Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan

Theory of Superfluid Ground State

Masakzu Ichiyanagi

Published Jun 15, 1975• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A theory is formulated for the ground state of a degenerate Bose fluid in thermal equilibrium. The fluctuations in the condensate are treated in terms of the fluctuation operators C = a 0 -α, and thir conjugate, α 0 being the annihilation operator for the zero momentum state and the order parameter α the quasiaverage of α 0 . The superfluid ground state is viewed as energy lowering by coherent excitations. The coherent state is defined in terms of the normal modes in the superfluid phase. The superfluid ground state is not the ground state of the type studied by Glassgold and Sauermann.

DOI
10.1143/jpsj.38.1586

Related papers

Equilibrium Fluctuations and Stability of the Condensate of a Degenerate Boson Fluid

A. E. Glassgold, H. Sauermann

A general theory is formulated for the fluctuations in the condensate of a degenerate boson fluid in homogeneous thermodynamic equilibrium. The point of view adopted is based on Bogoliubov's description of the condensate in terms of quasiaverages and on his "Principle of Diminishing Correlation." An essential aspect of the theory is the consistent treatment of the fluctuation operators $c$ and ${c}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$, where $c={a}_{0}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}$. ${a}_{0}$ is the annihilation operator for the zero momentum state, and the order parameter $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is the quasiaverage of ${a}_{0}$. After the Hamiltonian for the fluctuation operators is obtained, a stability condition is derived, which we then demonstrate is satisfied under very general conditions. The energy spectrum of the condensate fluctuations is shown to be discrete, and explicit expressions are derived for the quantum states of the condensate. The ground state of the condensate is not a coherent state of the type studied by Glauber. A detailed analysis is given of the fluctuations in the order parameter and in the number of particles in the condensate. The physical properties of the fluctuations are determined by two parameters, which are the averages of the second derivatives of the Hamiltonian with respect to the order parameter. These quantities are shown to be related to the one-particle Green's functions introduced by Beliaev. The implications of this general theory are also worked out for Bogoliubov's low-density, weak-coupling model. The limit of the ideal Bose gas is then shown to possess pathological features, namely an unnormalizable ground state and infinite fluctuations, in contrast to the interacting fluid where all properties are well-behaved.

Physical Review•Jun 5, 1969•15 citations

Theory of Superfluid Ground State. II

Masakazu Ichiyanagi, Masato Ooya

A theory is formulated for the ground state of a degenerated Bose system at zero temperature. By making use of the self-consistent field method, we determine the physical excitation of the system. The physical fields are obtained from the particle fields by the unitary transformation. The condensate wavefunction is determined as the expectation value of the slowly-varying field in the superfluid ground state, which is the vacuum state of the rapidly-varying (physical) field operator.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Dec 1, 1976•1 citation

The Coherence Theory of the Bose-Einstein Condensation

Yutaka Kano

The coherent-state representation of the density operator for an ideal Bose gas in a thermal equilibrium is introduced. It is shown that a pure coherent state can be an eigenstate of the Hamiltonian of the non-interacting boson system when the symmetry breaking term is added to it. However, at the limit of the vanishing “classical field” only zero-energy states can be a coherent state. It is also proved that the pure coherent state is the lowest energy state among all the zero-momentum states. The temperature dependence of the coherent state is then discussed. The diminution of the coherent state can clearly be seen as the temperature rises from zero to the critical temperature.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Mar 1, 1974•4 citations

Theory of superfluidity

Rafael F. Angulo G.

