Modern quantum theory is based on de Broglie’s relation between momentum and wave-length. In this article we investigate certain inconsistencies in its formulation and propose a reformulation to resolve them. 1 Inconsistencies in de Broglie’s relation Edward MacKinnon made a critical analysis [1–3] of Louis de Broglie’s doctoral thesis of 1924 [4]. With this thesis de Broglie is credited with deriving the first relationship between the momentum of a particle and its associated quantum wave-length. MacKinnon’s discussion draws some remarkable con-clusions. He points out that the most paradoxical feature of de Broglie’s thesis is the fact that, although his fundamental argument is essentially relativistic, the only successful appli-cations of his ideas were essentially nonrelativistic. It is well known that his relationship λ = h/mv was applied to the Bohr atom and later to the derivation of Schrödinger’s equation,
Modern quantum theory is based on de Broglie’s relation between momentum and wave-length. In this article we investigate certain inconsistencies in its formulation and propose a reformulation to resolve them. 1 Inconsistencies in de Broglie’s relation Edward MacKinnon made a critical analysis [1–3] of Louis de Broglie’s doctoral thesis of 1924 [4]. With this thesis de Broglie is credited with deriving the first relationship between the momentum of a particle and its associated quantum wave-length. MacKinnon’s discussion draws some remarkable con-clusions. He points out that the most paradoxical feature of de Broglie’s thesis is the fact that, although his fundamental argument is essentially relativistic, the only successful appli-cations of his ideas were essentially nonrelativistic. It is well known that his relationship λ = h/mv was applied to the Bohr atom and later to the derivation of Schrödinger’s equation,
Louis de Broglie’s doctoral thesis developed a concept of waves associated with material particles that was soon incorporated into wave mechanics and later supported by experimental demonstrations. De Broglie’s original development, however, relied on an incorrect identification of two quite different relations: the relation between the velocity of a particle and the relation between the group velocity of a wave packet and the velocity of individual waves in the packet. A clarification of this difference and its historial significance is followed by a tentative account of the reasons why de Broglie’s well-known formula proved successful, though the theory supporting it rested on a conceptual confusion. Finally, this development and clarification are related to some of the difficulties involved in the attempts top fashion a coherent interpretation of quantum theory.
This paper analyzes the quantities of energy and momentum in the definitional rela-tionship of relativistic mechanics, in the de Broglie momentum hypothesis and in the Klein-Gordon, Dirac and Schrodinger equation. The results of analysis shows that Planck constant and relativistic relationships on the length contraction and increase in mass are a reflection of the same physical principles in nature, that λ designated in the de Broglie hypothesis λ =h/mv as the wave of matter with rest state value λ = ∞ must be connected with a real dimension of a particle with rest state value λ = lo = moc and that on this ba-sis we can come to the fundamental equations of quantum mechanics that are the Klein-Gordon, Dirac and Schrodinger equation without the necessity of the wave functions.
Bohr’s theory of the atom was in trouble as soon as it was formulated. Further detailed spectroscopy studies encouraged a proliferation of quantum numbers and ‘selection rules’ in what became known as the Bohr–Sommerfeld model. It couldn’t last, and by 1925 the theory was in crisis. The immediate concern was with the quantum numbers themselves. Where did they come from? Could de Broglie’s hypothesis shed any light? In October 1925 the attentions of Erwin Schrödinger were drawn to a footnote in one of Einstein’s recent papers. Intrigued, Schrödinger acquired a copy of de Broglie’s PhD thesis. Although he eventually published a more obscure derivation, Schrödinger essentially applied the de Broglie relation to the classical equation of wave motion. He applied the result to the hydrogen atom, and showed that the quantum numbers emerge ‘in the same natural way as the integers specifying the number of nodes in a vibrating string’.
Louis de Broglie’s original theory of matter waves has until very recently received relatively little treatment in the literature on history and foundations of physics. This paper attempts to clarify a number of aspects of de Broglie’s theory, as formulated primarily in his famous thesis, which still give rise to confusion or debate. To this end, a re-examination is made of the scope and validity of the relativistic physics employed in de Broglie’s arguments concerning the existence of phase waves and their physical implications. Recent doubts concerning the soundness of de Broglie’s introduction of a wave group associated with the quantum are also analyzed in detail, and it is argued that the wave group indeed has a problematic, if minor, role in the overall theory.
In the first two chapters we have examined the basic principles – superposition (p. 18), complementarity (p. 19), quantization (p. 44), statistical algorithm (p. 57), and correspondence (p. 72) (see also Subsec. 2.3.4) – and the basic entities, observables and states, of quantum mechanics, as well as the main differences with respect to classical mechanics. While what we have discussed so far is rather a static picture of observables and states, in this chapter we shall deal with quantum dynamics, i.e. with the time evolution of quantum-mechanical systems. Historically, after Bohr had provided a quantized description of the atom (see Subsec. 1.5.4), Einstein showed the quantized nature of photons (see Subsec. 1.2.1), and de Broglie hypothized the wave-like nature of matter (see Subsec. 1.5.5), the first building block of quantum mechanics was provided by the commutation relations, proposed by Heisenberg in 1925, whose consequence is represented by the uncertainty relation (see Subsec. 2.2.7 and Sec. 2.3). This was the subject of the previous chapters. The dynamical part of the theory was proposed by Schrödinger in 1926, and is known as the Schrödinger equation. It is also known as wave mechanics (see Subsec. 1.5.7). In this chapter we shall show that Heisenberg's and Schrödinger's formulations are only two different aspects of the same theory. We shall also come back to this point in Sec. 8.1.1. Here, first we shall derive the fundamental equation which rules quantum dynamics (Sec. 3.1), and, in Sec. 3.2, we shall summarize the main properties of the Schrödinger equation.
The identification of particle velocity with the velocity of a wave group was a crucial assumption that resolved important inconsistencies in the theoretical developments of Louis de Broglie and Erwin Schrödinger. Interestingly, this was one of the few common aspects of their work. In this paper, we present a reconstruction of how group velocity became essential for both de Broglie and Schrödinger, as well as a comparison of important differences in their theories. Pedagogical lessons to be extracted from this episode are also outlined.