented. In particular, N´eel order is proved in a bilinear-biquadratic spin-1 system at low temperature. This result extends the famous result of Dyson, Lieb and Simon [35]. Dilute spin systems are introduced and the occurrence of a phase transition at low temperature characterised by preferential occupation of the even or odd sublattice of a cubic box is proved. This result is the first of its type for such a mixed classical and quantum system. A probabilistic representation of the spin-1 Bose-Hubbard model is also presented and some consequences are proved.
We implement an extended version of reflection positivity (Wick-rotated unitarity) for invertible topological quantum field theories and compute the abelian group of deformation classes using stable homotopy theory. We apply these field theory considerations to lattice systems, assuming the existence and validity of low energy effective field theory approximations, and thereby produce a general formula for the group of Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) phases in terms of Thom's bordism spectra; the only input is the dimension and symmetry group. We provide computations for fermionic systems in physically relevant dimensions. Other topics include symmetry in quantum field theories, a relativistic 10-fold way, the homotopy theory of relativistic free fermions, and a topological spin-statistics theorem.
This thesis is focused on the application and development of numerical methods for studying quantum many- body spin systems. Part I sets the stage for research projects. In chapter 1, I go over major milestones in the field of frustrated magnetism, how it fits into a larger category of condensed matter physics, and recent developments that provide context for the research projects presented in part II. Chapters 2 3 provide the reader with necessary concepts in physics of phase transitions and numerical methods that are often employed when studying ground states of quantum many body systems. Part II focuses on the research projects carried out during my PhD research. In chapter 4 I present a machine-learning inspired method for solving quantum many body problems. This method addresses issues of representation of variational wave functions and their optimization. In chapter 5, I present a numerical study on the embedding of an exactly solvable point in a phase diagram of an extended Heisenberg model on a kagome lattice. Chapter 6 studies a quantum Heisenberg model on the stuffed honeycomb lattice. Phase transitions in quantum many body systems manifest themselves as a reorganization of low energy spectra of the system. They come in a variety of forms ranging from symmetry breaking transitions, where a local order parameter is formed and to topological phase transitions where the change of the ground state can be attributed to non-local changes in the entanglement patterns. In chapter 2, I review classic models studied in the context of frustrated magnetism and briefly go over the formulation of Landau symmetry breaking theory and common order parameters. The breakdown of Landau symmetry-breaking theory for topological phase transition is discussed using the example of Resonance Valence Bond (RVB) state, which serves as a qualitative exemplification of spin liquid phases. I discuss means of detecting phase transitions with a focus on methods that are applicable in a numerical setting. Chapter 3 presents elements of the numerical machinery that the rest of the thesis employs and builds upon. I discuss traditional trade-offs and provide rough metrics used for analysis of strengths and drawbacks of different approaches. Then I focus on Exact Diagonalization (ED) and Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) methods that are used in later chapters. In chapter 4, I describe the application of machine learning techniques to the variational approach to the quantum many body problem. I introduce Computational Graph States (CGS), a new class of variational wave functions based on the dataflow programming paradigm. The use of computational graphs makes composing new wave functions easy due to its modular structure. Automatic differentiation allows us to obtain efficient derivatives with respect to variational parameters automatically. We also develop a novel optimization scheme, Supervised Wave-function Optimization. It combines ideas of supervised learning and imaginary time evolution. Our method resolves a number of technical challenges and allows seamless optimization of complicated variational models. During the exploration process we constructed a new class of system size invariant model wave functions that can be trained on one system size and generalized to other system sizes with high accuracy. In chapter 5, we study the phase diagram of the kagome antiferromagnet in the J2, Jz plane, which corresponds to second nearest neighbor interactions and spin anisotropy. We report an exactly solvable point with macroscopic degeneracy at J2 = 0, Jz = −0.5 and show that many phases emanate from around this point. In addition, we find a previously unknown transition within the spin-liquid region suggesting a possibility of two distinct spin liquids. In chapter 6, we consider a Heisenberg model on the stuffed honeycomb lattice which interpolated between the triangular and honeycomb lattices. Using exact diagonalization we compute the phase diagram of this model. We find that for this model, the triangular lattice J1-J2 spin liquid region is extended to a larger domain that has lower symmetries than that of the triangular lattice. We perform a variational study of projected BCS wave functions which we directly compare to exact ground states on 36 site cluster as well as consider variational energies from larger system sizes. We argue that construction of symmetric states is essential to obtain good variational energies and give evidence that Dirac spin-liquid state is likely to characterize the spin liquid phase.