A theory of superfluidity (S.F.) is developed from first principles using two novel concepts, (1) that of a 'superfluid Ensemble' (S.E.) i.e. a 'Restricted Ensemble' constructed from a 'Separable Phase Space' (S.P.S.) admitting independent configurations, at least one set of which are statistically equivalent. (2) The notion of 'Dynamical Equivalence' (D.E.), satisfied if and only if (i) all dynamical symmetries are rearranged (not broken) for two Lagrangian formulations of the same problem and if (ii) the expectation values of all the constants of motion are the same, even if their functional expressions are not. The dynamical variables (d.v.) of the S.P.S. are defined from the ('q' and 'c' number) fields of the most general 'Linear Coherent State Representation', more general than those of Glauber and Bogoljubov-Valatin combined. Three independent pairs of d.v. are obtained. D.E. is proven for the Ideal Bose Gas and for a non-linear, interacting zero order Bose problem (I.Z.O.P.). An exact relation is obtained from the action principle, ensuring the cancellation of 'low and high order dangerous diagrams'. From this it follows that D.E. for the exact interacting problem must be demonstrable at infinite order of perturbation, in the finite volume limit. The I.Z.O.P. is posed in the Random Phase Approximation (R.P.A.), free from 'anomalous averages' and solved for the three branches of the excitation spectrum in a pure state description; the lowest branch is gapless, whilst the upper two coincide and show a gap. The standard strategy of linearization is found to be faulty. The partition functions for both superfluid and non-superfluid ensembles are obtained for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A. The coincident upper two branches (in a pure state description) split into a band in thermal equilibrium for the superfluid ensemble, in agreement with an upper band recently observed experimentally. O.D.L.R.O. is found in the second reduced density matrix, but ruled out in the first. Integral equations are obtained in thermal equilibrium - for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A.; which differ, however, from those of existing approaches for the same problem. Most existing theories of S.F. are in fact shown not to predict superfluid behaviour. The present theory is applicable to arbitrary Bose or Fermi systems, whether superfluid or not. O.D.L.R.O. is found to be sufficient for SF. No a priori assumption is made as to the occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation, its existence being here contingent on the solution of the integral equation; in any case, it is not to be associated with O.D.L.R.O. or S.F.

•Sep 15, 2026•0 citations

Theory of superfluidity

Gretel Quintero Angulo, F Rafael

A theory of superfluidity (S.F.) is developed from first principles using two novel concepts, (1) that of a 'superfluid Ensemble' (S.E.) i.e. a 'Restricted Ensemble' constructed from a 'Separable Phase Space' (S.P.S.) admitting independent configurations, at least one set of which are statistically equivalent. (2) The notion of 'Dynamical Equivalence' (D.E.), satisfied if and only if (i) all dynamical symmetries are rearranged (not broken) for two Lagrangian formulations of the same problem and if (ii) the expectation values of all the constants of motion are the same, even if their functional expressions are not. The dynamical variables (d.v.) of the S.P.S. are defined from the ('q' and 'c' number) fields of the most general 'Linear Coherent State Representation', more general than those of Glauber and Bogoljubov-Valatin combined. Three independent pairs of d.v. are obtained. \n \nD.E. is proven for the Ideal Bose Gas and for a non-linear, interacting zero order Bose problem (I.Z.O.P.). An exact relation is obtained from the action principle, ensuring the cancellation of 'low and high order dangerous diagrams'. From this it follows that D.E. for the exact interacting problem must be demonstrable at infinite order of perturbation, in the finite volume limit. The I.Z.O.P. is posed in the Random Phase Approximation (R.P.A.), free from 'anomalous averages' and solved for the three branches of the excitation spectrum in a pure state description; the lowest branch is gapless, whilst the upper two coincide and show a gap. The standard strategy of linearization is found to be faulty. \n \nThe partition functions for both superfluid and non-superfluid ensembles are obtained for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A. The coincident upper two branches (in a pure state description) split into a band in thermal equilibrium for the superfluid ensemble, in agreement with an upper band recently observed experimentally. O.D.L.R.O. is found in the second reduced density matrix, but ruled out in the first. Integral equations are obtained in thermal equilibrium - for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A.; which differ, however, from those of existing approaches for the same problem. Most existing theories of S.F. are in fact shown not to predict superfluid behaviour. The present theory is applicable to arbitrary Bose or Fermi systems, whether superfluid or not. O.D.L.R.O. is found to be sufficient for SF. No a priori assumption is made as to the occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation, its existence being here contingent on the solution of the integral equation; in any case, it is not to be associated with O.D.L.R.O. or S.F. \n

•Jan 1, 1983•0 citations

Superfluidity without a Bose condensate

S. I. Shevchenko

We have developed a microscopic theory of superfluidity in a two-dimensional, slightly nonideal Bose gas. The theory is rooted in the fact that a number of bosons are concentrated in the small momentum region at low temperatures when the interaction is weak, in spite of the fact that there is no Bose condensate in the two-dimensional case when T≠0. This fact lets us reduce the description of the system from one employing creation ak+ and annihilation ak operators for bosons to one based on combinations of these operators ρk and φk(ρk = S−1Σqaq+aq+k, φk· = −(i/ns) Σ(kq/k2 + l)aq+aq+k, where n is the boson density, and S is the area of the system). The description in terms of ρk and φk is simple because the hamiltonian is quadratic with respect to ρk and φk. The operators ρk and φk can also be used to express the occupation number Nk = ak+ak and current operators. We find the elementary excitation spectrum (which is identical to the Bogolyubov spectrum) and the momentum distribution of the bosons. We calculate the normal density due to thermal oscillations in the Bose gas and to interactions with impurity centers in the substrate.

