Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Metafizika

K.F. VON WEIZSÄCKER’S RELATIONAL PROGRAMME TO BUILD PHYSICS

Andrey Yu. Sevalnikov, А.В. Родина

Published Dec 15, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper is devoted to the key ideas of K. F. von Weizsäcker. His book “Aufbau der Physik”, which is dedicated to building a unified physical theory, is in the focus. Confirming that quantum mechanics is a universal physical theory, Weizsäcker is looking for ways to construct it. Based on the logic of temporary statements, introducing the concept of the Uralternative, Weizsäcker comes to the construction of quantum theory. He shows that on its basis the theory of relativity can be obtained, the structure of space with a relational character can be deduced.

DOI
10.22363/2224-7580-2020-2-131-143

Related papers

Time in the Physical Picture of the World

Andrey Yu. Sevalnikov

The article is devoted to the problem of time in modern science, where in recent years there have been major changes related to the latest discoveries in the field of the foundations of quantum theory. The author refers to works of K.-F. von Weizsacker (which works are not well-known in Russian-speaking field). Weizsacker deploys a large-scale program of building modern physics, while starting (not only as a physicist, but also a professional philosopher) with questions of philosophical interpretation of postulates of modern physics, especially quantum mechanics. His key thesis is that time in physics is fundamentally distinct, which represents the whole physics as an integral scientific discipline. Weizsacker comes from physical and philosophical reflections, that give a special value to his work. Analyzing the conclusions of theoretical physics, namely the issues of substantiation of statistical mechanics, thermodynamics, and, above all, quantum mechanics, Weizsacker comes to the key idea of the structure of time in the substantiation of physical theory. The author in this conclusion disagrees with the opinion of most modern physicists that time has a subjective character, and the modus of the past, present and future reflects its essential character. The allocation of the time structure requires special logic. Such a logic is temporal and quantum. Starting from temporal logic, introducing the concept of possibility and probability, he comes to the substantiation of quantum mechanics. Being modal logic, it is based on the concept of possibility and probability. Key concept for Weizsacker is a binary alternative (Uralternative), closely related to the principle of superposition in quantum mechanics. By introducing the concept of certain alternatives, essentially actualized alternatives, Weizsacker shows how one can get the theory of relativity with its space-time structure. Further, he shows that based on its structure, you can get the theory of relativity. The space-time structure in this case is secondary, relational, as understood by Leibniz, Mach, and Einstein.

Epistemology & Philosophy of Science•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

The Encompassing Present

Andrey Yu. Sevalnikov

The article continues the research on the phenomenon of the present time in the work of K.F. von Weizsäcker “The Construction of Physics”. Weizsäcker considers the phenomenon of time based on its phenomenological and specific quantum mechanical description. This work deals to a greater extent with the last aspect of the description of time. Based on a scrupulous analysis of mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics (QM), Weizsäcker states that time is such a paradoxical structure, which escapes clear definitions, that it can be “expressed only in the form of negations”. He is led to this conclusion by the analysis of time as a real parameter which reduces to point time, that is, when we begin to consider zero-time intervals. The general formalism of QM forces us to aban­don such ideas. Considering that all the concepts of QM relate to the concept of probability, and the concept of fact with the concept of double probability p (a, b), Weizsäcker makes a far-reaching conclusion: some act of the present (a), “fact”, turns out to be only a possibility in the future of some class of events (b) that document this fact. In this kind of process, one can see how “the future af­fects the past”. Experiments have been conducted to confirm this phenomenon. We are talking about experiments with a “quantum eraser”. Within this approach, events are considered as reversible, which can be eliminated under certain condi­tions. Based on the phenomenological understanding, Weizsäcker formulates the concept of “the encompassing present”, which already includes the past, the present, and the future. From here, he formulates his main conclusion that a genuine event exists only in the all-encompassing present.