Soviet Journal of Low Temperature Physics•Oct 1, 1983•1 citation
A theory is formulated for the ground state of a degenerate Bose fluid in thermal equilibrium. The fluctuations in the condensate are treated in terms of the fluctuation operators C = a 0 -α, and thir conjugate, α 0 being the annihilation operator for the zero momentum state and the order parameter α the quasiaverage of α 0 . The superfluid ground state is viewed as energy lowering by coherent excitations. The coherent state is defined in terms of the normal modes in the superfluid phase. The superfluid ground state is not the ground state of the type studied by Glassgold and Sauermann.
A general theory is formulated for the fluctuations in the condensate of a degenerate boson fluid in homogeneous thermodynamic equilibrium. The point of view adopted is based on Bogoliubov's description of the condensate in terms of quasiaverages and on his "Principle of Diminishing Correlation." An essential aspect of the theory is the consistent treatment of the fluctuation operators ccc and ${c}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$, where $c={a}_{0}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}$. a0{a}_{0}a0​ is the annihilation operator for the zero momentum state, and the order parameter $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is the quasiaverage of a0{a}_{0}a0​. After the Hamiltonian for the fluctuation operators is obtained, a stability condition is derived, which we then demonstrate is satisfied under very general conditions. The energy spectrum of the condensate fluctuations is shown to be discrete, and explicit expressions are derived for the quantum states of the condensate. The ground state of the condensate is not a coherent state of the type studied by Glauber. A detailed analysis is given of the fluctuations in the order parameter and in the number of particles in the condensate. The physical properties of the fluctuations are determined by two parameters, which are the averages of the second derivatives of the Hamiltonian with respect to the order parameter. These quantities are shown to be related to the one-particle Green's functions introduced by Beliaev. The implications of this general theory are also worked out for Bogoliubov's low-density, weak-coupling model. The limit of the ideal Bose gas is then shown to possess pathological features, namely an unnormalizable ground state and infinite fluctuations, in contrast to the interacting fluid where all properties are well-behaved.
The coherent-state representation of the density operator for an ideal Bose gas in a thermal equilibrium is introduced. It is shown that a pure coherent state can be an eigenstate of the Hamiltonian of the non-interacting boson system when the symmetry breaking term is added to it. However, at the limit of the vanishing “classical field” only zero-energy states can be a coherent state. It is also proved that the pure coherent state is the lowest energy state among all the zero-momentum states. The temperature dependence of the coherent state is then discussed. The diminution of the coherent state can clearly be seen as the temperature rises from zero to the critical temperature.
A theory of superfluidity (S.F.) is developed from first principles using two novel concepts, (1) that of a 'superfluid Ensemble' (S.E.) i.e. a 'Restricted Ensemble' constructed from a 'Separable Phase Space' (S.P.S.) admitting independent configurations, at least one set of which are statistically equivalent. (2) The notion of 'Dynamical Equivalence' (D.E.), satisfied if and only if (i) all dynamical symmetries are rearranged (not broken) for two Lagrangian formulations of the same problem and if (ii) the expectation values of all the constants of motion are the same, even if their functional expressions are not. The dynamical variables (d.v.) of the S.P.S. are defined from the ('q' and 'c' number) fields of the most general 'Linear Coherent State Representation', more general than those of Glauber and Bogoljubov-Valatin combined. Three independent pairs of d.v. are obtained. D.E. is proven for the Ideal Bose Gas and for a non-linear, interacting zero order Bose problem (I.Z.O.P.). An exact relation is obtained from the action principle, ensuring the cancellation of 'low and high order dangerous diagrams'. From this it follows that D.E. for the exact interacting problem must be demonstrable at infinite order of perturbation, in the finite volume limit. The I.Z.O.P. is posed in the Random Phase Approximation (R.P.A.), free from 'anomalous averages' and solved for the three branches of the excitation spectrum in a pure state description; the lowest branch is gapless, whilst the upper two coincide and show a gap. The standard strategy of linearization is found to be faulty. The partition functions for both superfluid and non-superfluid