Voprosy filosofii•Dec 4, 2024•0 citations

On von Weizsäcker's philosophy of Quantum Mechanics

Daniel Parrochia

We are interested here in the program of reconstruction of quantum mechanics of the German physicist and philosopher Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker, which still has some supporters today. In the major part of this article, we limit ourselves to examining purely epistemological and philosophical questions. The theory of the German physicist is often interpreted with reference to Kant, but the most of the time in a rather vague way (categories of understanding, theory of experience). We can afford to be more precise. First we situate the theory of fundamental alternatives (or Ur-alternatives) of von Weizsäcker in the lineage of the Kantian theory of the transcendental Ideal. We then show that the physicist only substitutes for the classical logic, on which Kant relied, a quantum logic allowing to generate, from the alternatives, via the local isomorphism between certain spinor groups and groups linked to space-time, the whole of physical reality to which we have access. After examining some problems, we finally show how this perspective leads to a quantum theory of information.

arXiv:2103.07311•Mar 9, 2021•1 citation

Die einheitliche Beschreibung der fundamentalen Objekte und Wechselwirkungen der Natur in der Quantentheorie der Ur-Alternativen

Martin Kober

In this research work the quantum theory of Ur-alternatives of Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker is considered. In This theory all objects and interactions in nature are constituted by abstract purely quantum logical relations in time. Such structures can be devided into binary alternatives, which are called Ur-Alternatives with respect to this principle meaning, and this leads to a tensor space of many Ur-alternatives. The indistinguishability of the Ur-alternatives yields two Hilbert spaces, the tensor space of symmetric and antisymmetric states under permutations of the Ur-alternatives. It is shown how the structures in the symmetric space can be represented in a three dimensional real position space connected to time according to special relativity. Accordingly this theory obtains ultimately a deep understanding of the EPR-paradox, since logic is independent of topological structures and causal relations in space. The antisymmetric space, which because of the Pauli principle contains much less degress of freedem, yields the additional quantum numbers of the elementary particles. Based on the demand for the highest possible symmetry in the tensor space, the Yang-Mills gauge theories of the standard model as well as a translational gauge formulation of general relativity in a purely quantum logical description are derived. The equations determine entanglements of states containing many Ur-alternatives and this concept is the analogue to classical pointwise interactions between separated objects. This means that the main structures of the SU(N)-interactions of the standard model of elementary particle physics as well as gravitation according to general relativiy are unified in a purely quantum theoretical conceptional framework. Finally it is derived an extended version of the E8-group, the biggest exceptional Lie-group.

arXiv:1809.02469•Aug 24, 2018•0 citations

Features of the interpretation of physical knowledge on the example of the works of K. F. von Weizsäcker and H.-P. Dürr

А.В. Родина, Andrey Yu. Sevalnikov

The article is devoted to the interpretation of physical knowledge in the works "Structure of Physics" by K. F. von Weizsäcker and “Matter does not exist” by H.-P. Dürr. These works reveal a special understanding of matter in quantum mechanics. In the interpretation of physical knowledge H.-P. Dürr and K. F. von Weizsäcker postulate a special interpretation of matter within the framework of quantum theory, namely the inseparability of consciousness from matter. At the same time, we emphasize the fundamental difference between these approaches. H.-P. Dürr remains in the position of Advaita-Vedanta, his approach is closer to Eastern metaphysics, Weizsäcker adheres to the Western epistemological tradition, presenting physics as what we can know about matter. Heidegger also touches this issue, he criticizes the concept of "object" and "subject" in modern science, but does not say that both concepts must somehow be combined.

Vox Philosophical journal•Sep 30, 2021•0 citations

Raum, Zeit und Wechselwirkung in der Quantentheorie der Ur-Alternativen

Martin Kober

The quantum theory of Ur-alternatives of Carl Friedrich von Weizsaecker tries to constitute general quantum theory based on the concept of logical alternatives in time. Based on this interpretation of quantum theory the existence of free objects in space, their symmetry properties and their interactions shall be inferred. The alternatives are represented by binary alternatives, which are called Ur-alternatives because of their logically fundamental character. Through Ur-alternatives as elementary quantum theoretical units of information the Copernican revolution with respect to the question of space is realized in a consequent way. This means that not the objects of nature are in a given space, but the existence of space arises as a kind of indirect representation of relations between abstract quantum theoretical objects. The Ur-alternatives do not exist in a given physical reality, but the existence of space is constituted by Ur-alternatives at all. Such a concept of reality is implicitly contained within the uncertainty relation and can be seen especially in the EPR-paradoxon. It is shown in this thesis in a mathematical consistent way that a state in the tensor space of many Ur-alternatives can directly be mapped into a real three dimensional space which means that together with the dynamics a representation in a (3+1)-dimensional space-time becomes possible. By considering the $G_2$ an approach for the incorporation of the internal symmetries can be suggested. Furthermore the Ur-alternatives enable the constitution of a concept of interaction, which is based on quantum theoretical entanglement. By using this concept it is tried to obtain a purely quantum theoretical description of electromagnetism and gravity. This corresponds to a much more principle and in a radical sense background independent way of quantization.