ensembles are obtained for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A. The coincident upper two branches (in a pure state description) split into a band in thermal equilibrium for the superfluid ensemble, in agreement with an upper band recently observed experimentally. O.D.L.R.O. is found in the second reduced density matrix, but ruled out in the first. Integral equations are obtained in thermal equilibrium - for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A.; which differ, however, from those of existing approaches for the same problem. Most existing theories of S.F. are in fact shown not to predict superfluid behaviour. The present theory is applicable to arbitrary Bose or Fermi systems, whether superfluid or not. O.D.L.R.O. is found to be sufficient for SF. No a priori assumption is made as to the occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation, its existence being here contingent on the solution of the integral equation; in any case, it is not to be associated with O.D.L.R.O. or S.F.
A theory of superfluidity (S.F.) is developed from first principles using two novel concepts, (1) that of a 'superfluid Ensemble' (S.E.) i.e. a 'Restricted Ensemble' constructed from a 'Separable Phase Space' (S.P.S.) admitting independent configurations, at least one set of which are statistically equivalent. (2) The notion of 'Dynamical Equivalence' (D.E.), satisfied if and only if (i) all dynamical symmetries are rearranged (not broken) for two Lagrangian formulations of the same problem and if (ii) the expectation values of all the constants of motion are the same, even if their functional expressions are not. The dynamical variables (d.v.) of the S.P.S. are defined from the ('q' and 'c' number) fields of the most general 'Linear Coherent State Representation', more general than those of Glauber and Bogoljubov-Valatin combined. Three independent pairs of d.v. are obtained. \n \nD.E. is proven for the Ideal Bose Gas and for a non-linear, interacting zero order Bose problem (I.Z.O.P.). An exact relation is obtained from the action principle, ensuring the cancellation of 'low and high order dangerous diagrams'. From this it follows that D.E. for the exact interacting problem must be demonstrable at infinite order of perturbation, in the finite volume limit. The I.Z.O.P. is posed in the Random Phase Approximation (R.P.A.), free from 'anomalous averages' and solved for the three branches of the excitation spectrum in a pure state description; the lowest branch is gapless, whilst the upper two coincide and show a gap. The standard strategy of linearization is found to be faulty. \n \nThe partition functions for both superfluid and non-superfluid ensembles are obtained for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A. The coincident upper two branches (in a pure state description) split into a band in thermal equilibrium for the superfluid ensemble, in agreement with an upper band recently observed experimentally. O.D.L.R.O. is found in the second reduced density matrix, but ruled out in the first. Integral equations are obtained in thermal equilibrium - for the I.Z.O.P. in the R.P.A.; which differ, however, from those of existing approaches for the same problem. Most existing theories of S.F. are in fact shown not to predict superfluid behaviour. The present theory is applicable to arbitrary Bose or Fermi systems, whether superfluid or not. O.D.L.R.O. is found to be sufficient for SF. No a priori assumption is made as to the occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation, its existence being here contingent on the solution of the integral equation; in any case, it is not to be associated with O.D.L.R.O. or S.F. \n
We have developed a microscopic theory of superfluidity in a two-dimensional, slightly nonideal Bose gas. The theory is rooted in the fact that a number of bosons are concentrated in the small momentum region at low temperatures when the interaction is weak, in spite of the fact that there is no Bose condensate in the two-dimensional case when T≠0. This fact lets us reduce the description of the system from one employing creation ak+ and annihilation ak operators for bosons to one based on combinations of these operators ρk and φk(ρk = S−1Σqaq+aq+k, φk· = −(i/ns) Σ(kq/k2 + l)aq+aq+k, where n is the boson density, and S is the area of the system). The description in terms of ρk and φk is simple because the hamiltonian is quadratic with respect to ρk and φk. The operators ρk and φk can also be used to express the occupation number Nk = ak+ak and current operators. We find the elementary excitation spectrum (which is identical to the Bogolyubov spectrum) and the momentum distribution of the bosons. We calculate the normal density due to thermal oscillations in the Bose gas and to interactions with impurity centers in the substrate.