arXiv:1707.08640•Jul 25, 2017•0 citations
This paper is devoted to the key ideas of K. F. von Weizsäcker. His book “Aufbau der Physik”, which is dedicated to building a unified physical theory, is in the focus. Confirming that quantum mechanics is a universal physical theory, Weizsäcker is looking for ways to construct it. Based on the logic of temporary statements, introducing the concept of the Uralternative, Weizsäcker comes to the construction of quantum theory. He shows that on its basis the theory of relativity can be obtained, the structure of space with a relational character can be deduced.
The article is devoted to the problem of time in modern science, where in recent years there have been major changes related to the latest discoveries in the field of the foundations of quantum theory. The author refers to works of K.-F. von Weizsacker (which works are not well-known in Russian-speaking field). Weizsacker deploys a large-scale program of building modern physics, while starting (not only as a physicist, but also a professional philosopher) with questions of philosophical interpretation of postulates of modern physics, especially quantum mechanics. His key thesis is that time in physics is fundamentally distinct, which represents the whole physics as an integral scientific discipline. Weizsacker comes from physical and philosophical reflections, that give a special value to his work. Analyzing the conclusions of theoretical physics, namely the issues of substantiation of statistical mechanics, thermodynamics, and, above all, quantum mechanics, Weizsacker comes to the key idea of the structure of time in the substantiation of physical theory. The author in this conclusion disagrees with the opinion of most modern physicists that time has a subjective character, and the modus of the past, present and future reflects its essential character. The allocation of the time structure requires special logic. Such a logic is temporal and quantum. Starting from temporal logic, introducing the concept of possibility and probability, he comes to the substantiation of quantum mechanics. Being modal logic, it is based on the concept of possibility and probability. Key concept for Weizsacker is a binary alternative (Uralternative), closely related to the principle of superposition in quantum mechanics. By introducing the concept of certain alternatives, essentially actualized alternatives, Weizsacker shows how one can get the theory of relativity with its space-time structure. Further, he shows that based on its structure, you can get the theory of relativity. The space-time structure in this case is secondary, relational, as understood by Leibniz, Mach, and Einstein.
The article continues the research on the phenomenon of the present time in the work of K.F. von Weizsäcker “The Construction of Physics”. Weizsäcker considers the phenomenon of time based on its phenomenological and specific quantum mechanical description. This work deals to a greater extent with the last aspect of the description of time. Based on a scrupulous analysis of mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics (QM), Weizsäcker states that time is such a paradoxical structure, which escapes clear definitions, that it can be “expressed only in the form of negations”. He is led to this conclusion by the analysis of time as a real parameter which reduces to point time, that is, when we begin to consider zero-time intervals. The general formalism of QM forces us to aban­don such ideas. Considering that all the concepts of QM relate to the concept of probability, and the concept of fact with the concept of double probability p (a, b), Weizsäcker makes a far-reaching conclusion: some act of the present (a), “fact”, turns out to be only a possibility in the future of some class of events (b) that document this fact. In this kind of process, one can see how “the future af­fects the past”. Experiments have been conducted to confirm this phenomenon. We are talking about experiments with a “quantum eraser”. Within this approach, events are considered as reversible, which can be eliminated under certain condi­tions. Based on the phenomenological understanding, Weizsäcker formulates the concept of “the encompassing present”, which already includes the past, the present, and the future. From here, he formulates his main conclusion that a genuine event exists only in the all-encompassing present.
We are interested here in the program of reconstruction of quantum mechanics of the German physicist and philosopher Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker, which still has some supporters today. In the major part of this article, we limit ourselves to examining purely epistemological and philosophical questions. The theory of the German physicist is often interpreted with reference to Kant, but the most of the time in a rather vague way (categories of understanding, theory of experience). We can afford to be more precise. First we situate the theory of fundamental alternatives (or Ur-alternatives) of von Weizsäcker in the lineage of the Kantian theory of the transcendental Ideal. We then show that the physicist only substitutes for the classical logic, on which Kant relied, a quantum logic allowing to generate, from the alternatives, via the local isomorphism between certain spinor groups and groups linked to space-time, the whole of physical reality to which we have access. After examining some problems, we finally show how this perspective leads to a quantum theory of information.
In this research work the quantum theory of Ur-alternatives of Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker is considered. In This theory all objects and interactions in nature are constituted by abstract purely quantum logical relations in time. Such structures can be devided into binary alternatives, which are called Ur-Alternatives with respect to this principle meaning, and this leads to a tensor space of many Ur-alternatives. The indistinguishability of the Ur-alternatives yields two Hilbert spaces, the tensor space of symmetric and antisymmetric states under permutations of the Ur-alternatives. It is shown how the structures in the symmetric space can be represented in a three dimensional real position space connected to time according to special relativity. Accordingly this theory obtains ultimately a deep understanding of the EPR-paradox, since logic is independent of topological structures and causal relations in space. The antisymmetric space, which because of the Pauli principle contains much less degress of freedem, yields the additional quantum numbers of the elementary particles. Based on the demand for the highest possible symmetry in the tensor space, the Yang-Mills gauge theories of the standard model as well as a translational gauge formulation of general relativity in a purely quantum logical description are derived. The equations determine entanglements of states containing many Ur-alternatives and this concept is the analogue to classical pointwise interactions between separated objects. This means that the main structures of the SU(N)-interactions of the standard model of elementary particle physics as well as gravitation according to general relativiy are unified in a purely quantum theoretical conceptional framework. Finally it is derived an extended version of the E8-group, the biggest exceptional Lie-group.
The article is devoted to the interpretation of physical knowledge in the works "Structure of Physics" by K. F. von Weizsäcker and “Matter does not exist” by H.-P. Dürr. These works reveal a special understanding of matter in quantum mechanics. In the interpretation of physical knowledge H.-P. Dürr and K. F. von Weizsäcker postulate a special interpretation of matter within the framework of quantum theory, namely the inseparability of consciousness from matter. At the same time, we emphasize the fundamental difference between these approaches. H.-P. Dürr remains in the position of Advaita-Vedanta, his approach is closer to Eastern metaphysics, Weizsäcker adheres to the Western epistemological tradition, presenting physics as what we can know about matter. Heidegger also touches this issue, he criticizes the concept of "object" and "subject" in modern science, but does not say that both concepts must somehow be combined.
The quantum theory of Ur-alternatives of Carl Friedrich von Weizsaecker tries to constitute general quantum theory based on the concept of logical alternatives in time. Based on this interpretation of quantum theory the existence of free objects in space, their symmetry properties and their interactions shall be inferred. The alternatives are represented by binary alternatives, which are called Ur-alternatives because of their logically fundamental character. Through Ur-alternatives as elementary quantum theoretical units of information the Copernican revolution with respect to the question of space is realized in a consequent way. This means that not the objects of nature are in a given space, but the existence of space arises as a kind of indirect representation of relations between abstract quantum theoretical objects. The Ur-alternatives do not exist in a given physical reality, but the existence of space is constituted by Ur-alternatives at all. Such a concept of reality is implicitly contained within the uncertainty relation and can be seen especially in the EPR-paradoxon. It is shown in this thesis in a mathematical consistent way that a state in the tensor space of many Ur-alternatives can directly be mapped into a real three dimensional space which means that together with the dynamics a representation in a (3+1)-dimensional space-time becomes possible. By considering the G2G_2G2​ an approach for the incorporation of the internal symmetries can be suggested. Furthermore the Ur-alternatives enable the constitution of a concept of interaction, which is based on quantum theoretical entanglement. By using this concept it is tried to obtain a purely quantum theoretical description of electromagnetism and gravity. This corresponds to a much more principle and in a radical sense background independent way of quantization.